Commission Row
Commission Row Photos
Business Info
Commission Row Popular Dishes
COMMISSION ROW ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Commission Row
Recommended Reviews - Commission Row
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
Amazing food! This is a peek from my birthday dinner and they have my favorite dessert The best service in Indianapolis, the environment is beautiful and upscale.
Update: Came back for a work dinner and was able to explore more of the menu. Our server (forgot his name) was fabulous!! He made great recommendations and was attentive and fun! I had the purple haze and it was good! I enjoyed the presentation and the taste! Would definitely order again. We tried the popovers, crab cakes and meatballs for apps. My favorite were the crab cakes and the least fav were the popovers. That leaves the meatballs in the middle. Of the 3, the only one I'd try again would be the crab cakes. On to the main course. I ordered a filet with a sweet whiskey sauce. We shared broccolini, carrots, French onion mac n chz and au gratin potatoes. I ordered my steak medium and it came out closer to medium well-well. The sauce was super sweet but different. The French onion Mac surprised me ...it was better than I expected. The other sides were decent. Lastly we had dessert to go. I heard rave reviews about the pineapple cake so I opted for that. By the time I got home , it was cooked and it was ok. I like the glaze on top. If you love pineapple upside down cake , you will love this cake.
We decided to have dinner last minute on a Sunday evening and didn't have issues with getting a reservation. Commission Row is a beautiful restaurant with plenty of seating to accommodate small go large parties. While the food was very good, I want to say our server was very kind and helped us from ordering our food and drinks to ensuring we were satisfied with everything. This is the first time I've had some wonderful level of service and we enjoyed our experience at here.
Another solid Indy restaurant. We went before a concert - perfect location for a dinner before a show at Gainbridge. I think it was slightly underwhelming, but I'm giving the benefit of the doubt since they were so busy and we were a table of 10. As a Maryland girl, I am very particular about my crab cakes and these were surprisingly really good for a landlocked state. We didn't love the appetizer special, which was a brioche bread with 4 oz of lump crab. Again... I'm Maryland born and just lived there for 10 years, so I may be a crab snob. King crab isn't my favorite and that's what this is. It was on the fishier side and also salty, so for me... inedible. Blue crab would've been better. Beet salad was just okay. Wedge salad - good! Not the best I've ever had, but also not the worst. Good call on the red onions. It was really dense. I tend to like them manipulated a bit for easier eating. New York Strip was cooked perfectly medium - not overly seasoned, which I appreciate. The potatoes were the star of the dang show for me. Delicious. The sauce was great! The potatoes were tender but not mushy. Very good. Broccolini wasn't anything special. The sea bass was also just okay for me... which is disappointing because it's my favorite fish. It wasn't bad by any means. I think maybe I'd skip what accompanies and just do other sides next time. Service was lacking. I had a drink without a refill for the entire visit and our food took a while... we only had about 20 minutes to eat before our show and we were there 2.5 hours before.
Commission Row hosted such a fun Pacers Tipoff Party and honestly sets the bar pretty high for event nights. From the start, everything felt smooth and welcoming. Valet parking was quick and easy, and the gentlemen working were super friendly, which is always a great way to kick off the evening. As soon as we walked in, staff greeted us and pointed us toward the elevator. Once upstairs, we were welcomed by Douglas from Commission Row and Kim, who was representing the Pacers. They were both fantastic and made everything feel organized but still relaxed. They helped us check our coats, walked us through the food and drink options, and most importantly showed us where the dessert table was. Priorities! The food theme rotates each party and it was Italian night, which was a win. They offered charcuterie scones, caesar salad, pizza, and pasta. Everything was really good and easy to enjoy while mingling. The bar had beer, wine, and a specialty Winter Daiquiri that definitely did its job. Strong, but super tasty, which is a dangerous but very appreciated combo! We arrived a little early and it ended up being perfect because we got to enjoy the space before it filled up. The atmosphere was lively but relaxed, and the DJ played a fun mix of music that kept the energy up without being overpowering. It was easy to chat and just enjoy the night. Overall, such a great experience! Huge thank you to Commission Row for hosting such a well put together event. Kim and Douglas were absolute rockstars and made guests feel genuinely welcome! I would happily attend another event here & highly recommend keeping Commission Row on your list for a fun night out or special event!
Pizza was great in the lounge!! They also had charcuterie cones, small caesar salads, and a pasta as well. Italian is generally not my favorite but everything was good! The waitresses were polite and observant of the room and when guests were done eating. Also, the greeters were the best and politely offered coat check upon arrival. Getting there way early before the game, the crowd was light but the DJ played awesome tunes and the lounge itself was spacious, welcoming, and clean! Would love to go back.
Really enjoyed this spot! HolidayAmbiance was awesome! Trees, lighting, and overlooks the ice rink. Food was great! I had a filet, Brussels, and carrots. The crab cake app was wonderful! Could have made that a meal. Started the night in the bar (speakeasy was full) and had the old fashioned. Very well balanced. If you're a bourbon drinker I'd suggest trying it! Service was very quick in the bar and restaurant. If you're in town I'd recommend you give it a shot! If you're in town and it's a game night, plan to come during the game. Crowd could be slightly less and much easier to get in!!
What can I say? This was one of my favorite meals of 2025 and I'm sad it was so late in the year. I was on vacation with my boyfriend and we decided to check it out since they were named one of the best new restaurants in 2025 on Yelp. From beginning to end, the service was phenomenal. It was my boyfriend's birthday and they even gave him a birthday card! We started off with the crab cakes which normally I'm not a huge fan of. These were better than any I've had before. They were perfectly crispy on the outside. They were big portions as well and the crab was the standout of the dish. We planned on splitting each course and they plated them for us separately without us asking which was nice. I loved these crab cakes! Next was the salmon with lobster risotto. Nothing would prepare me for how much I would love this risotto. It could be its own by itself. It was creamy and cheesy without overpowering the lobster. The salmon was seared and cooked nicely with an amazing flavor profile. We then moved onto our NY strip. The crust was crispy and seasoned perfectly. The meat was cooked to a perfect medium rare. Our side of French onion mac n cheese tied together our meal. They finished it off with a surprise birthday dessert that went above and beyond my expectations. Everything about this restaurant was well thought out. The servers were well trained and knowledgeable. To my surprise, the Cunningham Restaurant Group runs Commission Row. I only wish I was able to dine here more often as I would! Unfortunately, we live in Cincinnati. Everything here was AMAZING and I do not say that lightly as I have eaten at so many restaurants throughout 2025.
First of all, I don't have proper food pictures BUT I can say that commission row lived up to the hype! We went on NYE, with two hangry toddlers (restaurant is across the fieldhouse so major win) the service was EXCELLENT! Our server instantly knew what he was getting into and he checked up on us frequently, and got our food out pretty quick! Now on to the food!! I'm a crab cake fanatic and let me say that the crab cakes here are phenomenal! The salmon was our favorite, and Caesar salad sounds blah but that was one of our favorites! I'd go back just for the salad! We cannot wait to go back!
With fresh seafood arriving daily, it's hard to beat the oysters at Commission Row. Service was great, waiter recommended the east coast blue tips and they were easily some of the best I've ever had. The crisp they achieved on this salmon was 10/10 and to serve it on lobster risotto.. *fork drop* The lobster bisque is easily the best in Indy as well. Highly recommend checking this place out.
First time Commission Row! I think it's very convenient if you're wanting to grab food before a pacer game or maybe another event happening at Gainbridge. It has a beautiful of the Bicentennial Plaza from the restaurants big bay windows. Starting with the "Lemon Drop". "It is a tasty drink, but strong. Do not drink it on an empty stomach because it's strong and it's not a punk." Our waiter was pretty cool and knowledgeable of the menu. I studied that menu up and down for a while before making my decision on the wedge salad and was able to try other dishes that people got a table. The wedge salad was actually tasty and offered more salad than I anticipated. The picture online does not do it justice. The macaroni and cheese was very tasty. I just could've done without the French onions on top. The brussels sprouts I wanted to taste because brussels sprouts are tasty however they weren't the best. I think it might've been due to them being a bit on the burnt side. All in all it was a great experience.
Amazing dinner spot! I had the filet Oscar style and it was delicious. My colleague had the salmon and said it was perfectly cooked! All sides were amazing as well. Service amazing.
Commission Row is located in the heart of downtown, offering ambiance, elegance, and of course great food! My friend had her birthday celebration there. The service was perfect, the food was delicious, and they made her feel extra special for this occasion. My salmon was cooked to perfection. The chocolate cake was super rich and enough for 3-4 people to share. I can't wait to return!
9 months ago
Haven't been here in a little over a year but it was just as amazing as I last remember. I tried brunch this time, ordering the French toast and Potatoes O'Brien which were delicious. The fresh berries/cream on the French Toast made for a beautiful balance of sweetness. The potatoes had so much flavor! Interior is still STUNNING of course. The light fixtures and bar area are so luxurious. I'd be remiss to not mention the outstanding service. They're always so attentive and kind. read more
10 months ago
We came here for our anniversary dinner and it was incredible. We split the 14oz ribeye and it was SO GOOD. Very tender and cooked to perfection. Our server was great - attentive and knowledgeable. He also congratulated us on our anniversary and brought us a surprise dessert. We were sat by the window by the ice rink and it was very romantic and sweet to watch the couples and families skating. This is a great, intimate spot. Even when it's busy you still get that intimate feel. This would be a great place for a business dinner as well. I always recommend getting a reservation in advance even if it's during the week. read more
Wow! Our first visit to Commission Row exceeded our expectations. The space itself was beautiful. The food was delicious. The service was great - prompt, friendly, knowledgeable on the menu, and with perfect delivery on the course timing. The lobster bisque was the best I've ever had, the popovers were melt in your mouth delicious, the filet mignon was perfectly cooked, the desserts were perfection. Cannot wait to go back! read more
2 years ago
What a magnificent restaurant choice for girls night! We got the private dining area downstairs for our party of 8 & wooooow I felt so regal! I used the valet service $20 & the staff that handled were all super sweet. I suggest everyone use this as parking in the area is scarce. The ambiance of both C/R & Mel's is top tier, the service was also a 20/10. To Bradley S, our server, thank you for being beyond helpful with the menu and patient while we ordered. I ordered the wagyu meatballs w/baguette as my appetizer $24 and must I say BEST MEATBALLS IVE HAD!!!! I mean it. They were soft & jam packed with flavor. For my entree I ordered the Chilean Seabass $52 I'd give it a 8.3/10. I'm assuming the fish was under seasoned to let the potato pave shine as most of the flavor was there and meant to be eaten together in a bite.. my cocktail of choice for the night was a sidecar $17 and was perfect! I can't wait to come back for date night. read more
1 year ago
Went to Commission Row for my birthday and had such an amazing experience! Valet was easy going! Our table was in the perfect spot by the wine room! Our time here is one that I'll never forget! I don't even know where to begin!! The vibe of the entire restaurant is so elegant, calm & just such a vibe! The music was very nice, heard some jams! The food!! THE FOOD!! Let's begin with the appetizers! Top tier! Did not miss! Our favs were the King Crab Toast, Wagyu Meatballs & Hamachi Crudo! All of the entrees were delicious!! Honestly couldn't pick a favorite! Well portioned with lots of flavor! Plating of everything was beautiful! My mom had oysters rockefeller with her entree and absolutely loved them. I had shrimp & scallops with my entree! So delicious. The crispy layer on the scallop & my chilean sea bass was perfect! The sides were also great!! Our favs were French Onion Mac n Cheese, Creamed Spinach & Potato Gratin! The salads were also very good! All items were shareable! Thank you Chef Bennett & team! You all had the best service! I will shout from the rooftops how amazing this establishment is! read more
The manager came to meet and greet us as soon as our party of 15 was seated. He even brought a balloon animal for the child in our party. How cool! I ended up being too busy eating and did not get pictures. I have to say the macaroni and cheese is phenomenal! Don't skip this! I ordered the fillet and opted for medium. It was cooked to perfection and melted in my mouth. Everyone on the weight staff was super friendly. The maître D even came to greet us. Since our party was so large, we had two waiters. They both were good, but one was exceptional. I really wish I would remember his name. Everyone in our party seemed to enjoy their food. A couple people got the Wagyu burger and said it was very good. One even said she thought it was the best burger she's ever had. This location is excellent for any Gainbridge Fieldhouse events. As it is directly across from it. The chocolate cake with gold flakes was definitely one of my top three ever desserts in my life. I can see me ordering it to-go with the side of mac & cheese for dinner some evening. Dessert before dinner, " yes, please!" read more
Business owner information
Commission R.
Thank you so much for your comments, our Culinary Team has worked…
Food: Delicious! Seasoned well. Good portions. I loved the salt and pepper service for the steak. The Brussels sprouts as a side dish is sooo tasty. I also got the Caesar salad and it's giving elevated salad! The crunch and flavor were spot on. Service: Amazing service. Great recommendations by the server. He was attentive and thoughtful in his responses. Ambiance: It's giving luxury. Loved the decor and environment so much. read more
Business owner information
Ian S.
Thank you so much for your review Paige, your photos are amazing! We…
From seafood to steaks to high end cocktails Commission Row has it all and did I mention it's located right next to Gainbridge? Great location to combine with a downtown event. Atmosphere matched the food. Steaks and seafood were equally good. The lamb was superb and probably the first time I have had decent lamb in Indiana. The price is up there so make it an experience they also have valet but there are quite a few convenient parking location very close by to walk. read more
Once Commission Row was announced, I could NOT wait to try it. I'll admit I never actually looked at the menu; just saw photos and the ambience had me sold. We scored a reservation just before all star weekend. The restaurant was packed, but service was great. I tried the shrimp cocktail and the sea bass. Both were PHENOMENAL. Everything that came out looked amazing. We ventured down to the speak easy, but it was packed and looked more like a date night v. girls night. I will certainly be back though. read more
Business owner information
Commission R.
Hello Kelly! Thank you so much for taking the time to write such a…
I don't know if there's any point to updating a review if you're giving the same rating, but we came back and had a different, yet similar level of experience. So I'm still giving 4 stars, but for a different reason. The main reason for losing a star last time was because of the cook on the steak being wrong not once, but twice. This time it was the crazy long wait for drinks. (But my husband's steak was cooked perfectly!) Like last time, I'm very happy with our server, but holy cow, the drinks took forever! On our first round of drinks, it was a little slow, (~15 min.) No big deal, except that my drink was wrong (ordered a vodka martini and they brought gin), and it took another 20 minutes to get the replacement. So by the time my correct drink came, the others ordered their second, and those also took 20 minutes to come out. It also took at least 15 minutes to get the bottle of wine that we ordered. The food was a little slow, too. Our entire dinner took over 3 hours. (Not ideal, but I do prefer that to places that bring out your entree while you're still on the appetizer.) The scallops & potatoes au gratin were absolutely delicious, but the delay on drinks was sort of insane. We had a reservation for Mel's, the bar downstairs, for after dinner, but dinner took so long that it was over an hour past our Mel's reservation time, so we just headed home. read more
Business owner information
Commission R.
Hello Darci, We thank you for your honest feedback. We are sorry that…
1 year ago
Decided to try a new place for brunch past Sunday everything was great very upscale place but laid back decided to ballet which was convenient they was great also read more
Commission Row was a five-star experience from the masterminds behind my absolute favorite Indy restaurants. While I visited during their opening week, I was blown away by how put seamless the entire service experience was the whole way. When I set my reservation, someone personally checked in before our arrival on any special occasions we were celebrating and dietary needs. When we arrived, the host kindly offered to take our coat and hang it. Walking through the space, the interior design is absolutely gorgeous with immaculate attention to detail and an environment that feels high-end while staying modern and welcoming. My party ordered the Ora King Salmon and Black Hawk Farms American Wagyu Burger for entrees and I got to try both to explore more of the menu. I really enjoyed both of them, as they were truly expertly prepared. Surprisingly enough the burger was my favorite in terms of the rich Wagyu beef and toppings! While the included sides (fries for the burger, a small salad for the salmon) seemed average to me, the additional sides shined. The order of my favorites is the Crispy Brussels Sprouts, French Onion Mac & Cheese, then the Mashed Potatoes. While our experience was amazing, Commission Row will be a special occasion or celebratory night out location for me due to the high price point. It goes toe-to-toe with local favorites like St. Elmo's or Ruth's Chris and in my opinion, comes out on top in terms of the menu, service, style, and overall experience. read more
2 years ago
We love this new place! Food was worth the hype! I love our lobster bisque, my ora king salmon w/ lobster risotto. The filet mignon was perfectly cooked as we requested. The chocolate cake was the best chocolate cake I've ever had! I see that they have a good wine selection Service was just perfect. Our server was super friendly and knowledgeable with the menu (both food and drinks), our water kept filled out. I love the place, it is really spacious and nice and there is Mel's speakeasy downstairs. read more
Upscale dining with an approachable inviting feel. Service was great and everything was tasty. The location is great and I enjoyed the view of the ice skating rink outside the window. A very warm and cozy setting for a good night. read more
6 months ago
Had no idea about this place until I was out to brunch with friends. We walked over to the Gainbridge area, went downstairs and found a cute little speakeasy. The lighting was dim, the seating was comfortable, and the vibe was immaculate. My group found the cutest 4 person seating area and immediately ordered drinks. I wasn't planning to eat since we had brunch not to long ago but soon as I saw oysters, my mind changed. Not to long after we'd been there the live music started and we had a front row seat. I loved all of it. I usually visit speakeasy's out of state, but I will definitely come back here. My husband would love this. read more
We decided to give Commission Row a try before the Pacers game and it did not disappoint. Major highlight was our waitress Maleigha who was the kindest, most attentive and personable server. Not only was the entire service exceptional the food was excellent. The lobster bisque was perfectly creamy and well seasoned and the bone marrow starter dish was exceptional. The Wagyu literally melted in my mouth. Not a single complaint about any of the multiple dishes we shared. Truly everything was fabulous, highly recommend! read more
Ordered the scallops. Came with three. On a bed of butter-soaked poorly seasoned cabbage. And a couple slices of bland carrots . It was fine but grossly underwhelming for the price of almost $60 including tax and tip for that single dish. Don't waste your money here. read more
1 year ago
The services were gold pay The meal was perfect , the space was superb The atmosphere was so sweet I feel very comfortable I appreciated everything with my friends read more
1 year ago
The salad was good a different spin on a Ceasars salad. I didn't care for the Salmon ot was too spicy for me but the presentation was nice. The service was good but be prepared to wait a little bit for your food. The ambiance was amazing and a total vibe. I will try it again but next time I will try steak instead read more
9 months ago
1 year ago
1 year ago
1 year ago
Business owner information
Commission R.
Thank you so much for visiting, we are extremely pleased to hear you…
Amazing wine list!!! Incredible crab cakes Outstanding service Sexy ambiance Best wedge salad I've ever had OUTRAGEOUS chocolate cake!!!! Another stratosphere delicious!!!!! It looks dark and dense and bitter but it's light, moist, creamy and perfectly balanced! Can't wait to go back!!! read more
1 year ago
Incredible dinner tonight at Commission Row!! Started with popovers accompanied by sun-dried tomato oil, followed by mussel conserva on a bed of fennel salad, and then octopus terrine (carpaccio). For entrees, I had the Chilean sea bass and my girlfriend had a New York strip steak topped with an awesome scallop. For dessert, went with Brie cheesecake, essentially a deep-fried wheel of Brie. Drink menu was simple, and the sommelier was super fun. The service was outstanding from start to finish (thanks Ben!!). He walked us through the menu and basically set it up like a tasting, after our meal walked us down to the speakeasy and introduced us to the manager who chilled with us to teach us about the interior design (thanks Danielle!). From start to finish the meal was epic! Legit no expense was spared on the restaurant, buildout, food, service all top notch! read more
We were excited to have dinner at Commission Row! The restaurant reached out to us ahead of our visit to see if we had any special requests which was really nice! The restaurant was pretty busy for a Tuesday, but there was also a Pacers game. The ambiance was great and the decor was beautiful. A lot of great light and very spacious. For starters we ordered the crabcakes and the lobster bisque and they were both tasty. The lobster bisque had a really good flavor but not a lot of lobster. For our second course, we ordered the Wagyu burger and the Chilean Seabass along with a side of potato au gratin. All in all the food was OK. I wasn't blown away and the fish was a bit cold. Our server was incredibly attentive and very pleasant so that was a plus. I definitely want to give Mel's, their speakeasy a try during my next visit but I'd probably skip dinner. read more
We had the dining room to ourselves for lunch on this windy day and so scored a window seat overlooking Bicentennial Plaza and the outstanding service of Marissa. The decor here is beautiful. As expected, CRG delivers on its food too! Hubs had the wagyu burger with onion jam and the bun comes monogrammed with the CR branding. The truffle potato leek soup was splendid. The house salad came with green goddess dressing as a choice. It took me back in my memory of that delicious taste and it was great. The wagyu meatball starter was good but large enough to share and full of gooey burrata. Our kind server gave us a tour of Mel's speakeasy, the event space upstairs and the patio for outside dining. Thanks Cunningham restaurant group for delivering another outstanding dining experience. read more
Business owner information
Commission R.
Hello Nancy, thank you so much for the excellent review! We will…
1 year ago
Simply amazing. Spent our anniversary here last night and everything was top notch. Great place to celebrate read more
3 years ago
Food, service, and environment were all amazing! We started with the bone marrow brûlée and it truly melted in your mouth. The wedge salad was massive and definitely a step above your average wedge. I ordered the Chilean sea bass and while I wasn't the biggest fan of what was underneath, the fish itself was cooked perfectly. Steak was full of flavor and loved the roasted garlic that came on the side. Brussel sprouts were pretty standard however, the STAR of the show au gratin potatoes and lemon yuzu cheesecake are a MUST. We are taking a break from alcohol and they have a large list of NA/mock-tails to choose from (their cocktail list of course looked incredible too). Worth every penny! read more
Business owner information
Commission R.
Hello Gracie,…
3 years ago
The inside is a great vibe! Low light and classy! The cocktails were standard but I hear they have fancier cocktails in the speak easy downstairs. The crab cake and the shrimp cocktail were my favorite appetizers of the many I have posted here. I had the salmon for dinner which had great flavor! I would recommend trying this place if you have not! Perfect for a date night or a girls night! I will definitely be back! read more
Business owner information
Commission R.
Hello Jasmine, Thank you so much for the excellent review and rating!…
More info about Commission Row
110 S Delaware St
Indianapolis, IN 46204
Mile Square, Wholesale District
Directions
(317) 550-2500
Call Now
Visit Website
https://www.commissionrow.com
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Services
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
From the Business
More Info
Health Score
Commission Row Reviews in Other Languages
Ask the Community - Commission Row
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
8 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
2 years ago
11 months ago
3 years ago
11 months ago
