This should be a 4.5 star review. 5 is a bit high, but 4 is too low. Comedor is one of my favorite restaurants in Austin and has delivered consistently great food since it first opened. It's an absolutely beautiful space, the service is always excellent, and the cocktails are delicious.
One thing I have never cared for is bone marrow. Comedor frequently pushes their bone marrow tacos on customers as the "house speciality". I fell into this trap on my first visit, and, unsurprisingly, didn't like them. My wife ordered different dishes that were all excellent, so we went back again, and again trying out other dishes. I haven't been disappointed since.
In particular Comedor makes amazing mole. The Colorado mole, is my favorite, but they are all good. They make several, and I never pass up an opportunity have at least one, usually two. They also do vegetable dishes and raw fish extremely well.
The menu has several options, usually between 15 to 18. The last three to four are large plates meant to be an entree. Typically there is a steak option, chicken option, fish option and vegetarian option. I have tried several and all were good, but I think the best way to eat at this restaurant is by exploring mutiple small plates. The dishes are creative, often using uncommon ingredients by American standards. I think this is where their kitchen truly shines.
I have had two friends who told me they didn't like the restaurant, after their first visit. Both friends also ordered the bone marrow tacos, because they were told it was the house specialty. I encouraged them to go back and try the crudo/aguachile, some vegetarian dishes, and at least one mole. Both did and both texted me while at the restaurant to express how much they loved the meal. They now go back frequently.
My last meal was outstanding: Avocado and beet tostada with salsa macha, hamachi crudo/aquchile, carrot tamale, and enfriojoladas with huitalcoche. For dessert we had a lemon and coconut pavlova which might have been the best dish of the evening. For dessert they frequently push the chocolate tamale. Again, not my favorite. I often find chocolate desserts too heavy to end a meal. If. you love chocolate go for it. If you like a refreshing and light dessert get that pavlova or whatever similar dessert they are offering and you won't be disappointed.
They stopped doing brunch, but one of the best dishes I have ever had at any brunch anywhere in world, was their pan dulce plate. Chef Speer knows desserts and baking so no surprise, but he still deserves a big fucking high five for that plate.
Pro tips: Unless you really like bone marrow, don't get those tacos. I'm sure a lot fo people like them, but I'm 3 for 3 on people skipping the bone marrow and going for mole. Check with your server about the spice level on the aguachile. It can be extremely hot, and if you don't like spicy it can be too much. If the carrot tamale is on the menu, order that fucker. I don't know if carrot allergies exist, but if they do, and you have a mild one, it's probably worth the bendryll after dinner to have ordered tried it. read more