Very good pizza! Yummy crust & garlic/cheese bread! Service was good too! Would get it again but maybe with less toppings.

We ordered A chicken Philly sub, The super sub, The works pizza and all of them were great. We didn't even eat the super sub the night of, but microwaved it two days later and it was still delicious. The fries were like any to go fries and not that good. The side salad had a nice mix, but the ranch tasted like your typical fake ranch. Awesome subs and good pizza so we will order again next time we are in the area. read more

We ordered pizza & cheese sticks to go, our first night in town. Our order was ready when we arrived. Service is friendly & efficient; all our food was good, with enough for leftovers the next day. Very cheesy pizza with a tasty crust too. We asked for Parmesan & red pepper to go & were given 1 of each in tiny containers--not really enough for our order, so that was a bit of a disappointment. But, overall, this is definitely good pizza if that's what you're looking for! read more

This pizza was delicious!! We get pizza every year on our first night in town and wanted to try something new this year. Usually we get Lazzaras which is good but takes for-ev-er!! I ordered 3 large. Nothing fancy, just pepperoni. Everyone thought the crust was excellent, thin new york style. Sauce was tasty & just the right amount. Even with the pepperoni it wasnt greasy. The price was fair. The staff was friendly. Our order was delivered within 1 hour & the driver was very nice. This will be our new go to pizza place in the future. Highly recommended. read more

Awesome food! We can't come to EI without food from Circle Pizza! We love the burgers as much as the pizzas. The salads are always fresh.

I feel bad giving this place 2 stars because everyone was so nice. But this has got to be some of the worst pizza I've ever had. It is definitely a freezer pizza. I would go elsewhere if you're actually craving pizza. If you just need a hot meal where your kids can be as loud or messy as they want, this works. read more

We love the pizza! Eat it at least 2-3 times a month! Yummmy! And staff is awesome. Our favorite is the white pizza add onion & mushrooms. You will not be disappointed with their service, or food. read more

The best! Really way better than any around. All fresh & great pricing. Love their pizza!

I called at 8:30 for a pickup order, online said they closed at 9:15. The person who answered said they were closed early because they were too busy and refused to take my order. At 8:30. I asked him "what kind of business closes because they are making too much money?" He said "I just make pizza, I don't make the rules." So why is he changing the rules to close early? Then he said "you must not be from the island" when I questioned his logic. I am a local and a regular and will not be ordering from here again. When we left our home a half mile away to go to another restaurant, the open sign was still on. Clearly they were not closed. I hope the owner sees this review. read more

Yelpers got this one right on. 3.5 stars in the perfect rating for Circle Pizza. Don't get me wrong, it was definitely decent and was a good look for our first night vacationing at Emerald Isle, but it was nothing fantastic. read more

Had large pepperoni pizza at lunch yesterday. Service was friendly and delightful. Pizza was classic and tasty. Large was plenty for two, with slices left for one more lunch (or teenager snack. ) Would go again. read more

I called at 4:42 on a Friday. Was quoted 45 minutes for 2 small pizzas. Pizza arrived at 6:22. I called to check after they were 15 minutes late and was told "sorry". Same thing when they were 45 minutes late. 2 stars instead of 1 because the pizza tastes good, but horrible service. Not worth $32. read more

You know what they say about opinions, but mine is that the pizza here is one of the best on the whole island!! The flavor is top notch! I did however have to knock off one star for service. The ladies here were very sweet but, it took SO long to get pizza every time we ate here, even when they weren't busy. read more

Hour and forty minutes after ordering, we're still waiting for pizza. They're 2.5 miles from here. I can't imagine this will end well. Update: pizza came close to two hours after we ordered (one pizza, wings, and two salads). The pizza would be pretty good to someone who only had pizza described to them, but never has actually tasted it. Unfortunately, I have had pizza before, I can say it was bad pizza. Wings were cold. Salads limp and greasy with cheap oily dressing. The Circle in Circle Pizza must refer to the ones in Hell. read more

Very disappointed in the whole process. Had to repeat the order a number of times and once delivered it was wrong (we ordered 4 subs - we got 3 subs and a pizza) took almost 2 hours to deliver (we are 7 minutes from the restaurant). Food was cold and meat in the subs was very minimal. read more

Very friendly and accommodating staff! Pizza is delicious. We ate there twice in one week while visiting Emerald Isle. We ate outside once with our dog at the picnic tables and once we had carry out. These folks are doing it right with food and service! read more

We ordered on the Saturday night after arriving at our rental, and grocery shopping, like everyone else. The order took about 15 minutes longer than they said but pizza was worth the wait. Staff was courteous and professional. Maybe hold up taking phone orders when supplies run low. The only problem was a few impatient, rude customers. read more

Pizza is the best choice while dining in Emerald Isle, fortunately we had better luck with pizza than any of the seafood restaurants we tried locally, which isn't saying very much. The pizza with all the meats was a great choice from here! Also give a gyro a try you won't be disappointed. read more

One star is generous. They were out of the majority of things my family and I wanted and the service was very poor. We waited at least 20 minutes for silverware in order to even begin our meal. There was also a soaking wet dirty rag underneath our feet. read more

Circle pizza was previously one of my top two pizza places in the county, and I ordered once or twice a month since they are one of the few that delivers to where I live. Unfortunately, when they reopened after this past off season, I think they may have a different cook or something? The pizza itself seems to be consistently slightly underbaked, and their fried pickles use to be amazing but now they seem to be using a different batter that leaves the pickles very dry and peppery. I've ordered 2 times since and found the same thing each time, but I keep hoping they'll get back to their old self! read more

Good, solid pizza! You always compare vacation pizza to your favorite back home pizza and Circle Pizza wasn't quite up to par in that regard, but I didn't really expect that either. We ordered 4 pizzas from vegetarian to meat lover's and all were delicious. Our take home order took about 25 minutes and was waiting on us when we arrived to pick up. Everyone inside was friendly. Definitely a place to try after a long, hot day at the beach. read more

Very good pizza, closest thing to Giovanni's back home. Wings were cooked well and sauced heavily. We had a two item large and an order of hot wings. It was busy in the lobby but our order was ready when we arrived and was quickly greeted and checked out and on our way. The takeout menu is including delivery so pickup is slightly cheaper. read more

This is probably one of my most favorite pizzas! Very good pizza and the service, even though very busy, did not take long. Price was reasonable also. read more

Our first time here. Ordered a pizza to go and it was great with more toppings than a chain pizza We would definitely recommend the Italian sausage and cheese! read more

Came here on a Friday afternoon, definitely a good find. Feels like a classic mom and pop type place. I got a super sub, which came with fries. THE best sandwich I've had in North Carolina plus the fries were hot, fresh, and perfect. The cheesy bread appetizer was to die for. I will be back here! read more

Horrible customer service. Can not get order completed on time. Long waits. Seem like only 1 employee is actually working.

Was told that delivery would take 2 hours so we decided to pick up instead and get it in 45-60min. We showed up 45 mins after we placed the order and ended up waiting another 45 mins. They kept on telling us 5 more minutes knowing they hadn't started on the order yet. When we finally got our pizza back home, we found out they messed up our order. Ordered pizza with sausage and got mushrooms instead. So an hour and a half for the wrong pizza that tasted like it came from the public school cafeteria. Don't believe the positive reviews. Stay away. read more

This pizza was pretty dang delicious! We ordered 3 speciality pizzas for around $51. They would've scored higher had they not forgotten to remove the onions and add banana peppers. I would still order again! read more

HORRIBLE PLACE, DON'T GIVE THEM YOUR BUSINESS. We called to order at 6:12pm and placed an order and my Wife had to keep repeating the order 3 times because the lady taking the order either could not hear or just did not want to do their job. I heard the entire order and the lady said it would be at our house in 20 minutes. At 7:45pm we called back asking where our food was and was hung up on twice because THEY promised the wrong time. We spoke to the manager Andy Amir and was VERY VERY VERY UNHELPFUL and CLUELESS and did not admit the problem was their fault. Had to call back a third time to ask for a credit card refund. read more

Superior Crispy crust, plenty of flavor, lots of delicious cheese , all added up to a delicious pizza. We got the supreme and we're happy with the sausage, and plentiful veggies. read more

Horrible. I ordered a burger and fries. Burger was over cooked.... the veg on it looked like it came from the trash can and the fries were cold. read more

Good pizza, loved the barbecue wings, delivery guy was cool, and the lady that took our order was very nice.

My family and I took a day trip for our first time to Emerald Isle and wanted to grab a quick lunch before heading to the beach and decided to check this place out. First thing I can say is the woman working there was the sweetest. Very pleasant, friendly and helpful. We ordered a large cheese pizza and and order of onion rings. The pizza was great and super cheesy. My kids loved it and they are pizza snobs. The onion rings were the best I have ever had! We will definitely be back for more on our next visit! read more

ordered through vittles2u app, have to order $20 for delivery so chose meatball sub, carolina burger, & chicken tenders with fries & onion rings. Meatballs, chicken tenders & onion rings taste like frozen stuff from sam's club...fried foods very greasy the best parts were the sub roll which was burned & the honey mustard dipping sauce..burger was big but not seasoned, chili not even noticeable... read more

Absolutely the best pizza I have had. Exactly what I was looking for. Crunchy and chewy crust! My favorite of anywhere!!!!

Probably a 2.5 but definitely not a 3. Ordered a small cheese And 1/2 pepperoni so my first comment is this, I hate pepperoni under the cheese always seems greasy and this did seem greasy. We ordered a small so be prepared the small was small, equal to about two slices in a regular pizza maybe 2.5 for 10 bucks, eh its emerald isle real estate ain't cheap. The flavor ok My wife thought is wasn't great a 1 but i thought it was eh, ok. If you are used to NE pizza, NY, Buffalo, New Haven-- u will not rate this pizza very high But u r not in the NE and the beach here makes it worth every penny lol-- read more

Stopped by for a quick bite to eat, big mistake placed a order for a chicken parmigiana sandwich and waited and waited and waited. Nothing quick about this place about 30 to 40 minutes later the sandwich arrived. The wait was horrible but the food itself was delicious. read more

This is our favorite pizza on the island! It's not your standard pizza, but it is unique in a good way. It's a little thicker than New York Style pizza. The pizzas and slices are a good size. The delivery is fast, which is convenient. I definitely recommend this place over the other pizza places on the island. read more

We called for a delivery order and they said 1-1.5 hours, so I decided to drive over and pick it up with my 4-year old son. There were about 8-12 people behind the counter, a sweaty delivery driver handling cash in the middle of the kitchen, and general chaos that didn't seem necessary for a place with 0 sit-down customers and moderate delivery/pick-up orders. They nearly forgot about our garden salads, and probably should have because one of them had a load of brown, old lettuce. We got a large cheese and a 4 topping pizza which I would classify as below average in quality. We also got the BBQ wings which were doused in sauce but fairly tasty, albeit a bit on the crunchy side. Probably would try a few other pizza joints out first before going back. read more

We had both Michaelangelo's Pizza and Circle Pizza. Hands down Circle is the best pizza in Emerald Isle. Great thin crust baked to perfection with lots of real cheese and pepperoni. I usually don't finish the heel of the crust on my pizza, but I sure did with Circle's. Wish I could take it home with me. read more