If you want AMAZING NY Style everything, Mario's is the place to go! Although they are a bit pricey, it is so worth it! The place is very clean, seating area is good size, and the staff and owners are great! read more

Was not impressed. Now I did not get pizza which is what they are known for. I got the spaghetti and the sauce was bland and the meatballs tasted like the frozen ones you get from Walmart. Not worth the money also was disappointed in the ranch. I thought it would be homemade but it's Ken's which I don't like either. Service was nice. read more

Love the feel of the restaurant, the service was great food came out fast and amazing, the pizza slices are HUGE, the mozzarella sticks were insane, and the marinara sauce topped my whole experience. My first time here won't be my last read more

Mario's Pizza - Pepperoni Plain Cheese Pizza Slices and Cheese Sticks - Pizza Near Me - Havelock, North Carolina

Great pizza Stromboli and a wonderful atmosphere absolutely the best pizza in havelock hands down

The Stromboli's in Havelock are absolutely the best...We prefer to drive from New Bern to Havelock, The staff is always polite and courteous, They are always good and hot and made exactly like we like them. read more

Mario's Pizza - Stromboli's are the best in Havelock - Pizza Near Me - Havelock, North Carolina

Just got done eating there. The pizza was absolutely delicious! One of the best we have had in a long time. The staff was extremely polite. Definitely recommended, and will be eating here again read more

We love Mario's Pizzeria! Ot is the closest to New Jersey pizza that is close to my home. Friendly, clean, delicious food, generous with salad portions, and reasonable priced. read more

professional, and technique in their way of service , as shows that with those simple ingredients, but yeah exactly the same time proved to be on time thank you so much for hard work you guys have done!!!!!! read more

Good pizza but whoever answers there phones are not very friendly whatsoever. I was also surprised by how good the fried pickles are

We ordered out while in town and I couldn't be more disappointed. We were looking forward to the pizza since we were told they had good food. Nothing about this pizza was fresh. The mushrooms were from a can. The middle of the pizza was soggy. I felt horrible throwing away half the pizza but I couldn't eat anymore. The fried ravioli was okay but nothing spectacular. read more

Pizza was recommended but fell way below standards. Toppings were canned and pizza was soggy and cold when we got it at the specified ready time. I'm almost fifty and have had pizza all over the place and this is the worst pizza I've had that I can remember. Frozen generic pizza is better and that ain't saying much since I don't eat that. We were starving but barely eat a piece before throwing it out!Sad! read more

Fantastic slices, friendly and professional service. Very clean restaurant. Will definitely visit again when in town.

Love their pizza! Customer service is hit or miss! Sausage and peppers parmigean could use more meat and cheese Also why don't you have Sicilian pies? Overall it's the closest thing to NY pizza hands down!! What about pinwheels? Garlic knots etc also why not deliver just saying yo read more

Got a pie to go, fantastic and quick service, didn't stay for the ambiance but seemed nice

The pizza is awesome will order anything out of here well kept up very clean on top of it

Great chill spot to have a slice and a Pepsi. Reminds me of a pizza shop I used to go to as a kid.

It's great pizza and my family enjoy it.we ordered two large pizzas and we had fed 7 of us and still had some left over. I would definitely recommend this place. read more

Service was subpar the guy taking our order couldnt even smile. The pizza was soggy, and my pasta sauce has no flavor and the sausages were burnt. It's expensive for the quality that you get. Wouldn't recommend read more

The only pizza we have. It truly is the Best tasting pizza in New Bern/Havelock, hands down!

Officially never eating at Mario's again I just got such an unappetizing steak sub and when I went to say something to the "owner" politely he started and argument with me saying "how was he supposed to feel that's his number one seller" and proceeded to argue with me in such a rude and unprofessional way and I reminded him that he is in the customer service industry and that he doesn't have to always agree with customers opinions but you don't argue with them about it. I didn't take a bite out of it because 1. It looked nasty and the meat looked old 2. I didn't want to not get my money back because I had eaten some of it. A customer sitting across from me said that she also thought it was poorly made and that I should ask for my money back. He kept on saying "how is that supposed to make me feel!?" And I told him I don't care about his feelings, that this isn't how you treat your customers he didn't even offer to remake my sandwich and said he wasn't giving me any money back either. I asked for his name he claimed to be the owner not sure if that's true but if it is this so called restaurant has gone to shit. I asked for his name and it's mostly illegible. I didn't appreciate this experience especially when this is where my mom decided to go for her birthday lunch. Thanks Rosario. **update he is the owners son.** read more

See all

I have been to both restaurants, in New Bern and Havelock and they are both great and calzones are the best in town

Best pizza in town. Been coming here a very long time and it never disappoints. Very friendly staff and delicious food.

Ordered a ham and cheese sandwich and got a cheese steak - no apology for wrong order - nothing- also ordered two cannolis both only had filling on ends - nothing in center. Poor service poor employee/owner attitude. read more

For the amount of food you get for the price, it would deserve a 4 star. For a very large slice of pizza it is only $2.50, and each additional topping is .50 cents. Toppings are a little pricey, but a plain cheese pizza slice price isn't that bad. Now, taking in consideration the quality of pizza... my rating drops significantly. For a freshly made to order pizza I was hoping the flavor would be better. It had a ton of grease on it with a few slices of pepperoni. Personally, I like a crisp pepperoni - these ones were sopping in grease. The crust was soggy where cheese was but rock solid on the edge. Overall, I would unfortunately opt for a chain pizza such as Dominos, Pizza Hut, etc., before here again in Havelock. read more

Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Havelock, North Carolina

PIZZA IS Great! Thin crust, good sauce, but not much sausage. I got a 14" for lunch and it was NY Style, cooked thru! But poor hubby! He ordered the "Dinner Special" Spaghetti & Meatballs. He got a cup of spaghetti, sauce and a HALF of a Meatball....!!! Don't call it MEATBALLS if you're only ploppin a half of one on the plate. NO bread, no salad...that was it! THAT IS NOT A DINNER!!!For $13.20 (and whats with the .20???) Too many other great places in New Bern to eat Italian, I will fagettaboutit...(they DO tell you at the online menu that's all you get, Our bad for NOT reading the menu online before hand, we would have gone somewhere else!) read more

Love this place! The pizza slices are huge and tastes great. The pizza is always hot. Their steak and cheese subs are super good too! All their food is filling and some! I would call ahead for easy pick up. read more

Pizza was real good and was cooked all the way. Short wait time on my order and polite staff made my stay more enjoyable. I'd definitely come back again and bring others with me. read more

Mario's Pizza - a slice of pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Havelock, North Carolina

Absolutely the best pizza anywhere! Huge NY style slices owned and operated by real Italians for over 35 years! read more

Mario's Pizza - Half Cheese and Half Mario's Special! Freshly made every single time! - Pizza Near Me - Havelock, North Carolina

AMAZING PIZZA!!! Delicious!! My husband and I love to get our pizza here I DEFINITELY RECOMMEND and I wish I could give you 10 stars :)

10/10 I LOVE PIZZA! Just sucks that I have pay for an extra topping each time, should have at least two free toppings...

Great service, fast. Ordered 1 gigantic slices of New York style cheese pizza, bottled water and a side salad for around $10. Super deal! So glad I got 2 slices. This was crispy and thin the way I like. Very flavorful. Will definitely be back next time I'm in town. These slices are BIG! read more

this place is awesome! food is so good and great service and atmosphere! make you feel at home

Love this place! Everyone is super friendly, and answered all my questions with no hassle. If you love NY style pizza this is definitely the place to get it! I pickup pizza from here about once a month and they never disappoint! read more

Awesome mom and pop place! They're always friendly with great food I just discovered it and now that's my first recommendations in town.

I'm from NY so I always get excited for pizza, this place would be mediocre at best in NY but a decent place here in Havelock, NC .. Got two slices of pizza and a side of cheese sticks. These slices are HUGEE, definitely filled me up.. price was alright but the toppings are a bit pricey, 50 cents per topping (50 cents each for a couple of onions and green peppers really??!). This place definitely beats the chain pizzerias like dominos and papa johns in town though. read more

Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Havelock, North Carolina

See all

Definitely the best pizza in the area. Subs, pizza, and calzones are all exactly what you want and expect from a New York style pizzeria. Staff is great. Not a whole lot of seating so if you get there when it's busy you may have a hard time. Definitely worth the extra couple dollars over the chain pizza pits. read more

Mario's Pizza - May not look like much but there is great pizza here! - Pizza Near Me - Havelock, North Carolina

I absolutely loved the food. This place is in an older building and you will notice a slight bug problem which would keep me from wanting to go back. I really hope they move to another location so they can keep dishing out that fine food! read more

Absolutely THE best pizza that Havelock has to offer. Forget your chains and your deep dish, Mario's has authentic east coast-style pizza. It's thin, floppy, crispy, hot, perfectly seasoned and topped, and most of all: it's consistent every single time. The owners and staff are very friendly, and will make you feel at home as soon as you walk in. Available on multiple food delivery apps, but getting takeout is just a great back-home experience. 100% recommended read more

I hit up Mario's anytime I'm in town! Even after all these years, nothing has changed and that's what I love

The garden salad was just as delicious as the pizza. This is a hidden gem off of the beaten path. The pizza was huge!!! I'm definitely coming back! read more

Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Havelock, North Carolina