A "new to us" place and we were not disappointed! 3 pizzas ready for pickup in 20 min , service was fast and reliable. Pizzas were delicious! I think we've tried every other pizza place on EI and Kostas has been the best so far. They have a wide selection of food, drinks in the fridges in the shop and tables outside to eat there. Highly recommend! read more

Pizza and wings were fine. Good service and quick. It made our dinner on our first day here enjoyable if not especially memorable.

Mediocre pizza. Didn't try anything else. I read good things about the place, but that wasn't my opinion.

Service was fast! Wings were good but more of a vinegar barbecue which wasn't documented.

Great pizza spot- friendly and delicious! Also offer a gluten free option. Stop by next door to have a drink and bring your pizza to sit down. read more

We visit this place when in town. The have good pizza and other items. The ranch dressing was great- they make it homemade! My eggplant sandwich with extra cheese was very yummy and filling. I loved the marinara sauce it had. The lemoncello cake was interesting. Nice lemony flavor. All desserts displayed in a dessert case. Service was very friendly. Kinda cold in the restaurant so bring a sweater. Lol They said the menu will be changing soon. So we will what happens next time. We will return. read more

See all

Kostas was delicious! We ordered a large pepperoni and a large veggie pizza while visiting. Post were outstanding! Everyone in our family said that they wished they had a shop like Kostas near home. Ordering online and pick up was quick and easy Highly recommend. read more

From ordering over the phone with Sheryl, to picking up the food, and enjoying our dinner, everything was great! The food was delicious and was exactly what we were looking for in a takeout pizza place. If you are in Emerald Isle, this is your spot for takeout pizza. read more

See all

We got pizza to go for 11. The sizes are terrific, and 5 pizzas were more than enough for 8 adults and 3 children. When we picked up, the workers were helpful and kind. I personally wasn't a huge fan of the sauce or the crust. The sauce wasn't very flavorful and the crust reminded me of fast food chain pizza crust. My fiancés family enjoyed it so I may just be the oddball out since I'm used to NY pizza. Overall, it was edible, the workers were friendly, and the large pizzas are a good size for how much you pay. read more

Kostas was okay. I placed a pick up order through Uber Eats and got an alert that the food was ready within 15 minutes of ordering, but when I went in it still took a few minutes. Not a big deal, and it may have been a glitch on Ubers part but still wanted to mention it. The greek gyro was great but the chicken gyro was really dry. The BLT sub and jalapeño poppers were also decent. And then there was the garlic bread, it was only $3ish so I wasn't expecting much but it was literally just a loaf of scored bread sprinkled with garlic powder/salt. We only had about two pieces (the remains are what is in the picture) before tossing it. The bread itself was great quality, but it was basically like eating a plain loaf of bread with an overly salty top crust. Probably wouldn't come back unless it was to give the pizza a chance, but if you're in need of a quick and easy meal Kostas isn't the worst choice. read more

Kostas Pizza - GARLIC BREAD - Pizza Near Me - Emerald Isle, North Carolina

Kostas knows how to pile on the delicious toppings. Absolutely loved the Hawaiian pizza we had. Quick service. Only thing that was a bummer was that it is only take out. There are a few picnic tables outside but they weren't in the shade. read more

These people know weekday they're doing when it cums to pizza. Hands down the best available in this area. read more

Kostas Pizza - Delicious!! - Pizza Near Me - Emerald Isle, North Carolina

Just what you're looking for quick and delicious pizza. Tried the cheese, pepperoni and Hawaiian. All three delicious would definitely go back again. read more

Best Pizza Ever! Loved the ranch!! Such sweet girls!! They were so helpful and nice! I loved the all meat pizza and the veggie, but I don't think you can go wrong!! read more

not great service. order was missing a few things. messaged business and never heard back. pizza was pretty average.

Great pizza and amazing service! The staff is super friendly and personable, making it a very welcoming atmosphere. Highly recommend to locals and tourists alike :) read more

Really good pizza and a really nice manager who was engaging everyone coming in the door with a little bit of conversation and not only serving them their food. Amazing how quick they can get the order taken and the food ready! read more

The pizza was SO GOOD. We tried this place for the first time a few days ago and it was honestly amazing. The food was ready in a timely manner and the staff was very friendly. Definitely recommend and will be back. read more

This place is a must stop every time we come to Emerald Isle. Seems like they make a lot of items in house and you can tell! Pizza has great sauce and very cheesy! The wings do not have a ton of breading on them (which is how I like them) and the sweet Thai chili sauce is one for the books! Ended up dipping my pizza crust in it! 10 out of 10! The only complaint I would have is I wish they had seating inside so you could enjoy it fresh and right from the oven! They do have picnic tables outside but in the middle of July that is a bit hard to sit out and eat. Other than that, we love it! read more

We LOVE No Name! We were so excited when they opened one closer to our house. I am not a thick crust girl, but I so enjoy their thick crust. I've tried their thin but ironically it doesn't do it for me. We get take out a lot and it's always delicious, but if you want the real experience, eat it on a picnic table as soon as it's ready. That's when the crust is at its best! We have tried other things but when we grab from No Name EI we are grabbing pizza! If you want a great burger, check their Morehead Location. read more

Best pizza I've ever had! While on vacation I decide to get some pizza and boy am i glad I got Kostas Pizza! I highly recommend it to anyone! read more

Fluffy crust- very different. Loved the pizza. Generous portion of cheese on the white pizza