Best shrimp and spinach pizza evah. We'll my only shrimp and spinach pizza evah. It was delicious. It is a thick crust white pizza with just enough saltiness to make it sing. I want more. Service was good, drinks were fine. When it's sunny out outside dinning on the dock is outstanding. On rainy days, ambiance is of a pizza joint. read more

This place has the formula figured out! They're on the water, they charge fair prices, and their food is delicious!! And they have a 99 health score! We ate there twice because the pizza is perfect! The service is great despite being packed! It's a comfortable place to be with no pretense! read more

Black Sheep - So good!!! - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

See all

Love your food and location! The pizza wood-fired in the beautiful black tiled pizza oven. The water view and boardwalk are amazing. I do wonder, sometimes I get food to go. Sometimes I hand my card to the staff and they ask if I'd like a receipt and then wait for my food. But then sometimes certain workers will point at the iPad thing for me to give a tip. Unsure why those particular workers do that. I'm not discounting the hard work they put in at all or saying wait-staff doesn't deserve a tip. Just the shaming into tipping thing seemed weird. read more

Excellent view and they didn't give me too much crap about taking up a table to enjoy just a pint and the view. It was early in the season and I'm sure it gets busy during peak season so don't expect that kind of treatment always. Service was excellent and the bathroom was relatively clean for such a busy spot. Wanted to get a t-shirt but saving up for next visit. read more

Great service, and we enjoyed a table for two by the docks. Perfect for sunset dining. We shared a salad and devoured a pizza between the two of us. It was upscale dining without being formal. I'm holding back one star because there weren't many vegetarian options. read more

Another fantastic meal at Black Sheep. Sat right on the waterfront and had a great time. Food was great, and so was the service. read more

Black Sheep - Caesar salad - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

I've eaten at Black Sheep twice now. I ordered the Four Cheese pizza both times without realizing it. I wish I lived closer as I've been trying to find my new place for pizza after my favorite pizza place closed. Black Sheep has the best pizza with thin crust and wood fired. I haven't tried the other dishes yet but there is next time. Although the pizza could win out next time too. My first time at Black Sheep I ate outside as that is where I was offered for seating. This time it was just too hot for me to sit outside so I got a table inside. Outside seating is on the water so I think I preferred that but when you've been outside most of the day the AC has its perks. Service is really good here and I was really thirsty so I had both tea and water and those cups were kept full. I was brought a carafe of water. I was even given a tea to go. I look forward to my next visit to Black Sheep. read more

See all

The drinks, food, and atmosphere were great! They made a delicious old-fashioned. The cheese sticks were delicious and homemade, which is a nice change! They could use a little more breading, but would still order again. Overall, everything was great. Prices are a little high, but it is waterfront. Will definitely visit again. read more

See all

I come to Black Sheep every time I am visiting the area and love bringing guests to this spot. The location is great-- right in the heart of downtown Beaufort with both indoor and outdoor seating. Great boat watching from the back patio area. The service here is always good and the wait for a fable is never too long even on busy nights. The food here is mostly pizzas, sandwiches, and salads. We had the tomato pie pizza and shared a few large appetizers with the table: crab dip, burrata salad, and a charcuterie board. I would order everything again. The crab dip was especially delicious and flavorful. read more

Black Sheep - Crab dip, charcuterie board, and burrata appetizers - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

Black sheep was great. Don't be disoriented if you walk in through their "secret entrance" someone will point you in the right direction. The place wasn't packed but we had to get on a wait list and they told us 20-30 minutes but we were seated in like 15. They have like 3 sections in the restaurant, one section outside and the other two inside. One of those inside sections is a lounge area where you can wait and order drinks while you, as we did, wait for your tables. Once we sat down Parker gave us the rundown on all the specials and they all sounded and WERE delicious. Parker was very attentive to whatever we needed and explained the specials in such a way that we ordered all of them. First off we got the soup special. Imagine a "crab chowder" mixed with corn chowder it was sooo good. Next the Mac n Cheese special which was delicious and a good stepping stone to our figgy piggy pizza. I was skeptical because of the figgy part but Parker sold us on it and the pizza was soooo good. Good balance of sweetness and pizza. Overall it was a great experience. I do wish they would have a bit more beer selections but other than that I highly recommend this place for a bite. read more

See all

The pizza was addictive (the sauce, crust, and cheese were all perfect!) and even the house red wine was an impressively good Cabernet. The mixed greens salad was ok, but it WAS a salad with mixed greens, lol. read more

Black Sheep - Margherita pizza and mixed greens salad. - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

It's a small pizza restaurant right on the water. I had the Mediterranean Platter which I loved. Husband had a salad with grilled chicken. The service was great. read more

Black Sheep - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

Great food and vibe right on the water in downtown Beaufort. The Green Room next door is an extension with more relaxed seating areas for drinks and conversation or watching a ball game. read more

Love the vibe! We have eaten here many times over the years. It is consistently solid food. They also serve food next door at the Green Room bar. read more

Walking along the waterfront in Beaufort will make anyone hungry, and my husband and I were not the exception to that! Not feeling fancy enough for a steak dinner we saw this unassuming restaurant called The Black Sheep and decided to give it a try. We managed to walk in through the wrong door lol and had to be rerouted to the hostess stand. They were super busy and we didn't want to sit outside so we were sat at corner table for 2 which was cozy. The waitress was quickly out to take our order and we received our piping hot Four Cheese pizza shortly thereafter. Neapolitan style pizza is not for everyone, but it's our favorite! The sauce was minimalistic really bringing out the flavor without it being overpowering. The cheese was gooey and delicious, while the crust was perfection with just the right about of texture. It's super hard to find amazing Neapolitan pizza in ENC, but the Black Sheep is the real deal and we most definitely will be back!! read more

Black Sheep - Four Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

See all

Stopped in for a late lunch Sat on the waterfront deck Food was good Service was excellent Dog friendly is always a Plus for us read more

I liked it here! First, they have a nice location on the water. So the ambiance is nice. Also, the service is good! Next, the food was good! I really enjoyed my anchovy pizza. The crust was good and the seasoning was good. I do wish my side portion of Brussels sprouts was a tiny bit bigger though! Finally, it was not super hard to get a table on Thursday night without a reservation, and I appreciate that. read more

See all

Gluten free, dairy free pizza? Count us in! Our server was helpful in figuring out which pizza toppings would be okay for our dietary restrictions. We went with the Bishop and the Charcuterie pizzas, both of which were fantastic. They also have gluten free wraps and crackers to sub for sandwiches and appetizers with bread. We were sat at the windows facing Front Street, so people watching was fun. However, surrounded by other tables/ other people in our little corner the noise level got really loud. read more

Delicious food (potentially the best Caesar salad I have had ever), quick service, kind waitress who offered to take photos, and wonderful view. Will absolutely return on our next weekend getaway! read more

Black Sheep - Margarita Pizza, Crab Chowder, and Caesar Salad - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

The atmosphere is fun and the food and cocktails are excellent! We had the crab dip, Philly cheesesteak and the margarita pizza as well as their Margaritas. read more

Food is delicious and service is great! Beautiful view watching the boats up and down the waterway. Pizza was outstanding for NC!

I think I've found my new favorite place to eat. We ended our night last night with the torta which was an indescribably good tart lemon flavored dessert. We were looking at others people's dinners and knew we needed to come back for lunch, so we did! Outside seating was packed, so we sat at the bar. Excellent service provided by Caleb, but the staff truly do zone coverage, so if he was mixing drinks but our waters were empty, another person would fill them up. The low key atmosphere both inside and out was perfect. And from the bar, you can see the horses roam the land across the water. We got the pizza bites appetizer (not just for kids) and the Pedro pizza. For two people, this was more than enough food. And the béchamel sauce on the pizza - so light and just really brought all the flavors together. Definitely will return with the family next time. read more

See all

Location right on the water so the view is fantastic. Lots of windows so the barroom feels very open. They have friendly and amicable bartenders. Had a delicious and local IPA at a good price. I will certainly come back here and have a drink or two next time I visit Beaufort, NC! read more

Black Sheep - The delicious IPA at the bar. - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

One of our favorite casual spots in Beaufort! Great food, chill vibe, and excellent service every time we go--I'm not even a big fan of pizzas, but we always love the pizza here! read more

Great views if you eat outside. The wood fired pizza and appetizer was great. Highly recommend! read more

Black Sheep - Baked pimento cheese appetizer - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

We waited a long time for a cold sandwich. When it arrived it was a mediocre amount of chicken salad on dry focaccia bread . When we said the bread was dry we were told it was because it was a different type of bread? Lots of dirty tables when we arrived . Oh and apparently we waited for a long time because of a computer error. read more

Fantastic WOOD FIRED pizza! We ordered the pepperoni which has caramelized onions on it too. We ordered it extra crispy. The pizza is very thin and light, perfect. We also ordered a green salad which they had offered to split in the kitchen, it came lightly dressed, greens with cucumbers and radishes. They have a good beer list with local beers on draft. I had iced tea. They are dog friendly and immediately brought a water bowl for the dogs. Great view AND great service. read more

See all

Despite being short handed, they really took care of us well. We came in for drinks and light snacks and ordered the Mediterranean platter. Very light, very diverse Mediterranean fare. Olives, hummus, other veggies were fresh and really good. We were in the Green Room side, which feels part like a library and part like an art museum. This place is really nice. Totally felt relaxed and at home here. Can I move in? read more

A fun evening with pizza and draft beer! Popular waterfront spot with a great vibe and pleasant service. Look forward to returning. Indoor seating and pet-friendly outdoor seating availabe. read more

Never disappointed with the food here. We made it there on an evening with no wind and a beautiful sunset. Sat out on the deck and enjoyed the view. The staff were very attentive, asking to remove our plates or fill our glasses of beverages the moment they got low. read more

Black Sheep - View from the deck. - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

See all

This is a fun casual restaurant on Beaufort's waterfront boardwalk area. They serve an interesting variety of 12" thin crust pizzas which make 6 slices and were perfect for the two of us. They carry an interesting variety of local beers on tap which I enjoyed. The service was friendly and attentive even though it was busy with large family groups. We had pizza, salads and my beer and it cost half of what a fancier restaurant was the night before. We would revisit again when here. read more

I love this little dockside restaurant!!! It has a great view, great service and great food!! The pizza was so flavorful and had that perfect amount of "chew" to it. My salad was fresh and tasty as well. I'd come back any day! read more

Black Sheep - Pizza and Caesar salad - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

We eat here almost every time we come to Beaufort. The pizza is delicious and made with high-quality ingredients. Sometimes the service is excellent and other times it can be a little slow. Overall, we enjoy the food and would definitely recommend you give it a try. read more

See all

I wish I could give this restaurant 3.5 stars so I went up instead of down bc it was more positive than negative. A group of us camped for the weekend at cape lookout and my boyfriend and I stumbled upon this adorable water town. We checked the yelp reviews and menus and settled on black sheep. We were greeted and seated immediately. Not overly friendly but not rude. No smiles. Just, how many without looking up. Inside or out? We chose outside for the view even though we have had been water view all weekend. Waters were brought promptly. We ordered the crab dip as an appetizer. That came out in less than 10 minutes. Here's where the lower stars come in. Presentation was beautiful but the food was extremely bland. He ordered this sandwich with thick floppy bacon and pimento cheese. Again, presented beautifully and excited for the first bite... disappointed again. Bread was soft, bacon soft, with very little flavor. I ordered the wenny pizza. Crust was perfect and the pizza was beautiful. I ended up covering it with red peppers and Parmesan to liven it up as much as I could. 3/3 we're bland. Inside is a very cool, eclectic restaurant. It ran efficiently but nobody was overtly friendly. Nobody was smiling or acknowledging even. Walking into the bathroom, I even almost got trampled by a server not caring she was cutting me off walking. Bathroom was behind a huge photo of a man's face. read more

See all

I was on a vacation this past weekend and found this place and decided to try it and i was not disappointed, i ordered the Sausage & Pepper Pizza and was pretty good the only down side i will say is the size it wasn't that big and the menu didn't specify the size, but it was pretty good and the service was good as well. read more

See all

My family and I all work in the food business - we LOVE great food- great food is very, very important to us. That being said, truly great food is unfortunately quite hard to find- especially in tourist destinations like The Outer Banks. I have come to rely on Yelp to help steer us in the right direction in any city we're visiting. I saw Black Sheep rated fairly high- the menu looked interesting and the atmosphere/ location, well the Beaufort Waterfront is tough to beat. So we ventured over there this evening after a few hours at the beach. We were seated quickly outside (just as we were hoping) - the hostess and our server were quite warm and welcoming. We had two of the specials, one of which was a Watermelon Gazpacho - DANG...we all wished we had ordered a bowl with a to-go vat for home! We had several sandwiches (the Cuban and Beaufort Cheesesteak) as well as the Tomato Pie. Everything on our plates was very obviously made with love and care. There was not a single "throw-away" component. The Pickled Golden Beats, the Potato Salad, the homemade Focaccia, the House-Cured Pork - etc....everything was given thought and made with excellence. There were 5 of us picky food snobs in our party- we all tasted every component on each others plates and we all walked away thoroughly impressed and amazed at what great eats we had just experienced. Thank you for putting such love and thought and heart into your food - it matched at beauty of your location and gave us a truly memorable evening as a family / we left thoroughly blessed and thankful that we dined at Black Sheep this evening! read more

When you imagine a restaurant that can successfully appeal to all audiences, this place hits it on the head. The bar room is great for adults and the outdoor dining is great for families. Regardless of where you sit, be prepared for a bright, cheery atmosphere with great views of the bay. The food is delicious as well. read more

Black Sheep - Mediterranean Platter and happy fingers - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

Pizza was delicious, great crust! Yummy Caesar salad, next time I'd order it without the anchovies. read more

Black Sheep - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Beaufort, North Carolina

We ordered several pizzas for the table and they were all good, spirts were also nice. We had to listen to a screaming child and I would still give it a good review! read more

Our first visit to Beaufort. What a nice town. We started with lunch at Black Sheep. The atmosphere was ok and the service was welcoming. We ordered a Caesar Salad, Pimento Cheese Dip, and a Sausage & Pepper Pizza. Everything was good but not outstanding. It was an interesting take on pimento cheese but the "ciabatta" was really just pizza crust which overlapped a bit too much with the pizza. I liked the flavors in the pizza toppings but the crust was pretty ordinary. A good meal though. read more

See all