We stayed on Emerald Isle for a week and were told that this is the best pizza on the island by a couple of people... so we decided to give it a chance for dinner one night. It was a supreme type of pizza. And it was bad. It was not cooked all the way. So we tried 15 more min in the oven at our condo... We didnt even keep the leftovers. Based on my experience, drive across the bridge for pizza.. read more

Lazzara's Pizza & Subs - Pizza Near Me - Emerald Isle, North Carolina

The positives: delivery was fast and the Stromboli was tasty. The negative: the pizza and the marinara sauce. The sauce tasted more like ketchup than marinara. The pizza was so flavorless and disappointing. read more

Garlic rolls were delicious, a must and huge for their price Cheesy bread was top tier, large size and ample cheese to enjoy Get the pizza pies a little more overdone, they can make it too doughy. read more

Best tomato pizza of my life!!! The crunch to this crust is astonishing. I miss it already read more

Lazzara's Pizza & Subs - Tomato pizza - Pizza Near Me - Emerald Isle, North Carolina

More of a bar or football style pizza, not a traditional New York style. Pizza was solid for Emerald Isle, I would give it a 6.2 on my version of the Portnoy scale. Can't say much about the restaurant or the ambience we did carry out. read more

After 10 hours of driving and getting checked into our vacation house we did not feel like sitting down somewhere and eating. We picked Lazzara's after a quick yelp search. We ordered a pizza with everything and a half cheese half pepperoni. Both were fantastic, the cheese was different on the cheese pizza and made it the best of the bunch. We'll definitely stop back and grab a slice or two before we head back home. read more

We've always enjoyed this pizza place for the many years we've visited EI! They go above & beyond, letting us order their incredibly delicious Sicilian pizza-- as long as we give them at least 24 hours notice. The crust is to-die-for, thick & perfectly chewy. We add just onions to the cheese Sicilian and it's pure heaven on the tongue! Very friendly, hard-working staff. read more

We got takeout pizza from here. When we were ordering online, we were a bit confused as to what bk bacon was, but learned it was breakfast bacon after calling. We got a large cheese, pineapple, and bk bacon pizza and a sausage and mushroom calzone. I found the pizza to be pretty fine, however, the calzone was amazing. The fennel in the sausage was just right and the whole calzone was creamy and delicious. While I liked the pizza, I really loved the calzone. I highly recommend asking for extra marinara on the side for the calzone because it's pretty huge. read more

Lazzara's Pizza & Subs - Pineapple and bk bacon large pizza - Pizza Near Me - Emerald Isle, North Carolina

Pizza is great, fresh ingredients, not skimpy on cheese. Husband liked lasagne, I tried his and thought it was just ok. Pizza is both our favorite! read more

Pizza is great. We literally get it every time we go to EI. Love the fact they have vegan cheese!

Excellent NY style pizza. They delivered too! I was really impressed with the accuracy on the time of delivery too and the pizza was hot, which you don't often get with delivery! Will definitely be back! read more

My kids love the pizza, mozzarella sticks and even the chicken tenders are yummy! Great local place

Solid pizza, whether you want a whole pie or by-the-slice. Most shops like this (in my experience) do not have a lot of offerings for pizza by-the-slice beyond pepperoni, sausage or cheese, but Lazzara's has tons to choose from. The sandwiches are great too - especially the chicken sub with bacon and ranch. I've tried the spaghetti, and it was ok, but that's not really why you go to a pizza shop, so I'll cut them some slack there. Lazarra's gets a solid 4-stars from me! read more

Cheesy, thin but puffy crust pies. Friendly staff and outdoor tables. Definitely going back during this visit to Emerald Isle!

Great service and pizza was excellent. Crust was soft on edges and crunchy in the middle.

My brother really wanted to try the godfather 2ft pizza so he had some delivered to the house. 4 of us decided to go eat in the restaurant which has a few booths and a table that will fit about 6-8 people. The crust was crispy but also kinda soft and chewy. Their garlic knots were huge like the size of giant Cinnabons. There is a self serve drink fountain if you eat it. It took about 20 min for our order and everyone is pleasant. We heard several locals come in and there was a steady stream of people in an out. read more

See all

Best pizza around! Huge slices 2 will fill you up. Great selection of pizzas to choose from.

I was working my way down the North Carolina coast when I decided it was time to stop for lunch. I wasn't looking for anything fancy or expensive so I decided that a slice of pizza would be a good choice. I just happened to see this restaurant as I was going down the road so I decided to stop in. Nice small little neighborhood pizza place. Obviously very popular with the local working crowd which is always a good sign to me. The small display case in the front of the store was packed with great looking food! I decided to have two slices of pizzas, a slice of meat lovers and a slice of mushroom, and a drink. They were both very good with ample toppings. In reality one slice of their very, very large pizza was a lot of food. Would I go back there again when I'm in the area? - absolutely!! There's a limited amount of indoor seating and for those that want to eat outside there's plenty of outdoor seating as well! read more

Lazzara's Pizza & Subs - Mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Emerald Isle, North Carolina

See all

Waited 2.5 hours on a pizza that never arrived. Finally got someone to answer the phone and was told it would be another 45 minutes or more. We canceled the order, and now have TWO CHARGES on my card. How can you bill out something that hasn't even been made yet...TWICE! And now the restaurant is closed for 2 days!! Never again. read more

Amazing pizza and calzones! We ordered for takeout and the food was perfect. We ordered online and the food was made perfectly and was hot and fresh when we picked it up. Great quality too! The restaurant was hard to find along the row of stores, but we followed our nose and saw the storefront. read more

60$ for 3 pizzas,then she shoved card machine in my face for 20% tip.Hell no It's not that good Tooo rich for my blood My kids said never again which was fine with me I don't like posting this but dang read more

Great pizza....everything is so fresh and light. Great service to boot. So very good. read more

Lazzara's Pizza & Subs - VEGGIE pizza w sausage - Pizza Near Me - Emerald Isle, North Carolina

All we got was a medium pepperoni pizza & it could definitely feed three women!! It was so delicious, fresh & well prepared! We called to place the order for carry out & they said 30 minutes, it took a little less than that!! There's lots of tables for outdoor seating (shared with the ice cream place next door) & a few tables inside as well! We took it to-go for a picnic on the beach!! read more

Lazzara's Pizza & Subs - Medium pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Emerald Isle, North Carolina

We ordered three large pizzas for a group. The pizzas were very tasty. We did take out. The staff were very polite. The people that had pizza had many good things to say. read more

Placed an online order for 2 pizzas at 5:30. They confirmed they would be ready to pick up in 2 hours. It's 8:00 and they haven't even fired them yet. They need some adults to run this business. Finally got our food. Back at the house started eating. There was a STAPLE in my salad. read more

Lazzara's Pizza & Subs - The staple that was in my salad. - Pizza Near Me - Emerald Isle, North Carolina

Best supreme pizza! And the bread knots are always delicious with lasagna. Go here once a month and it never disappoints! Delicious!

4+ great sub italian The only thing that would have made it better would have been a warm toasted roll with the cheese melted Fresh garden salad with chicken was great Definitely we will be back next trip read more

Their food is delicious and staff is great! I always pick up or eat in. I haven't used the delivery.

I wish I had better things to say about this place. I couldn't decide what I was in the mood for and a local told me this was the best pizza place around. I ordered online. I ordered an Italian sub and a salad with ranch dressing. When I got there to pick it up I saw they had slices so I wanted to try a bite of their pizza. The slice was over $4.00. They heated it and I tried it right away. The crust was so hard I couldn't eat it. The actual pizza had a decent taste. The sub was so plain and the deli meat tasted so cheap. The bread was average. The onions on the salad stunk so bad. They were comparable to hot dog onions and not red onions. The worst of all was the ranch dressing. Probably the worst ranch I ever had. Even bad ranch is good. This was awful. Tasted like creamy Italian. The interior is a small, dingy place. The servers were nice and even called me about a question with my order. I will definitely not be eating here again. I barely ate anything. read more

See all

This place was supposed to be one of the best and I can't lie. It was pretty good, but there were some things that I would definitely change. I would ask for your pizza to be a little bit more cooked when I got it. The dough was very chewy and a little bit undercooked and I would ask for the garlic knots as well to be cooked a little bit longer because it's very doughy and it just needs to be cooked a little longer the service was great. I would say you need to plan your visits there because the lines are very long on the weekends and if you or through the phone, you'll have to wait like an hour to an hour and a half. the restaurant inside was pretty clean and lots of seating but overall a good experience with a few minor changes read more

Outstanding pizza. Outstanding service. Made a mistake on the online order system, got a call a minute later asking us if we really wanted as much as ordered- we didn't. Very nice. The pizza is really good. Dough was tasty and airy. Toppings good. The sauce was just slightly sweet but very good. read more

This is the crap pizza of my dreams. Like, it's not amazing. It's not any particular style. Maybe New England generally, pseudo new york, maybe a bit of greek diner. Garbage toppings, but tasty ones. Same with the rest of the menu. They have mastered the genre. Impressive especially in a location with such absolute nasty dirt as Michelangelo's continuing to exist. Like, how? I really feel a bit bad doing 4 * due to how well they accomplish their thing (tm), but their thing (tm) is sooooo unambitious. There's a historical bit of early pandemic times that makes me also itchy about this. But they sell good stuff by the slice, they have silly large pizzas available, and their tomato and garlic slices are the shit. Thank you, Lazzara's. May my penance some day be adequate to justify eating here so much. read more

Ordered a mushroom pizza. Done in 15 minutes. I have never seen a pizza with so many mushrooms. Being from NJ, I have had my fair share of great pizza. We were pleasantly surprised at how much we enjoyed this pizza!! Would definitely recommend read more

Absolutely love their pizza. It's no wonder they are rated the best on Yelp. Their pizza sauce is by far the best around. It's the only crust I actually will eat. My dogs would prefer we order elsewhere so they can eat the crust. Perfect pepperoni and cheese. All around 5 star pizza read more

Lazzara's Pizza & Subs - Meat lovers and mushroom yummy - Pizza Near Me - Emerald Isle, North Carolina

See all

Pizza was great and the slices are HUGE! The rest of the family got the garlic knots and they were great also!

Their pizza and heroes are the best locally and the slices are large. The staff are always friendly, and service is quick.

Great pizza, fast service!!! The Godfather pizza is amazing, make sure you have a large enough vehicle to carry it home read more

Ordered pizza from here one night. It was a Saturday night and must have been busy! It was about an hour for delivery, but about the same for carry out. The pizza is good. Not the best I've ever had, but pretty good. I also ordered a Greek salad, it was pretty average. Super friendly staff on the phone, and the large pizza was great for the price. Highly recommend if you're looking for a night in and don't feel like cooking! read more

Lazzara's Pizza & Subs - Large pizza - Pizza Near Me - Emerald Isle, North Carolina

This pizza is soooo good! The kids were excited to see the giant pizza too! We were vacationing there so I came home and tried to find another similar local to me. Highly recommend! read more

Lazzara's Pizza & Subs - HUGE soooo good! - Pizza Near Me - Emerald Isle, North Carolina

My friends and I are camping in Emerald Isle and decided to make dinner easy one night and order from Lazzara's, which is conveniently right across the street. Our order was big (lots of kids) - they had everything ready for pick up in about 40 minutes - they were very busy. Customer service was friendly, and the food was delicious. We will definitely order from here again. Highly recommend! read more