On the road again & kept hearing about these homemade Mozzarella Cheese Stix from this local pizzeria...so I had to try it out! Yes, if you are in The New Bern area and have a craving for Pizza - This is the SPOT! 1st they told me it would be about 40 min & they showed up w/in 25-30min!!! The Mozz Stix are amazing (see pics). You can order a 3 or 6 piece & comes w/ pizza sauce for dipping. Also ordered a slice of cheese just to check out their sauce & style - great thin crust w/ flavorful sauce & extremely large slices for $2.95. Finally had to check out the Stromboli. Ordered the Steak & Cheese and it did not disappoint. Overall this spot is a local hidden gem w/ homemade flavorful items at a great price range. Definitely worth a try if you are in the area! read more

See all

I moved to New Bern from New Jersey four years ago, and I'm so grateful to have found this little piece of home away from home. The pizza is exceptionally good, the garlic knots are delicious, and the mozzarella sticks are honestly some of the best fried cheese I've ever had. Don't sleep on their subs or salads either! I've had the Italian sub and the steak and cheese salad with oil and vinegar as the dressing--both are absolutely spot-on every time. There are a few tables available for dine-in, and if you live in River Bend (the neighborhood it's located in), they offer delivery right to your door. Ordering for pickup is also super easy and convenient. read more

Great meat calzone and garlic knots. Pizza was decent. Sauce could have been a bit more flavorful, but still delicious. Will add to our pizza rotation :) read more

Terrible food. I ordered the Veggie pizza and it tasted like cardboard. The cheese I'm pretty sure just tasted like the bread even though the pizza was fresh out of the oven. Terribly expensive, for extremely low quality. Cashier basically started off insinuating to-go when we wanted to dine in. Lack of clarity in their menus pricing, plus $2 per topping is RIDICULOUS. They also make you tip up front, which is another real shame. Overall very empty environment around lunchtime with not many customers, probably due to very poor tasting food. read more

Best calzone I've ever had! Workers are so very pleasant. Will definitely take the drive back to New Bern to eat here. read more

Panichelli’s Pizzeria - Pepperoni calzone - Italian Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

food was great best mott sticks i've had service was great ambiance was good so good read more

Panichelli’s Pizzeria - pepperoni and bacon pizza - Italian Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

We have loved the food and the great customer service since the very beginning. The food is awesome! Eating there with my daughter and her family when they come to visit has become new family tradition. Kudos to Josh! read more

Panichelli’s Pizzeria - Very clean! - Italian Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

See all

Still my favorite pizza in town. Great service and the owner is very friendly. I just tried their sandwiches and they are outstanding as well. read more

Headed to DMV and decided to find a new place to try out. I've heard a lot about this place but never went. Today I changed that and this is what it was like. It's hidden in the corner. You look at it and you don't expect much. As you enter the door, greeted straight away by more than one person. The place is pretty open inside and whoever is doing the cleaning, they are doing it right. The whole place was clean all the way to the restrooms. You figure out what you want from a decent variety. The menu is pictured on here. Then order at the counter and they bring it to you. The staff was awesome here. Friendly and helpful. Of course I tried the mozzarella sticks which they made themselves. I have no words for what it is they do. The crust is so crisp and different. The cheese pulls so nicely. They can be a meal all in themselves. They are a must try. We also had a 20" pepperoni. Wow is what I'll say. The crust is crisp. The grease isn't to much and all over. Plenty of pepperoni and the cheese was real. The sauce isn't to sweet or spicy, it's kinda what I've been looking for. I wanted more of it but I'd have exploded. Lol. My daughter had the chicken Alfredo and enjoyed it much. She said the noodles tasted homemade and the chicken was fresh. She also questioned if the sauce was made from scratch. The garlic knots were large and full of flavor. I don't know if they are made from scratch but they did not taste frozen. Perfect amount of garlic flavor. Needless to say, if you've read all this then you know that this place was worth stopping at. I'll be back for sure because I can't resist those mozzarella sticks. Thanks y'all for the great food and service. They deserve more credit then what they are getting. read more

See all

River Bend's go to for NY style pizza! Our favorite! Thank you Panichelli's for always delivering great food and a good spot for the kids to meet up. Interior is older and could do with an update but we love it! read more

Excellent pizza and steak and cheese subs! A regular delivery spot for us when we don't want to cook or go out. Quick and friendly service. We dinned inside once and it was a little warmer than what I prefer. Would recommend. read more

The best pizza I've had in NC. My husband and I always grab some when we're in New Bern. Awesome staff, great service, and a cozy atmosphere. read more

Panichelli’s Pizzeria - Large pepperoni pizza - Italian Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

The food is great the service is awesome and what they do with cheese sticks is unbelievable. I highly recommend this place.

My search is over for the best Pizza in the New Bern area. Pannichelli's Pizzeria checked off my preferred pizza tastes..,NY/NJ style with a balanced sauce topped with flavorful Cheese and quality toppings. The fried Mozzarella and Garlic Knots appetizers just add to the venture across town. This gem is nestled in a small strip center in River Bend. Nothing fancy but great Italian food. We absolutely will be back. read more

This place is so good and the people are super nice patient and helpful. The prices are great and food came out piping hot. The fries are the battered fries that I like. I'd come here again. 10/10 recommend. read more

Panichelli’s Pizzeria - Menu - Italian Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

If you are craving NY style thin, foldable, delicious pizza with great friendly staff, this is the place!!! Highly recommend the cheese sticks as well! read more

My boyfriend and I just recently discovered this pizzeria and I'm so glad we did! We have had it twice already and the food does not disappoint. The mozzarella sticks are fresh and homemade and the pizza is always cooked to perfection. If you are around I definitely suggest stopping by and trying it out or ordering it to-go. read more

Panichelli’s Pizzeria - Meat Cravers 18" Pizza - Italian Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

See all

Good my pizza. I liked it. The folks are nice. I wish it had more of an old school Italian restaurant feel to it because the food is right on the money. read more

Greasy and no flavor!!!!! Not good and charged me even though I threw up! Not EVER, AGAIN!!!!!!! New Bern's dining is pitiful!!!!!!

Yes, and it is close to me when I come into town. Go there several times a week. I like most everything they serve. They are so cute as they really try to take care of the customers. They will take your food to your car if doing take out. Way to go! read more

Good food, good people. Fast service. Wonderful local owned business right here in River Bend! Best mozzie sticks EVER!!!

Nothing to brag about. Got a slice with pepperoni and mushroom. Pretty standard pizza. The slice had maybe six tiny mushrooms on it but plenty of pepperoni. They serve thin crust pizza with just enough sauce to cover it. No more. I won't be going back soon unless I'm in the neighborhood. Not worth it. I think Pizza Hut has tastier pizza. read more

I'm so glad we decided to stop here for lunch, on our way to our Airbnb because this place is legit! We had the appetizer trio with hand coated mozzarella, chicken bites and onion rings, and that was on point. We also had a couple slices of NY Style pizza & ordered pasta to go for dinner, 10 out of 10, highly recommend! The vibe is family friendly and warm, and the young gentleman is super sweet and friendly. Food comes out hot and fresh. I would like to have taken pics but, we were hangry, ha. read more

We decided to try this place out due to the reviews. Our family absolutely loves pizza and we're not that easy to impress. We have loved absolutely everything we've tried here. Delivery takes about 25 minutes and they're always so nice. Pizza is amazing!!!! We had a large pepperoni. The slices are big they don't skimp on ingredients, whatsoever. Subs are so good. We've specifically tried the meatball, chicken Cesar, and Italian sub. The calzones are great too! Chocolate dipped Cannolis are the best too, Husband loves them. We can't get enough of this place. I'm literally craving it writing the review! read more

The struggle is real when it comes to finding good pizza in the south, but Panichelli's got it right! Started off with the garlic knots & handbreaded mozz sticks - huge portions for a great price, sauce is good, everything piping hot. For entrees we ordered a 14" pizza, a calzone, and the baked ziti. Everything cooked to perfection, crispy yet chewy crust on the pizza, overly stuffed calzone, and great portion of pasta & garlic bread! Once again everything was piping hot & fresh, generous portions, lots of dipping sauce. Highly recommend to anyone missing good NY style Italian! read more

Always our go-to for pizza when we don't want to cook - always, always order the cheese sticks and garlic knots for sides. Great pizza!

Do it, just do it. Order delivery or takeout from these guys. We made the mistake of thinking there was no good pizza in the south. Coming from New York City our pizza expectations are unreasonable. But this place is as close as you can get to a New York slice. We had the bbq chicken pizza with pineapple, a white pizza and pepperoni. All amazing. The pizzas are big, and I mean big. A medium is your typical large. We're beyond pleased with our new found gem. Thank you Yelp and other reviewers for the great find! read more

Amazing quality for prices. Super happy to have in riverbend. They will also deliver for free in neighborhood.

The cheesesticks are amazing!! Biggest one I have ever seen and full of cheese and only lightly breaded. Every time I visit my brother we grab an order. read more

Found this gem on Yelp during an East Coast road trip. After all the seafood in the South, I needed pizza! It was not fancy and I was a bit concerned when I walked in but this place had some of the best pizza I have ever had in my life - even WITH the canned mushrooms (vs fresh). The crust. The crust is this magical sphere of crispness that spoke to my pizza-loving soul. We ordered the sausage & mushroom. Couldn't recommend it more. Might have to relocate to the area just so I can eat here again. And again! Staff was polite and helpful. Try this place! They deliver! read more

Awesome little spot, great well done crust on my pie, and nice people I was just passing through on vacation and they had great hospitality.

Honestly our favorite pizza place in town. They are always helpful and courteous and the pizza is so good! Not to mention the cheese sticks!! I recommend to everyone when asking about pizza in New Bern. Probably the best kept secret around. read more

The pizza here has a really nice taste and thin and crispy. I would deffinitely recommend this pizzeria.

Great service and pretty good NY style pizza. As a New Yorker, I enjoyed the thin crispy crust and sauce. I would definitely order again.

Best advice? Just go. And keep going. It's THAT good. And I'm from NY. This is as close to home as you'll get in the ENC.

Best pizza in town. The large is more like an XL. Great ingredients. Great customer service.

I wouldn't normally give five stars on a first visit. This pizzeria delivers but not the 6 miles away where I was in a hotel. Based on the five star rating that others have given it I decided to order a pie and pick it up. I arrive at the restaurant before the pie was ready and paid for it in advance. The young lady on the register was very courteous and friendly. I asked for paper plates napkins and crushed red pepper and she took care of all of it. She brought my pie out early. She offered to help me take it to the car and open the door for me. I got back to the hotel and ate the best pizza I've had in years. I asked for double pepperoni that's it. What I got I swear was quadruple pepperoni! The crust was not too thick and not too thin and was very crispy on the bottom. It was amazing!! I would definitely come back if I lived locally. read more

I just love the food here!! All FRESH ingredients! The chicken tenders are real cut up chicken breast battered and fried. And they make their own ranch dressing! The pizza is the owners own homemade pizza crust recipe and it's delicious!! The meats are good quality meats. The staff is extremely friendly and polite. It's nice to see that staff will open a door for you and thank you for coming. Great job guys, keep up the good work! read more

Hands down the best pizza in New Bern. The staff is always friendly and everything is always fresh.

What a great neighborhood place! Awesome eats, great delivery service, and great prices. Lots of food for the price, creating tremendous value for their customers! I highly recommend this place! read more