Sugar Hill Pizzaria

8

105

132

8 months ago

Grabbed a few pizzas plus steak and cheese to go while in town for the weekend. Food was delicious and customer service was outstanding...love Southern hospitality!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

K K.

0

42

3

7 months ago

I frequently head to Sugar Hill Pizzeria on Sunday evenings when I have work in Kinston. I always order the same thing, a supreme pizza, so I can't speak for all of the other things on their menu. But I've enjoyed delicious pizza each time I've visited. The staff is friendly and helpful. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Shane G.

0

1

0

4 months ago

Thank you to Sugar Hill Pizzeria for hooking us up with a free pizza after a long night working a gas leak outside the pizzeria. The guys from Wright Traffic of NC appreciate you greatly. The pizza is great and the staff are friendly. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rob S.

0

12

0

5 months ago

Excellent food, excellent service and a great atmosphere. Pricing is reasonable and they have the best pizza in town.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jody S.

64

578

222

3 years ago

Service was great and this restaurant is conveniently located across the street from Mother Earth Brewery. Once your order is placed and paid for you can go back to enjoying refreshments at the brewery and Sugar Hill staff will bring your order to you. I found that exceptional and really convenient. We ordered a large peperoni pizza. I wasn't a fan of the crust but everything else on the pizza (cheese, sauce, etc.) was really good. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Chelsea H.

Elite 24

22

108

262

3 years ago

Really a 3.5, but rounding up! I enjoyed the pizza! We had classic pepperoni and it's what you'd expect for NY style pizza. A good crust to sauce to cheese ratio. The side salad comes with tomato, cucumber, and onion. Unfortunately mine had several brown pieces. I also missed getting a fork, so I just sprinkled it on top of my pizza, which is actually a classic move of mine. I can't speak much to ambiance since I just ran in to pick up but it was clean and no wait. Tables inside and a few outside. Hubby said it was slightly salty. We did take out, and a small pizza with salad was more than plenty for both of us. About $22. I also love that you can order ahead online. I would totally come back! Especially to walk it across the street to the brewery. read more

Sugar Hill Pizzaria - Small pepperoni pizza - Italian Near Me - Kinston, North Carolina

Sugar Hill Pizzaria - Side salad - Italian Near Me - Kinston, North Carolina

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Tom B.

1

43

130

2 years ago

Home delivery this time - pizza was a little overcooked, however lasagna and SHP Stromboli were fantastic! Everything was ready and hot on delivery. Next time I think thick-crust pizza may better meet our mark! Thank you Sugar Hill Pizzaria! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Bradley L.

0

9

7

2 years ago

The pasta here was well made with a delicious, creamy sauce. The seasoning was perfect, and I loved the fresh toppings. The bread served on the side was warm and soft, great for dipping. The ambiance was cozy and comfortable. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rebecca S.

Elite 23

135

377

1418

4 years ago

Great spot to grab lunch with the family! We ordered the supreme pizza. It was good could've had a little more sauce & cheese. Otherwise flavor was good! Mother-in-law ordered the window with fries the wings looked and smelled really good. Nephew ordered plain pasta and the Stromboli. Stromboli looked really good too large portions. The dessert was amazing I should've grabbed photos but we ate it too fast for that! We ordered the caramel cheesecake and the Reese's pie. Both were so good! read more

Sugar Hill Pizzaria - Supreme pizza subbed jalapeños for olives - Italian Near Me - Kinston, North Carolina

See all

Helpful 6

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Jeff S.

42

188

721

4 years ago

We like to order a medium pie and head over to Mother Earth taproom with the pie. You can expect a 15-20 minute wait on Friday nights when ordering or coming inside to dine. Plenty of options beside pizza, but that seems to be our go-to choice when visiting. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Nate C.

0

4

1

4 years ago

Straight FIRE pizza. Served it up hot and even brought it to us while we were sipping at Mother Earth Brewery. Can't ask for much better than that! read more

Sugar Hill Pizzaria - Real good pizza - Italian Near Me - Kinston, North Carolina

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sue N.

0

35

6

3 years ago

We must have looked like we hadn't eaten in days since we nearly ordered everything on the menu for 3 people, but we just HAD to sample everything! Garlic Knots, Meatballs, Fried Ravioli, Mac & Cheese Bites, salads, pizza, spaghetti, manicotti, cheesecake, cake, oh my! What can I say... if you like and want New York style pizza... this is it. When the slice came out, it was just like what I've gotten in New York - and delicious! We enjoyed it tremendously and the staff was great as well...especially Sam - she is a great face of the place. Great sense of humor, helpful in describing the food (ha ha, maybe that's why we ordered so much food!) Highly recommend this place. Stop in and sit for a spell! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Donna T.

0

16

0

3 years ago

One of our local favorites! Be sure to grab a dessert too!! My favorite is the steak and cheese sub!! Hard to chose between the cheese cake or cannoli!!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Leo C.

30

57

16

3 years ago

I stopped in because I had a hr wait to charge my car ... I will be back so impressed with the food. I will drive from New Bern to eat here... love it read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Coley M.

1

24

0

3 years ago

Great place!! Pizza exactly as we asked for it Been there three times and liked it better each time Great staff just a really good place to eat!!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lisa L.

39

62

53

5 years ago

Stopped in for impromptu lunch while passing through town on errands. Ordered a large supreme and it tasted great. Thin-ish crust. Similar to Michelangelo's in Greenville (if you are familiar with that). Had about a 20 minute wait for the pizza, but it was during lunch rush so not that bad. read more

Sugar Hill Pizzaria - large supreme pizza - Italian Near Me - Kinston, North Carolina

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Everett B.

21

12

4

4 years ago

Had a slice of supreme pizza and my mother had the chicken parm sandwich. Called in the order and it was ready shortly after I arrived. The slice's topping were not really attached. Pretty sure they were added to a slice of prepared pepperoni pizza and warm for a short time. The taste was good but I chased most of the topping around the table. Next time I opt for a slice, I will get just pepperoni or cheese. Stick with the basics. My mother's chicken parm was delicious according to her. I can say the smell was great. It is a really good pizza place if ordering whole pies or sandwiches that they make for you. Best pizza in Kinston for me. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Ryan R.

25

10

0

4 years ago

Amazing wings!! Get the garlic Parmesan. They have huge slices of pizza also. I recommend them both

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jeff B.

93

827

2161

10 years ago

We stopped in last evening while traveling. We ordered their meat lovers pizza, an order of garlic knots and an order of fried mushrooms. The garlic knots were good and the fried mushrooms were pretty good but could have been out of a pre breaded bag. The pizza was really good and we were pretty excited to have found this place just by chance. The staff was cordial and it appeared they had a lot of younger folks working up front. A little more personality and positive energy would have made us feel appreciated as patrons. The interior of the restaurant was small and appeared clean (including bathroom) . The exterior deck and interior restaurant had a cool look. This place is worth a visit. read more

Sugar Hill Pizzaria - Meat Lovers pizza - Italian Near Me - Kinston, North Carolina

Sugar Hill Pizzaria - Garlic Knots - Italian Near Me - Kinston, North Carolina

Sugar Hill Pizzaria - Fried Mushrooms - Italian Near Me - Kinston, North Carolina

Sugar Hill Pizzaria - Inside with televisions and reclaimed lumber on walls. - Italian Near Me - Kinston, North Carolina

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Richard B.

0

4

0

3 years ago

Great pizza, got a pizza half supreme half peporoni, was charged $12 dollars extra for making it half and half, there are other pizza places to go to read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kim P.

Elite 21

477

269

479

7 years ago

I'm impressed. Best Garlic Parmesan wings I've had in life. EVER. I stop by whenever I'm in town because the pizza and wings are yummy. I love the high top tables and the flat screen TVs. It's perfect for a birthday party or family night out. read more

Sugar Hill Pizzaria - Garlic Parmesan wings - Italian Near Me - Kinston, North Carolina

Sugar Hill Pizzaria - Small cheese pizza - Italian Near Me - Kinston, North Carolina

See all

Helpful 4

Thanks 0

Love this 4

Oh no 0

Larry W.

0

24

7

3 years ago

Always good vegetarian option for a thin crust pizza. Friendly service and delivery to the local brewery. Thanks Sugar Hill.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Peyton G.

2

1

7 years ago

Stopped by here for a "snack" before our late night dinner reservations at Chef and the Farmer. My husband got buffalo wings and I got a slice of Greek pizza with added chicken that was to die for! Maybe one of the best slices I've ever had. Will be making another stop by here anytime we are headed toward the beach this summer read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Diana F.

2

6

2

7 years ago

Really good pizza. Hard to find great NY pizza and this fit the bill. Great atmosphere and super friendly staff. This is how big the slices are. read more

Sugar Hill Pizzaria - Veggie slice - Italian Near Me - Kinston, North Carolina

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kyle A.

132

828

3419

8 years ago

I had a salad which was iceberg lettuce with tomatoes and cucumbers plus onions. The balsamic vinaigrette dressing came on the side so you can add as much as you want and had a great sweet and tart flavor. Also croutons. It has outdoor seating. We ordered a supreme pizza which had a thin crust and lots of toppings. I Recommend this place. read more

Helpful 4

Thanks 0

Love this 5

Oh no 0

Michael M.

65

482

545

10 years ago

I originally popped in for a slice of pizza but decided at the last second to order an Italian sub. I wasn't disappointed! Very filling, flavorful and I's order it again in a heartbeat. The meats were great and the dressing is fantastic! The unsweetened iced tea was also oddly very good! Refreshing on a hot day. They have some pretty decent cannoli too. The pizza looks good and smells good, too. If I get back up here, I will hit up this place and try it. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Karen K.

0

7

1

8 years ago

Our very first visit to this Awesome Gem in Kinston NC! From the moment we were coming in the front door with my momma in a wheelchair we were greeted with such friendliness!! Our food came out hot, savory, cheesy, just the right amount of spice. Tried several appetizers, two pizzas, sandwich and fries. The Best I can remember having in a very Long time. The other customers made us feel so very part of the community. But I have to tell you no matter the great food we will be Back again soon because of Colby, Brittany and Ursula. They made our whole time there feel like we were family and not paying guests. They brought out a slice of some of the Best cheesecake I have had to celebrate my momma's 94th Birthday. To the owners...great place and Wonderful people that pass on your kindness and hospitality!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Geron W.

101

43

33

9 years ago

I was visiting Kinston, NC for work for about two weeks and I was miserable. Kinston doesn't have a lot of good eateries, everything is Bojangles, McDonald's and Sweet Tea. I'm from NY so you know I was over it!!!!! I thought All the good eateries were in Goldsboro or Greenville UNTIL I stumbled upon this diamond in a ruff. So one of the ladies at the hotel desk recommended this pizzeria and said it was better than Ny pizza, I laughed so hard and gave her the middle finger. HOW DARE SHE NOT EVEN COMPARE BUT SAY THIS PIZZA WAS BETTER THAN NY!!!!! THE NERVE OF HER, SHE MYST BE ON SOMETHING. So that night I was starving, I read all the great reviews but still wasn't moved until I tried it for myself. The first night I ordered a chicken Philly, JESUS IN HEAVEN it was everything, everything everything!!! The only problem I had was that it wasn't big enough. OH WELL!! So the next day I went for lunch and ordered two slices!!!! Son!!!!! The slices were huge and smelled like goodness. The pizza were straight SEX, it was actually better than a NY SLICE!! Huh?!! YES I SAID IT!!! So long story short I've eaten hear everyday for six days! That's how good it is, and the staff is so wonderful, this place is rocken fr fr. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Maranda W.

0

4

0

4 years ago

Soooo good! Pizza by the slice is huge! Service was quick and the ladies were so friendly! We can't wait to come back and walk over to the park also! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Charmaine J.

0

91

181

7 years ago

Food is ok here. Nothing to write home about great if you are tired of other pizza places but still go to Pizza Hut any day over this place. Update: the wings are really good but the subs are dry and no flavor no sauce and disgusting. Only reason I came back is because was at appt it was late and close by read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Billy W.

Elite 22

46

261

111

7 years ago

Holy smokes! One great pizza spot. Fresh ingredients and a great tasting pizza. The garlic knots are delicious as well. Love eating local. We will be back soon. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Johnny E.

0

20

2

5 years ago

Was in town and grabbed a pizza. Pepperoni and mushroom and it was outstanding. Was ready right in time and was very hot. Great option to have in ktown vs all the big pizza chains and their private jets. Will be back when back in town. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mallory B.

0

10

0

7 years ago

Best pizza place in Kinston! My husband and daughter love their wings and mozzarella sticks. This is also one of the only places in Kinston where you can get cheerwine so it makes me super happy! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rick R.

19

7

2

6 years ago

This place is normally awesome but the last two orders the crusts on their pizzas have been way too tough. It's not normally like that so hopefully this is something they will fix soon. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kathy C.

112

5

2

8 years ago

Really good pizza. Unless you're starving don't order a large! Went in with a party of 15 and they handled us with ease. Great place to eat in Kinston, NC read more

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Amanda W.

Elite 19

190

46

32

8 years ago

Positive first - the steak and cheese sub was really tasty. Great flavor. My husband and I ordered one to split, and waited 20 minutes before it was ready at a time that the place was not busy. So that was disappointing. Also, the sub is supposed to be served with chips, but they were just a pile of the crumbles from the bottom of the bag...also disappointing. Also seemed overpriced for what we got/the experience. We most likely won't visit again. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Conner B.

460

281

435

9 years ago

Ight like foreal doe, this place be getting me all pumped up bout expanding dat waist line on sum real shit. Like I just buss through da front doe and be like gimme dat cream pie!! Throw some toppins on it, make that shit good fam! Went here wit some co-workers, and the place was litty! Had all kinda good Italian pies on the table, garlic knot and meaty balls as well. I'm pretty sure the person that got the balls said she noticed a bit of hair in her plate, but she didn't mind and that it added to the experience. Last time I was hear I had me a couple pitchers of beer and, well, that just takes it up a notch. Especially, since I'm just a good ol mississhitty boy who likes to get drunk and throw my hoe down. Love pizza and beer, and I love sugar hill even more! Solid 4 outta 5, I'll be back. read more

Sugar Hill Pizzaria - This is America and I'll over-indulge if I want to! - Italian Near Me - Kinston, North Carolina

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 2

See more reviews

More info about Sugar Hill Pizzaria

211 N Heritage St
Kinston, NC 28501
Directions
(252) 686-8800
Call Now
Order Takeout
Start Order

Full menu

Hours

What time does Sugar Hill Pizzaria open?

Sugar Hill Pizzaria opens at 11:00 AM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.Sugar Hill Pizzaria opens at 12:00 PM on Sunday.

What time does Sugar Hill Pizzaria close?

Sugar Hill Pizzaria is closed on Monday.Sugar Hill Pizzaria closes at 9:00 PM on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.Sugar Hill Pizzaria closes at 8:00 PM on Sunday.

Mon ClosedTue-Sat 11:00 AM - 9:00 PMSun 12:00 PM - 8:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Sugar Hill Pizzaria take credit cards?

Yes, Sugar Hill Pizzaria takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Sugar Hill Pizzaria serve alcohol?

Yes, Sugar Hill Pizzaria serves alcohol. Beer & Wine Only

Indoor Amenities

Does Sugar Hill Pizzaria allow dogs?

Yes, Sugar Hill Pizzaria allows dogs.

Does Sugar Hill Pizzaria have TVs?

Yes, Sugar Hill Pizzaria has TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Sugar Hill Pizzaria have outdoor seating?

Yes, Sugar Hill Pizzaria has outdoor seating options.

Does Sugar Hill Pizzaria have parking?

Yes, Sugar Hill Pizzaria has parking options. Street Parking

Other Amenities

Does Sugar Hill Pizzaria have free WiFi?

Yes, Sugar Hill Pizzaria has free WiFi.

More Info

Health Score

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Green Basil

5.0(1 review)

2.1 mi

I have eaten here twice - spaghetti bolognese and linguine with clam sauce. Both were outstanding…read more Davide, the chef, is very talented, and authentic Italian

Olympian Restaurant

3.6(32 reviews)

0.6 mi

Good was good vegan Pizza was awesome Was referred by a…read morenurse at the hospital! Crew was nice

The best subs, lasagna, spaghetti, salad, salads, and the pita bread and Greek dressing is awesome!read more

Counter

Desserts

See all

Peach House Restaurant

4.5(57 reviews)

2.3 mi

Great food and awesome service is what you get when you dine in or carry out of this restaurant…read more They have really great sweets treats that you can see as soon as you walk in. They warmed my strawberry muffin and it was so good. My turkey sandwich was very good. It was soft and tender and great experience. I highly recommend this place for lunch if you're ever in KINSTON North Carolina.

After a fun day at a local Jeep event bestie and I decided to give Peach House Restaurant and we…read morewere so glad we did! The restaurant was clean with beautiful decor inside, nice clean bathroom (a definite plus), and friendly staff that were happy to help! Bestie and I both ordered a Bird Dawg Club with pasta salad. Every layer of the Bird Dawg Club was fresh, crisp, and flavorful, making me want to go buy some Boar's Head deli meat the next time I'm at the store! The pasta salad was fresh as well with a nice Italian Vinaigrette. I got a Southern pecan bar for dessert which was ok but you know not everyone makes pecan pie bars to my likings. The Guinness Cream Cheese brownie really stole the show as it was warmed and I'm so glad my bestie shared a bite with me! We will be back the next time we are rolling through town!

Decor

Bird Dawg Club, pickle spear, and pasta salad. Look at how fresh that tomato was for March!

See all

Outdoor seating

Lily's Pizza

4.4(11 reviews)

1.7 mi

Lily's Pizza & Subs also serves burgers and pasta dishes! The title of this business is incomplete…read moreand incorrect. Their ambiance is relaxing and the restaurant has been renovated. It is incredibly clean and inviting! Service is excellent, though I recommend calling your order in ahead of you're in a rush. I love it! My favorite is their Steak & Cheese Subs, all the way!

Great food and great service. Reasonable pricing for quality food! The ambiance is welcoming and…read morewell maintained.

The restaurant's interior has been completely renovated and is well-managed by the owners.

See all

I *heart* Lily's pizza and subs

Pizza Villa

3.8(36 reviews)

1.2 mi

Great food, we had the pizza, spaghetti, and the grilled chicken Alfredo…read more Great service, kept our drinks filled. Great atmosphere, eclectic decorations!

Delicious pizza crackers, we had it with pizza sauce and ranch…read more Delicious pizza, we had a medium pepperoni. Grilled chicken on the fettucini alfredo was the most tender and tasty ive had. Lynne had the spaghetti with meat sauce, and said it was delicious. The staff was friendly and informative. They kept our drinks filled. The eclectic decorations, apparently pulled from old businesses in the area made for a great atmosphere.

See all

Little G's Pizza & Subs

2.7(10 reviews)

4.6 mi

Yum yum yum yum The best sub…read more The best service The best restaurant The best. The best. You can try

Someone once said that this restaurant is not delicious. So I want to experiment. Is it really like…read morewhat people say? Just found out that they have changed management with a new chef. It's really delicious. Confirmed.

This is the the wrong kind of sub

See all

Ruby Tuesday

2.2(55 reviews)

3.2 mi

This is me and my Fiancé's 3rd time coming to this Ruby Tuesday and we absolutely love it every…read moretime! It's one of our favorite places to go. Our server was Jazmin and she was amazing! Very attentive and very nice! The food was also so delicious as always. Comparing to other similar restaurants Ruby Tuesdays easily surpasses them. The restaurant itself is clean and ascetically pleasing. Another thing is how could you pass up on the amazing deals they offer! As a father of 5, kids eat free is almost unheard these days. But here it's every Tuesday! Today's deal was 6.99 for a smash burger and fries. You spend more than that at fast food these days! Love this place and highly recommended:)

Food has been great 12 of 12 visits Service is good place…read moreseems clean Staff is friendly A go to I'm Kinston

See all

Little J's Pizza & Subs

4.4(23 reviews)

11.6 mi

The lasagna is great the staff not so much . I was standing at the counter for 15 minutes before…read moreanyone asked what I wanted. They were busy talking about people.

Great local spot -- always fresh and well prepared. There are daily specials that beat any fast…read morefood places hands down on quality, taste, and even price.

Meatball sub

House special

See all

Greg's Pizza

3.9(31 reviews)

11.3 mi

Don't order the garlic bread. It's just toasted bread with nothing on it and it's a waste of money…read more All their other food usually good. Just a warning so you don't waste your time.

PLEASE SHARE: I'm…read moregoing to tell about the experience we just encountered with Greg's Pizza in Grifton. Side note: my daughter requires a service dog and he had his vest on clearly stating he was a service dog. There were NO other customers in the restaurant and they close at 9. We walked in with the dog and a young arrogant gentleman immediately said, "NO-UH UH...we are closed. No dogs allowed. We're closed. We're not serving you." An older gentleman, noticing the service dog vest, jumped up immediately and said, "No, we're not closed. We will serve you, have a seat!" And the other gentleman said, "No, we're closed and we're not serving them with a dog. Come back next time and we'll gladly serve you." I looked at the older gentleman and thanked him for his kindness and then I looked at the younger gentleman and said, "Let me tell you one thing, you won't ever have to worry about us coming back here again and you will never get a dime from us. You're nothing but an arrogant asshole and it's obvious you don't want our business and I will be making a Facebook post and blasting how rude you were." He said, "I don't care!" And I said, "well it's a good thing, because it's getting posted. Have a good day asshole!" And I walked out.

Menu

See all

My chef salad from Greg's they charged me $ 7.00 for this as takeout. Wife and I was so disappointed never again...

Domino's Pizza

3.2(13 reviews)

1.0 mi

It was good not necessarily NY as we've lived there and there is nothing like it, but it was good…read more The service and the crew just the atmosphere of the store when I went to pick it up FIVE STARS!!! That will bring me back time and time again !!

We had to stay in Kinston at a hotel. We decided to order Garlic Twists and a pizza. The driver…read morecalled at 7:55 and said thru had just walked into the hotel. He never arrived by 8:05 so I walked down. He was finally entering the hotel lobby. He handed me the boxes and walked away. Returned to the room and found that there was no marinara. I tried to call the driver thinking it was in the car, no answer. Called the store every time someone FINALLY answered they would say "please hold" and hang up. The fifth attempt someone answered I explained they said hold please, and hung up. This is the worst customer service and experience ever!!

See all

Heavy sauce, greasy crust, light toppings and a manger that could care less. Totinos pizza would have been better

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

5 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Armando K.

7

8

6

2 years ago

The pizza had a perfect thin crust with a nice crunch. The cheese was rich and melted beautifully, and the sauce had just the right amount of tang. The toppings were fresh, and they didn't skimp on them. Service was quick, and the place had a cozy, welcoming feel. read more

James Alston

0

5

0

1 year ago

That was the most disgusting food in Kingston do not waste your money. You make better time throwing your money in the news river.

Staci B.

0

2

0

9 years ago

Delicious! Pizza, fries, subs, ... it's all great!

A P.

0

3

0

8 years ago

Good pizza, friendly folks. Nice atmosphere.

Elisabeth M.

33

9

0

8 years ago

Awesome food and a great atmosphere!

Sugar Hill Pizzaria - italian - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Sugar Hill Pizzaria also viewed

Panichelli’s Pizzeria

4.8

(77 reviews)

we had the mozzarella sticks and the hawaiian pizza very…read moretasty and loved the friendly service. definitely recommend and we will be back

Had our first pizza from Panichelli's today. Ordered the thin and crispy supreme and it was…read moredelicious. The service is also excellent. I highly recommend. I don't understand why River Bend residents don't support them more.

Carolina Pizzeria And Grill

4.7

(3 reviews)

Such a funny little place, I was a little concerned but I ordered the chicken pita and some fries…read moreand the chicken pita was really delicious! The fries were decent but had zero salt so I added my own and some ketchup and I ended up eating way too much. A lot of food at a decent price and it's good!

I usually get the cheesesteak all the way and it is delicious. They put plenty of meat on the sub…read moreand it is always consistent. The staff is very friendly and helpful too.

Jerry's Family Restaurant

4.8

(8 reviews)

Visiting West Craven MX and made a stop at Jerry's for pizza! The pizza was delicious NY style with…read moregenerous cheese and toppings! Very casual atmosphere, but we loved the come as you no frills atmosphere! The staff was also very friendly we'd definitely visit again.

Great local shop with the good greasy pizza. Calzones and Stromboli's are nice too! They know what…read morethey do well and keep to that with minimal menu offerings.

Thirty Seventh Street Pizzaria & Pasta

3.2

(118 reviews)

37th Street Pizzeria is a fantastic restaurant in the New Bern area. The prices are very…read morereasonable. The food is delicious. The staff is always so friendly and courteous. You sit down at a table and the staff and the atmosphere makes you feel like you are sitting down at your Italian grandma's kitchen on Sundays. It's a very easy restaurant to make it to. They're located right on Neuse boulevard, past the traffic light on Simmons. Overall this place is great and convenient. I would definitely recommend keeping 37th Street in your queue for a future visit. You will have a happy full tummy afterwards.

Place never fails me. The atmosphere is great. The restaurant is clean as to what I see. There are…read morenever many empty seats. That's good. The staff has always been pleasant and professional. The food is exceptional. I've ordered quite a bit here and no matter what it is, it never fails to hit home. Fresh and hot always. The taste is perfect and the crisp on the pizzas is great. I'll always come back here.

Benvenuto a Mimmo's Pizza-n-Pasta

4.1

(26 reviews)

Mimmo's is the full, correct name of this Italian Restaurant. Their food is always good! Our server…read morewas very attentive without being overbearing. We were celebrating a birthday, so she even offered to keep the cake in their kitchen while we enjoyed our meals! The dining room is quiet and enjoyable, with private dining available.

The best pizza in Goldsboro! I love this place! Service is great . They are so friendly. the pizza…read morecant be beat! Pizza by the slice too!

Pizza Plus

3.4

(7 reviews)

Always a good pizza and great service !! I am a regular customer.i recommend this place to make…read moreeverybody.

This was my first time trying pizza plus I must say it was really tasty! I loved the fact that the…read moretoppings were all smaller and they loaded the pizza down with them! The woman who took my order was very nice and patient with me since I had never ate there before. I got it delivered to my house and it came in a timely manner

Paula's Italian Restaurant&Pizza

3.6

(127 reviews)

Love the food the atmosphere the service everything is lovely. I enjoy coming and eating there. I'm…read morecoming this week to get chicken Parmesan.

Our service; Audrey was amazing, the ambiance was phenomenal and the food was awesome. Perhaps…read morefresh shaved Parmesan at the table would elevate the experience to a 6 out of 5 but as it is I would highly recommend this to anyone that loves authentic Italian food.

Aggie Pizza

3.9

(8 reviews)

Good food and local! Nice mom and pop eatery! We get pizza and subs from here often.read more

Aggies in Trenton - horrible customer service! online hours…read morestate 8:30 when I called at 7:50 the lady answer "Aggies, where closed" I responded with "oh, online it states 8:30" women responded "nope, 8". The women was extremely rude, huffing and puffing on the phone like I was an issue. I reminded her it wasn't even 8, it was 10 minutes till closing and there was no reason to be rude! (not that I would have ordered that close to closing anyways, but it was the point of the matter). She continued to argue with me about the fact that is was "close enough to 8". I don't know the owner to this Aggies, but if you see this I highly recommend looking into the women working "closing" on June 11th 2021. Its bad when the only "fast food" type restaurant in Trenton is staffed with ignorant people!

La Casetta

3.8

(155 reviews)

I recently coordinated the food for our company's annual summit. We have staff from across the…read morecountry come to New Bern to work together in person to brainstorm, socialize, and engage in professional development. This year, there were 13 of us, sharing multiple meals together. We've ordered lunch for our smaller staff on multiple occasions, always for take-out. Organizing the buffet-style dinner for the team was a wonderful experience. I went into the restaurant to meet with Francesco to go over the menu. He made recommendations on what would work best with the buffet style, and we came up with a wonderful selection. The entire process was well organized and simple. The staff on the night of our event was fabulous. We sat in the semi-private space. Our server and the bar staff were all on top of their game. As always, the food was phenomenal! Our food allergies were accommodated well (Tree Nuts and Strawberries). The staff even provided some takeout containers for some of our staff to take home leftovers to family. Soup-to-nuts, this was a fantastic experience and we will definitely consider La Casetta for our events in the future.

Bestie and I swung by for an impromptu lunch of Italian food on a weekday, as she had been here…read moreonce before and raved about it. We were promptly seated after ogling the dessert case (next time I'm taking something sweet to go) and our server brought out 2 slices of bread. No silverware or napkins. Just bread. I mean I could've easily licked my fingers clean after tasting that pillowy soft bread but still. The bread had was warm and flavored with a little olive oil and Italian seasonings, and was phenomenal. I mean I honestly don't know how they got a crispy yet soft crust, along with a soft pillowy inside. I probably could've wolfed down at least 4 slices had I not ordered pasta. Bestie and I both ordered what she had had previously, the three four cheese tortellini add meatballs. The tortellini and the white sauce were so delicious that I couldn't wait to cut into the meatballs! Unfortunately the meatballs were cold in the middle so I had to cut them up into small pieces in order to let the hot pasta and Alfredo sauce warm them up. Hey we all make mistakes right? The flavor and texture of the meatballs were pretty good tho once they were heated through. As I finished up my meal I bit into something hard and when I took it out of my mouth it looked like a small piece of wood. I wasn't going to complain but my bestie called the server over to alert her, who said it was a pine nut. I'm not sure why there was one random supposed pine nut in my dish but whatever. Maybe they were just having an off day. I'll give them another try next time we are back in New Bern.

John’s Pizza

3.7

(10 reviews)