Ordered calamari pizza for pick up. Not heavy like most pizza, great flavors. Staff was friendly and got me my order right away. The display case has a bunch of really yummy looking pies. Will definitely come back to try other dishes. read more

I'm not sure where these raving reviews came from but it's why I came to try the place. We used to come to Olive Press Eatery and miss it greatly. At first look the outdoor seating was very nice on a beautiful Friday night. We asked for a table and were given a wait time given the packed place but it was awkward where we were supposed to wait. When a table was getting up we were told to go grab the table (3 chairs for 7 ppl) and tried to get our own chairs from different tables until there were enough for us to sit. There was only one gentleman taking orders and he was very irritated with anything and everything. Didn't want to take our drink order and insisted we give him our entire order at once (vs taking appetizer order n coming back to take our meal orders). Then told us to go grab our own drinks from the fridge inside- so we sent the kids in (middle schoolers not rowdy or rude). The food didn't all come at once, my friend got the wrong panini 2 times and my meal was forgotten even after a reminder. We had sent an over cooked burger back and my friend asked for the manager, the waiter replied he was the owner. Didn't seem like it since he wasn't very customer service friendly. I had to walk in and ask again for my friends panini and my pizza. Everyone else had finished their meals and I contemplated just going home and eating something else but I tried to be patient as I know they are fairly new. Not once did we receive an apology for the mistakes or delays. When the kids went in to ask for containers to put their leftovers in, the "owner" ignored them!!! They had to ask a lady who didn't speak English but she was able to help them and gave them containers. Again we sat there waiting for the "owner" to acknowledge us so we can pay. When he came to get the card he started to give an apology and blame it on being short staffed. My friend tried to tell him the best apology was to simply be nice and not as rude as he has been to us- and he snapped back something in a heavy accent we couldn't understand and he dashed away. The food was OK - not the tastiest and not the worst. But I couldn't get over the rudeness and delay. I'm not sure I'll try this place again but it's unfortunate because the location is perfect for a summer evening meal. read more

Always a good meal! Especially love the mussels appetizer and the fried calamari. Hopefully they will put baked clams on the menu soon! Good service and quite busy all the time. Love going there! read more

See all

Highly recommend!! I was visiting New Jersey for a college football game and went searching for a pizza place because where I'm from (Washington, DC), there isn't a lot of good pizza. Ended up at Che Pizza. I was immediately impressed by the ambiance (very hole-in-the-wall Italian vibe) and the service. The owner is lively, fun, and clearly passionate about Italian food. He was extremely helpful giving recommendations from a robust menu of options. I ended up with a slice of pizza with sausage and peppersand the chicken Parmesan sandwich. Both were very good. read more

Che Pizza - Kitchen/food - Pizza Near Me - Metuchen, New Jersey

See all

Definitely one of the top new hitters of restaurants that have arrived in 2022. There is a surprising variety of pizza and each of them baked to perfection. I recommend the vodka slice. You also can't go wrong with their pastas, we had the gnocchi bolognese and the pasta arriabata both of which were excellent. read more

Che Pizza - Gnocchi bolognese - Pizza Near Me - Metuchen, New Jersey

See all

I had gnocchi and my friend had Cesar salad. Both tasted amazing. I know there's not much to do in Cesar salad but my friend some how felt everything was fresh and tasted great. I love gnocchi but not a lot of places have it. Here not only was it available but it tasted amazing. I loved it. The quantity was also big enough that 2 people could have shared. They also had big selection of pizzas but of course, we did not try. Will be back next time. read more

Clean, bright and playing the World Cup soccer final on delay we were at the Plaza for a town event and walked into Che Pizza. With a full menu of delicious options, we took a look at the yummy pizza offerings first. Hubby had the Square Margarita pizza and I had a slice of veggie. Nicely warmed up, it still felt fresh and tasty. Will be coming back! read more

See all

On a slow decline after being uniformly excellent since it opened. Caesar salads are swimming in dressing. Penne arrabbiata sauce is creamy now? The spices in the meatballs don't mesh with Italian fare. Pizza has a different crust and the ratio of toppings has changed. Overall, it just isn't as good. What happened to the chef? read more

Great food, very tasty lots of different food choices and the have hazelnut gelato Good for lunch and dinner. read more

Their tomato slice, Bomba, Pasta arrabiata are some of my family's favorites. So so good!! But above all their service and care for their patrons is what keeps us coming back! Also don't sleep on their frozen espressos! read more

First time visiting. I would recommend it. We ordered 4 slices and a pasta. Everything was delicious. The slices were pretty large. I would suggest a veggie option with onions and peppers too. The inside is super chill. When you walk-in you see their large pizza display. More than enough space to dine-in with outdoor seating area. Music was lively- international. The person behind the counter was very nice, friendly and quick to suggest vegan options. Price for total with 2 bottles drinks was approx $40 Felt really taken care of here. Great find. read more

See all

Best Italian in Metuchen, NJ. ALWAYS OUR FIRST STOP when we visit from Hawaii. Generous servings. Very friendly owner and employees.

First of all the pizza didn't look good second of all the girl behind the counter couldn't even speak English what poor representation of a pizza place than the person you meet at the counter whoever wrote all of those good reviews had to have been the friends of the owner cuz I don't see anything that's four and a half star about this place read more

Great service and even better food. Everything we've gotten is delicious. It's our go-to pizza place.

It's my favorite place in town! They are my wonderful, happy neighbors who never serve without their smiles... Yummiest pizzas in Metuchen... read more

You might not think of this as a place to get coffee and a dessert but it is a nice place to stop and get an awesome espresso. Very relaxed and excellent service. read more

Service is excellent and everyone in the place is friendly so off the bat that's a plus. I've had calamari, chicken parm, napolitano panini, and pizza of course. Calamari was cooked perfectly but lacked some flavor, just a bit of salt but I like salty. Chicken parm was great. To me, a good chicken parm has great bread and their bread on the chicken parm is great! Crunchy but soft and pillowy inside. Panini, not good. Again the bread and fresh ingredients make a good panini. In this case, the bread used was like sandwich bread. Focaccia would have made a wold of difference. Pizza. I love Delucia's so that's what I'm comparing it to. Too soggy and doughy for me but to each his own when it comes to pizza. Sure I'd eat there again but not for a while. Good and prompt service, nice folks and a good local neighborhood spot. read more

The food is good but the service was subpar. I ordered rice balls as an appetizer and meatball parm sub for my entree. My son ordered the gnocchi. My order came out within 20 mins of ordering. The server brought my son his side salad while I was eating my meal. 15 mins past and we flag down the waiter and asked if they forgot my son's order. He disappears into the kitchen and pops out 5 minutes later and says his meal is on it's way. Another 5 minutes past and my son tells the waiter just to prepare his entree "to go". We wait another 10-15 minutes and the owner happens to glance over at our table and inquired if everything is "ok" and respond, "they forgot my son's order". 5 more minutes and my son's order finally comes out. Not once were offered an apology for their screwup. Food is tasty if and when you get it. I will not be returning to dine in, maybe takeout. read more

Thin crust pizza, very good. Tried the arugula pie and chicken parm pie. Both very good and would order again. Entrees look great too. Great new addition to the area. They play Italian music, not a huge seating area, people waited to sit down. Desert as great too, cocoa coffee ice cream was very nice read more

Person 1. One They forgot my food, and I ate bread and lettuce. The bread was good though. Person 2. The pizza was mediocre. It was too greasy. Person 3. The Alfredo was good read more

I just came to know about this pizza place as it opened this week. We order two pizzas grandma pie and baked ziti pie. I have been going to Francesco from last 17 years and we wanted to give chance to new place. So the review, The pizza was good but the only issue was it had bit salty and that it the reason for 4 star. The place is newly opened and smells fresh , they have few tables to sit outside, I did see they have fountain soda and fridge. read more

I got the Veggie Pizza today, it was delicious! One star taken out b/c when I got home, looked at the Receipt, they charged me a Credit Card Fee & I didn't even use my credit card to pay, I gave them CASH. read more

We tried the new pizzeria in Metuchen called Che Pizza. Nice place on Pearl Street that used to be the Olive Press Eatery. I went in looking for sicilian slice but they didn't have one so I went with plain for the first time. Very nice slice. No flop on the crust. My wife had a specialty slice and she enjoyed it. They have about a dozen different pies to choose a slice from. We will be back to try their entries from their extensive menu. read more

I'm a long time Metuchenite, lover and critic of pizza. This place is legit. You can tell that they do not cut corners when it comes to ingredients or quality of product. I ate two slices and already feel full, which is ridiculous. Compare that to when you can down an entire Dominos Pizza with no problem. Once again, ingredients are legit, quality is authentic, pizza is well-prepared and tastes delicious. Nice work guys, great addition to Metuchen. read more

See all

Hey everybody there is a new pizza joint in Metuchen Plaza that serves excellent food!

Got takeout. Don't get the grandma pie. Trust me. They should take it off the menu. 1 star for that. Also got the grilled chx sandwich w rrp and meatballs. Those were fine. They seem nice and the place looks good. It's a nice location. read more

Great food and service. Their pizza is great, absolutely, but shud also definitely try other main dishes, they are all great!! Would strongly recommend. I go their almost weekly now. read more

Food was fantastic and delicious! Service was friendly and great. Atmosphere the best is like being at home with your family. Dario and Maximo great combination and outgoing. I feel like I'm going to my mother's house to eat. Great place read more

Excellent food. Nice variety on menu. True Italian style. The people here are friendly and accommodating. Will always come here first before any other place in town and there are many! I love when they put out coupons as an extra added bonus! read more

If I could give this place 100 stars I would ! First off the place is located in the cutest area of Metuchen. When you finally enter the restaurant it is so cozy and adorable. The staff is extremely friendly happy and give so many amazing recommendations, the service is overall amazing. Now the food, one thing is better then the next! The bread is fresh and homemade, the starters, the salad, the pasta, the dessert it's never ending amazing delicious food. Finally the cherry on top it's BYOB. You won't be disappointed you must try CHE! read more

Very disappointed...pizza was bland ..garlic knot Pizza not worth the price...very dry and lacked enough garlic. Sauce is too tangy and needs more flavor. read more

Amazing pizza! The chicken chipotle pie is my favorite. The buffalo chicken pizza is also pretty good and interesting. It still has a thin layer of tomato sauce which was a first for me. As for sandwiches, the chicken parm with vodka sauce on a garlic knot bun is just perfect. Tip: to order this online, you would select the chicken parm sandwich and in the notes write "K Bomb". read more

Che Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Gourmet Pizza Personal - Pizza Near Me - Metuchen, New Jersey

See all

Been pizza dating for the past 6-8 months as my pizzeria for the past decade changed owners and has not been the same. After trying every pizza joint in town- we thought we had a winner. It was near the middle school in town (if you're a townie, you'll know which one). That place was good but not great - but the best at that point. We were about to go on our second date when my wife suggested this place. We tried it and were like "this is what NJ pizza is supposed to be". It had been months since we had it so we savored it. We had our second date and stood up to to test #2. Looking forward to expanding the menu on test #3! For now we are hooked. read more

Great Fresh pizza made fresh with quality ingredients! Great staff also. Inside has a great vibe.

Ordered here last week friends during the jazz festival. Great job keeping up with the high demand that day and the food was delicious.

Che catered a lunch for the school I work at. Everything was amazing and they were unbelievably generous with the food they donated. I especially enjoyed the grilled veggies, lexy salad, eggplant parmigiana, and baked ravioli. The pizza and sandwiches were also excellent. I strongly recommend this gem and will definitely try some of their other menu items soon. read more

Outstanding quality, portion and value. The waitstaff are all personable. The venue is small but decorated tastefully.

We ordered dinner last night and I was blown away by my chicken francese dish. It was delicious! Had so much flavor but not overpowering, which some spots tend to do. Last time we ordered, our sandwiches got messed up. I ordered a meatball parm hero & got a chicken parm hero instead.. but even that sandwich was good would definitely recommend. read more

Unbelievable pizza so fresh. the crust was perfect and so much to choose from. staff was knowledgeable and friendly. i want to try everything on the menu. next time i will bring a nice bottle of wine so i can really enjoy the fun Italian music playing. the food is delizioso! bravo! read more

3.5 stars. We were excited to try the pizzas here after reading all the positive reviews. We ordered several pies and wings for our party. The sauce was good but the crust was on the dry side. One of the pies was just tasteless. We really wanted to love this place but it was didn't turn out that way. read more