After trying all of the pizza places in this town more than once, I will say that this is my first choice for local pizza. Slices are huge! Others will say their pies are tasteless and prefer other places in Piscataway while I'd say the same about those other places and prefer this one. So I think it's just preference. But I'd also like to highlight their chicken caesar salad, because at one point, I think I was ordering this weekly, along with my co-workers whenever we'd order food for lunch. Their homemade caesar dressing is THE BEST! I wish they sold it by the bottle because I'd always buy it. Their chicken is always perfectly seasoned and never too salty. You get a generous amount in your salad also. I've always had really friendly service. My office, including my boss, order from here really often so some of their staff recognize our office just by our phone number. My boss always gets their tilapia special (I believe it's their Friday special) with broccoli, almost every week. Again, I think when it comes to pizza from New Jersey, everyone has their go-to place. This happens to be mine. read more

Service is bad. Placed an order online it said 20 minutes I get there 20 minutes later. The guy says 25 more minutes. I have to work I didn't have time. He was not friendly he said the pies take that long. The grandma pies. Someone needs to teach him time management and efficiency. He spends too much time running around pizzas never make it in the oven. I was in there for like 15 minutes and he never got one in. read more

I ordered here for pick up and it was ready within 15 mins!! Super quick. The food was absolutely delicious. The wrap is huge and the fries are cooked to perfection. It was only $13 for all of this food!!! I like how they gave Cesar dressing on the side and didn't saturate my wrap in dressing. They also gave plenty of ketchup packets for the fries. I will definitely be returning!!!! Thank you for this great lunch. read more

Piscataway Pizza - Grilled chicken Cesar wrap and fries - Pizza Near Me - Piscataway, New Jersey

It's a real shame that I have to give this place a 1 star because the food actually wasn't so bad. The delivery was outrageously late - over 30 minutes late. Called twice and not once was there an apology or clear information on where the driver was. Ordered from seamless and usually they allow tracking of the driver but I'm assuming they used their own driver because I couldn't track where he was. So over 30 minutes late. Finally driver calls and says he had the wrong address and I'm like okay? Lady at the store said she'd call me back when I called the second time to ask her to me the status but nope nothing; no call back. Unbelievable. It doesn't matter how good your food is, if you can't provide good service, you can kiss business from me goodbye. Never again. read more

Cooked as requested and tasted good but Pepperoni little greasy! Delivery driver was awesome! He gets 5 stars! read more

Piscataway Pizza - Large Pepperoni! - Pizza Near Me - Piscataway, New Jersey

EVERYTHING WAS AMAZING 10/10 service the owner was wonderful very friendly and welcoming. A very comforting place you feel like you're eating at home with family! Warm and welcoming !!!! read more

I support small business, but if you cant make it in this economy and you choose to go with cheap ingredients and lower quality products, then - either raise your prices or just close. Piscataway Pizza - aka "Restaurant Depot" to go. The large pie, not like any pizza I ever ate before! The pizza sauce must be out of a 1 gallon can, so off putting just because it's so Blood RED & sweet. We also ordered the Supreme Stromboli, and i can only surmise they ran it through the dish washer to freshen it up before delivery - can't even identify its ingredients & the doz. Zeppolli - fried pizza doe with powdered sugar - does not a Zeppolli make! I spent over $60... and we're eating PBJs for dinner . Done with Pway Pizza, and all the township pizza shops! Cheap ingredients, labor & poor quality is a recipe for disaster. EVEN THE DOG DIDN'T WANT IT ! read more

See all

I had the 16" pepperoni pizza. The pizza was good. There pricing policy is a little bizarre. They has a small notice to the side of the cash register that says they charge 3.5% more for credit card processes. I paid with credit card the first time because I didn't see the sign. The next time I paid cash and the receipt says discount of 5%. So, when I compared they prices I paid, it looks like they charge about 8.5% more to use a credit card then cash. False advertising. read more

I tried this place for the first time on 9/26/23. I ordered online and scheduled delivery for 12:30 PM. I usually take the delivery time as a "suggestion" but I was very pleasantly surprised to see my pizza delivered at 12:33. I received exactly what I ordered. I ordered a mushroom pizza and other than being very slightly on the salty side, it was excellent. I would definitely order from them again. read more

The lasagna is great. Have ordered from here numerous times. Last few times it has been more oily but still my go to

Completely dissatisfied with this order. I ordered a Sicilian slice of pizza, tiramisu, and lasagna. They sent me a hard old slice of cheese pizza which was disgusting. The tiramisu slice was OLD AND HARD, tasted like it's been sitting in the fridge for days, not to mention how small the slice was and I paid 5 something for it. And the lasagna was swimming in oil. First and LAST time I will be ordering from this place. Paid almost 30 dollars for this order. This place doesn't even deserve one star. I will be waiting for my refund from Uber Eats. read more

See all

It's a sad day when you come to a pizza place and your Mountain Dew is the best part of your meal. I've never had such bland pizza and garlic knots. The garlic knots smelled super enticing, but were doughy and extremely lacking in garlic flavor. We got two slices of pizza: chicken parm and chicken bacon ranch. Maybe it was because we got there around 8:45 pm, but there was only one tiny slice of chicken bacon ranch left and it tasted like it had been sitting out all day. The chicken parm slice was huge like the other reviews said, and the cheese was gooey, but it was utterly flavorless even after adding the spices on the side. The staff was friendly, but it was poor consolation for the terrible food. Never coming back here again unless it's while drunk. read more

Piscataway Pizza - Garlic knots, chicken bacon ranch (left), chicken parm (right) - Pizza Near Me - Piscataway, New Jersey

Hi. I ordered Pizza for delivery about 2 hours ago. The driver came around 2 hours later. He didn't call on the number given. He said he did. But he didn't. I did t receive any calls at all. I asked them to send paper plates also with the food he didn't bring them. The driver left the pizza on the steps and started leaving. Who leaves food on the steps? read more

Wanted to try something new. Wasn't bad but wasn't great. I did order a pepperoni Stromboli and when we went to go eat it saw that it was a chicken parm Stromboli so was kind of bummed. read more

I've had Piscataway pizza before and enjoyed their pizza slices l but recently I've noticed a change in the texture of the dough. I don't know if it's me but the dough isn't as chewy as it was before. The dough kind of had a grainy texture and was a bit harder. Perhaps they changed something with the recipe but it's definitely not the same. Also, it seems like the amount of sauce is getting less and less as well. It's kind of disappointing because this is the only pizza shop my parents go to. Now we are considering a different place. read more

Tried their chicken Frances's pizza. I like to stick to what i know when it comes to pizza. They guy suggested i get it. And let me tell you. This might be my new favorite pizza. This is amazing! Love when a Quick pick up turns into a new fav! read more

I ordered the Pizza Supreme....it was one of the best pizzas I've ever had. Easy ordering and efficient deliver, on time and hot. The price was fair, maybe underpriced for the great quality. Will order again and recommend to friends. read more

Ordered a plain pie via DoorDash. Took forever probably because they were busy over cooking my pizza. I'm honestly not very picky but this has to be the WORST pizza I've ever had in NJ and I've lived here my whole life. The crust is super chewy, the sauce tastes like either straight up tomato paste or canned Pizza sauce, and the cheese is similar to plastic. The only pizza I can even compare this to is the 1$ frozen Celeste pizza. Can't speak for their other food options, but as a pizzeria, the pizza is not worth it. read more

Piscataway Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Piscataway, New Jersey

Amazing pizza will come again! Quality service and excellent customer service at the convenient location

Not the best pizza in the area, but it does the job if you are looking for a quick pie. We got wings which was weird cause they had the sauce on the side and the chicken was over cooked. We also ordered jalapeño poppers and mozzarella sticks which were your standard, nothing crazy. read more

Holy sh*t, they make the most amazing garlic bread with cheese. That is all I got. Haven't tried the pizza. But I will be coming back for the garlic bread for sure. read more

Piscataway Pizza - Garlic bread with cheese. I died. - Pizza Near Me - Piscataway, New Jersey

I don't know what happened, but last Friday I had some of the worst pizza of my life from these guys. Selection was scarce, and everything tasted old and left out. Margarita pizza was terrible. Wife took 2 bites of the buffalo chicken and tossed it. The garlic knots were greasy, doughy and flavorless. I'm only bumping it up to 2 stars for the employees. The guy with the beard that is usually there when I go is hilarious and nice. But wow, what a mess. read more

This is my favorite pizza and then some joint. The people are very friendly and very accommodating to special requests. All pizzas are made to perfection! Pasta dinners are superb! My faves are veal piccata, Seafood fradiablo, spaghetti bolognese. Don't forget to order their fries and zeppoles read more

Last Saturday on August 20, it was my first time at this Piscataway Pizzeria. The Manager and his staff were very professional and very friendly to myself and my friend. Our orders were made perfectly and beyond our requests. When I noticed that the Manager and the staff put our customers' orders and requests FIRST, I gave a VERBAL compliment to the Manager about it. This Manager, Rob, told me that he always puts the Customers first regarding in how he runs his business and how he and his staff serve their Customers. Bravo, Rob! Our Pizza Slices and the Turkey Burger was Fantastic too! read more

I got the fettuccine alfredo (comes with side salad and bread). It was pretty average alfredo. I'd say it was more expensive than it's really worth in terms of taste. read more

Excellent chicken parm dinner and the garlic knots are unbelievable! Chicken Parm was one of the best I've had, great sauce, cooked perfectly, lots of mozzarella. Garlic knots are awesome! Crisp, garlicky on the outside, but soft and delicious on the inside! Will definitely be back again. read more

The slices here are enormous, one to two are more than enough for any patron. The Cheesesteaks and Chicken Tenders are also quite good. Super friendly staff, plenty of seating. If you're in the Piscataway area, this is the place to get pizza. read more

This pizza shop used to be awesome, but, now is just plain horrible. Bought 2 slices and they were both over cooked, hard, and just not good. Could not eat the entire slice. read more

There are so many Pizza places in the area and this is the best. The pies are huge and have that NY Crunch, not the soggy pies most places have. The staff always addresses me by name. Price is in line with everyone else but you get more for your money. read more

Re-review... Ordered some slices to go. Once back in work I notice one of the slices had green mold on the crust. Yes, I'm sure it was green mold, exactly the same as old bread. read more

Pro: slices are HUGE Con: the plain was not good at all and old Ordered one slice, clearly made hours ago. The sauce tastes funny... If this is the best pizza in the area, I fear for central Jersey. read more

They day I was here they didn't have the best selection of specialty slices. I went with a vegetable and mushroom slice because nothing else really seemed too appealing. Vegetable pizza is my favorite though and I've had great vegetable slices before (so maybe I'm spoiled) but this one was ehhhh, not so good. Seemed like it was old or something, definitely not freshly made at least. I got a side of their sauce to dunk it in and also wasn't impressed with the flavor of the sauce. The only true positive comment I have is that the slices are huge. I didn't even try the mushroom slice, so I can't comment on it. Probably wouldn't come back here though. read more

Piscataway Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Piscataway, New Jersey

See all

All I can say is Yaaaassss honey yaaaasss this isn't the first time ordering from Piscataway pizza, nor is it the first time I'm highly impressed by them. There consistency for excellent customer service is out of this world. Long story short (I'll try to keep it short lol) after enjoying the first 70 degree Sunday and doing yard work, cooking for myself and the hubs dinner was out of the question. He decided to ring old faithful. He placed the order and asked since it's 8 something pm when the food does arrive for the driver to please call, my little was already knocked out by this point. Of course the driver did as asked. The food was hot, so fresh and flavorful. All there ingredients are amazing and there prices for the portion you receive is more then fair! I also asked for extra vodka sauce since I never finish my meals and usually anything pasta dries up by the next day! We'll see my photos, not only was my dish nice and saucy they gave me a whole side container! The large calzone is made for two or three depending on your appetite and it's always fresh and amazing! I really love this place and the owners clearly take pride in there work, staff and customer service and food quality! You have a repeat customer in us!! Thank you for being consistent and thank you for keeping it even during these crazy times read more

Piscataway Pizza - Penne Vodka & chicken! I asked for EXTRAAAA SUACE and they delivered - Pizza Near Me - Piscataway, New Jersey

See all

Horrible pizza with more than half the pizza having bubbles and air pockets. Crust was doughy, dense and undercooked. Not sure how you can screw up pizza this bad. I would suggest ordering from somewhere else. read more

Piscataway Pizza - Doughy and dense undercooked crust - Pizza Near Me - Piscataway, New Jersey

See all

Takes 30 minutes to get a wrap and 15-20 for a slice of pizza sometimes, and they're not even busy! Imagine if they were! I spent my entire lunch break waiting for my food rather than eating it, twice! Would not recommend. read more

Yuck Yuck Yuck!!! Everything I bought from here is absolutely disgusting. It seems like a place run by a bunch of handymen. Stay far away from this place. read more

We ordered via app based off the views from Yelp verses the other pizza place that's near by. Ordering on the app was a breeze, easy & quick. The delivery came in about 40 minutes (average time for a delivery). Upon getting opening my food (which was already cold), I realize that we got the wrong food. I called, spoke to the man at the register - he didn't really seem sorry or empathetic. He assured me that my correct food would be made .. I had to wait another 30 minutes for my mediocre food. Overall, one star. Should've stuck with the other pizza place across the street. read more

Hamburger looked and tasted homemade. Excellent Stromboli especially cold on the next day. Good crew behind the counter the day I went.

Last minute order of several pies and salad with many changes in between, Piscataway Pizza handle it all in stride. They were helpful, made suggestions when I was indecisive and best of all they were ON TIME for my event. I couldn't be more happier and my team was happy with the food. Will definitely use Piscataway Pizza again in the future. read more

The pizza is not real pizza. It's like play chuckie cheese pizza. I was very disappointed when it showed up