We ordered a whole pizza pie, half pepperoni, and half sausage. The pizza crust is perfect. The side crust is soft inside and a little crunch on the outside. The under crust has nice charring! The topping was plenty. The sausage covered the four slices. And the pepperoni almost covered the other four slices. There was a lot of cheese covering. It's been 2008 since I had their pizza. Really don't know why I waited that long. But no more. One of the top pizza restaurants in the area. Will be going here soon again. The order of zeppoles were shaped like doughnuts. It was ok. It was on the chewy side. Probably better if it was more fresh. Order ahead so you don't have to wait! They are very busy and I know why! Love the pizza! read more

See all

I stopped in with my family today to place a large, last-minute pie order for a family gathering, and I was blown away by the experience. Despite how busy they were, the owner went out of his way to make sure our order was ready quickly. He--and the entire staff--were incredibly kind, welcoming, and attentive. To top it off, the owner surprised us with free Italian cookies, which was such a thoughtful gesture and truly made our day. Their outstanding service and hospitality have earned my loyalty--I'll be coming here forever. read more

Good Food and Service and Reliable and have been going for years. A neighborhood staple. read more

I called DiMola's on Route 22 in North Plainfield to place an order and simply asked if they offer a senior discount. The man who answered (he told me his name was John) immediately became nasty and sarcastic. He refused to answer the question and insisted I give him my full address first before he would even tell me yes or no. His tone was rude, condescending, and downright hostile the entire call.I've never been spoken to like that at any restaurant in my life. There are dozens of great pizza places in the area that treat customers with basic respect--I won't be ordering from DiMola's ever again, and I'll make sure my friends and neighbors know about this experience too. Completely unacceptable. read more

Buffalo chicken slices and pepperoni pinwheels are the best, been very good for years

Just got my special pizza from Di Mola's best tasting pizza in town if you go anywhere else you are wasting your time and money love these guys read more

Dimolas is now my go to spot in North Plainfield for pizza. They are quick on the phones and answered all my questions. When I got there my pizza was so fresh that the box was steaming hot. So glad I chose them for my pre-thanksgiving dinner. I highly recommend. read more

I am from Tennessee, but originally from the Bronx. We do not have Pizzerias in Nashville, just Artisanal pizza at high prices. Dimolas serves delicious food at reasonable prices. I've had their pizza, chicken parm and chicken Marsala. All very good. The folks behind the counter are very nice and treat you respectfully. Their sauce is tasty, their portions are generous and their prices are on point. Try them, you won't regret it. read more

I LOVE this place! They are so awesome! I was shopping at Costco, and on my way back, I visited this gem! Not only is the pizza fantastic, but the staff is awesome! The woman who took my order was dope! read more

The pizza was fantastic! We ordered lunch for the whole firm, and everyone loved it--generous portions and everything tasted great. We got 3 pizzas, wings, and knots, all reasonably priced and delivered warm. The delivery person was also fantastic. Di Mola's is a must if you're around Route 22 in North Plainfield, as well as in Plainfield and nearby areas. I haven't dined in, but the food for pickup and delivery is excellent. Their pizza is top-notch--I'll definitely be returning! read more

This was my first time ordering from here since I recently moved to town. I would just like to say everything was excellent! From the friendly person who took my phone order to the wonderful people working at the counter when I picked it up.... everyone was so nice and that really goes a long way. I ordered one of their special combos of a pizza, wings, and soda. Great value and great food. I had a sausage pizza and it was loaded with sausage and very tasty. The buffalo wings with blue cheese quite tasty as well. I plan on making this one of my regular spots and I highly recommend you do too... As always support local business... read more

Di Mola's Pizza and Restaurant - Sausage pizza and buffalo wings - Pizza Near Me - North Plainfield, New Jersey

All was good, a huge pizza and super taste. The service was efficient and the delivery I consider was not late. read more

Everything food was amazing and the service was great ! Will be coming back the ambience was calm and nice

Excellent pizza! Today it was the broccoli one. Outstanding service for the past 20+ years! Thank you!! read more

Di Mola's Pizza and Restaurant - a slice of broccoli pizza - Pizza Near Me - North Plainfield, New Jersey

Ordered pizza and wings for our No Cook Friday ! Pizza was good and I loved the Buffalo sauce on the wings ! A pleasant and welcomed change from ordering Dominos lol read more

This is one local restaurant you keep going and going. The food is delicious and the price is reasonable. I highly recommend

The food is yummy and the staff are so sweet !!! I especially love the garlic knots and zeppoles

I am torn about Di Mola's, but ultimately will probably look for a new pizza place. On the one hand, their pizza is delicious and is certainly the best I have tasted in this area. On the other hand, I have never once had an order be ready on time when I have arrived to pick it up, even when I have received notification that it was ready. I wouldn't mind if I had to wait a few minutes, but the last three times I have had to wait more than 20 minutes past the scheduled pick up time. The worst part is the staff was never overly concerned about this. I received a perfunctory "sorry" that was half hearted at best and no further attempts to rectify the situation. The final factor for me, though, was when I went to pick up an order recently during the second influx of Covid and not a single employee was wearing their mask properly. Two had them below their noses and one had it hanging off his ear, then on his chin. I know that might not bother some people, but it does bother me, especially when they have signs posted telling patrons they must wear masks. Di Mola's, your food is delicious, but unfortunately the poor service outweighs it. read more

Service and food are wonderful! Very attentive to customers and high quality ingredients.

This restaurant has terrible service! They made me order completely wrong and charged me extra then refused to rectify. I will not be ordering from such rude people again. read more

Di Mola's Pizza and Restaurant - Does this look like angel hair pasta? Well I paid 1.00 extra for angel hair and received this. - Pizza Near Me - North Plainfield, New Jersey

I use to go to this place a lot. I was In there tonight. I'm there in line they take a call, and sell the slices I came in for. I'm good off di Mola's. This is like the fifth time I've been disappointed. The pizza is just okay for me to be told I gave the slices to the ppl on the phone. Looks like Marino's for the win. read more

Great grab a slice type place! Was heated up perfectly to have that crispy bottom and tastes excellent.. looking forward to try other things here over time! The staff here is super friendly and polite. Great experience! read more

Nice people good pizza. Dough could use a little more flavor and cook time. Everyone that I saw in the kitchen was wearing a mask. Inside is old school casual and comfortable to pop in whenever which I like. Overall I'll be back. read more

Di Mola's Pizza and Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - North Plainfield, New Jersey

Food is always fresh and the staff are always super friendly. The Sicilian pizza and the Strombolis are the best I've ever had.

Always a great experience ordering from Di Mola's everyone is very nice, the food is excellent and the service is always terrific.. I've been ordering from them for a while never disappointed especially love ordering from them when I have guests over everyone is always raving about the quality of the food and how delicious everything is read more

this place had to change hands. We ordered a large half meatball and onion pizza with an antipasto salad last Thursday. The pizza was cooked beyond recognition. The meatballs were actually sliced so thin they were cooked crispy the onions that were on the pizza was beyond caramelized onions cook so much just about disappeared, the bottom of the pizza was dark dark brown one shade away from burned. They told me to delivery would be an hour and 10 minutes when it arrived an hour and 40 minutes later my Bill had a 495 delivery charge. and $1.75 service charge a half an hour late and cold. The driver asked why I wasn't offering him a tip. I tried to explain some a tip is always for good service not for poor service with a burn pizza I should really dispute this on my credit card $40 for a pizza and a salad is out rages even if it was good read more

I am new to the area & was looking for a great pizza spot because I love pizza. This one had the best reviews so I tried it & to my surprise it was definitely the best I've had in the area. The pizza was fresh & hot. The owner was really nice & friendly. Glad I found my pizza spot! The price is reasonable read more

Di Mola's Pizza and Restaurant - Sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - North Plainfield, New Jersey

Visiting my in-laws in green brook. Wanted some good New York pizza before I left the country. Saw di Mola on Yelp. Very good pizza. Not the best I've ever had but hit the spot in terms of craving New York pizza. Service was excellent, super friendly and gave honest recommendations about which sandwich would last best on the long plane ride I had coming up. Ordered a half mushroom/half sausage pie for lunch. Both were very good, no complaints. Will return next time I'm in the area visiting for sure. read more

I've ordered delivery a couple times. Regular cheese pie is pretty good. The reason for the 5 stars, vodka grandma pie. It's delicious. Probably the tastiest pie I can have delivered to my house . Get it, you Won't regret it! read more

Spot on pizza for a south arkansas man! 2 larges was more than enough for my crew of three! Sauce was great to taste and the pepperoni was thick and still crispy! Good experience for some southerners read more

This place has been around for sometime and I heard nothing but good things about their pizza and hot sandwiches. I really didn't feel like cooking which is not like me in the least so I decided to order a Sicilian pizza and a chicken Parm sub. From the time I placed the order until I picked it up was about 20-25 minutes. This place is located on rt. 22 east in North Plainfield in a small strip mall.There is parking , and you can eat there. My Sicilian pizza was delicious. When I took my first bite, the dough was soft just the way I like it. Di Mola's sauce had plenty of flavor and the crust had texture and was golden brown. It reminded me of the way my Aunt Mary made her homemade Sicilian pizza. It was very authentic ! The chicken Parm sub was equally good. The chicken was breaded and fried and then layered with marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese on a hogie roll hot out of the oven. The chicken was very tender and moist loaded with sauce and cheese. You can't go wrong! I wanted to try their fried calamari but I was too full. That will be on my list for next time. This place is definitely worth trying! read more

Di Mola's Pizza and Restaurant - Sicilian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - North Plainfield, New Jersey

I'm not sure I will ever find a decent slice of American style pizza in this area. I was anxious to try Di Mola's as I read the reviews of people raving about. I ordered a large cheese pizza with chicken toppings. The girl on the phone was very nice and recommended many options but I was just in the mood for chicken. The delivery driver got there fifteen minutes quicker than the expected time and she was also very polite. Unfortunately that's where all the good things end. The pizza itself looked decent but as soon as I took a bite I was overwhelmed by the sweetness of the sauce and I was having trouble chewing the mozzarella as it was sticking to my teeth. The sauce itself tasted almost like ketchup and left an odd bitterness in my mouth throughout the rest of the day. The cheese tasted very processed and almost synthetic. Cheese should melt on pizza not consume it-this is a no no. Finally, the chicken was rubbery and had a slight gray tone to the color which usually means it's either old or had been recooked. Drive the extra ten, fifteen minutes to the surrounding towns if you wanna experience good tasting pizza. read more

Di Mola's Pizza and Restaurant - Pizza with chicken - Pizza Near Me - North Plainfield, New Jersey

Local pizza joint serving the usual local pizza joint items. However, this is better than average. We moved into the area about a year ago and after trying everyone, DiMola's won out business. The crust is perfect and soft, not chewy like most. They deliver which is a bonus. Salads are always fresh which can be an issue with some places. My kids love the cheese pizza and I like pepperoni, Pizzas are big enough to do both in one. I love their chicken marsala! Subs are good as well. read more

Great customer service, always willing to help, and fast delivery. They have a fantastic staff and owner! They really value their customers. They also have an amazing grandma pie!! read more

Tried this place as it was the highest rated pizza place by my new home and it did not disappoint. They have a great pepperoni pizza and a Caesar Salad--I am always happy to find a place with a great Caesar dressing. I will be back to try more things. Stay tuned! read more

I moved to the area at the end of August and was stressed from a crazy ass moving day. I ordered a Sicilian pie with garlic and sausage from this place for pick up. Upon arrival I had a pleasant convo with the guy working the register and ended up leaving with a bunch of free slices in addition to my order since I told him it was my first time there. The pizza is delicious and as a Jersey kid (whose mom is obv Italian too) who has eaten a whole lot of NJ/NY pizza that's saying a LOT. Since then we've gotten delivery at our house and the meat Stromboli and accompanying sauce are great. Calamari has a little too much breading but was flavorful. Same with the wings. Pizza is the way to go! Haven't tried any dinners yet but hope to soon!!! read more

Di Mola's Pizza and Restaurant - Sicilian pie with garlic & sausage - Pizza Near Me - North Plainfield, New Jersey

Always a pleasure eating at this local pizzaria. The owners and staff are friendly and helpful. They make the pizza the way you want it and they aren't skimpy on ingredients. There's usually places to sit on a Fri night since most people either takeout or deliver. The pizza isn't too salty and ingredients taste average to me. The pizza isn't too thin but it isn't thick either. With a lack of local pizzaria's around the area, Dimola's stands out as one of the better ones I've had. I'll easily come back here on the regular! read more

I absolutely LOVE this pizza!!! I feel like they bake their pizza with love because it is amazing every single time!!! Super friendly man always answers the phone to take the order. Delivery is always on time and pizza is hot like it just came out the oven!!! Highly recommended! I already can't wait for more. read more

Di Mola's Pizza and Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - North Plainfield, New Jersey

A really good pizza place. Good selection, reasonably priced, great crust... What more can I say?!

Everyone reviews their pizza which is no doubt good. But their cannolis are to die for. If you have not had them, please order next time. An absolute favorite in my family. read more