I ordered a few slices, a mac and cheese ball, and two garlic knots. On the plus side, the staff was friendly and helpful, and the place was well maintained. But here's my honest feedback: turn up the oven temperature. I was hoping for a crispy slice and instead got soggy, chewy pizza with more flop than I wanted. It wasn't horrible, but the sauce lacked flavor and was a bit too acidic. The mac and cheese ball was cold in the middle and bland -- another customer on here made the same comment. Season it up and crank up the heat or leave them in longer. The garlic knots were oversized, which made them come out doughy instead of light. For 3 slices, two garlic knots, one mac and cheese ball, and a medium drink, I paid $25.53. That's a bit pricey, but I get it -- costs have gone up across the board. read more

I LOVE THEIR PIZZA! Always fresh and delicious! So many yummy varieties! Definitely addictive.... I'm here often. Staff is always friendly. Garlic knots are awesome too. read more

Pepperoni pizza was terrible. Garlic knots meh. Mac n cheese ball was soggy and bland just not good overall.

New thinny thin bar pie is my family's favorite in the area. Would definitely recommend. read more

Trevi Square Pizza & Kitchen - Thin & Crispy - Round Pie - Italian Near Me - Watchung, New Jersey

So impressed with the food and incredible service. My family ordered a few trays of food for Easter. The food was delicious, but what impressed me the most was the wonderful service I received at pick up time. They really went above and beyond to take care of our order. Will not hesitate to order for an event from here again! A+ read more

Good pizza. Nice staff. Convenient when shopping at Walmart,/Home Depot mall here in Watchung.

Ordered the chicken parm. The chicken was so dry and over cooked. The cheese was just placed on top and barely melted. It was terrible. Def would not recommend. read more

I can't believe I have been skipping over this place for a year. I moved to the area from Northern New Jersey, where the pizza and Italian food is great at a lot of places. I listened to every neighbor and local review about food and finally decided that... I have different tastes than any local has. The Chicken vodka parm was one of the BEST I've ever had!! Eggplant stogies, to die for. we ordered a pie and while it wasn't the best I've ever had...it gives everything around here a run for its money. We loved the Hot honey pepperoni. If you want a great Italian entree I suggest stopping in. The restaurant is super clean and the service is friendly. There was 45 minute wait on the food, which is normal at every good Italian place on a weekend. read more

See all

Their round pie and subs are delicious. The fresh mozzarella on the pies is a nice touch

Expected more from this place :( I recently stopped by this place with my sister for some pizza and garlic knots for lunch! Because I live so close to this place and have always drove by, I figured maybe I should give it a try after my local pizzeria was closed that day. Because the place is fairly new, the ambiance is really nice, something I didn't really expect for a pizza place lol! There was a bit of a wait to order, I figured the pizza would be good if it was busy. WRONG, from the looks of it, the pizza didn't look as fresh compared to my local pizza place but I still remained hopefully when I got my order. We ordered a slice of Grandma's pizza, a slice of Margherita Pizza and 4 Garlic Knots. The Grandma's pizza was ok, I've definitely had much better. Rating it a 2/5. The Margherita pizza was simply ok but I prefer the one from my local pizza place giving it a 2/5. This place only allows you to order Garlic Knots in 4's or 6, or 8 I believe. This was quite disappointing since we were looking to only get 1 each. However since we were really craving them we went ahead and ordered 4. Turned out to be ok because we managed to eat them but as mentioned before I've definitely had better. Unfortunately I would not recommend this place since I believe there are better pizza places in the area and I would give it a 2/5 overall rating! read more

Trevi Square Pizza & Kitchen - Grandma's Pizza, Margherita Pizza and Garlic Knots - Italian Near Me - Watchung, New Jersey

I did expect a little more from this place. It was a bit disheveled when I got there. I ordered an antipasto salad and my friend ordered a chicken sandwich. Salad was ok and they were able to scrounge up a chicken sandwich with bacon bits instead of strips of bacon which I thought was strange. Something about the service was a bit off. I personally don't like servers with the hair hanging all over the place which is what was happening here but not a deal breaker. Ehh maybe they were short on staffing. All and all it was just ok and may or may not go back. There is nothing else around that mall so they could really make out in the location. read more

See all

I have to knock my previous rating down a bit. I got a 16" square pie to go. The crust was tough. I could barely chew it. Not a good thing on a thick crust pizza. My teeth are not getting soft, either, my wife had the same reaction. This can happen if there is not enough water in the dough, if it has been over-kneaded, if the yeast is bad, or if it hasn't been given enough time to rise. I can't speak to what went wrong, but if all you do all day is make pizza, you need to make the dough correctly. read more

The food is good but for some reason (maybe it's just me) i'm not crazy about the sauce.. other than that, the food was tasty

The best Grandma's pizza. Thin and crisp w cheese and not too much tomato sauce. Perfection!

I have only had their pizzas and each pie has been delicious. We love the Vodka Florentine, Uncle Alfredo's Artichoke, and Old School Spinach pies. I love vodka pasta sauce and theirs is tasty and they are generous with the toppings - great job and thanks! The only reason they are not getting 5 stars is because they could improve on the customer service experience. read more

Trevi Square Pizza & Kitchen - A slice of the Vodka Florentine pizza. - Italian Near Me - Watchung, New Jersey

Love the pizza here, it is always fresh and tastes amazing. Sadly can't eat here much because I only come by during the weekends. The tables are always clean and the servers are very nice. They have a lot of options to choose from and the prices are pretty good. read more

Little Italy. I wonder if they stole a chef from there! The Chicken Parm was just like I get in NYC. Nicely balanced marinara sauce with real breaded, hand fried chicken cutlets. (Not the processed kind you get from a large food distributor.) Topped with the right amount of fresh mozzarella and fresh basil, it came over a lot of good penne pasta. I forgot to take a picture and by time I thought about it, I had eaten half. The other half I took home because it is way too much food for me. My adult son blew right through his, and he is a pain in the a... with food. It more than passed his critical palate. The rolls and the salad were not my focus, so take my opinion lightly, but I'd say they were nothing special. Spaghetti bolognaise is not my thing, but that is my wife's favorite. She obviously enjoyed it because she took home what she could not finish. Typically, she'll just leave it if ho-hum. It is in a pink-cream sauce, reminiscent of vodka sauce. Has fine ground meat, which although good, was a little less than expected. I tasted and found it pleasant, but radically different than other recipes that offer a ton of meat and totally different kinds of sauce. It is probably chef's own dish. They have a ton of different pizzas. Plenty of pasta options. However, the entrées are limited to six chicken based dishes. Well, to me do what you do best and don't add more for the sake of filling out a menu! So this is just right. The ambiance is quite different than I'd expect with food this good. It is casual. Limited table service and a lot of DIY things. You can pick up your own salt, pepper and such, get your own utensils, fountain soda (when you pay for it), to-go containers, bags, and you even get to bus your own table if you want! But you don't have to. If you ask, the staff will take care of you. The only criticism I have is that I don't really need TVs blaring sports events. If I wanted that, I can go to a bar. A lot of people don't seem to mind, but I am used to having a more peaceful environment with gourmet food like this. read more

Just okay Popped in for lunch because had to stop for groceries too Had a margherita and a veggie slice The margherita was decent and the best one. Still crispy after being reheated The veggie slice was a soggy mess with vegetables and goopy cheese. Got to a point I didn't even want to finish it If you want food square pizza go to Massa I felt like this was a waste of my lunch time read more

Do NOT, I repeat, do NOT order pizza for delivery. I ordered 2 pies at 7:15pm and was told it would take 45 min. I called at 8:10 and was told that they were on the way. I called again at 8:40 and was told again they are on the way. When I said you already told me that, they said there are not a lot of Uber or DoorDash drivers available. Had I known they used a service for delivery, I would have picked it up myself. Mind you, it's about an 8 min drive from my home to Trevi. Their pizza is good, but it's now going on an hour and 45 min and still no sight of my pizza. read more

7:58 for the third time and we're told that it's closed . I can imagine how many customers that they turn away trying to keep the kitchen cleaned for a quick closing . Do not work in food service ! Decent pizza but I officially hate this place and will never purchase another item from here! read more

Ordered two pizzas from here on the day we moved to Watchung. Thin and crispy crusts on both the square and round pies were much appreciated in our house! The quality and taste of the chicken and peppers we added to the square pie were very good. They are on our list to have again now that we are locals. read more

Trevi Square Pizza & Kitchen - Square pie with chicken and roasted peppers - Italian Near Me - Watchung, New Jersey

See all

Super disappointed today. Ordered an Italian sub which I always get. For some reason today it was covered in a crazy amount of mayo. Never once when I've ordered here has a sub come with mayo on it. Ruined the whole sandwich. read more

I work roughly 10 minutes away from Trevi & let me say I love it here! The dishes are always fresh and flavorful. Staff is amazing & very warm/welcoming. Always good vibes when you enter Trevi! I highly recommend 10 out of 10 read more

Take out order was missing our dessert and side salads. Pasta dish was missing the protein Cheesesteak has peeper and no where on the menu does it say peppers read more

Just called to place an order and was told the pizza oven is closed but kitchen is still open. They close at 9:00pm and I called at 8:12pm. Took my business to Dimaio in Berkeley Heights instead. They close at 9pm and pizza oven was still open. read more

Good pizza, welcoming service, resonable prices and a nice clean atmosphere. Definitely worth a try!

Amazing food! You won't be disappointed here the chicken sicilian is my favorite they also have delicious penne vodka. I love the food here and the atmosphere is so welcoming. I am always given good service and fast service at trevis i would recommend them to anyone! read more

Great pizza love the hot honey pepperoni slice & the buffalo chicken slice. Kind staff who are helpful

Me and my family love this place! I already left a google review and ofcourse I have to in yelp. The staff are so courteous and polite! They have a lot of younger staff and each time we went we were greeted nicely, the way they speak to their customers is really notable! Their pizza is so good! I love their artichoke pizza, i cant get enough! Even the veggie slice..my bf said its the best buffalo slice hes had.. and he gets buffalo in every pizzeria we go to LoL! read more

I ate at Trevi on two different occasions for takeout. First I tried the Old School Spinach Square pie. I enjoyed it. The thin crust was different from what I am used to but I definitely would go back for it. Although, on the second attempt I tried a pasta dish. I ordered the Shrimp Scampi Malfadini. Now that I didn't enjoy. The dish lacked seasoning I could barely finish. I do not like to add salt to my food after its cooked personally so I didn't enjoy it. All in all, I would return for a pizza ! read more

Trash Pizza! DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE. We ordered a 10" pie with veggies, no cheese, well done. We had to order the 10" because they were not willing to "make" any larger gluten free pie because they closed in 30 min. I say "make" because the crust tasted like they just bought the gluten free disks from the stop and shop next door. When we picked it up, they still put cheese on it...so had to make another one, even though we called after placing the order to add a second pizza and they said that 2 people ordered after us in the span of 5 min and the kitchen was no longer taking orders. The mushrooms were raw, the other veggies were also barely cooked just like the uncrisped crust on our well DONE pizza. All that to say, what a waste of 24 dollars on a personalized sized pizza. Threw it in the trash. read more

Mi son loves their thin crust so today I ordered penne vodka, and also 2 slices of pizza. Unfortunately didn't check my order because I trust that everything was okay. When I got home, I didn't get the pizza, and the penne vodka was more like marinara sauce... when I called the manager he started to argue and got the nerve to tell me that he is serving the community like he was doing me a favor to feed me, like I didn't pay for my food with my debit card. He also added that ppl eats the food and then calls to complaint to get it for free! That's probably true cause I see it all, and that's probably what he and his people do. But some of us are decent people and if he cannot take a criticism for his business then he should no be the manager did I say he was unprofessional? He may need some customer care classes! read more

Take out was terrible. Half of one pi, za was upside down. Then the pizza itself was so bad. So greedy they the bottom of the crust was orange. Just not good. read more

This is our go-to place when I'm visiting the area. Their square pizzas are SO good. Thin crust, perfectly delicious sauce and melty, melty cheeeeeze! We get a regular square and a mushroom sausage square. It's so yummy that we really need to try their other flavors and toppings. read more

Truly one of the best crusts I've had in a long time. Buffalo chicken cheesesteak was AMAZING!!! The hot roast beef with mozzarella was perfect. Oh and those smaller sized pepperoni goes so well on a slice. I seriously don't want to chomp on the traditional oversized ones. These are perfect. read more

Took FOREVER for a lousy bowl of soup. Manager didn't even acknowledge me, apologize or throw in a garlic knot. Sorry, not coming back. Paisanos we miss you!!! read more

Kyle and I have dined here on multiple occasions. We are always greeted promptly. Their most popular slice and Kyle's personal favorite is the Trevi which contains peppers, onions, ham, pepperoni, sausage and mozzarella. The pizza is always fresh, however my plain slices tend to be hit or miss. Good for a quick bite, especially if you enjoy square pizza slices. There are better options in town. read more

We were shopping nearby so decided to give it a try. The young girl behind the pizza counter was very friendly and helpful. Hope the owners appreciate her! We got 2 slices each so covered 4 varieties which were all very good. We'll definitely visit this restaurant again when we're in the area. read more

I normally NEVER write reviews, however, I ordered two sandwiches. A Buffalo chicken cheesesteak and a chicken parm with vodka sauce. The chicken parm came out fine. However, they gave me the wrong sandwich for my Buffalo chicken one TWICE! I even drove back to get the correct one and they still gave me the wrong one!!!! I called again, the ( I'm assuming manager) asked if I wanted to come back I said NO I already drove twice just to give me a refund. He then gave me a refund and hung up on me. Also, the menu needs to be updated because I asked on the phone for NO onions, onions were on the sandwich. And the menu said no onions, or peppers and still they were on the sandwich! Will never be back! read more

I ordered from Uber Eats and I was told the driver forgot a portion of my order. I called to confirm and I assume I spoke with a manager because they said they had spoken to uber and received a refund. I accepted their offer to deliver the item anyway. Uber had reimbursed me and I offered to pay for the item. I called back an hour later and was told the pizza must be out for delivery. I waited another hour and the manager (he sounded the same) said no one had spoken to me and there was no pizza. I used to get food from this place all of the time when it was Paisanos, but I tried Trevi's pasta and hated it. I decided to try their pizza and I never got it, but I don't like that supposedly the "driver" forgot my order, because the staff are liars when they said they never spoke with me. I can't believe a word that they say. read more