Subslingers

We showed up about 10 minutes before closing and weren't greeted or told they were about to shut…read moredown--no heads-up, no hello, just silence when we walked in. That set the tone a bit, and the staff stayed pretty flat and distant throughout. In a place serving Italian sandwiches, you'd hope for at least a little of that classic deli energy, but it felt more transactional than welcoming. On the plus side, the sandwiches were loaded with meat--generous piles of gabagool (capicola) and the other cold cuts, so you definitely get your money's worth in terms of quantity. That's the highlight. Flavor-wise, though, they fell short. Everything tasted kind of one-note and under-seasoned. The meat was good quality, but it needed salt, maybe some oregano, a splash of vinegar or oil, or just more care in the assembly to bring it to life. It wasn't bad, just forgettable--more filling than satisfying. Overall, it's a solid 3-star spot if you're purely after a big, meat-heavy sandwich and don't mind basic service. If you want personality behind the counter or a sub that actually pops with flavor, you might want to keep looking. We left somewhat satisfied but not impressed, and probably won't make a special trip back.

What a welcome addition to the neighborhood. We have waited for a deli like this since our Hoboken…read moredays. Great sandwiches, fresh ingredients, helpful staff and the decor is perfectly nostalgic. Warning: the sandwiches are enormous, so bring your appetite! Prices are a bit high, but what isn't these days. They are still working out their flow, so bring a little patience as well. Welcome to the neighborhood!

See all

Sub zone

3.9(63 reviews)

3.1 mi

•$

Great. Great food, Great service, and Great ambiance…read more Best subs and sandwiches. They know how to... Make Subs Great Again

Wasnt sure what to get and the lady behind counter said I got you and made me a top tier chicken…read morecutlet sandwich.. dubs in the chat

Cutty

3 3/8" of cold cut goodness.

See all

Place your order. What else do you think you do here?

Avenue Deli

4.7(83 reviews)

3.9 mi

•$

Stopped in to grab some subs, Great Service, great subs, all around a go to spot in new providenceread more

Best quality in town... and all heart…read more After you try these sandwiches, you won't hesitate to saunter the meager half block from Subway (it's across the street) or Jersey Mike's (same side of the street). Thankful for such kind/accommodating hosts and subs that were fresh, delicious and gigantic. (When I say gigantic, I mean I ordered a full sub, and when it arrived, I thought I received TWO full subs. Each half measured in at 8-1/2 inches each.) The price... unbelievable. Sorry other sandwich guys, we have a new fav in New Providence. Also noticed wraps, great salads, and more listed on that menu board. Thank you Avenue Deli, for such a pleasant experience. First class.

Outside

Dagwood sandwich (Turkey, ham, Swiss cheese, joeslaw, and Russian dressing made on three tiers of rye)

See all

Taylor ham egg and cheese sandwich

Tino’s Artisan Pizza

5.0(10 reviews)

Tino's rocks! Italian food is not my favorite. I'm one of those weird people who generally isn't a…read morefan of pizza BUT I have had their pizza three times since they've opened! And I find myself craving it! I'm gluten-free and their vegan, gluten free crust is amazing! I have had their Capracotta (twice) and Ruchetta and both were excellent! I can't wait to try some of their other "formaggio" pizzas and their gluten free chocolate cake. My husband has also had one of their pizzas and enjoyed it, but his favorite is their chicken parm, at the moment. He said it is so good! They did an excellent job with the interior of the space and all the employees have been very nice and helpful. So happy to finally have a great pizza place in town. If you haven't tried them, go now!

For some reason this place barely shows up on google maps unless you zoom all the way in but I'm so…read moreglad I found it. Even though it's been open for a while, it's still a hidden gem. I'm proud to write the third review! The pizza is incredible..the 12" American Pie ($16) and 12" Cacio e Pepe ($18) are perfectly delicious with toppings so evenly distributed that every bite is full of flavor. They use olive oil too, no cheap oils and their website is "nojunkpizza." The business adds real charm to little Berkeley Heights town and the inside is more spacious than others there.

Gelato

See all

Menu

Millburn Deli

4.3(925 reviews)

7.3 mi

Over the weekend I made my at least 5th order here. Every time it is very predictable no matter…read morewhat I get., excellent!!! They have to put a lot of thought and love into everything that they put out. Home of the best Sloppy Joes!! From sandwiches to salad to iced tea and desserts I highly recommend this place. I had to take the time to leave a review this time because I felt it was very overdue. The gobbler sandwich is yummy, The Godfadda, The Gossip Girl, I also have had an egg salad with layer of tuna salad Sloppy Joe-that is amazing! The Cobb salad is also a fave. My friends rave about all the sandwiches they have tried. They are very friendly behind the counter and the order takers are fast and efficient. It gets crowded but moves fast.

Sandwiches are really fresh and tasty. The gobbler can be a little skimpy on turkey but still…read moredelicious. The sloppy Joe's are great and don't forget the chili basil bowtie salad. My go-to is the make your own salad with chunks of turkey. They don't skimp on the protein or your choice of veggies and the salad is huge!

Wild Bull

See all

Old school exterior

Chatham Sandwich Shop

Family-owned & operated

This is the place for a sandwich! The service took its time because they make everything fresh to…read moreorder. The meatball sandwich has 3 large meatballs that are warm and tasty. Outside seating along the Main Street is simple and beautiful on a nice day.

So I ordered from here cause they had a pretty good reviews on yelp, itv says they've been around…read morefor 40+ years and they were running a pretty cool Bogo deal on Uber eats so I got the turkey club. Sometimes I like to throw random instructions in there like toast bread, melt the cheese and make the fries well done and surprisingly this shop hit on all points. The bread was fresh and so was the turkey, and the fries were well done to perfection and they had that golden crisp to them. The shop itself looks nice inside and my food was ready for pickup as soon as I arrived. If you are in the mood for a good sandwich then I recommend this spot will be going there again stars.

Peppercorn turkey wrap

Tuscan crispy chicken

See all

Pepperoni sub

Staci's Sandwich Joint

4.8(61 reviews)

15.1 mi

Women-owned & operated

Catering service

Absolutely insane sandwich spot. Worth the hype in my opinion. The chicken cutlets and bread…read moredeserve all the praise. HIGHLY recommend the chicken Caesar sandwich - that was the star of the show. Be prepared to wait as it does get super busy, especially during lunchtime.

Ordered the chicken Caesar sandwich for takeout and honestly - holy moly cow!! This thing was…read moremassive, which definitely explains the price. I was a little hesitant when I saw the total. If I'm paying around $20 for a sandwich, it better be worth it... and this absolutely was! It was so so good - fresh, flavorful, and super satisfying. Honestly, this was lunch and dinner, and lunch and dinner again the next day. Leftovers can go in the fridge and can be enjoyed the next day just as much. Will be back to try the other sandwiches! Only thing to note is their limited hours, so plan ahead--but it's 100% worth it.

See all

Clemente's Pizzeria & Cafe Italiano

3.3(92 reviews)

Ordered a Grandma's Pizza and a large original pizza half pepperoni and half mushrooms. Asked for…read morethem to be sliced double because it was for an event where mostly finger food was being served. Pizza was delicious as usual, sliced as requested. Only complaint is that I was surprised that I was charged an $8.69 "tip". Had no idea about the gratuity. I mean, when I'm eating a slice or two at the pizzeria I'll put a couple bucks in the jar at the counter for the kids taking the order. But for picking up a couple pies? C'mon now. I'll be more careful when ordering online now.

Pizza was barely warm and I was there before the expected given ready time. The crust was rubbery…read moreas well. I should've known when the box wasn't warm. My thoughts are the person taking the order should have a better idea of the current pizza turn around.

Basil garden for my Personal Pie

What I received A bit different very disappointing

See all

Half & half

Charkoal Portuguese Grill

3.7(44 reviews)

Hidden gems or hole in the wall kinda place. If you love the train experience, this is the…read morerestaurant for you. I am big on supporting small businesses, this is a small restaurant with only a few tables. Most people pick ip to go, but we enjoyed the train come and go. The restaurant is inside or basically part of the train station. The cook is also your server. A great place to grab a quick dinner and people watching. We love the chicken alot. I highly recommended

Delicious portuguese restaurant nom,nom I really enjoyed ordering their roasted chicken and pork…read moreribs it comes with rice and French fries or black beans. The service was great the owner she was very friendly and offered some extra bread and sauces for my meal. The ambiance is very cute a small restaurant but nice and clean. The decor is very homey very lovely. I got the flan as a dessert and that was super tasty I will come back again

Fried Plantains

See all

House cappuccino

Carved Rotisserie And Catering

4.1(8 reviews)

5.0 mi

I would rather not add stars for this review because I have been here 2X and really like the food…read moreand the service is great. However, last week I looked them up and ordered through Yelp (facilitated by Grubhub, apparently). I ordered 2 of the roast beefs, 2 chopped chickens and a chicken Caesar salad and salivated during my 30 min drive to pick up. I arrived to an entirely still and locked store. No sign of anyone. I've often noticed vendors failing to update working hours, and that is frustrating. But what's worse is when I've got Yelp blaming Grubhub and Grubhub blaming everyone. I called and there was never anyone at the store though Grubhub took my money and gave me a pickup time. They agreed to refund me in several days but did absolutely nothing to compensate or remedy the situation and took no responsibility. So I will not be using Grubhub again (and that may mean ordering through Yelp if they only work through Grubhub). I hope Carved cleans up their act with times. Very frustrating when nobody takes responsibility and I don't know whether I can even trust ordering food through Yelp.

Carved offers some interesting sandwiches in the old Dorsi's Pharmacy deli/store area. However, it…read moreis unrelated to Dorsi's, which means no more wonderful chicken salad, a Dorsi family recipe. Life moves on. We tried the Stirling Dip, which consists of sliced roast beef, sharp provolone, and caramelized onion on a garlic baguette. It also comes with a side serving of beef au jus, pickled cucumbers, and red onions. The beef was high-quality and so tender! The sandwich was stacked with a lot of beef, and we split it. It was super filling, and we had a hard time finishing it. The bread was soft and delicious. The sandwich cost $18.00. It was juicy enough that it didn't need to be dipped in the au jus. I would have given it 5 stars, but it was on the salty side. They told us that they will start serving meals in the future.