Great white pie and regular cheese. Love the cheesesteak! Friendly family Always a smile and greeting read more

I love the Sicilian slices here the cheese is fresh and the sauce is good. The service is quick and friendly. It's a neighborhood pizza spot so it has a local vibe to it. Definitely worth a visit if you want pizza read more

Ciccio's Pizza - Sicilian pizza - Pizza Near Me - South Plainfield, New Jersey

This is my "go to to-go" slice when I'm in South Plainfield. The crust tastes good, but is almost too thin as the tip sag forces you to fold it back over itself before you fold the slice to eat it. The pepperoni is a bit greasy, so do not try to eat the slices while driving unless you wear a bib. Two slices are going to set you back over $5 these days. Now, on to the hot sandos... I get pizza steaks, sausage, and/or the various meatball varieties. The fresh bread makes the sandwich worth the trip. The sauce is fresh and flavorful and the other ingredients are fresh. There are other choices in the area, but you won't be disappointed here. The restaurant is clean and the staff is friendly. read more

So I can't stand reviews that are based on niche issues or a poor service. Reviews should be culinarily based, right, that's the reason you're checking reviews. That being said Ciccios isn't on the downward trend they're sitting at the bottom. I used to love their pizza and now it is reminiscent of a Poconos based summer camps cafeteria pizza, plastic cheese and all. Every pizzeria has a below the bar pie come out now and then but this pie was engineered to be gross, you could taste every corner Ciccio's cut to produce this atrocity. I really hope it's because of the current economic climate and not because they sold out. Maybe one day they may return but for now it's a CicciNoooo. read more

I don't really like the pizza. The bread is not that cooked It's not the best pizza ! read more

My boyfriend and I recently moved to South Plainfield and we were in the mood for some pizza. We've heard that Ciccio's is one of the best in town so we decide to given them a try. We ordered a pepperoni pie and mild buffalo wings. The pizza was pretty standard. I wouldn't call them the best but it satisfies a craving. We really loved the wings! They had a good flavor to them. Very close and convenient to home. I would order from here again. read more

Ciccio's Pizza - Mild buffalo wings - Pizza Near Me - South Plainfield, New Jersey

See all

One of the BEST pizzeria's around. They use all fresh ingredients. Pretty much anything you order from their menu is AMAZING! We drive 40 min to just enjoy a good slice of pizza or a fabulous grilled chicken sandwich. The staff is amazing. Family owned and operated. They are very welcoming to make everyone feel like family! Highly recommend if you're looking to eat amazing food! read more

Ciccio's Pizza - Slice with Olices - Pizza Near Me - South Plainfield, New Jersey

Decent local spot. Only tried the plain and pepperoni pizza slices. The pizza was good. Your standard thin slice pizza. Slightly greasy and a good balance of sauce & cheese. Tables are taped off for social distancing dine in as well. Good solid spot. I'll try there other slices next time. read more

Ciccio's Pizza - Pepperoni & Plain Pizza Slices - Pizza Near Me - South Plainfield, New Jersey

First time stopping by, I was looking for something to have for lunch while I enjoyed the sunny day in Spring Lake Park since I happened to be in the area. They had a nice assortment of slices available so I went with my usual favorites the white and a sausage. I thought it was a bargain $6 and change with a drink included. The woman at the counter was very friendly too! When I finally ate my pizza at the park it was crisp and delicious. Now I definitely know where to go for pizza when I'm back in the area. Definitely recommend!!! read more

Ciccio's Pizza - Pizza in the park- Sausage and White Excellent! - Pizza Near Me - South Plainfield, New Jersey

Good pizza when you're hungry for a slice. Service is friendly. I would definitely stop by again.

#1 pizza in South Plainfield! Owner lives in SP and always gives back to the community. Their pizza is amazing!

No idea how long Ciccios has been open but I have been coming here for over 30 years. This is what you think of when you think of a local pizza place. Lots of table for people to hang out and order a slice, a friendly staff not to mention all the standards for an Italian restaurant. They make a good pizza but I really come here for their dinners. I love the eggplant parm or chicken parm, and they have really good meatballs. read more

Ciccio's Pizza - Eggplant Parmesan sandwich - Pizza Near Me - South Plainfield, New Jersey

Always consistently good pizza and service. Subs are ok. Go for the zepoles on Friday and Saturday !

Stopped in here on our quest to try vegan pies in & around NY. This was my boyfriend's favorite spot! Delicious pizza & fantastic service. The staff was super friendly & made sure to let us know they used uncontaminated tools on our pizza. Will definitely be back! read more

A great staple in my town, been there since I can remember. Nice staff and great food. Had a half veggie Hal pepperoni, and was pleasantly surprised by the veggie side; didn't expect eggplant on there! Come here whenever I'm in town and feeling pizza. read more

Yes, it is a typical pizza place. I did not notice anything that makes it unique and maybe that is one of the good points. You get what you expect coming in and the food is good. The other nice thing is there is a relatively large parking lot for the strip mall it is in and it seems to be one of the quieter ones. Bottom line, easy to get to and a nice place to go. read more

Typical local pizza place. Haven't tried anything out of this world. Pizza, Stromboli, and calzones are all good. I've gotten pasta dishes a few times which were just okay. The staff is always very friendly. Plenty of parking in the lot. read more

Ciccio's Pizza - Penne vodka with chicken. Very simple. - Pizza Near Me - South Plainfield, New Jersey

See all

I ordered @ 9:15pm on Sunday and they treated it as I ordered 5 mins after opening. No matter what you need they least treat every order like it's a family order. The food is great and the pizza is off the chain. The family is straight from Italy and they make the food like they are back home. Each pasta dish is made to order and nothing is mass produced. It's just real comfort Italian. I asked for extra fresh Mozzarella and basil and without question it was done. read more

Ciccio's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - South Plainfield, New Jersey

This review is gonna be a bit late cause I went here over a month ago but anyways it was first time here and ordered an eggplant parm sub and asked the guy if they had Buffalo chicken slice. The guy goes I can make you one. Me not knowing that he would just take the chicken slice that's sitting in the front display go to the back and just drizzle some hot sauce on it , I said yes okay. The guy came back and all you could taste is Buffalo sauce. I didn't wanna be rude so just ate it. But it's a joke. Like if you don't have something then just be honest and say that you don't instead of trying to make something that isn't. The slice did not look like Buffalo chicken slice nor did it taste like one. I DO NOT recommend it at all. If you really wanna eat Buffalo chicken slice go to another pizzeria. Eggplant parm sub was okay. read more

This place has been around for a very long time and run by the same people. Great true feast style Zeppole on Friday and Saturday only! A town favorite. read more

Fantastic pizza and perfectly fried calamari. Prices exceptional and friendly folks work here. Looking forward to trying more menu items.

They serve the best dinners and subs! Sev, Carmine, Fil, and family are always so very nice. read more

See all

My favorite pizza place. Hands down. I've tried pizza places all around Bergen County with my boyfriend just to prove how good the pizza at Ciccio's is. Plus, customer service is always great. They're quick to address customers' needs and questions. read more

My husband and i are visiting his hometown from Ct, while exploring we stumbled upon this place. The pizza is thin crust and not greasy or heavy at all and the cold cut sandwich was the best i ever had. After eating my husband and i went back to order two more sandwiches to bring back to CT with us. Ciccio's pizza keep doing what you are doing and we will be back trust us. And by the way the chicken caesar slice was amazing!! read more

After driving for over three hours straight, I was starving and looking for something other than highway fast food to eat. Making my way to my destination on local roads, I stopped at the first pizza place I saw, super hungry for at least a slice of pizza, and possibly a hot sandwich. As I'm standing at the counter, I look over at the pizzas on display and see a cockroach casually walking around the counter...and walk underneath a tray with a pizza on top. I tell the girl at the cash register..."uhm...I just saw a cockroach walk under the pizza tray." She lifts the tray, with the pizza, and sure enough, the roach is still walking around. She takes a rag, and pushes the roach across the counter, into the glass display, and squishes it to death. I was so hungry that I almost stayed, but thought better of it. "Actually, I gotta go. Sorry." I turned around and left. I figured if I saw one roach, there's gotta be a lot more that I don't see, and I didn't want to take any chances. Eat at your own risk. read more

I personally am a fan of Ciccios. I think it's thin and tasty. Always good service and the pizza doesn't leave you feeling disgusting afterwards. My wife thinks it's too thin but I find it perfect. And they have the two pie specials as well. read more

Young females cashier (family member) apparently doesn't know how to properly interact with customers. Has an attitude and treats you like you're an inconvenience. Papa pizza owner should work on her people skills. They're not the only pizza joint in South Plainfield. Pizza is average. It's customer service that keeps patrons coming back. read more

Pizza is sub-par. For an Italian owner I am incredibly disappointed. I come from NYC, so when I saw a pizzeria in Jersey with an Italian owner I thought to myself that this is going to be great pizza (there are tons with polish owners, Mexican owners, etc - not that I have anything against other ethnicities, but if you walk into a Chinese restaurant and find it is owned and made by Indians, you will question the quality). I couldn't even eat the pizza. I threw it away. I work only a couple blocks away so I figured I would give it another chance... big mistake! It was even worse on the second go - round. I will NOT be making the same mistake again! The young female cashier is the owners daughter. She's never been disrespectful toward me, but she isn't exactly friendly either. The owner sits in the back chit chatting with the same group of men every time I've walked in. Yes, I've only eaten the pizza twice - but I do stop in from time to time and grab a snapple. I wonder what they do all say long... maybe this is why the pizza stinks. read more

Good spot to go for lunch or grab a slice. I like their chicken Parmesan sandwiches and they have zeppolies on Fridays (even though I have not tried it them yet) they are friendly and quick and you can even call in an order ahead if you are in a rush. read more

I have long hopped to find a pizzaria that wa as good as the one from my childhood. Ciccio's is it. Their pizza is so good - IMO on of the best in NJ and certainly my current favorite. Everything is just right. Right amount of thickness (not doughy), sauce and cheese. I see two Italian gentlemen's making them and that is certainly reassuring. The staff here is also supper friendly and welcoming. Highly recommended. I come by here every time I drive by and have a few slices. read more

Great local family-owned spot with excellent friendly service. Perfect for impromptu picnics as it's conveniently located across from Spring Lake Park. Our go-to pizza toppings are the Caesar salad with chicken, buffalo chicken, sausage and pepperoni. Added bonus: they regularly host our children's sports teams and support our school events. read more

This place used to be a go to spot for all my pizza cravings. You can't go wrong with big, greasy, cheesy slices of pizza. The pizza here isn't out of this world, but it satifies those late night pizza cravings. read more

I've tried a few different pizza places in the area and this is the best one I've found so far. The sauce on the slices was great and the cheesesteak I had was very good also. 4 stars because there's not a very large selection of specialty slices at lunch, but all of the slices I've tried at lunch are very good. read more

This has been a great debate in the area for quite sometime. "Who has better pizza in the area?" With each parlor having their own secret way of throwing a pie together,. Ciccio's finds them self with a unique flavor all their own. The cheese proportion is just right, the sauce has a sweet after-taste, and the crust is more chewier than crispy. When your their, ask to be sat in the "Big Al" section so you can watch how pizza boxes are folded together. Ciao read more

This pizza was ok, but nothing special. The slices in the window were pretty standard, and even included a "chicken" which was literally just a chicken cutlet, cut up and thrown over a pizza. Like, at least toss in in sauce and call it a buffalo slice no? Anyway, I got a veg slice and the plain chicken slice. The slices themselves were pretty big, but both went floppy. It was weird, there was a good crunch in the crust and tip of both slices, but the middles were a greasy, oily slop fest. Nothing special here. read more

I love Ciccios. The friendliest staff. My favorite pizza, and my first go to when I don't feel like cooking. Great place, great value. I could live on their sausage n pepper subs. read more

This is South Plainfield's 2nd best pizza. The crust is awesome and the toppings are plentiful. The Strombolis here are also great. They have a multitude of hot and cold subs too. A personal favorite of mine is the meatball parm sub. Ciccio's has the best one in the area. You can't go wrong whether you just want a slice or something a little more substantial. read more

I like this place. It's has the old-fashioned pizzeria-style bench seats, they serve zeppoli's on Friday's and Saturday's, the slices taste great right out of the oven and they even make a Pizza Hero...which is your typical hoagie/sub roll filled with cheese and pizza sauce like a sandwich. I used to get these as a kid in Elizabeth and forgot all about them until I was brought back in time with Ciccio's. Good food, good service, good staff....you won't go wrong. read more

I love it when typical run of the mill pizzerias have good bread! The husband ordered a pepperoni slice and a cheese steak. Pizza is your typical NY style, oily, and greasy pizza. I wouldn't have it any other way when I come home to visit. However, this is the first time we ordered something other than pizza. Got a cheese-steak with all the fixings and it was delicious! It was filled with ooy--gooy cheese on a nice French-style baguette. Not the typical soft Italian rolls. This really adds texture tot he cheese-steak, the crust on the bread.. wow. Bring the sandwich to a totally new level. read more

Pizza is ok. Not one of my top pics for Pizza in the area. They don't deliver. They gave me a problem about one of their own coupons and I just never went back. Too many other good restaurants in the area to go back to this one. For delivery I'd go to Carmen's for P/U I'd go Rudolfos. read more