The personal Sicilian pizza was AMAZING - four slices of heaven. My son and I each could only eat one. This pie can easily feed two people for only $9.50. What a steal!! We'll be back for sure! read more

Rome Pizza - Slice of Sicilian - Pizza Near Me - Dunellen, New Jersey

I went in after work last night, to grab something quick. I asked for 2 slices, guy was on his phone& acting like I bothered him. Like I interrupted something........ Looks like pizza was old from the morning. Guy was more focused on his phone than my service. & the Guy didn't even heat it up enough. Rushed it... Gave it to me cold ish Will I go back , absolutely not Will I tell people to go there. Absolutely no way. Not a fan& I'm definitely given my business to the other pizza places in town. read more

The guy on the phone was super nice when taking our order, and the pizza looked great! We got an 3/4 Pepperoni and 1/4 Cheese, XL size. In regard to the taste, I was expecting a little more pizazz based on previous reviews, but it was still pretty good and I would definitely return and ask for extra sauce next time. Also, they are a cash only business, so please prepare accordingly! The inside is very old school Italian joint. We did takeout, but they have tables if you wish to stay and eat. read more

Rome Pizza - 3/4 Pepperoni 1/4 Cheese XL --Exactly how I wanted it! - Pizza Near Me - Dunellen, New Jersey

I love this pizza! We ordered a whole pie. Two slices had pepperoni, two slices had sausages, and the other half pie was plain. Quick service, too 10 minutes. We ate in and ordered a 2L Coke. The pie was so hot! It was perfect! The cheese was perfect! Not over cooked like other restaurants! The crust ends were soft. The under crust had some scorching! The sauce has a slight sour! I love when the sauce is not sweet! Brought the family for dinner tonight! No ice small restaurant! read more

Rome Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dunellen, New Jersey

Feels like a classic old school Jersey pizza spot the second you walk in, cash only, the owner John was really great and chatted with me for a few minutes while the pizzas got ready. Got the pizzas to go and the entire family enjoyed it including the kids. Not on door dash or Uber Eats but worth taking the time to pick up or eat in. read more

This place is so cool. It's like it froze in history and you walk into a time capsule. Everything is meticulously cared for and in the original condition from its opening. My girls and I stop by for a slice from time to time after their class at the gym next door. $10.60 get us all a slice and a drink. The pizza is just right for Jersey. Simple crust, not too greasy. The family who owns the restaurant makes you feel like family just stopping by for a slice and watching Jeopardy. Stop by, not just for a slice, but to enjoy a bit of Dunellen history. read more

Absolutely amazing am visiting family here in jersey I have never been to this pizzeria before and OMG I want to come back every day!!! Pizza is so fresh and very delicious amazing service very friendly staff and amazing ambiance felt like home will definitely be back before I leave read more

Rome Pizza - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dunellen, New Jersey

Great pizza made from quality ingredients- the peperoni pizza can't be beat. They also make an amazing calzone.

Always great pizza from Rome Pizza. One of the few places still offering an 18 inch pizza. The best cheese, never that oily cheap cheese that too many places now use. A healthy amount of toppings and always great service. And fair prices too read more

Vintage, Old School, What is missing today. These are the three things that come to mind about this perfect pizza spot. It is a multi generational family owned business that brings you to the past. It's Cash only, so what get over it because it should be. Because nothing about this place is modern and that is what makes it special. The service is local and friendly. And guess what, the Pizza IS AMAZING and AFFORDABLE (See Cash only). They have an ATM and there are about 10 other ATMs within a 5 min walk so all good. Please try this place once so you can say you have been here read more

Great pizza spot_cash only and it's been around forever. It has a very old-school vibe, but the quality is elite and it's a staple in the community. Nestled just off the main street in Dunellen, you can't go wrong here, unless you only have Apple Pay. Excellent family-run service. Highly recommend. read more

Love this family owned cash only establishment! The atmosphere is spectacular. Love the bar seating and the decor with the history! I'm a sucker for places with an interesting history. The service was phenomenal. Attentive with a smile. The pizza is where they shine! The prices are affordable and they even offer a nonna pizza that has no cheese and no onions for anyone who might be allergic. I didn't get a chance to take any photos cause I made it all magically disappear before I could even think about a photo! Don't miss out! Eat here asap. Pizza and drinks only! read more

Best NY slice I've had in NJ and the calzone is unparalleled. It was freshly rolled and baked after ordering. I'm not usually a fan of calzones and would make a trip back here just for that! read more

Rome Pizza - Pepperoni calzone - Pizza Near Me - Dunellen, New Jersey

This is hands down some of the best pizza I have ever had! Born in New York, traveled all over the world, and been to Italy 4 times... this pizza was epic! Fed my entire moving team that was working for a customer and even our customer had some and was blown away! Super epic! If I am ever in town again....I WILL BE BACK! read more

just not my cup of tea and didn't like the atmosphere, bad energy and not worth the price. honest truth

I love Rome pizza, small business with a BIG Game. Their pizza is delicious at a good price.

After moving from Brooklyn to central Jersey, I couldn't find anything that compares to a true NY slice.. That is, until I found Rome!! Reminds me of home- the taste, the atmosphere, the cash only (annoying but it's ok). I haven't tried anything else besides a plain pizza but it's just so good that I can't order anything else! read more

Delicious pizza. Family-owned and very friendly. They have been around for a while for good reason. Reasonably priced but CASH only.

Another FANTASTIC sausage, peppers and onions pizza. Look at those toppings. Just the way I like it! Mmmmmmm! read more

Rome Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dunellen, New Jersey

See all

Obviously this neat clean old school storefront in Dunellen is doing something right since it's been around for 50 years!!! The pizza is the key here--it's very good with a delicious crust, tasty sauce and right amount of mozzarella on top! Hats off to the friendly family members who run the business. Looking forward to returning! read more

Best Sicilian slice I've had in a long time. Most places don't do it the way it was done back in the day. But Rome does it the old school way in those oil rubbed black pans. Fantastic. Definitely will be back. read more

Went to a small pizzeria in Dunellen Nj today to try out a slice of pizza . Rome pizza is a small but very clean pizzeria. Parking is on the street only and meter parking quarters only ! . They don't have a Hugh menu mostly pizzas. I order two slice to go they were fresh and tasty for a standard type pizzeria. They had a lot of chesse on the pizza more then any other pizzeria would put on . It's a cash only spot . It was ran by the two owners mom and son . They have been in business for over 51 years . They must be doing something right . Good standard pizza for a good price . read more

See all

I have been looking for a pizzeria that gets it right in my area for a while. After reading all the positive reviews, I decided to try this place out. The pizza (pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms) was excellent! Definitely plan to go back again. read more

By far the best pizza around. The calzones are also noteworthy, and large enough to feed AT LEAST two. Overall, a really nice family owned business with great food. Highly recommend read more

We had a few slices here and would describe it as authentic NJ/NYC pizza. Large thin crust with good cheese and sauce. A bit greasy, but overall delicious. Old school mom and pop place that is worth checking out. Cash only. read more

A classic pizza place!!! We were walking back to the car after a few hours at The Break Arcade next door and saw this place. My little guy loves pizza so we stopped in for a slice. I love seeing the old school pizza place and having a little chat with the woman behind the counter finding out that they have been there over 50 years. Thats amazing!!! Any pizza place that has letter boards as menus is good in my book. The modern place can keep their damn flatscreen menus. I did feel a little bad as the place was practically empty on a Saturday afternoon. We sat and ordered 2 slices and a drink, which is a special for $4.50. The pizza was really good...Nothing beats good ole Pizzaria pizza. The prices were very fair about $2 per slice and even 20oz sodas about $1.85. I would recommend this place to everyone. Support the local businesses!!! read more

See all

Pizza is really good and good price only bad thing is is that pizza is the only they make here but I love the old school style of the restaurant read more

The pizza is delicious. The service is good. My only concern is that they only accept cash. It makes things a little inconvenient when you want to grab a pie real quick, but don't have any cash on hand. You have to plan ahead for this pizza night. read more

Rome Pizza is old school, excellent pizza. I've been living in Central NJ for about 30 years now. Originally from NY. Yes it's cash only. But there's a bank right across the street and another bank 2 doors down (with an outside ATM) to get cash. My 5 stars is for their consistently great pizza and Calzones. Pizza places shouldn't be about the decor, or the ambiance. It's about one thing: great consistent pizza that tastes excellent. You shouldn't pay $20 or more for a pizza with toppings, or a large cheese pizza that costs $18.00 or more The pizza at Rome is made every day from scratch by the Owners. It's not a high priced pizza maker from Naples at $25 a pie. It's not a bunch of kids who have no idea what old school pizza should taste like. I order a medium cheese pizza a little well done and a large meat lovers pizza (pepperoni, meatballs, sausage). Sometimes I order the white pizza with mozzarella/ricotta. All are delicious. The medium cheese and large meat lovers pizza cost me less than $30.00. And they are worth more. The meat lovers pizza is filled with meat and three to four slices for me at 6ft 225 lbs is a meal! The place takes you back in time to pizza places from the 1970's. It's not dressed to impress, and I like it that way. It's clean, simple and has lots of tables and there's no rush to eat. The pizza is the best in Central NJ. I come from 20 minutes away and pass alot of mediocre pizza joints for these pies. I call them while I'm driving over, and when I get there 20 minutes later my pizzas are ready and waiting for me. My wallet and my stomach are very happy after having their pizza. And their Calzones are awesome too. If you want decor, and a guy from Naples making you pizza that costs $20 or more a pie and doesn't taste like old school pizza, please keep going to those places so I can simply come into Rome Pizza, grab a table and have not have to wait to have comparable as well as better pizza at half the price. And give my money directly to the owners who are busting their butt every day making scratch pizza for decades. read more

Complies with all safety precautions the state has put in place one of the cleanest and safest places I've ordered from

The absolute BEST pizza in the area, the sausage is so good and I am usually not a fan of sausage

I'm a little torn with my review of this place. I went here strictly because it had excellent reviews. I will say this... the pizza itself was good. The sauce has a little different taste than I'm used to, but I do think the toppings were fresh and plentiful. I ordered extra large pies, not thinking they'd be massive and weigh a ton so that was good! It was a little pricey though! And their website is out of date so thankfully I had a little extra cash on me. Cash only too. read more

They are still open for business. Take out only. SUPPORT LOCAL BUSINESSES. If this place didn't exist I'm sure I wouldn't eat pizza in NJ. They are the best around. read more

We go to a pizzeria once a week and decided with all the good reviews to try Rome Pizza in Dunellen. I grew up in Brooklyn and Brooklyn still has the best pizza and bagels fuhgeddaboudit. Any way, I went with the sicilian and my better half tried a regular slice with sausage. MEH is the right word for it. Crust was nice and cheese had flavor but the sauce...the sauce..it was red and it was wet, and that's it. Maybe someone forgot the seasoning tonight. It's too far out of our way to give it a second chance so for now 2 stars is all I can give. read more

Great pizza!! One of the best I've had in NJ. Definitely worth a stop if you're in this area.

Looking for that place in the neighborhood, that has the Jersey Neighborhood feel? Then check out Rome Pizza in Dunellen, NJ. Its located on 334 north ave. While walking on this street, I noticed a sign that said voted be "slice of heaven" champion by the home news. http://www.mycentraljersey.com/article/20120923/NJNEWS/309230006 . You go inside and you definitely get that neighborhood feel, its a mother and son operation and you got locals watching the news on tv as some wait for their takeout order. I can vouch for the "localness" when another patron comes in and chats with one who was sitting by the counter. The atmosphere is pleasant and so is the pizza. Pizza is not on my list of quests, though I have tried brooklyn pizza, which as a reputation all its own. The pizza is thin slice, the flavor with some variance, I did notice some herbs on it maybe oregano? But it did have a character and I would be more than willing to stop by again or order a whole pie for takeout. This write up made me think of this question? How would you describe your ideal slice of pizza? In my experience, they have been slightly salty, sour, and somewhere in the middle when it comes to taste and Im a fan of texture, when the pizza is thin slice (New York style?) not salty or sour and the dough layer has a slight crisp to it when you fold it NOT thin crust mind you..Let me know what you think in your comments? As for my best or memorable experience of pizza? I would have to say it stated in New York City, Manhattan 14th street, close to P.S.19. I think the place was called "Alto's". I will always have fond memories of that place since My grandfather and I would go there to get a slice during lunchtime. Feel free to share your pizza slice experience as well....hehe read more

See all

I can't believe this place doesn't have more reviews. C'mon people! We arrived at the town of Dunellen, NJ, exhausted from a 3-hour journey from New York City and hungry for some good food. Rome Pizza was one of the only options as far as we could see on the street we were on so we went in and decided to give it a try. What we got was pure amazement. We each ordered two pizzas, topped with pepperoni, sausage, onions and garlic. The garlic and onions were fresh and nearly raw on the pizza, so at first I was worried it would taste bad. However, the nearly raw ingredients were what made the pizza truly great - every bite was a bite of freshness and chewiness. It was unlike any other pizza I've ever had before. This place has a very homey, mom and pop type feel, which I truly appreciate. It seems like the owners know a lot of the customers who come in. It's great to witness a small town feel, especially when you're coming from somewhere as busy as New York City. I truly loved Rome Pizza and I will definitely visit again should I ever find myself in Dunellen, NJ again in the future. read more

Fantastic pizza. One of the best places you can go to. Delicious sauce, cheese and dough. I can tell they put passion and care into it and this is why they've been around since 1967. I just don't give 5 stars to a pizza spot but they do it right here and the first bite is like heaven. read more

Honestly, this place is over-hyped. I went with the Rome Special, sausage, pepper and onion. The slices were floppy in the middle and all the cheese and topping slid off. The distribution of the sausage was bad, mostly in the middle where the topping were falling off. That said, the actual taste was pretty good. A shame they can't figure out how to make the crust hold up to the toppings. For everyone touting this as the "best pizza in central NJ"... There is better 15 minutes away, closer to my house. No reason to drive all the way over here for this. read more

Rome Pizza is by far the best pizza on the planet! These wonderful people take pride in their Pizza. They don't just throw it in the oven it's homemade sauce it's just amazing and they make it to order. It is never just sitting out. I've gotten to know the owner over the years and his mom. They are just all-around wonderful people they treat you like family. You had the rest now try the best at Rome Pizza I promise you you won't be disappointed. A&J Yeag. read more