We decided a pizza and onion rings would be good for dinner tonight. One of the pizzerias we like is Dominicks. Well not anymore. They jacked their price on a medium pepperoni pizza by $6.00 I cannot believe that is even close to being reasonable. AND though they have onion rings still on the menu they do not sell them any more. I have attached pictures of their menu. Last one they used to deliver, not any more even though it is still on their VERY SAD MENU. I should have looked at the reviews before we ordered. With service like this they should lock their doors. We employees can tell customer them they are to busy to help them, they should lock the door. When they have a Menu that has had all the prices blacked out they should close the door and lock it for good. Even so I am very sad that they are going out of business. read more

See all

This isn't the first time that this has happened but it's the first time that I'm leaving a review. Our family just tried to place an order for a pizza and they called me back stating that my card was declined so I asked politely if they could run my card one more time because he probably misunderstood me and he said that he had tried three times so he would not be trying again so so I mentioned can you please try again if not, just cancel the order and he said OK and hung up the phone on me. There has been multiple occasions where we order pizza for our family. This was a place that we've been ordering from over 10 years and it's always the same bullshit negative rude attitude they don't even let you finish placing the order on the phone before they're trying to rush you off the phone never again read more

any topping pizza i have ordered from here has been delicious! this time i ordered a chicken bacon ranch and it was so good! service over the phone and in person is good! drive thru makes it so much easier, i recommend this place for pies! read more

Dominick's Pizzeria - chicken bacon ranch pizza - Pizza Near Me - Piscataway, New Jersey

See all

Absolutely HORRIBLE experience at Dominick's where I overheard a manager belittling and humiliating his employee in front of everyone. He said to the employee "I don't need your mistakes [profanity] up my business. If you do one more mistake you're done after today. I don't need you [profanity] up this business when I can run it by myself. Don't forget that." And kept repeating it in his employees face OVER AND OVER again. The employee, who very obviously had just started out in this location, was apologizing profusely and trying to be as perfect as possible. Unfortunately, he did something that ticked off his manager and the manager said "don't come back tomorrow." And continued to repeat it again and again while the employee was still trying to work. It was heartbreaking. I have done food service roles before and learning all the ins and outs takes time and is a learning curve. I feel for the employee in this situation and wish he knows that he provided excellent service to me. The manager however, made this such a horrid experience. DO NOT COME TO THIS LOCATION. OVER PRICED food (that is not worth the price) and hostile work environment. To the manager at this establishment, if you do not have the patience to train and have empathy for your employees then I suggest looking for experienced staff members that have worked in pizzerias before you hire them. You could've taken this employee to the back or had a debrief after the day was over. Not hurt and demean him as you did. I will not be coming back here and I suggest others do the same . read more

So I grew up in Piscataway and while I dabbled in just about EVERY pizza place in town, Dominick's was always, by far, my favorite. I've been going to Dominicks for over 35 years and EVERY time I go back to P-way I stop in at Dominicks for a couple of slices. Sneaking down to there a couple weeks ago once again proved to me, that even with all of the changes over the years (how many of you remember when the original place burned down?) it is still that place that brings me back to my childhood. I really think that if I did a taste test I could pick out the slice from Dominick's. The thin crust is always perfect, and even though the sauce has changed a little from when I was a kid (it's a little sweeter now), it doesn't take away from the quality of the pies. Growing up, I was always a big fan of the extra chees pie, but these days it's usually either just a plain slice or their sausage is delicious. Ok so I'm reminiscing a bit, but just writing this brings me back to the old shop with the original owner (well, at least as far back as I can remember) and watching him and the other guys tossing/stretching the dough and arguing over everything...toppings flying all over the place, Dad letting me get a slice while we waited for our pies to finish cooking. I need a fix. Gotta get back down there again soon. read more

Very very very bad spot DO NOT COME HERE GUY CHARGES 5$ a slice 10$ for only two single pizza slices!!!! Take your money across the street to the bagel pizzeria instead these guys are a big scam!! read more

Dominick's Pizzeria - Pizza slice - Pizza Near Me - Piscataway, New Jersey

Good variety of "gourmet" pizzas. Excellent thin light crust, it is just the right balance of crispy but not hard or dry. Lasagna pizza with ricotta, chopped meat, mozzarella, grated cheese and tomato sauce really tasted like lasagna. I also tried what looked like bacon chicken ranch, although it's not listed on the menu, the "bacon" tasted somewhat like pancetta. It was tasty. The interior is very clean and open. I will definitely return when I'm in the area. read more

See all

Their pizza is usually pretty good, but after ordering their lasagna today, we won't be returning. "Meat Lasagna" was meatless. Literally paid $11 for a tomatoe soup and bread. When called to ask what happened to the meat, their response was I have to check with the chef and then disconnected. Rude service and highly disappointed with the food. read more

Dominick's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Piscataway, New Jersey

See all

Highly disappointed! The person who took my order on the phone was so rude !!! I'm a loyal customer but not after today! On top of that they did not deliver my right order! Never again will I be ordering from this place and I'll be sure to mention to my close peoples about not ordering from here. Save your money and don't give It to these people! read more

This review is going to be very biased based on 2 things. 1) I went at 11:30 on a Saturday, so all the pies were fresh. I got first slice on all 3 pizzas I tried, and 2) I ate there, so I have my food right out of the oven. So I went with the buffalo, chicken/bacon/ranch (CBR) and Caesar. Buffalo was really good- nice bit of heat, tasted like Franks- which I am down with. Pizza held straight with a little crisp to the crust, but I could have used just a little more. The CBR, while not my favorite slice to order, was the best slice of CBR I've even had. I don't know, something is just always off for me at other places- dry chicken, rubbery bacon, weird ranch... this place just got all 3 just right. Caesar was also good, but not my favorite flavor of Caesar dressing. If you go early for fresh pies and get it out of the oven (and maybe tell them you want it left in a little longer), this place will not disappoint. read more

Don't waste your time. Ordered via GrubHub at 8:40, and at 9:10 called to see if the order was en route, as there was no update. The guy who answered said "uh I didn't check, but we don't deliver orders made past 9 so it's too late now. No we didn't get it" and cancelled it as we hung up the phone. Solid customer service read more

Do not trust these people to give you what you order. I ordered online and they delivered the wrong pizza and left it on the porch1 I had waited an hour for it and when I called to report the problem, they said to call back because they were busy! They refused to make it right. I will never order from them again. I'd give them 0 stars if I could. read more

I grew up in Piscataway and have always eaten at Dominick's even before their new location across the street. Great pizza, great quality. Now with the drive thru, it makes getting a slice easier and faster. Try their garlic knots, but make sure you have some gum or mints afterward. read more

Have had pizza from here several times and am always pleased. I am a huge fan of the white pizza with broccoli. The slices are gigantic and have pockets of creamy ricotta and garlicky broccoli. A delicious combination that is not too rich for a white pizza. Their cheese and veggie pizza aren't bad as well. A bit on the pricier side but definitely worth it. read more

Dominick's Pizzeria - White broccoli pizza - Pizza Near Me - Piscataway, New Jersey

My family has been longstanding fans of Dominick's, but last night they pulled a fast one on us. We got 2 pies to go and didn't look at them before leaving (we were all hungry). Got home to find the contents of one pie all on one half of the pie. Not up to their usually higher standard, as well as much greasier than normal. Word to the wise, always look inside the box before leaving. My kids want to look for a new favorite pizza place. read more

So this is my second time getting pizza in Jersey, and this place was pretty good. Their sausage and mushroom pizza was great. I LOVE the fact that they shred the sausage instead of having it a little more clumpy. What I loved most was the variety of flavors. I saw a kale/broccoli pizza, supreme, Sicilian, a chicken Caesar, too! That chicken Caesar was awesome! The only drawback of this place is more of google maps fault. I hope they get it fixed because I missed it twice while using Google as my GPS. Extra bonus of this place: drive thru!! read more

Rude and over priced...i was in restaurants damn near 20 years and never in my life was told 30 mins for burger and then charged 19 and change for 3 slices mozzarella sticks and a drink...the cook came had a straight attitude for no reason...and on topool of it all the place was empty...as a former member of the restaurant industry I never do this but today itbvbhad to happen read more

You owe's me $40 I ordered a pizza and sides on 08/03/2018 at 915pm. I never received my order.

Everytime I order a sandwich, I get a slightly different variation. One time I had received red sauce, another time onions (always ask for no onions), sometimes with cheese, and lately I get unbreaded chunks of chicken instead of a chicken cutlet. It wouldnt bother me, but it's bland and dry. Mind you I order the same thing often enough and it's not a custom item. I went in to get my money back, and the young employee was very nice about the situation, but the older guy behind the counter had an attitide. You would think that he would ask what went wrong or how it could be made better to a customer that spends about $2k over the course of a year but instead he repeated "I don't have time for this." Luckily, Enzo's does and they know the difference between a cutlet and dry chunks of chicken. It's a shame because for a while they had a good run. I guess their lack of time is leading to these obvious mistakes. read more

Ordered 3 Meatball Subs and a Cheese steak. All came out great, A good Pizza spot on the North Side of town

0 stars because I walked in and walked right back out. Please wear a mask while cooking and serving the food. How is it that you want a customers to wear a mask, but all of your mask are pulled down. read more

Okay, I've been here a few times to pick up a slice or two for the kids. Not too bad a slice. Today I ordered for delivery. The order arrived in a timely manner, only took about half an hour. The wings were soggy. The coating was falling off of them and they smelled a little "off". Can't give a review on taste because I didn't try them due to the smell. The mozzarella sticks were not the average breading, think more of a fish n chip batter. I tried one and didn't care for it. My wife got a chef's salad that didn't even come with a salad dressing. On to the pizza. I think I lost a filing. The dough was extremely tough. Not sure if this means it has been sitting around for a few days, or if this is a bad batch of dough. My three year old couldn't even chew it. He spit it out and asked for something else. My five year old smothered it in ketchup and let it get soggy. My previous experiences with this pizza have been okay. I've been going there every few months since I moved to the area 6 years ago. Average local spot for pizza with a decent slice. Seems like quality fell off a cliff recently. After this experience I'll get Papa John's before I order from Dominick's again. read more

Came here to celebrate a tournament basketball win with our 3rd grade boys, just to be greeted with negativity and annoyance. The Owner, Vinnie gave our team along with their families trouble just because we wanted to eat here and celebrate. We were too many people he said...THE PLACE WAS EMPTY!!!! Considering all of his 1-star reviews he's lucky we came here out of convenience since it was so close to the gym and give him business. For an owner of a pizzeria with SO MANY negative reviews, he's lucky he's still in business. If you want a warm, friendly environment to eat. DON'T COME HERE....THAT'S NOT WHAT YOU'RE GONNA GET. read more

Ordered food from this place and everything was great! We had Cavatelli and Broccoli, Eggplant Rollatini, and a Sausage and Broccoli Rabe Stromboli just to try it out. My only complaints are that the eggplant could have been a bit more seasoned, the Cavatelli was REALLY oily, and the Stromboli was a little too doughy*. However, the food was still really delicious especially for pizza place entrees and we will definitely order from here again! *full disclosure: we reheated the Stromboli and we are big foodies so we have high standards, hence the 4 stars despite the complaints read more

Our food was tasteless broccoli Rabe was tough noodles were hard and seemed to have been fried in a frying Pan garlic bread was like rubber as if it was cooked in a microwave tasteless will not order from there again. read more

We go there on an average twice a week always get the 2 large pie with the coupon the pies are the best around that coming from someone how travels all over to try pizza Dominick's foods is always great just like the pizza we like the chicken parm dinner baked ziti and the best sausage Stromboli . Thanks to staff for great service . Rick read more

If your going get a PIZZA from this joint make sure you ask for a GARLIC pie, It is with out a doubt the best!!! I'm a Pizza freak.. not face!!! It's better then the plain pie, If you like garlic then this is the place to order one they bring it to you now YEAH!!!! nice people too!!! I've been going thier for almost 38 years :-) Johnny from Piscataway.. read more

The lady below is right this place is rude. I came here when they were across the street at 7/11 since I was in preschool & went to young learners academy. I called today to make a order he rushed me & sounded just so obnoxious & rude. I debated for about 5 seconds if I wanted to pay the delivery fee even tho I'm like 2 minutes away from their place (I just couldn't drive today) & within those 5 seconds he goes well that's the fee you call me back and tell me when you know what you want & I told him he was being mean & he says "I'm not being mean" like man you could of said sorry. Very sad about this after I been coming here since pre-K and the only reason I still do is to support & the pizza isn't even that good read more

RIPPED OFF - ran in for 2 slices, got a regular and grandma's - "10 bucks!" On my way back to the car it hit me, "no way?" I just got 2 slices for $10... but I did. I just checked their menu online - should have been $5.85. It's a shame they weren't bad, and I am new to the area... they just lost my business. read more

WHAT A DISAPPOINTMENT this place has become. I live 2 blocks from here but will rather go eat a slice of pizza from 7-ELEVEN across the street than from them. UNPROFESSIONAL young kid at register. My boyfriend asked him if he could get a refill on the soda he purchased with his meal... kid replies "no. I'll tell you what I tell everyone else, go to 7-Eleven if you want a free refill". read more

Gross... dead bugs on the tables, flies everywhere, the wings tasted like soap, some of the greasiest pizza I've ever had, and the garlic knots were dry. The workers were handing someone a takehome box and dropped it, they looked annoyed when the customer asked for a new one and then proceeded to talk about him behind the counter. They put the dropped box back in the stack. When we asked for water, they gave us water with pink dye in it from the same spout as another pink drink. Just save yourself the trouble and go somewhere else. read more

Recent return to the area after 22 years and met some high-school friends at Dominick's for a reunion. Amazingly the place has not changed since 1986!. It is like walking into retroville...same booths, same plastic pitchers of pop and the same great pizza. My Texas-raised husband was confused when the he was asked if he was waiting for a "pie!" The place is primarily takeout as evidenced by the several folks coming in and out, but was able to deal with a table of ten including our kids. Still as I remember, great pizza....! Your classic neighborhood joint! read more

The BEST pizza in the area bar none. Oil on the crust and awesome tasting garlic, damn I wish I was back!

Pizza was ok. Bottom of my sliced where burnt. Especially on my plan slice after they reheated it. The Chicken Bacon Ranch was better. The topping made up for the burnt bottom. priced for the quality. read more

My family and I Love Dominicks Pizza. We go there 2-3 times a month we enjoy the food and prices. They do a awesome job. Place is very clean and the staff is great!! read more

I recently ordered a cheesesteak for pick up and when I got the order home the bread burned.

Kid that took my order handled my pizza with his bare hands after touching money, wiping his hands on his clothes, and had a sore on his finger! I had to tell him to use the spatula to handle my food!!!! read more

I've been going to this spot since middle school (40+ years). I ordered a large cheese steak sandwich yesterday but got a cheesesteak PIZZA. The owner refused to give me the correct order because I bit the pizza (what was he going to do with it? Try to re-sell it after it's been delivered to my house?) When I got it I knew it was the wrong order but decided to try it since it was delivered. It was disgusting. I had to drive to the restaurant just to get my $ returned. This jerk was rude as hell.. Mind you I order from this spot a couple of times a month. This BIG DUMMY would rather lose a faithful customer rather than make me a cheesesteak. I'll never order from this spot again!!! Pizza spots are a dime a dozen. Jerks forget who their loyal customers are. read more

Love Dominicks, I've been coming here since I was a kid. Really good pizza, a great neighborhood business. I've only eaten in the back restaurant one time and it did not disappoint. read more

This is my third time coming here to get a ham and cheese sandwich. Each time the service was fast, friendly, courteous and polite. And best of all, I've never tasted a better ham and cheese sandwich. read more