Returned to Carne Mare for dinner on a busy Saturday evening and had a great meal. Started with the Yellowfin Tuna and Caesar Salad - both excellent. For our mains we had the Prime Rib (impressive!) and the Sweet Corn Raviolini (great flavor) along with the Mushroom Marsala (very good) as a side dish. The Lemon Sorbetto (with the limoncello ) for dessert provided a nice finish to the meal. Very friendly staff and our server Craig was terrific. Great, lively atmosphere. Hope to be back soon! read more

See all

My 2 nd time dining here & all I could think about was the 17 layer chocolate cake We started with fresh bread and a hearty wedgini salad but no Gorgonzola for me ...along with mozzarella sticks with caviar For our 2nd course the Chef sent us out a delicious plate of ravioli filled with smoked ricotta with a creamy corn sauce. For the entree we had the Ribeye with Rustic potatoes, but again all I could think about was the 17 layer chocolate cake & when it finally hit the table for my mouth watered from anticipation . It is the most delicious and creamy cake I've ever eaten . So hats off to The Chef for all the food and whoever is making the desserts deserves a medal and a statue in his liking. 5 stars! read more

Came with a friend on a Wednesday night at 7 and sat outside- would absolutely recommend. The view is stunning. Started with martinis. I will admit it was beginning to get busy, but the service was incredibly slow. Could've ordered 2 more drinks between the time the oysters and mains came of the server stopped by. Ordered the grilled oysters- DIVINE. The lobster spaghetti was decent, the sea bass was alright (could use salt) and the ribeye was cooked perfectly. read more

See all

Service was great and so was the Bloody Mary. I would say however the food was as average as they come. I had a salmon Benedict and could have certainly made a better version at home. First time there and only had brunch, dinner may be better. Would certainly give it a second chance. read more

Carne Mare - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

Food was very good, can't imagine visiting and being upset. Have heard ridiculously positive things about it but didn't feel it was on that level, but can't fault the restaurant. Some items particularly better than others, would skip the mozzarella sticks and the oysters had not been properly prepped. A lot on this menu we'd return to try. Brunch also looks interesting. A good option in this sterile neighborhood. Was almost empty on a weekday night, can't imagine needing a reservation. Because it's next to the river and they had the doors open, there was a persistent poor odor. read more

Carne Mare - Outside - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

I came here with two friends to celebrate our friend's 28th birthday, and we had an amazing experience from start to finish. One thing worth mentioning is that parking was easier than expected. We were able to find free street parking nearby, although I would recommend arriving about an hour early if you want a good chance of finding a spot. The birthday experience started the moment we walked in. When I checked in at the front desk, the hostess asked, "Who's Jhelani?" and then immediately wished him a happy birthday. It was a small gesture, but it made the celebration feel special right from the beginning. I ordered the 8 oz center cut filet mignon with a side of broccolini. The filet was cooked perfectly, tender, juicy, and full of flavor. The broccolini was surprisingly one of my favorite parts of the meal. It had none of the bitterness that broccoli can sometimes have and was seasoned really well. The atmosphere was classy and upscale without feeling stuffy. We were seated on a floor that was relatively quiet, which gave us a great view outside overlooking the boats and made the experience feel even more special. What really stood out was the service. The staff was attentive throughout the entire meal and always made sure our water glasses were filled. They were knowledgeable about the menu, offered great recommendations, and made us feel well taken care of from beginning to end. A detail I really appreciated was when our steaks arrived. The staff encouraged us to cut into the center of our steaks right away to make sure they were cooked exactly as ordered. It showed that they genuinely cared about getting everything right and wanted us to have the best possible experience. For my friend's birthday, they also went the extra mile by printing his name and birthday message directly on the menu, which was such a thoughtful touch. They finished the evening by bringing out a complimentary dessert with a birthday candle. Overall, the food, atmosphere, and service were all top notch. Every interaction felt intentional and focused on making sure we enjoyed ourselves. We had a fantastic time, and I would absolutely come back again. Highly recommend for a special occasion or a nice night out. read more

See all

Great oysters! Stopped in for some beer and oysters. Took advantage of happy hour and enjoyed them for only 2 dollars each. We had 3 dozen! They were so fresh and delicious. The service was on point as we were greeted by some friendly people and served with class and finesse. This is a very nice looking place. It's been a while since I've been back to the south street seaport and everything is so different. It used to be a public place where people could go and enjoy the views and have some fun eating and drinking but now it's become a more exclusive place with restaurants and music venues, cool but not the same. Nonetheless I can still enjoy it but I miss the old outdoor patio where you can just sit and have a beer. read more

See all

We went to pier 15 the Watermark to have a late lunch and was dying to have oysters well that didn't happen and a story for another time. Like I always say things happen for a reason, we continue our walk towards pier 17 a sign with oysters yes yes yes lol. They were it serving outside due to the air quality and heat . We were skeptical because it looked like a high end restaurant but they were very welcoming. The experience was amazing delicious salty oysters first round went down like water so we ordered two more dozens lol-sooo fresh went down perfectly with my tiny mini olive oil martini-what an end to our seaport experience. Will definitely will come back. All our servers was so professional they made you feel welcome thank you guys . read more

See all

If you're looking for great food, steakhouse style, this is it. I really loved it. Service was amazing and the food just better than I expected. Good for family diner, birthdays and dates. Will come back. read more

My experience at the restaurant was disappointing. The prime rib was served with a very heavy sauce that overwhelmed the flavor of the meat. A well-prepared prime rib should allow the quality of the meat to stand out, but this dish did not meet that expectation. The service also detracted from the experience. The hostess repeatedly attempted to remove the chair I was using to hold my purse, despite many empty tables and chairs available. This felt unnecessary and made the dining experience uncomfortable. Overall, due to the quality of the food and the service issues, I would not recommend this restaurant and do not plan to return. read more

See all

I like this place a lot but not today we walked in for brunch place was half empty. The hostess was rude. Made us wait 10 minutes. Took care of 2 other guests that came in after us . Then proceeded to tell us there's nothing available and we have to eat at the bar. We were so turned off. We just left. We are local to the area so it was very disappointing.. read more

See all

My most recent visit to Carne Mare was for the Winter 2026 Restaurant Week menu, and it absolutely delivered. I started with the wagyu beef tartare--outstanding and exactly what you want from this classic: rich, impeccably seasoned, and beautifully balanced. For the main course, I chose the King Salmon Salsa Calabresi. The ingredients were clearly top-tier, and the sauce had just the right amount of acidity to complement the salmon without overpowering it. The skin was crisped to perfection. Dessert was the mascarpone cheesecake, and honestly, it was flawless--light, creamy, and the perfect way to end the meal. I also have to compliment the bartender. She made one of the finest Negronis I've ever had, and I've had more than my fair share. Perfectly balanced and expertly executed. When I visit Carne Mare, I usually sit at the bar, which I highly recommend. The leather barstools are genuinely comfortable (with proper backrests--an underrated detail), and the bar itself is a stunning mix of warm wood and hammered copper. It's a beautiful space and a great way to experience the restaurant. Between the food, the cocktails, and the atmosphere, Carne Mare continues to be one of my favorite spots in the city--sophisticated, welcoming, and consistently excellent. read more

See all

Andrew Carmellini's Italian chophouse at Pier 17 blends style and substance. Standout dishes include the woodland mushroom agnolotti that's luxuriously delicate, with tender pillows of pasta giving way to an earthy, deeply savory filling. The solo di bruna adds a silky richness that elevates the dish into something refined, comforting, and quietly indulgent all at once. The honeynut squash cacio e pepe is tender and caramel-kissed, coated in a blanket of sharp cheese and cracked black pepper that melts seamlessly into each bite Pair it with the house wedgini and a 12-ounce gorgonzola-cured Wagyu striploin, and it'll deliver a memorable finish. Plus the server was amazing! He was sassy and from Brooklyn! So fun read more

Carne Mare - Wedgini and burrata special - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

Came back to Carne Mare for my birthday this year and was not disappointed. The weather was nice to view the seaport clearly but not to eat outside. As usual the service was impeccable as Anthony and his team really looked out for me. The chef had a calamari special so I ordered that to start. New on the menu from the last time I was here is the Lasagna. It's a generous size but not an overly thick pasta and so delicious. I ordered the King Carne prime rib (medium rare) as my main and it was AMAZING . I was so full I couldn't order dessert but since it was my birthday they brung me a complimentary gelato, it hit just right. Side note the A-mock-xicillin is a great drink (non-alcoholic). Had an amazing experience made some new friends. Perfect place for a group dinner or an intimate date. 10/10 read more

See all

We dined here in October and it was excellent! The sommelier and oysters made the experience. My whole party just decided to have oysters although we usually are not big on them, and we have been thinking of them ever since! The ambience was perfect for a special occasion as we were celebrating a birthday. The meal was worth the splurge. The food was very good as well. read more

Carne Mare - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

We stopped at Carne Mare for early dinner and made reservations in advance for the AMEX credit. The restaurant opened at exactly 5 which left us waiting outside for a bit. Forfood, we ordered the mozzarella sticks with caviar, steak tartare, baked potatoes, and the Tomahawk steak. This was definitely too much food for two people. I definitely recommend getting the mozzarella sticks with caviar and the baked potato. The steak is good for someone who is feeling meaty and is definitely enough for two people. We also got the baked Alaska, which they lit up front of us, it was cute but the rum flavor was overpowering. Overall cute restaurant with good food, lots of seating, and a nice view. read more

See all

This place is terrific. Right along the water at the seaport. Atmosphere is like an classic, old school, steakhouse style. Service is excellent. Cocktails are creative. Food is fantastic. We ate so much because everything caught our eye and tasted so good. The portions are a good size. I really enjoyed the halibut, twice baked potato, the bread, and the mozzarella stick with caviar. I recommend coming hungry. Have come back a few times for a drink at the bar and have enjoyed every visit. Definitely planning to come back and eat again, too, that baked potato has been calling my name. Food tips: Twice baked potato, mozzarella sticks with caviar Drink tips: Lambrusco with Gin read more

See all

I was here for a baby shower in a private room. It was such a memorable experience and the service was excellent. The restaurant itself was stunning and the view of the seaport and river was the icing on the cake. Thank you!!! read more

Carne Mare - 17-Layer Chocolate Cake - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

Great food, amazing service, and a special ambiance. A dear childhood friend who lives in FiDi recommended this spot, and it did not disappoint. We started with perfectly seared scallops, then moved on to steak--mine was a tender filet mignon, his a decadent Gorgonzola Wagyu (he shared a couple of bites--OMG!). We added broccoli on the side, and for dessert, indulged in a towering chocolate cake with what felt like an endless number of layers. read more

See all

After a hot day of roaming FiDi we wanted to eat by the water. Cool off, enjoy the breeze and have some good eats. We had a reservation at Carne Mare so off we went. We ordered the Granita and Alpino for drinks. The drinks took a very long time to come. It came way after we were finished with our appetizer. The granita was a cup with chunks of ice, grapefruit, and other flavors. They bring a bottle of Prosecco to finish making the drink table side. The server had to carry other drinks and the bottle. She struggled to balance the bottle with everything. I was worried something would drop. The bottle didn't have enough Prosecco. They should just finish making the drink at the bar. The drink was delicious though! Fruity and refreshing. The Alpino was skippable. For our appetizer we had the spicy crab lettuce cups. Small portion for the price, but tasty. Careful when eating this, a misplaced bite can cause all your sauce to leak out. We also had some complimentary bread. The bread was baked well! Hot and toasty, the cheese and salt flakes were amazing. Service was a bit inconsistent here. When the bread was served, some tables were given butter some were not. We had to ask for butter twice and it took them about 20 minutes to give it. As for our mains we had the Mezzi Rigatoni and Milanese Cowboy Veal Chop. The rigatoni was not good. Lukewarm and loaded with rosemary that was overpowering. The rosemary was not chopped at all. Whole leaves of rosemary was in the dish. Each bite had dry and hard to chew leaves. The veal chop was just straight up bad. It was a huge dry piece of meat. It felt unseasoned and extra fatty. I had to cut off pieces of fat before eating my chop. $75 for this absolute rubbish topped with a sprig of rosemary. The sides were okay. We had the potatoes rustica and creamed spinach. The potatoes were fried to perfection. Well seasoned, probably the best thing we ate besides the bread. The creamed spinach felt like a wet slop. With dinner being so disappointing, we didn't bother to look at the dessert menu. Save your money and go somewhere else. read more

See all

Went for brunch and left pretty disappointed, especially considering the reputation. It took over an hour for the food to hit the table despite the restaurant being nearly empty, which didn't set a great tone. The beef tartare was easily the highlight, and the French toast was also worth ordering. Everything else ranged from forgettable to bad. The mozzarella sticks with caviar arrived cold, the red snapper crudo was slimy and far too fishy for my taste, and the soft scramble crostino just didn't work--the texture of the eggs with the prosciutto was a miss. The house wedgini and Brooklyn burrata were perfectly fine, but neither was enough to change my mind. For a restaurant at this price point, I expected a lot more. read more

Wow. If you want to show your friends, clients, or family a really good time. Upstairs here is just Devine, the food options are tremendous. Incredible seafood incredible steaks. Service is top tier. Great location. read more

That Gorgonzola Wagyu is perfection. Go for that, but everything is amazing. Craig was a great server, location is awesome, treat yourself!

This restaurant spared no expense in decorations and comfort. Most tables are super comfortable booths. Upstairs and downstairs seating with nice city and river views. Service was prompt and friendly. Not stuffy. Food was delicious. Everything was 5/5 Tomahawk my wife, daughter and I split ($195). Tuna Appetizer and Caesar were both excellent. Rhône on captain list at $99 was perfect soft lucioius. Very expensive but it was a birthday celebration and we splurged. read more

See all

Disaster for those with allergies; the incompetence and contradictory messaging by waitstaff, managers, and chef sent me to the hospital via an ambulance. What was supposed to be a nice meal with my parents and new fiancé ended up costing me $1,200 and a major health scare. When we arrived, I told the waiter that I had a tree nut allergy and he took note. We ordered the burrata--no indication on menu that there were tree nuts, and waiter said nothing when we ordered it and he knew I had a tree nut allergy. It came; my mom took a bite and told me there were nuts. I flagged down the waiter and asked him directly if there were nuts. He denied this, clearly stating no nuts. I asked again, stating that my mom had taken a bite and said there were nuts; waiter said that it was the sun-dried tomato. I said what was the crunch? He said that there was a nut-free pesto. I pressed him--are you sure there aren't any nuts in the pesto? He assured me that "all of our pestos are nut-free." (Really?) Since I'd asked multiple times, and had been assured multiple times that there were no nuts, I ate a bite. There were clearly nuts. I started having an allergic reaction. The manager then came to the table to apologize--not because there were nuts but because there could have been "cross-contamination." I told the manager to please ask if nuts of any kind were used as an ingredient in the dish. He didn't know, so he went to check. The person whom he checked with (chef? unclear) apparently informed him that he/she uses almonds in the dish. I sent the manager away. The waiter then came over to apologize, and confirmed there were indeed nuts in the preparation and that he didn't know as the dish was new to the menu. I left shortly thereafter to take my epi pen, which didn't stop the reaction so I called 911 and went to the hospital in an ambulance. This was a nightmare scenario for anyone with allergies. A total failure of front-of-house staff. If you don't know, or are being pressed by a patron, do the right thing and double check immediately with the back of the house. I am appalled. read more

Great food and atmosphere. We stopped in prior to a concert at Pier 17. Would eat here again read more

Carne Mare - Lasagna - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

Had dinner with my family, party of 4 adults, on a Friday night after work. The restaurant ambiance was cute. We dined on the 2nd floor. Views of the seaport were nice. We participated in Restaurant Week but also ordered off the menu too. The oysters were great, we preferred the regular more than the grilled. The burrata was good. Steak tartare was great. The octopus carpaccio was new to us but we enjoyed it. The petit filet was amazing: perfectly cooked and well seasoned. Preferred the broccolini to the potatoes. The chocolate cake was also delicious. Cocktails were okay. But the standout was our server, Aaron. He was absolutely fantastic! He was friendly and knowledgeable and very attentive. He made the experience 5 stars. I would go back for the steak and the service.. read more

(Husband Sal here) We were really looking forward to dining here for date night. I was with my pregnant wife and our daughter, and my wife had been excited all week to try the lobster pasta and the mozzarella with caviar. We arrived at 6:00 p.m. to find the restaurant more than half empty, both inside and on the patio. We were told, rather abruptly, that nothing was available until 8:00 p.m. I politely asked whether any of the empty tables on the dining room floor, at the bar, or outside were reserved, and was told they were not--but that the restaurant simply wasn't accepting walk-ins until 8:00. When I asked if there was any flexibility, we were quickly dismissed. As people who genuinely enjoy dining out and have been fortunate to eat at everything from Michelin-starred restaurants to small neighborhood gems around the world, we've never felt so unwelcome. It wasn't the lack of availability that was disappointing--it was the dismissive attitude and the feeling that we weren't wanted there. Ironically, we walked by about an hour later after enjoying a wonderful dinner elsewhere, and the restaurant still appeared just as empty. A great restaurant is about more than creating an exclusive image. Exceptional hospitality should make every guest feel welcome, whether they're regulars, first-time visitors, or simply hoping to enjoy a memorable meal. Unfortunately, that wasn't our experience here. read more

The restaurant was beautifully designed, a real pleasure to look at. The service was attentive and helpful. The pesto itself was a bit strange, watery almost with big chunks of uncrushed pine nuts. Not how I'm used to eating it, but it was still really good. I'm not in an enormous rush to come back, to try other dishes, however. read more

TLDR: Another AC spot but as the name suggests, meat/seafood is the star. Mozz & caviar, lobster pasta, duck. If you're in the area, worth a stop. Very random weeknight dinner with some colleagues. Popped in and tried a bit of everything. Apps-wise, got the spicy crab lettuce cups, mozz & caviar. The crab cups were good but kinda tasted like a spicier crab cocktail although maybe that's the idea. The mozzarella and caviar is expensive at $16 each but it's very well done. That crispy coating, the cheese is sweet, stretchy and that briney cavier complements it well. Lobster pasta, spicy, very tasty but probably would get one per two people if sharing. Veal chop milanese was good but kinda what you'd expect. It's cooked wel but yeah, fried chop. The duck was very tasty, well-seasoned, not gamey and quite luscious with that sauce. The creamed spinach and the roasted potatoes went perfect. Overall, would stop in again with the wife one day and come back to try some other things. read more

See all

Saturday, 6/7/2025 - Tried Carne Mare at Pier 17. Address is 89 South St, Pier 17, New York, NY 10038 (South Street Seaport). Restaurant looks nice. They have a 2nd floor where you can dine. The bathroom is on the 2nd floor too. They have outdoor seating too. There's a beautiful stair case. When we went there to check in, the hostess said they had seating outside. So we dined outside. I guess they were full inside. It was raining this day, so the chairs outside was wet. But my jeans were wet from sitting on the chair even tho a waiter wiped it down. Bummer. Loooong wait for anything we ask for. Goodness the service was slow. But besides the extremely slow service outside, foods were good, water tasted good, restaurant looked clean, inside restaurant looked beautiful. read more

See all

Polite limited staff, one other table taken we waited far too long for service. They were out of the wine we ordered then they brought the wrong appetizer, and then my niece wants salad was far smaller and less ingredients than I had expected for the price. The ambience was lovely. We had a shaded table outside. But much improvement is necessary for the prices. read more

For a steakhouse on Pier 17, which has been built up lots in recent years to become a destination for tourists and locals, it still has a calm and sophisticated vibe! Def a great spot for a romantic dinner or a celebration. Great service too, from the host who seated us to all the servers/runners we interacted with during our meal. Our cocktails were very well made and tasty! They even had a few spirit-free cocktails which were also great. The food good, but didn't blow me away. The meal started with complimentary bread, which was so flavorful and light and fluffy! We started with the $16 mozzarella with caviar appetizer - tasty but overrated. It tasted like both individual ingredients put together, and not like something new or unique. For entrees, we had the ribeye and the filet mignon with sides of creamed spinach and rustic potatoes. Everything was good except the filet which was tougher than I'm used to and kind of dry. The steaks came with a couple of different sauces, which saved the filet, but for the prices they charge, it shouldn't need it. That said, the salsa verde is chef's kiss! We wrapped up our meal with a lemon sorbetto and some port wine, which was also good. read more

See all

Absolutely the very best in the truly amazing restaurants in NYC's finest location at the Financial District at picturesque Pier 17 overlooking the Brooklyn Bridge and the wide river, this place is not a touristy at all. The service is top notch and foods are amazing. The prime rib comes out 16 oz. of perfectly cooked medium rare, breads are truly delicious and so nostalgic worthy of what the very best of the American Cuisine used to be like, each appetizer is seemingly made with Michelin Stars Chefs and the main dishes are served without any distractions. The price is what you expect for the best quality of what the center of the universe of capitalism provides. I would definitely like to recommend this one. The wine list is very much Italian and French centric. The ambience and location are as good as it can get. Big fat five stars. read more

See all

Came to Carne Mare with clients for a work event, it totally lived up to the hype. From start to finish, the experience felt elevated but still welcoming. The service was amazing--super professional, attentive, and just really on point. You can tell the staff is trained to give you that fine dining experience without making it feel stiff or pretentious. The restaurant is so beautiful inside, a lovely ambiance too--elegant but not over-the-top, with a cool, classic NYC vibe. The food was so delicious, a specialty chefs menu was made for our party. Highly recommend the mozzarella sticks with caviar! read more

See all

We had a perfect night to eat out on the patio. They started us out with some garlic parm bread which was a great start to dinner, holding us over til our meal arrived. My daughter and I both had the filet mignon ordered medium and medium well, both cooked perfectly to our liking. The creamed spinach was absolutely delicious. The roasted potatoes were our other choice also very tasty. The service was prompt and our waiter was very helpful. We went early in the evening so it wasn't overly busy yet. The seats on the patio were slightly tight with neighbor which may be my only critique ! read more

Can't rave about Carne Mare enough! Hosted my graduation dinner here and it exceeded my expectations. Everything was perfect from the service to the food to the amazing views of the city! Would definitely recommend! read more

Carne Mare - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

See all

An excellent steak place in a great part of downtown Manhattan at the Seaport. You walk in to a classic embrace of old-school steakhouse vibes with wood paneling that just exudes class. Have a drink at the bar while you wait for your table (they make it easy to transfer to your table, but be a sweetheart and tip the bartender!). Once you are seated, you are welcomed by name. They even printed out a birthday message on personalized menus for me and my friend. Classy! I have never seen that before. On to the food ... we started off with delicious oysters, followed up with a tomahawk cooked perfectly medium rare, with sides of creamed spinach and roast potatoes. The steak had a perfect char and was tender. The creamed spinach was one of the better ones I have had in Manhattan. I'm not a big roasted potato fan, but these were inspired, crispy and full of flavor. To finish, we had the apple cobbler, which is fresh baked when you order. It was great! read more

See all

4.5 stars rounding up to 5 bc of the amazing service and ambiance. For food, we enjoyed the Caesar salad, red crab corn agnolotti (it was seasonal), the prime rib (limited quantity per night warning), and the broccolini. Although good, I didn't think much of the mozzarella sticks with caviar ($16/stick!), the roasted bone marrow (should've come with a bread), or the 17-layer chocolate cake. For drinks, I got the granita cocktail given the rave reviews but didn't love it. While it was somewhat refreshing, I didn't love the massive chunks of ice which left very little drink. We sat outdoors and loved the ambiance. Beautiful views of it doors and the indoor dining area was nice as well (request a table by the window on the second floor). My one critique is that I didn't love the music. The service was amazing - everyone was super friendly and attentive. I also liked how easy it was to get a same-day reservation and that they didn't give us a hard time for being 15 min late (was running late from work plus subway delays). Will definitely return! read more

See all

This is a nice place with a nice brunch, albeit pricey. Two small complaints - still had a good time, but I figure I'll mention them regardless because details matter folks! First, the steak that came with the steak and eggs had way too much salt thrown on it, and it definitely wasn't medium rare as ordered. Even calling it medium would've been a stretch. It was still good, but properly cooked steak at a chophouse seems like the bare minimum, even at lunch time. Second - our waitress didn't know the correct pour for a glass of wine, but luckily a manager was nearby and came over to correct it, which was much appreciated. Overall we had a decent time, the prix fixe menu ($55) comes with quite a bit of food. The Panna cotta and Caesar salad were fab read more

See all