We had recently watched Under The Radar about Brighton. We were in town for the night and wanted to try their pizza. We noticed the restaurant was closing in 20 minutes but we thought we would stop and see if it was too late to order. They said it was no problem and went right to work making one of the best pizzas we have eaten since leaving the east coast. We will definitely be back for more. read more

Just visited for the first time, although my girlfriend has been before and has been asking to go back. Ordered a pizza and bread sticks on-line. Walked in and the order was hot and ready to go. The breadsticks (garlic and cheese) were great, good flavor and I love the parmesan. Pizza was awesome, mushroom and old fashioned pepperoni. Great combination, light and not greasy. We were going to eat in the truck but it was so nice inside, we decided to eat in. Nice crowd and music playing, a pizza shop with the cozy coffee shop feel. Loved it all around. I would highly recommend and we will be going back to try more of the other pizzas and bread sticks. read more

If you are a garlic fan, this is where it's at! The roasted garlic cheese bread had me dreaming about it days after consumption, and the wood fired pizzas are perfection. I've had both the Margherita pizza and pickle pizza with cheese and bacon, and both were too-notch. Eating healthy? There are some great-looking salads here, too. Looking for a coffee drink? They have you covered here, too, with all of the extras and seasonal specialty drinks of the "other" coffee biggies, but cheaper and in support of a small business. Not a coffee drinker? They have beer, wine, pop, milk, juice, hot chocolate, bubble tea, matcha tea, and more, both for in-house consumption and a variety of to-go options. My favorite feature? They have a community board where you can choose to pay it forward by purchasing any meal item for future patrons. The itemized receipt is posted, and anyone can take advantage of another's generosity, no questions asked. The staff is friendly, fast, and genuine, the vibe is casually cool, and there is an outdoor patio out back to take in the sun or shade. This is a must-visit stop in Brighton. read more

Captain’s Ön Main - Pickle, Bacon, Mozzarella, Cheddar Pizza (Don't knock it 'til you try it!) - Pizza Near Me - Brighton, Michigan

This is our new favorite pizza place! We've ordered carry out from here and it's perfect every time! The pizza is by far the best in the area! The musheroni, flying Hawaiian, and cheese is so good! We literally will be ordering from here from now on. The staff is super sweet and ordering is a piece of cake. read more

See all

Great pizza and cheese bread!! Great service!! I like their ranch! Very cute place and perfect for a quick bite.

A legit neopolitan styled pizza pie! Legit wood fired great selection of Craft beer and canned cocktails. Kid friendly. The downtown district Is awesome especially for the holidays. Get to Brighton and get a great pie. read more

Pizza, coffee and some drinks. Came for pizza on a recommendation. Cute little town place, thin fire roasted 12" inch pizzas. Flavor was good, but everything was VERY salty, and I like salt lol. Probably would not go again for pizza. BUT... the expresso martini ... let me tell you, sooo delicious with Fresh expresso brewed !!! Will be back for that lol Service is counter walkup and they deliver to table. read more

Stopped in here on a recent Friday night. Their menu had a lot to offer. We settled on the pesto pizza and the creamy garlic bread. Service was quick and entrees were delicious. My wife had a London fog - she enjoyed it. I had a Michigan IPA. It was a perfect little stop. I look forward to coming here again. read more

Captain’s Ön Main - Pesto pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brighton, Michigan

See all

Finally, a new kind of restaurant! Wood fired pizza in downtown Brighton. We heard from others that we must try this place and I'm so glad we did. They support Michigan businesses so have a lot of made in Michigan beers, spirits, and pop. They still have coffee items available. Right now their food menu is limited to pizza and cheese bread as they perfect their pizzas. "Captain" said they are looking to add salads and a few other items soon. They will also be having breakfast. This place is great and can really use the support of the community. The pizzas are 12 inches and gave 6 slices. Perfect for my husband and I. We got pepperoni and sausage. Simple and fresh. The dough was chewy and I loved the Parmesan on top. The pepperoni was a tad spicy. It was amazing wood fired pizza. Now that I know they have good, high quality pizza, I'm going to brave the Cuban! Mustard on pizza? I'll give it a whirl! read more

See all

If you are a fan of wood fired pizza as I am than Captains on the Main will definately hit your sweet spot. This new restaurant in Brighton hits on all cylinders when it comes to taste and a well prepared pizza. It all starts with a fresh nice thin crust for me followed by fresh tasty toppings and of course the wood fired cook which adds so much to the pizza in my opinion and is the base premise for Captains on the Main pizza's. For my initial trip to to this business we ordered the Cuban pizza, pepperoni pizza and white truffle cheese bread. The pizza's were well cooked, with a great crust (both top and bottom) and fresh ingredients that combined to provide two very tasty pizza's. The Cuban pizza is definately something you don't see every day but boy of boy it really makes for a tasty pizza. The pickles, ham and pork with wood fired thin crust crust are a great combination. Also, I loved the charred fringes and slight charring on the bottom of the crust that is a signature element of a wood fired pizza. Relative to the truffle cheese bread this was so tasty where the the truffle notes definately come through on this bread and complements the cheese so well. Definately something not to be missed. Overall a very nice addition to the Brighton dining scene and definately the best pizza in the area. If you are a fan of fine wood fired pizza this is a business you should absolutely check out as you will not be disappointed. read more

See all

I've been here a couple times and I have loved it every time. They have a variety of things, coffee/pizza etc. There is plenty of seating and they have booths which I'm a sucker for good booth seating. The coffee is great but the pizza is even better. The pizza boxes come with a photo that you put your head on top of which is really cute. Anyway if you are looking for an ice family friendly and fun atmosphere this is a great option. read more

Captain’s Ön Main - Pizza Near Me - Brighton, Michigan

Best pizza I have had in a while. Crust is just right on flavor and texture the homemade sausage is on point. Service is good and it's a must try. read more

Captain’s Ön Main - Captains Classic Cheese Bread 12" Sausage Party Pizza Three Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brighton, Michigan

Highly recommend the wood fired Cuban pizza! Pulled park, ham, pickles & mustard....absolutely fantastic...you won't want to stop eating it! We also enjoyed the healthy pizza....spinach, feta, banana peppers, mushrooms & balsamic reduction. Sign up for their points program for rewards every $100. If you haven't been here, you're missing out! read more

Captain’s Ön Main - Cuban pizza...a must try!!! - Pizza Near Me - Brighton, Michigan

See all

The food was amazing. They make some great pizzas. All hand made and made to order. The service was quick and friendly. The place has great above to it and there is seating inside and out. The ambiance is very relaxing and inviting . read more

Very good pizza and friendly staff. The food came quickly and the iced tea was especially good. The plastic table ware is disappointing--and flimsy. If you have ""real plates" why not real silverware? The outside patio looked inviting, although we chose to eat inside. It is very dark inside however and challenging to read the menus in the darkness. We will be back and bring our flashlights! read more

Excellent place for a quality crafted cocktail or espresso. Best pizza within 20 miles easily and you can't beat the price. They do it all right here and I've been a fan since it was just a trailer at the farmers market. Do yourself a favor and next time you are feeling pizza come in and grab a musheroni and an espresso. Undefeated combo and they do it just like the real Italians. Very impressive! read more

Food is amazing and staff friendly. Love to support local small businesses and this one is great

One of the best wood fire pizza in Brighton. The staff are nice and the ambience is excellent for a chill time. read more

Captain’s Ön Main - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brighton, Michigan

Excellent pizza, pastries, and coffee. Sasha and I come hear cuz they have the best water in town for doggies. I haven't tried it, that's just what she says. You guys are great! Oh and the music and vibes are spot on too! read more

We were fortunate enough to be invited to their soft opening! They are going to be a huge success in our town! I think we were the first customers and it was fast, friendly, and amazing! Highly ~ highly recommend! Our kids being Italian and pizza critics, absolutely loved it as well! Great job guys! Wishing you huge success! read more

See all

Amazing experience! We attended Brighton's first Gilmore Girls event on 9/21/24 and Captain's on Main took on the persona of Antonioli's. They were selling some awesome cider beverages and pizza and while waiting in line we were informed that all of their cider beverages were sold out but they were anticipating more cider arriving soon. In the meantime they were passing out free small pieces of pizza to everyone waiting in line and thanking everyone for their patience and patronage. Awesome customer service and experience overall! Will definitely return to Captain's on Main for dinner at next years Gilmore Girls event! read more

Captain’s Ön Main - "sookie's spiked cider" - Pizza Near Me - Brighton, Michigan

See all

Fantastic pizza! Friendly ambiance. I used to have coffee in here with previous owners and stopped in, not realizing the change. What a delightful restaurant. And, while they make an incredible wood fired pizza they still make coffee drinks. So I was able to contribute my tradition of a latte and afternoon work. So nice. The other reviews are much more elaborate and Captain's is worthy. Navigate through the current Brighton construction on Main Street, and give these folks your business! Their food and great service are well worth the effort! read more

Very likely the best pizza in Brighton. Have loved every pizza we've ordered, even the basic pepperoni. Friendly staff, great food.

Great service, awesome pizza! Garlic bread is sooo tasty! Delicious cocktails! Cool atmosphere! Highly recommend read more

The pizza is always great. I like trying some of the new specials that use unique ingredients. The local beer selection is nice as well.

Good wood fired pizza! Fun spot. I have not had the coffee, just the pizza but I will be back.

Hands down best pizza and salad I have had in soooo long. It's new and due to construction on Main I hadn't been there yet. So glad we tried it and will be back. Recommend this place highly! read more

I rarely write reviews or give reviews as I am a bit of a food snob and would never want my personal opinion to affect the livelihood of another. Captains not only deserves your attention, but Brighton should take notice what they have built. The city lacks creative, REALLY good food, and it's amazing to think on Main Street we don't have better options. Captains is turning out REALLY good pizza, AMAZING coffee (well done on bringing in Good Sense), and doing it with personality and a laid back vibe that makes eating fun. I waited to write this until I had tried every special, breakfast pizza and beer they had to offer and I've been going in once a week since they opened. No restaurant in Brighton as ever gotten that much attention from me. I take every client and friend to Captain's and we causally order as many pizzas as we can while enjoying drinks. My kids love it and watch as the pies go in and out of the wood burning oven. We do ALOT of cooking at home and once I've tried a restaurant, if it doesn't compare to how we make it at home, we don't come back. well done Captains...you guys are officially family read more

This pizza never disappoints! I can always count on having a good meal. Ps. They have the best ranch! read more

The food was amazing. The best wood-fire pizza I've ever had. We had the Margherita pizza, added crumbled Italian sausage, and the garlic cheese bread. Both were so amazing. We both had an old fashioned, also amazing a properly made. We will be back! Definitely check this place out! read more

Captain’s Ön Main - House made old fashioned (they also have pre made (and Michigan made) old fashioned mix. - Pizza Near Me - Brighton, Michigan

See all

Great service, fun atmosphere, strong pizza. BBQ chicken pizza, is it pizza? Here it is. Layers of flavor, fire oven crust cooled perfectly, and generous toppings. Well done, we'll be back. read more

Excellent pizzas, not just for lunch and dinner but also breakfast pizzas. Michigan beers and wine definitely recommend and the management really care about giving good service. Forgot to mention outdoor area at the back which is really pleasant. read more

Would give ZERO stars if I could. Terrible experience, forgettable food and the rudest staff I've ever seen. We had lunch here once and won't go back. They have zero identity and nothing that makes the place remotely interesting. Will be surprised if this places survives so don't waste your money. read more

Service was good. The food was alright but there are just better pizza places to go to in town. I would not recommend this place over several of the other pizza places in town. read more

Great Pizza, exactly awesome and the way it should be made and cooked. Go for the pizza and a beverage. Might find a little pricey but see this a special treat; not a Domino's Pizza experience where cheese just does seem to be cheese. read more

Absolutely LOVE this place. We stop for coffee and tea often in the mornings. They have the friendliest baristas. Their pizza is absolutely AMAZING!!! Our favorite is the Healthy and the Truffle Shuffle bread is so yummy. Their back patio is so cute and cozy. Great spot to just chill out with the family. read more

Staff unprofessional, highly aggressive and not somewhere I would spend my money. Save your time and go across the street.

From a northeast pizza snob...this is a great pizza - available right here in Brighton, MI. Fresh ingredients, perfect cook on the pie, great outdoor space and indoor feel, and nice attentive staff. These guys are doing it absolutely right. read more

Great pizza! Great service! Usually a long line but they move so quick and are organized so you Usually don't wait long for the pizza. The pizza was big enough for 2-3 people, the sauce was a great balance not to acidic from the tomatoes and not super sweet. The dough was nice not to thick and had a crispy crust with delightful amount of char. The bottom of the pizza was crispy and wasn't floppy or droopy until it had sat for a few minutes and the truffle oil soaked into the bottom. The cheese definitely taste like quality as it melts in the mouth. The cheese covered the pizza eventually and every bite tasted equally sauced. Definitely a top pizza place with the flavor and service. read more

Captain’s Ön Main - Mushroom mania pizza with sausage - Pizza Near Me - Brighton, Michigan

Pizzas and cheese breads amazing taste. Not too doughy. One pizza enough for two people. Several specialty pizzas available. Owner Nick is a great chef. read more