Don't miss this restaurant when in Key West.. the staff is friendly and efficient to make your dining experience a plus.. the restaurant is beautifully furnished and comfortable with a touch of history.. with all of that the food is the star with the menu changing with what's fresh. We had the kale Cesar which was a great twist on a classic. The fish was fresh and cooked to perfection.. Don't miss this read more

Cafe Marquesa - New American Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

I have enjoyed Cafe Marquesa in the past and the service and food quality is still excellent But honestly I think it is now over priced for the selections offered. Hence my degrade to 4 stars I suggest looking st the menu and pricing carefully beforehand and decide read more

Went to Café Marquesa on a recent week on trip to Key West. Obviously, we've heard great things so I had high expectations from the reviews and quite frankly very high expectations because of the price point as well. Unfortunately , this experience was simply not worth the money; about $375for the two is us (not including gratuity). We obviously are at multiple other locations around town and quite frankly virtually all of them were better and for half the price! We had the foie gras appetizer and it was very good. We also had the char grilled oysters and they were good but for the price they weren't anything special and we had oysters at multiple locations around town that were quite a bit better. The last item we had as an appetizer was the crawfish tails and angel hair pasta. This one was quite frankly a disappointment. It wasn't horrible, but the flavor profile was quite frankly rather bland. The pasta itself was not angel hair, it was actually even larger than standard spaghetti and it was simply overcooked and way too soft. For an entrée, my wife had the grilled swordfish piccata, and it was actually quite good. Swordfish is easily overcooked and I'm typically not a fan because it's almost always too dry, but this was cooked very well and it was simply a good plate of food. I had the seared duck breast and was not impressed. When ordering I asked how it was prepared and was told medium which is the chefs recommendation. I asked for it medium rare which is my preference... Unfortunately, it was not served medium rare, and was absolutely medium. The server agreed and asked if I wanted it remade. I said no because this is a 15 minute dish at minimum and my wife was already eating her entrée. The fat wasn't as rendered as it should've been as well and was still a little more chewy than I should've been. The final blow was a billing issue... we were charged for two bottles ($60 each) of wine instead of two glasses (&15 each). I had already paid the check when my wife noticed the error of being overcharged by $90. To their credit, they did cancel the transaction and it showed up on my credit statement immediately and they were able to make the correction and charge the correct amount. Overall, this was not a horrible experience, but there were some pretty big missed steps on the restaurants part. For an almost $400 meal (well over that with gratuity) this should've been a GREAT dining experience, but in the end it simply wasn't. read more

Excellent dining experience here. Stellar service and ambiance to match a well executed menu. Caviar service is beyond expectations and the chef's interpretation of a 16 oz ribeye is fantastic. read more

See all

The service was a fabulous experience. The wait staff was wonderful and food out of this world. Love the atmosphere. Small, but busy!

Came in for breakfast today. We shared the Tropical Fruit and Berries which came with yummy Greek yogurt, fruits and honey. We also shared the Garden Omelette with Cotija cheese. This was a perfect pairing and very filling for two. We asked for regular coffee and wanted it to be more like cafe con leche so we asked them to heat up the milk and they frothed it and gave it to us happily. Very good place for breakfast!!! read more

Cafe Marquesa - Tropical fruit and berries - New American Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

The best meal our group had in Key West. The staff is highly professional - always there when you need them but never intrusive. Location, ambience, quality of food and presentation and the staff make this a truly 5 star experience. read more

We dined here while staying at the neighboring Marquesa Hotel. Every bite was impeccable. Oh my, one of the best restaurants I've dined at in a long time. Service was spot on, the decor in this Historic former residence is lovely and wonderful dining memories were made! While staying at the neighboring hotel we came here twice - for dessert and breakfast. The late evening dessert of Key Lime Pie and Beignets were heavenly. How thoughtful to wish us a Happy Anniversary in chocolate writing on the beignet plate! Their breakfast was equally delicious! My Garden Omelette with fresh spinach, mushroom, tomato with my choice of goat cheese was fantastic - eggs cooked perfectly, the creamy goat cheese added decadence - definitely a reorder if returning. Hubs Eggs Benedict plate was clean and an affirmation of its deliciousness! I hope to return again! read more

See all

We had an amazing time at Cafe Marquesa! Best dinner of our entire trip. We had the crab cakes which were pure crab- no bread here. Complimentary amuse bouche and bread were great as well. I had the shrimp and grits as my main entree. Wow. Best I've had outside of New Orleans. My husband has a fish that was prepared New Orleans style with red beans and grits. We also had their key lime pie and beignets, but were a little too full at the end to really enjoy them. Charlotte was our server, and she was so attentive and helpful. She made sure we had an excellent dinner, and had great suggestions. She also told us about the local event going on during our trip. Some other guests got drunk and angry during our dinner, and tried to ruin the experience for everyone. However, Charlotte and the male host/manager of that evening handled it well and made sure we felt safe. We loved this restaurant, and would recommend it to anyone visiting or local. read more

See all

A terrific dinner served in a room that's very upscale yet feels quite comfortable. It's located on a prime intersection just a short couple of blocks off Duval, but still manages to feel tucked away while still being in the middle of things. The service is of that silky smooth variety, where they're right there when you need them and not there when you don't. There's a nice variety of entree and appetizer choices, but I went seafood. The she-crab soup was stunning, with a rich shellfish broth that gave it heft while spotlighting the delicate bits of meat. My snapper entree was also delicious; I even ate the accompanying broccolini. read more

Cafe Marquesa - Best she-crab soup in the universe - New American Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

This place is small and cozy with a great ambiance. Small candle lit tables. I really wanted to love the food, but it was good but great. It was mostly New Orleans cuisine, but it didn't hit the mark with the flavors I'm used to being from there. read more

See all

Five Stars Isn't Enough for This Experience I recently returned to Cafe Marquesa with my love -- it was his first time, and for me, a long-overdue reunion with one of the most exquisite dining gems in the heart of Key West. I've lived here before and have dined at Marquesa a few times, but this visit? Unparalleled. We didn't have a reservation (pro tip: make one), but decided to take a chance -the host greeted us with the kind of warmth and grace that instantly made us feel welcome. Even though they were fully booked, he went above and beyond, personally arranging cocktails for us and escorting us next door to enjoy them at the Inn. Our wait was short, but the hospitality was already unforgettable. Enter: Nelson. Our server, our guide, and honestly, one of the highlights of our night. Nelson has that rare mix of professionalism, warmth, and just the right dash of charm. From the moment we were seated (with our cocktails waiting for us), his menu suggestions were absolute perfection. I opted for the beef carpaccio -- yes, as my entrée -- and it was a chef's kiss moment. Silky, flavorful, and plated like edible art. My love had one of the seafood specials of the evening, and I still don't have the words. Delicate. Flaky. Cooked to absolute perfection -- it was the kind of dish that makes you close your eyes after every bite. Dessert? Oh, we didn't just stop at dessert. We ordered the sampler -- and those beignets? As someone who's been to New Orleans more times than I can count, let me just say this: superior. And that's not something I say lightly. And I must give a standing ovation to their Key Lime Pie. As a Florida native of over 30 years -- and a former Key West local -- I can honestly say this pie ranks in my top three of all time. Balanced, tart, creamy, unforgettable. Caffe Marquesa isn't just a restaurant -- it's an experience. A love letter to fine dining, elevated service, and next-level cuisine tucked away in a town too often mistaken for nothing but bars and barefoot chaos. This is refined, intimate, soul-stirring dining in the heart of Key West. If you're looking for a place that blends elegance with heart, and culinary craftsmanship with soul -- this is it. I'll be dreaming of this night for a long time. And we will be back soon! read more

See all

Vibes: sophisticated and elegant but low key; bring a friend or a few Tasting notes from breakfast and dinner: - Blueberry cornmeal pancakes: delightfully fluffy with excellent amount of blueberries; lovely to dip forkfuls in small dollop of whipped cream on the side - Breakfast sandwich: extremely buttery, flaky croissant; quick to fall apart because of layers of egg, ham, tomato, greens; generous layer of scrambled egg (my choice); absolutely loved the perfectly crunchy and salted, fork tender side potatoes - Huevos rancheros: two over easy eggs atop a thin soft tortilla with fine filling and a tomatoey, slightly spicy sauce - Key lime beignets: very thin and crispy exterior with piping hot, almost spongy interior; doused in plenty of powdered sugar; side of creme anglaise was indulgent and creamy but did not overwhelm curd filling - She crab soup: finished with some sherry vinegar at tableside; delightfully creamy, smooth, and rich with a few lump pieces of sweet crabmeat - Chargrilled oysters: mayo forward with some cheesiness; good for sharing with one other person as an appetizer Other notes: - Service overall is attentive and friendly - Able to charge to room if staying at Marquesa Hotel - Fairly quiet on weekday mornings and early evening on a weekend night Impression: would recommend stopping in for at least one meal when in Key West! read more

See all

Charming restaurant situated at the corner of Fleming and Simonton street. My husband and I decided to do the tasting menu with the wine pairing. Each course had a nod to low country fare with a level of complexity. The wine selections were unexpected but made for some fascinating pairings. Chef Lee was on hand to provide insights into the food prep and wine choices. Our waiter, Wilson, was fun and attentive. I am attaching photos, even though they will never do justice to the taste of each course. Don't miss this bright spot on the island!! read more

See all

Simply marvelous in every way! They win the Mary poppins award. Service was exceptional and the food was superb. Very quaint intimate restaurant. I highly recommend the caviar service with french onion dip and house made potato chips. Cocktails were delightful and I was happy to find they hand stuff their olives. I will be returning. read more

The food is amazing. You do not need to sprinkle salt and pepper at all because of the flavor already infused in everything on your plate. Kate was our server and she was thoughtful and kind. It is extremely quiet inside and they play great music, not extremely loud, thankfully. read more

Cafe Marquesa - Breakfast menu - New American Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

I struggled between four and five stars based upon our Valentine's Day experience. Four of us, all in for the $150 per person four-course pre fix menu. My food was delicious - she crab soup, pork belly appetizer, filet, and key west pie. The service was terrific and the atmosphere was lovely. While we really enjoyed the meal, I wrestle with whether it was worth almost $800 ($150 x 4 + tip). We had several other meals during our time in Key West that, while not as fancy, were far less in price and equal in enjoyment. Truly glad to have experienced this occasion, but this was a splurge that I'd second guess doing again. read more

Wonderful atmosphere (except for the GenXers at the next table FaceTiming at top volume). Wonderful service. The she crab soup was by far the best part of our meal. Yellowfin snapper was just fair and definitely not worth $60 as was the key lime pie. I grew up in New Orleans so it's not easy to impress me. read more

The atmosphere elegant. Michelin award level experience. Every single dish exceptional. Presentation deserves a 10 from food to drinks. Expensive & worth it. read more

The breakfast choices are a bit limited, but the atmosphere is lovely and spotless, making it super relaxing. We had a great time!

Enjoyed breakfast at Café Marquesa while visiting Key West - location is great, lovely decor, and excellent food. Prices are somewhat elevated - perhaps to be expected in this small, upscale spot. Service was adequate but a little impersonal. read more

We stayed at the Marquesa hotel and had breakfast included with our stay (30$ per person per day). It's such an elegant dining room, it felt very different from Duval st! The breakfast was a highlight of our stay at the hotel- I loved the Huevos rancheros and ordered it multiple days. The restaurant is not known as a vegetarian place but I was surprised to realize I never ate any meat during our stay! Service is great, friendly and quick. We were supposed to go to dinner here but sadly didn't make it. I was looking forward to trying it! read more

This is a 5 star restaurant. I called to make reservation they were lovely. I had on blue jean shorts and a tank and they still welcomed me with open arms. read more

Cafe Marquesa - Osso Bucco - New American Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Excellent dining experience! Very cozying dining room in the Marquesa Hotel. The Miso Glazed Black Grouper was phenomenal as was the Pan Seared Duck Breast. Finished with delicious Key Lime Pie and Beignets! read more

See all

Outstanding dinner from start to finish! Thank you to the chef and wonderful staff for a wonderful meal and evening. Staff's attention to detail is impeccable. Food was excellent. Everything was fresh, beautifully plated and delicious. Cocktails were great as well. We will definitely visit again when we are back in key west! read more

See all

Sophia K. was our server and bartender as we dined at the bar. Her hospitality was unparalleled. Best bartender in Key West!!! She took great care of us all while handling the rest of the restaurant's bar orders! We ate and drank like kings and queens. Food was amazing, drinks were amazing, atmosphere was wonderful and service was impeccable. read more

Cafe Marquesa - Cheers from Sophia! - New American Near Me - Key West, Florida

Historic Charm & Breakfast Perfection at Café Marquesa! A morning walk through Old Town Key West led us to Café Marquesa, a quaint yet luxurious dining spot inside the historic Marquesa Hotel (which dates back to the late 1800s!). The history, atmosphere, and food were simply unmatched. What We Ordered: Breakfast Sandwich - A toasted, all-butter croissant loaded with eggs, avocado aioli, shaved Parma ham, aged cheddar, fresh greens, sliced tomato & locally sourced 'Mack Farms' breakfast potatoes. Absolutely delicious! Beignets with Lime Curd - These famous, golden-fried beignets were pillowy soft inside, crisp outside, and the tart lime curd was the perfect finishing touch! If you're in Key West and looking for a truly special breakfast spot with a touch of history, Café Marquesa is a must-visit! read more

See all

The food, service, and ambiance is perfect. We had a great dinner celebrating my birthday. The tenderloin is delicious, the beef carpaccio is the best on the island, and the beignets are amazing! read more

Cafe Marquesa - beignets - New American Near Me - Key West, Florida

Went for breakfast while staying at the hotel. Took a long time to get seated and then an extra long time to even get coffee. Managed to place an order for food but that then took even more time. Best estimate is that it was 20 minutes for coffee and then another 45-60 for food. Avoided it like the plague for the rest of my stay. read more

Went here on a Sunday night for dinner. The service was great and the cocktails were creative and good. The food was crazy expensive. The pork belly amuse bouche was very good. The crawfish pasta was a very small portion with a couple of tails mixed in for $27. My husband had a fish dish that was good, but priced at over $60. Our friends had the short rib special and a fish dish. Short rib special was $80. The food was good, but for what they are charging, it should blow your socks off. I know Key West is expensive, but this seemed really over the top. Nice place with nice people, but be prepared to pay the price. read more

See all

Food was delicious, both breakfast and dinner. Upscale and a bit pricey, but worthwhile if you can afford it on vacation.

Perhaps we had a rare bad experience but the Cafe disappointed twice. On our first visit I ordered 2 egg whites and got regular eggs. I sent the order back. The last day, today June 1st saw several service failures. The meal I ordered came with a choice of protein. I selected bacon and it was not on the plate when it arrived. Since potatoes were part of the meal I asked the server to bring ketchup. He never returned with either. After 7 minutes and seeing the bacon on the window I flagged a server and she brought both. By then the potatoes were cool. We placed the coffee urn lid up to signal a refill was needed. The young man who started the table never returned once to check on us. The lady who brought the bacon and ketchup never asked if we needed coffee. After 17 minutes of waiting for coffee I advised I wanted to speak to the manager. Since I knew I was going to leave a comprehensive review (bad) with time lines I felt obligated to let her know. Frankly she was not engaged in her job since there were only two tables eating with a total of 4 people. Service should have been perfect but clearly fell deeply short. read more

Cafe Marquesa - Empty coffee pot for 17 minutes before I gave up and left. - New American Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Chef's tasting menu was excellent. Everything was perfection from the first bites of tuna, foie gras, oysters rockefeller, tenderloin with crab cake. Do not miss out on house made beignets! Service was impeccable. Only two notes: It was incredibly loud because of a few larger tables and this detracted from the overall experience. Very few nicer wines by the glass. Will definitely be back when in town. read more

Amazing! All of it! From the wine selections to the desserts, we enjoyed it all! Fabulous service, a wonderful dining experience on Key West! We will be back!! read more

The service for breakfast was impeccable. The garden omelette was delicious. The potatoes that accompanied the omelette were perfect.

Great place excellent vibe, we had a beautiful dinner and very nice wine. Service was excellent! Tom was very gracious the food was outstanding! No corners were cut! Great job Tom and your entire staff!! read more

We enjoyed grouper with a delicious coconut rice on the side. The restaurant is very lively and fun. Service was good.

New chef. Do not believe sample menu in photos posted. Limited menu now. Pompous night manager. Crab soup tasteless. Crab appetizer, toast was charred. Service very slow. One item non fish? $78 steak. Crab pasta overcooked and cold. Save your money go elsewhere. read more

Overall the service was really good, consistent with checking on our party and doing refills. Admittedly we may have high standards, but this food was beyond subpar. The crab cake was non traditional, more of a ceviche than anything, yet this wasn't stated on the menu. Our table was brought out a tasting of braised pork, with a tomato sauce (seen in the pic w crab cake), this bite was luke warm- we were laughing trying to figure out if it was meant to be served hot or cold! The tuna tar tar, was unseasoned. Both (seafood) dishes were bland, and didn't come with lemon lol, and the tar tar came with no vehicle to eat it with as well. The angel hair pasta was the best dish of the entire meal. Again it lacked flavor but was better than the previous. I would suggest going here if you like normal food but I wouldn't say it's beyond what you'd get at any other place around here. read more

See all

We made a resy for early seating on a Thursday night. This restaurant is a small, so the sound level was quite loud later in the evening. It was hard to decide what to eat because everything on the menu looked good, but our waiter helped with recommendations. The service was excellent; timely and attentive. The food was expensive but delicious, although our meals would have benefited from a dash more salt. read more