Stopped by for a quick bite with my son before Kino's for shoes. Ordered the chicken quesadilla and fries for my son, and a medium Dulce con leche coffee for myself. The fries come out made to order and be forewarned they are HOT. They come with ketchup packets but the flavor is so good you don't need anything else. My son ate his quesadilla but as expected, got full (hence why this mother knew not to order any food for herself). I had the last piece of chicken quesadilla with the accompanying guacamole that had a perfect blend of tomato, onion and avocado. My dulce con leche coffee was also pretty good but not the best I've had though I'd recommend if you're in the mood for coffee. Easily a hole in the wall you'd miss if not looking for it and glad we stopped in. $30 for a chicken quesadilla, fries and coffee seems a bit steep but I guess it's to be expected in Key West read more

See all

Lobster roll was disappointing, was a little chewy/ overcooked. Pretty but pretty small portion from first glance when first opening to go container. Wish I would have tried some other recommended spot for the lobster roll honestly. read more

Lucy's Cafe - Hot lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

I'm trying to do my entire 5 day stay in Key West without eating at anything named Bubba Gumps. So I'm leaning on Yelp as always for good local spots. They came thru with Lucy's, a really cute tucked away cafe. The person behind the register was extremely helpful and the food was excellent, just went traditional chicken tacos. Yum! read more

Lucy's Cafe - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

Blackened yellowtail tacos fucked so hard. And not too crowded which is really nice. Tucked away in an alley, a few seats to eat inside or outside. Also pretty large and diverse menu read more

My wife and we're looking for a coffee before watching the sunset in Mallory Square, so we stopped by Lucy's. They had many good food options which looked great, but we had recently eaten so only got to try the coffee. I had a Colada, which is like a super concentrated espresso and my wife got an Americano. Both were fantastic. As we sat in the very small and hidden away shop, the woman was back cooking some food on what looked to be a conventional home cooktop. Very mom and pop vibe. Next time we are in KW we will be sure to go by Lucy's for a meal. read more

See all

Not much seating area, no alcohol. Hole in the wall tucked away like many other restaurants but very good. Chips are plantain chips read more

Lucy's Cafe - Lobster roll. Cold lots of mayo and "bun" is buttered bread - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

Really love it! It's a small, tucked-away gem in an alley. The owner clearly puts a lot of heart into the food, always aiming to make it as fresh and delicious as possible. read more

Wonderful staff, great menu, amazing food and Coffee!!!! This place is a must! 1/2 a block off Duval open for breakfast, lunch and dinner. read more

Lucy's Cafe - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

Very small joint that can be had to find. Kinda of tucked away in a shopping square. Just follow the signs. We shared a steak quesadilla for dinner and it was very good. The steak was tender and packed with flavor. Nice little mom/pap joint read more

Food was fresh and delicious! Cute little spot with outdoor seating. Service was fast and friendly. read more

Lucy's Cafe - Steak Quesadilla - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

The lobster rolls were on point. 10/10 I'd easily get again. The amount of lobster you get is surprisingly plentiful, making it worth the money. Service was also very friendly and helpful. read more

The best tacos...especially the incredibly flavorful Al Pastor. Been there a couple times in just a four day stay.

Service A. Ambiance C, kinds scruffy. Delicious food. Clam chowder A. Steak and cheese sandwich A. Cuban Sandwich B.. Generous servings. Off the beaten path how in the wall. Follow the sandwich board signs. read more

Don't expect inexpensive here. Two of us ate lunch for 54.00 before tip. Ordered lobster roll and pork and shrimp tacos (2 each). Sweet worker took our order and helped us figure the menu out. Only two tables to sit at with four chairs each and a small bar with 5 seats. One table is outside, one table is inside. Picture of 'courtyard' attached. Tacos were much tastier than the lobster roll to me and much cheaper! Worth visiting while in KW! read more

Lucy's Cafe - Inside view of Lucy's. Very quaint. - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

Hear me out: At first, the lobster roll felt overpriced, served on what looked like store-bought toasted white bread. But one bite changed everything: it was 80% perfectly cooked, sweet lobster and just 20% bread. It was SO GOOD AND FILLING. It was so flavorful I'm convinced I'll remember that taste years from now. The fish tacos were equally impressive: freshly caught that morning, light, citrusy. The service was warm and genuine, and the atmosphere brought it all together: laid-back but artful, with cool decor ranging from Picasso prints to playful nautical touches. The whole place just worked--the food, the people, the vibe. read more

See all

I wish we found them sooner. The coffee and guava with cheese pastry was delicious. Small open air cafe with a couple of tables outside.

The food was the worst. Don't waste your money. Even the key lime pie was the worst. The lobster roll was micro size and had zero flavor. I feel it was frozen lobster. read more

No lines, no waiting. This stop is tucked away and you have to be looking for it. Just ordered the lobster roll. Nothing spectacular. Just mayo, lobster and a toasted roll. It was ok, wish it had better seasoning. Service was quick. read more

Lucy's Cafe - Lobster roll 26.99 - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

Fantastic and so so fresh! The suisse enchiladas are simply amazing. The Cuban mix is delicious and has little extra touches that really make it stand out in a town of a million Cuban mixes. This place is a hidden gem. Shop local! Ps- you can go around the corner and grab a beer if needed:) read more

Lucy's Cafe - Cuban mix so delicious! - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

Hidden gem, great service and price! Authentic taste and menu. This little cafe has outdoor seating tucked away in the streets of Key west. I would definitely come back if I was down in the keys again. read more

Lucy's Cafe - Enchiladas - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

The food is incredible!!!! I had a steak burrito and my daughter and I shared shoestring fries, it was so good!!! Wow!

Our 2nd January in KW where Lucys is our favorite hidden gem. Easily the best Lobster Roll on the island and the best Family service you will experience read more

Excellent small business! I received outstanding service, and the young lady really cared about the quality of the food -- which was excellent. I 100% recommend this place. read more

Wonderful place to eat and a small family cafe. My mom and I got a lobster roll, iced tea, cafe con leche, and a tuna sandwich. The lobster roll was amazing and my mom loved the tuna sandwich. They are very helpful and friendly. A must go to in Key West! Also accommodating to my service dog read more

See all

We try the lobster roll and they were delicious, two thumbs up for Lucy and her cook! Will recommend to all my friends and family!

10/10 I've tried almost every place in key west and Lucy's cafe is definitely in my top 3 brunch spots. I have very high standards for food but luckily they go above and beyond here and very generous with the food. - steak burrito was my favorite, they add a lot of veggies to it which i love and the salsa verde was the cherry on top. -conch fritters was one of the best i've tried in key west, and their sauces were phenomenal. -pork tacos were great with the sauce and pico. read more

Stopped in here for a quick breakfast before a boat trip. Ordered a Cuban mix sandwich and my husband and I shared it- it was big enough for 2 for breakfast. It was delicious and had a good amount of meat in there- cheese was melty and bread was crispy. Cute courtyard to sit in as well. Highly recommend for a quick bite near the marina! read more

The food tastes great along with great service. Tucked away off Duval St. Great prices as well.

Wonderful service, cute little place. The food was delicious and the lobster rolls were super full of lobster. Super awesome place, 10/10 recommend. read more

Lucy's Cafe - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

Seriously, if you want the best, Mexican food in Key West, go to Luces, the food is phenomenal. The service is great and the people are truly grateful. read more

Lucy's Cafe - I asked for the best burrito they had, and I was not let us down at all. - Seafood Near Me - Key West, Florida

Awesome hole-in-the-wall spot. Stopped in for lobster rolls and they didn't disappoint. Definitely recommend!

Delicious shrimp tacos and conch fritters! Go here immediately! Outdoor seating, quick bites no shortage of flavor.

Hidden gem. It was close to our hotel so we went in to grab something simple. I had the crabmeat sandwich. It was delicious on a croissant roll and came with a side of coleslaw and plantain chips. I don't care for coleslaw but this was delicious. Service was great and the crab was really good. I would go back again for something simple and rooster free. read more

Tremendous authentic Mexican food with awesome lobster rolls and truly nice people to boot!