This is a multi day review. Our 1st breakfast with Tio as our server was very good and enjoyable. The food (Avacado Toast & Eggs Benedict) was plentiful and Tio was a pleasure to speak with. He indicated this was his last week and he will be a loss to Hilton and the restaurant. The next day we had Jose as our server and he was quite the opposite experience of Tio and unfortunately soured our breakfast experience. However, the food (made to order Omelet & Yellowfin Breakfast) was as good and plentiful as the previous day. The menu here is pretty awesome so we went for dinner too. The restaurant was lively, it seemed like Alex, our server, recognized some guests and they all chatted like old friends. Alex was very engaging, attentive and fun. We devoured our Tropical Spinach Salad and Tomato Burrata Shrimp Pasta. We got "nice clean plates family" from Alex. The night wasn't too late so we got a delicious Mudslide to go as we planned to sit by the pool. Glad we went to the restaurant for dinner! Last breakfast before we departed was equally good & once again, we enjoyed having Andrei serve us and chat with us. read more

See all

The Yellowfin Bar & kitchen was only a few steps from the docked boats and pool with giant 180* windows to peer out - ice cold A/C too and today was brutal hot. Sat at the long gray polished stone top bar and met with the bartender Marcos who was attentive with a great personality. Ordered a cold Iguana Bait craft beer at a low 5.2% abv but had a cool name. The gender assigned bathroom had contemporary decor and was clean. read more

See all

What an amazing Resturant!!!!! The food was phenomenal! The tuna nachos were out of this world and the mahi, and the burger were exceptional and our service was spectacular. This was our first time at the Resturant as we are staying at the Hilton and Alexander took such amazing care of us as if we were regulars at the restaurant and had been going there for ever!!!!! Thank you for an amazing experience read more

Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen - Amazing Mahi dinner & Waygu burger - American Near Me - Key West, Florida

Lovely bar at the OceanEdge Resort with Marcos who was a fun bartender. He made me two Aperol Spritz cocktails and it tasted Oh Yes!!! Some really good meals on the menu mostly that you would find in the Keys and priced reasonably. read more

See all

Food quality is there but the service was a little slow and our order came out with issues all but once. The limited menu also adds to the lack of stars here. The staff although friendly forget to bring basic items so by the time they come back with ketchup or an extra plate our food was cold and less appiti read more

Filet mignon and fried spiny lobster were great. Both cooked exceptionally. Natia was attentive and very informative. Tall unobstructed windows let in just the right amount of natural lighting. Facing south east avoided the sun's glare making late afternoon to evening dining very pleasant. Wanted to linger at the bar. read more

Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen - Fried lobster - American Near Me - Key West, Florida

We ate at Yellowfin many times over a bachelorette weekend. I had a burger and fries after a long flight. Delicious but expensive. A bagel and cream cheese after our first night out. $7 but worth it. And this avocado toast on our last morning. This was definitely the best thing all weekend! Again, wildly expensive for what it is but you're paying for convenience! read more

Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen - Avocado toast with egg and bacon - American Near Me - Key West, Florida

We went to this restaurant for Thanksgiving at noon and we sit outside (we had a dog). It was raining and they push us to the outside and went I sit down I was all wet. I decide not to say anything and brushed off. We felt a little weird since the begging as service was not bad but they were no good either. Was a strange all over interaction. So we order food and when the coconut shrimp appetizer came, after the first bite we found a long hair stuck in the fried batter of on of them. I decide to inspect the other ones and we found 2 more with hair stuck!!! We felt disgusted by the quality and talk to the sever and told her that this is not what we expect and to cancel all our order. She didn't even call the manger or knew how to deal with the situation, I guess she was just embarrassed but it ways. I would no recommend this place at all. If you zoom in on the photo and see in the right top corner you would see one of the hair sticking out. We didn't pulled all to show the server. It was really long. read more

Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen - Zoom in right top corner- long hair stuck - American Near Me - Key West, Florida

Jen is a bad mommy! She has a heavy hand and a light personality. The woman knows people and she knows how to pour a stiffy. read more

Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen - American Near Me - Key West, Florida

Alex was great. Very warm and knowledgeable. Inside was comfortable but outside was far more desirable for dinner however large fans were blowing at the tables so it was t an option. Had the pistachio grouper. It was quite tasty. My partner had the mahi. Both had good flavor, chocolate lava cake...yum. read more

Great service and well prepared food! We got the breakfast free with our room and couldn't recommend it more! read more

See all

Alex V was an amazing!!! He went above and beyond with service. Such a kind and sweet man. read more

Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen - Filet Mignon - American Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

And I have come back here several times this time we brought some friends. The food again was amazing. I went off the wall and ordered cauliflower steak. It actually is pretty good but I like cauliflower. I did order it with grilled shrimp. Next time I think I'll go back to seafood because I do like my seafood :-) The other thing I noticed tonight they had Pilar rum. That's my upgrade over the mountain rum. Peggy had the wet salad, Janice has already tuna nachos. That's what I'm ordering next time it looks awesome. Matt had the garlic shrimp that looks great too. There were no leftovers. Another outstanding night at yellowfin bar and kitchen. read more

Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen - The view while eating breakfast isn't that bad - American Near Me - Key West, Florida

Came for lunch. The service was extremely slow. When I food finally came we had no napkins or utensils. Had to grab it off of another table The waiter hardly came to check on us . food was good but not worth the wait. Very disappointed, been here before and it wasn't like that. My mom is a local and she felt like locals were not welcome. read more

Worst service ever. Sat down and waited 10 minutes and no one came so I got up and left. By reading some of the reviews I guess it's common practice to ignore people read more

Location, location, location! Amazing restaurant right in the water! I had a mixed seafood po'boy! Never had anything like it. I had a raw oyster with delicious accompaniments! Service was great and I was by myself just enjoying a great treat!! read more

The breakfast lasts from 8:00-11:00am. They also have a cafe that has more of to go items. We arrived around 9:30am. The reason I state that is because I was looking to order a croissant with my breakfast & they were out. Minus 1 star. Food: The food was decent as well as my latte. I ordered their main breakfast (pictured). A little overpriced but so is almost everything in Key West. I do have to say their cheesy potatoes that come with the main breakfast are delicious! Service: Service was okay. My husband is unable to have added sugar at this time so he tries to stick to protein & veggie options. He opted for the omelet (not pictured) which he liked. He wanted a smoothie but asked the waitress if their whey protein had any extra sugar in it & instead of offering to go see she just said she didn't know & it comes out of a bin so she wouldn't even be able to read on the label. Fortunately my husband isn't allergic to sugar, but hopefully they take any serious allergies into consideration for any future guests. Minus 1 star. Ambience: It was a nice area on the patio right next to the marina. Chairs were comfortable. The only complaint is lack of enough shade if you want to sit outside. There were plenty of guests who were trying to pull tables & umbrellas from other areas of the patio to try to get a decent spot. But inside was air conditioned & had nice views also. Overall: If you are a guest in the hotel, it is worth a try. If not, there are better meal options closer to downtown. read more

Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen - Yellowfin Breakfast* Eggs (cooked however you like) White toast (others available) Bacon (sausage is another option) Cheesy potatoes - American Near Me - Key West, Florida

Great atmosphere at sunset. Best Fries on the island and Jen makes a masterful Pina colada!

Jen is amazing at Yellowfin Bar--friendly, attentive, and makes you feel at home! Highly recommend

Food is okay for a Florida resort restaurant. Terrible service tho. Breakfast- We waited 10 minutes for someone to at least acknowledge us, finally let the host know we were still waiting, then the server argued with us about how long we'd waited. He then proceeded to slam food, coffee, sugar basket, etc, down on the table. Dinner - Bartender took exception to our comment about asking for water, placed my wine glass on the bar, said "there ya go", and ignored me for the rest of the evening. KW restaurants are all overpriced, but at least the service is nice EXCEPT FOR THIS RESORT. Ugh , if i want to be treated badly by servers, there are cheaper places at home. read more

Strong five for this resort bar restaurant that delivers on exemplary hospitality and wonderful food. Debating myself, whether or not this is the best burger in the Keys. It's definitely in the top two. Quality sings with this one. I'd read a few reviews here and there and heard some things from others about the burger and they're right. Worth coming I'm just for that and the poshish setting. Well worth mentioning, they deliver an exceptionally high level of hospitality and customer service on a level I haven't seen in a long while. read more

We stayed at the resort and it was vacation life. Great staff and food. We enjoyed lunch and breakfast at the Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen. Everyone is so friendly from front desk to housekeeping. Beautiful hotel and restaurant and would return to stay and dine the next time we are in Key West! read more

See all

Service is really bad here. We stayed at the resort so we tried this place multiple times for quick bites and drinks and the service was truly awful. Very slow, inattentive and often rude and grumpy. The food wasn't bad. The prices are terrible tho read more

I have a warning for anyone who visits in the summer. This is an open air establishment. On a hot August night after touring Key West I came here for a meal. I was hot and there was nothing to cool me down. I even asked to sit under a fan. The prices are not for the faint of heart. They are expensive. The food that I had was solid. My first visit I only ordered calamari and it was calamari. Nothing stood out as being the best nor the worst. You can see from my picture the size of the plate of squid. My second visit I had blackened grouper served with broccolini, jasmine rice, passionfruit butter sauce. Blackened grouper was fried grouper. If you are thinking it is a true blackened dish in the tradition of Paul Prudhomme you will be disappointed. It was not a bad dish just not prepared in the New Orleans way. One thing was new to me was the broccolini. They somehow take broccoli and make it slender I did not take a picture but it was darn good. A person should rightfully ask why I ate here twice? Well Ocean Edge is not located in Key West. So you are not going to walk to fine dining. You can get a Burger King if that is your thing. read more

Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen - Calamari - American Near Me - Key West, Florida

Big portions, amazing presentation of food and the food was delicious!! Staff were friendly and very attentive. read more

Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen - Cauliflower Steak - American Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

We are staying here, and these are some amazing people and chefs. Very attentive and very friendly staff. You can sit outside or inside. Hang out and watch the boats in the Marina come in. read more

Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen - Fresh caught Wahoo with plantains and steamed veggies. I know because we caught it. - American Near Me - Key West, Florida

I stayed here a few nights and tried a few different breakfast items! Food was amazing ! I loved their meat lovers omelette! Their crab egg Benedict's were amazing! It was stuffed with a lot of crab meat. Staff was cool and actually remembered me lol! Gorgeous setting and view too! Even if your not staying here worth a cozy breakfast!! read more

Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen - a plate of food on a table - American Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

We've now done Breakfast, lunch and dinner here over the course of 2 days, and the food and service have not disappointed us. Lunch at the bar day 1, Marcos was awesome. Great views, and music at night adds to the experience. read more

Food is delish. We've had dinner and breakfast here now. We got a calamari appetizer. Very flavorful, crispy, and well prepared. I had the chicken piccata. My husband had the grouper special. Both meals very good. We had key lime pie for dessert... and a chocolate mousse. Wonderful! Sadly, I'm taking 1 star off because the service - while friendly - was extremely slow - and not very attentive. This happened for both meals. Seems like they're short staffed (like everyone else). But very good meals and clean/bright restaurant with bar. BEWARE: Gratuity is INCLUDED (even if you are dining alone)... So no matter what service you get - everyone gets a trophy behind the scenes. read more

Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen - American Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

We only dined here for breakfast as we were staying at the resort. I ordered eggs benedict and I enjoyed it. The eggs were done just right and the potatoes were actually pretty soft and buttery. I was surprised because by looking at the whole round potatoes, you'd expect them to be hard and dry. Complete opposite! My husband also enjoyed his scrambled eggs, potatoes and bacon. Service was lacking and we had to hunt down other servers to get some things we needed. The price is also high... but expected when dining on resort. read more

Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen - Eggs Benedict - American Near Me - Key West, Florida

The best hotel I've stayed in Key west, I've been in key west before but this one just worth it! Clean, feeling new and charming. The pools are phenomenal and the service is just great. My fav place so far in the keys. Stay here, go scuba in the closest local spot, and enjoy good food and great vibes! Highly recommended!! read more

Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen - Sunset. - American Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

We were hesitant about visiting this restaurant based on yelp rating (3 stars) but glad we did! Service was quick and amazing while food portion is very generous and well prepared. Not only was our server attentive and ensure that we have everything we need, he was also understanding and friendly. Our food is made with fresh ingredient and we like the robust flavor for our snapper dish. The rum is strong and was not too sweet. Overall, enjoyed our meal. read more

Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen - White Wine Garlic Shrimp Pasta and Blackened Yellowtail Snapper - American Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

This is the restaurant attached to the Ocean's Edge hotel. We had several meals at this location, breakfast, lunch and dinner. They were all good, nothing great and nothing awful. The breakfast was nice, but the coffee selection on the menu strangely does not list just plain drip coffee which is available. Lunch and dinner were fine. The food is well seasoned and nicely presented. For the price point, you can likely go elsewhere and get better offerings. Wait staff is generally nice. Jen, the bartender is exceptional! The manager (I think), Cindy, was a bit rude one evening for no apparent reason, other than the fact that we were a large party with no reservations (not sure that should result in unnecessary biting comments from her). read more

The food at Yellowfin is always top notch whether dining in for dinner or grabbing a sandwich poolside. Service is quick and friendly and the music is never so loud that I can't hear the person next to me talking. I really appreciate that. I love eating here whenever I stay at Ocean's Edge. read more

Do not waste your money or time or calories! Coffee is good as well as service. View is ok. Food and prices are ridiculous.

Great food with daily specials. Friendly service and good outdoor seating with music from Lee Sharp.

It's not cheap, but the food is great and the portions are large enough for two to share. The fish and the tuna nachos both hit the spot. Found a lot of the food in Key West to be plain and flavorless but this was a pleasant surprise. read more

Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen - American Near Me - Key West, Florida

We celebrated Father's Day 2022 with a fantastic Brunch Buffet at The Yellowfin Bar and Kitchen. Chef Juan prepared a delicious menu sure to please any guest. The Prime Rib was tender and very flavorful... an A+ in our book! Turkey was also a hot carved selection. Home made garlic mashed potatoes were over the top awesome. Fresh vegetable medley was prepared with just the right seasoning. Quiche, bacon, sausage, waffles and scrambled eggs rounded out the breakfast options. Salad toppings were an offering of healthy nuts, fruit, and veggies with many choices. Mini fruit and chocolate cheesecakes were the perfect ending! Key Lime and Hazelnut chocolate beignets were warm and yummy. They even gave us free sorbet BUZZ Bars for saying "We Love Stock Island" Can't get more perfect than that! Our hats off to Chef Juan and his whole team Do go try this place for yourself! read more

Now that is a pina colada! It was super relaxing with the perfect balance of class and relaxation. Very enjoyable lunch. read more

Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen - a man sitting at a table with a glass of lemonade - American Near Me - Key West, Florida

They have a great menu with an awesome view of the water, and the service is impeccable. We have had lunch as well as dinner in this restaurant and never been disappointed. You should try this if you have a chance, because I know you will enjoy it. read more