If your looking for a great place to relax and have a great meal, lunch or dinner, this is the place. Service was terrific and ownership couldn't be more welcoming and warm to the customers. Big bonus was the deserts, save room, won't be able to resist. Highly recommend. Dennis I Mahwah, NJ read more

The best Salads anywhere! Favorite is Cheese and Fruit with a raspberry dressing Yummy!

Place was nice and food was great . Only things the girls in the front were not to friendly . No hello or have a nice day. Since it was my first time going first impression are important . Our server Stephen was great and always checked on our table. The food was great. Specials had so many choices made it hard to choose. Over all I would recommend them and go again. read more

Who knew food in New Jersey could be this good! The service was great and the portions were ginormous! I got pasta and I sampled some of my party's food and everything was delicious. read more

Good Quality Food! Very convenient! Pasta is amazing! The wait can be a little long though.

I've lived in Wyckoff my whole life but have only recently tried the food here. I ordered a burger with a side of fries and a slice of cheesecake for dessert. The dessert was a bit expensive for 7 dollars a slice. The quality of the food was great and the waitress was attentive without being intrusive, coming over only when she saw my glass was empty to offer a refill. I would return. read more

We went there with a party of 8, Service was very good, food was worth going for. will return. Just keep in mind its a BYOB.

This is a fantastic local restaurant. It has a nice and quaint feel to it, and the service is always great! They have a really nice variety on the menu and everything that I've had so far has been great, especially the salads! I highly recommend the gelato to finish off your mea tool, so good! read more

Expensive salads, quality ok but wasn't impressed with the execution. My fish was overlooked and dry. Loud and not likely a place I'd return to with so many options locally. read more

LOVE this place! Always a go-to restaurant for my family and my best friend's family! However, we miss the coconut cake SO MUCH from the original baker. Bring it back! Definitely worth 5 stars if there was a coconut cake :( read more

Business dinner for 10. Excellent food and great service. The Ahi Tuna meal was one of the best I've had.

Food here is very good and priced appropriately. I am in love with their gravy (tomato sauce for those of you from another planet). Doesn't hurt that all the waitresses are very kind and attractive. read more

This place is great! The owner is so accommodating and friendly The food is also fresh and delicious and prices are also good too read more

Went here on a Saturday night. It was crowded and we waited about 15 minutes for a table. We ordered the chicken dumplings as an appetizer. They were really good ~ crispy, flavorful and with a delicious sauce. The bread was foccacia like and very good too. For entrees we choose the swordfish which was excellent and came with an amazing potato croquet and the hangar steak which was cooked perfectly medium rare. Both were large portions and plated very nicely. The swordfish was one of the daily specials and came with a salad. For dessert we had tiramisu which we also highly recommend. Overall it was a great experience and we'll definitely go back. read more

Great little place that was recommended by a few friends- had The Godfather and my wife had the Turkey Brie sandwich- - both were great- top quality, fresh ingredients- great atmosphere and it was packed at lunch time today- will be back again soon! read more

Love Brent. He is warm, hospitable and cares about his staff and guests. Amici is a great cafe.

I've been to Cafe Amici twice, and both times have been pretty decent with good service and generally good food. I'm a vegetarian so I'll admit I can't give as good of a rundown on their food as others, but I've always enjoyed their Margarita Pizza. For the price range and quality, the place has a nice ambiance. BYOB like most places in Wyckoff, and they don't take reservations. Overall, it's a good place to go out for dinner. read more

Food never disappoints. Nice atmosphere and a very fresh and seasonal menu. We have come here weekly for years, and have always been more satisfied every single time. read more

I frequently order from Cafe Amici, but there's only one thing on the menu that's good . . . the Turkey Burger. Every single time that I have tried something different, I have been utterly disappointed. After a long week of poorly eating, I was looking forward to trying out the Melanzane Rigatoni. Bad decision. The menu failed to say that there were hot pepper seeds all throughout the pasta. I couldn't even finish my meal because of how hot it was. Well, there's $20 down the drain and a loyal customer that was unfortunately lost. read more

This a a nice BYOB local restaurant........service ice is good.....the food is good.....I thought the menu could be a little more creative.....but it is a good ......... read more

Great spot with very good quality food! The place is pretty small, and you will most likely need to wait although I've been lucky enough to get a seat right away but quickly realize the line once we're sitting. Chicken parm is amazing and it comes with a small side of pasta that is always perfectly cooked, and you have to try the homemade crumb cake - so delicious. read more

Alway a great meal. My wife and I come here often, mostly for lunch. Salads are portioned nicely and delicious. I alway recommend Cafe Amici for a great lunch. Service is always great as well. read more

Food is fresh and made with care. Omelets and salads are great and service is just fine. Only complaint, though small, it is a noisy space. I would recommend. read more

I had the worst experience with Cafe Amici in Wyckoff. I called the restaurant and asked if they delivered, the woman answering the phone told me to go on Door Dash. I contacted Door Dash and ordered from the Cafe Amici menu that was listed. I ordered 3 dinner salads, all with chicken. All 3 orders came without chicken. When we called Cafe Amici to tell them, they told us to call Door Dash, as the order has nothing to do with them, as they don't use Door Dash. Makes no sense, as the Amici menu was on Door Dash (same menu as restaurant), the 3 salads were prepared and packaged by Amici, and then picked up from Amici's restaurant. How they could possibly state they do not have anything to do with Door Dash is not logical. When I asked to have the chicken for the salads redelivered, the woman stated she has nothing to do with the order and they are not responsible for it. She started screaming that it was not her problem, she's refused to refund my money, or send over the 3 chicken sides for the 3 salads. When I did not back down, she then woman screamed that she would drive over the chicken (we were 10 minutes from the cafe). After an hour, when it was clear it was not coming, I got back on the phone with the owner who was also extremely nasty, just kept repeating they have nothing to do with Door Dash and it was not his problem. He actually said he doesn't even get paid for the orders that he fulfills, all the money goes to the delivery service. I am not sure how he doesn't realize how ridiculous that sounds. If they had nothing to do with the delivery service, why did they prepare the food and have their menu listed on the site? I had told the owner all that all 3 of us were regular customers (I eat/order from there several times a month) which meant nothing to him as he continued to be extremely nasty, basically told me to get lost and then told me he was hanging up the phone. More than anything, my friends and I are stunned that a small local restaurant would speak to loyal customers in that manner. It's one thing if you have a teenager who is clueless being nasty, but the fact that the owner was as nasty, was shocking. It got to the point where I put my friend on the phone as maybe she could reason with him, but he just continued to talk over her and tell her it wasn't his problem. I guess "lead by example" is true in this case as his staff is trained to be interact with his loyal customers just like he does. This could have been so easily remedied, an apology, a refund, delivery of the missing ingredients, just treating your customers with respect. read more

We always come here and suggest it to friends. Owner is nice and attentive. Hummus is awesome and the arugula pizza is great!

Went for lunch today. Like many other reviews, I found it to be too LOUD. I'm guessing the tile floors make things much noisier. The place was packed and we had to wait a few minutes for a table of four. The food is OK at best. I had the Turkey BLT, which is described as a BLT with roasted turkey on it. For the price paid, I would expect to get real roasted turkey breast. What I got was thinly sliced cold cut type turkey. The fries were good. Wife had a salad with grilled chicken, cranberries, walnuts, and apples. Very small portion for the price, the chicken was ice cold, and the "lite" Italian dressing tasted fresh out of the bottle. The other folks in our party had the steak sandwich (looked and tasted like Steak Umms), and the burger which was a nice size and cooked as ordered. I'm not sure what the attraction is here, as I said, the place was crazy busy. Took about 30 minutes to get our food. Sort of reminds me of diner ambiance and food with too high prices. Not going back. read more

This restaurant is very clean and has a great lunch menu! However, as of last year, the salads seemed to get significantly smaller while their price rose. It's a great family restaurant with something for everyone! Wish they would take reservations! read more

Very very disappointing. Our first time here and we had very high expectations. We ordered our kids entrees first with the apples so they can come out together and they can eat . Well, our server put them in with our entrees and they came it very late . My daughters birder was supposed to me medium well and it was clearly undercooked. We wanted to speak with the manager and she could care less. Horrible customer service with an attitude. Our server said it was her first day. I've never seen any manager so carefree as her. The food was also mediocre at best. Would not go back. read more

Nice little place to have lunch in, it's typical very busy, food is pretty good. It's a little pricey but its Hard to get a really good quality lunch so it's worth it. read more

The staff was very friendly; we were celebrating a birthday and they put a candle in the cannoli, which was delicious. I had the short rib with goat cheese fondu sandwich: very tasty, but a little pricey at $13. I, however, will never go back because of the dining room acoustics. At lunch time you can forget about being able to have any kind of conversation. The place is so noisy our waitress could not even hear my order and got it wrong. read more

Consistently good and quite possibly the best penne vodka I've ever had! Great staff and always great service!

I have eaten here a couple times. Food is just okay. Order the buffalo chicken salad and it was drenched in too much dressing and was tasteless. The Thai chicken salad was nothing special and a very small portion for $17.00. Over priced and not worth it. read more

Since I am from Wyckoff, I was a little offended by the critique of the "Stuffy Clientele" who dine at Cafe Amici. I frequently eat here, and must give my opinion about Jennifer L's comments. The two older women are the friendliest and most professional servers. Never had a problem with service . And why would someone go out for lunch and split it 4 ways on 4 different credit cards..can't you do your own math? read more

Upon entering the customer is greeted by a plethora of beautfil girls. Brett the manager is just great. The food at Amici reminds me of home cooking, it is tasty and made from good quality produce. Don't be afraid to get the fish! The food has improved on sundays since they have replaced the relief chef. You have to ask for Jonny to be your waiter, he is the best! You won't have trouble finding him as he is the only male waiter and is just adorable! read more

I love eating at Cafe Amici.... It's like being with family. Everyone is so friendly and on top of that the food is creative and delicious! I love the Tuna And Avocado appetizer and the Liver special they have occasionally is to die for... They also favor using local farms and on many occasions have fresh harvest such as rabbit etc. Love this place! read more

Always a pleasure having lunch here, sometimes alittle slow on service but for a lunch spot it is Truely a gem

Nice neighborhood cafe. Mostly do take-out - have eaten at the restaurant 2-3 times. The sandwiches are very good and the desserts are amazing. They can be a bit pricey, and the atmosphere pretentious at times, but overall I've always had a good experience. read more

We have been regulars at Cafe Amici for years and have recently noticed some changes regarding the greeting and seating at the door. At times, it seems to be one of the servers running from the podium to the tables, and at other times it is someone new and unfamiliar with the usual seating process. What once was a very organized and pleasant experience, is now a chaotic nightmare. The staff at Amici is wonderful and has always been on top of everything, until now. We are always impressed with Lily, as she greets everyone as if it were her home. She seems to be the only hostess who is quick and efficient. For us, consistency is key. read more

As far as appetizers, the meatball dish and the grilled octopus were amazing. Fried calamari was good too as was the mushroom pizza. All great dishes for sharing, but can be ordered for a smaller main course as well. Penne vodka entree was good but could have used some vegetables or protein as it was just plain penne in vodka sauce. Pecan pie gelato was a great way to end the meal - awesome selection of gelati to choose from. read more

Nice, fresh, unique dishes, mainly for lunch. Caring but harried and overworked wait staff in a pleasant environment. From Cobb Salads to generous sandwiches you will not leave unfulfilled, though your wallet may be lighter. read more