Awesome! The best is the Nona! Expensive but worth it. The sauce and the cheese are great. The crust is perfectly crunchy.

They serve the best Eggplant parmigiana!! Veal Marsala is tender and tasty! Their pizza is outstanding! This restaurant serves food that feels so homemade, you'll think mama is in the kitchen! And great service makes this our go to once a week! read more

See all

Tonight we went there. Usually the service is excellent and the food good. Tonight it flipped totally . The food was great but our server left . She charged us $ 17 for 3 glasses of sparking water What? And we couldn't find her. I never saw her there before so disappointing . We looked and finally one of the wait staff helped us. Honestly, it was so weird. Usually the wait staff is lovely and so welcoming . What happened ? read more

Food is alright. Dishes are better than the pizzas. Pizzas are over priced. $27 for this. Unacceptable read more

Pizzeria Mandara - Large pepperoni - Italian Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

I ordered a large pie and it was very salty and topped with died oregano. I would not order from them again $20.00 spent on horrible pizza. Even the cheese wasn't tasty . Stay away read more

I usually come here during the week for lunch--the food is decent, the bathrooms are clean, and service is quick. However, when I came for dinner with my family, the experience was disappointing. As other reviews have mentioned, the counter person, Nicole, was rude. On top of that, she handled both the register and food without gloves. Meanwhile, other employees were leaning on half-folded pizza boxes, chatting instead of working. If you're okay with decent food and indifferent service, this place might work for you. read more

Pizzeria Mandara - Stromboli - pepperoni -- it was delicious! - Italian Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

See all

I have mixed feelings about completing a review for this establishment. In the past, I have had fair/good experiences here yesterday was the exception where I would rate the overall experience is poor. I attended a small group function in their back room. It took 45 minutes for bread to come out onto the table. The staff of two seemed ill prepared. They never asked to take any orders for beverages and at the end of the event, they did not offer coffee or dessert. It seemed like they were just overwhelmed. Overwhelmed, although the restaurant itself was empty. I just felt embarrassed for the host. As for the food, again, it was only just fair. No real skill involved in the preparation. Just a lot of tomato sauce heaped on top. read more

I had one of the poorest experiences I have ever had at this pizzeria. I am embarrassed to have spent my money here. The food: average and not an ounce more. I spent 48 dollars on ONE pizza and one small Cesar salad. I asked for a small side of parm cheese because it was a pick up order. I was blown away with the response that I got from their employee. "I have to charge you a dollar for parm cheese. It's a new policy from our owner." This is despicable. Almost 35 dollars for a pizza and 13 for a side salad and you need to charge me for a sprinkle of Parm cheese for her to go order that I would not have to pay for if I dined in? The owner and this establishment should be embarrassed for the way that it treats the people that keep it in business. read more

Overall a good experience. We were in on a busy Saturday night. Staff was prompt and attentive. The group had pastas and salads. All of the pastas and salads are good. Prepared in a way typical to east coast Italian food. read more

Usually my family gets good pizzas from here, but sometimes when it's busy we get pizzas like this one we got recently: half plain, half 1 topping pepperoni, but the toppings were not evenly distributed... it's happened before (different day, different toppings) but when it's done right, you can get a good pizza from here. read more

Pizzeria Mandara - Italian Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

Very good quality pizza and made with quality ingredients. Both the regular and Sicilian pizza are the best in the area. Service is also good. Never had less that a good experience at this place. read more

The food was fine. Nothing special, but good enough. The service? Horrible. We had a 7pm reservation, the kids were served at about 7:40 and the adult's food didn't hit the table until 8:15pm. I waited 40 minutes for a refill on my soft drink before flagging down another server to help me. We didnt make it out of there until 9pm and our kids were going to pieces by then after waiting for so long. Awful service, I felt like the server was avoiding even being in the room. read more

Eggplant parm hero terrible, eggplant grilled and chewy, bread soggy, sauce watery, not enuf cheese. Pizzas have toppings THROWN on when theyre busy- some slices have NO topping... quality has gone down last few years. read more

We love coming here. Their Pasta Amitriciana is my favorite. The calamari is tender with a perfect crispy batter. The coconut cake is light and dreamy. And it won't break the bank! read more

See all

At work they treated to my favorite kind of pizza. Free pizza. I hear that if your in Wyckoff this is the spot. I've only tried their plain pizza and it was on point. Fresh ingredients with the perfect mix of sauce and cheese baked to perfection. They have pizza and your basic Italian meals and sandwiches. Their taste is similar to any other basic pizzeria. Traditional pizza, great service and reasonable prices. They have their own customer boxes so you know their legit. Enjoy. read more

Pizzeria Mandara - Italian Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

See all

Guys, (OWNERS) please take my advice, my family and I have been going to you for years however, the last year or so, things have been sub-par. Service has has gotten bad, staff walk by us like they do not see us, they do not even say, "hi folks I'll be right with you", I have to snap my fingers and I hate doing that. Portions have gotten small and quality low. We ordered two pasta dishes and a chicken parm dinner, $95, like Crazy Eddie used to say "our prices are "INSANE". read more

A great local spot for takeout or sit down. They have a cute dining room with a large menu selection. Brought the kids here - ordered pizza, shrimp scampi, Caesar salad, pasta and of course their amazing gelato. Everything was really good! Service was nice - we would definitely go back! read more

Top quality food coming out of this pizza kitchen. Served fast by a very efficient staff who are always watching to make sure you are happy. Very nice room for being in a strip mall. Prices are high but worth it for the great food and service. read more

First time I went, warmed up calzone. Second time New Year's party, wasn't given the dish that was advertised, many ingredients missing. They spilled sauce on my husband's new jacket, never asked to pay for dry cleaning nor apologize for it. Will not go back! read more

Pizzeria Mandara is a fairly large Pizzeria / restaurant with lots of seating, every time I've visited I've never ran into an issue of having to wait 30+ minutes for my table which is gold especially when you make plans to visit on the fly. Service is spotty to be honest, on some visits I'll have the most attentive waiters/waitresses however on others I'll have those who lack social skills and basically forget to check in. Pizza's are delicious - my favorite is the vodka pie, but you can never go wrong with a plain cheese pie though my husband would argue that the best is their pepperoni. Other then pizza's I've tried out their Penne all Vodka and I have to say it's pretty good, but they constantly fail me on the amount of sauce they give. I've literally been charged because I asked for more sauce, I don't think that's right, but if you're used to having saucy pasta you'll do the same. read more

We love the food and the people who work there are very nice but there is nothing to absorb the noise. The walls are Brick and other hard surfaces and sound just bounces around the dining room. They should hang tapestries or something on the walls to absorb the sound waves and lessen the volume. We still go there but not as often because it's so loud. It's an easy fix and I know others feel the same way. Only 3 stars because of the noise and because they could do something about it very easily and don't. read more

We always enjoy ourselves at Pizzeria Mandara. The location is great. Parking is nearby. The dining room is spacious. And the high ceilings keep noise down. The staff is always very welcoming and accommodating. Last time we had minestrone soup, personal pizzas and a chicken scampi sandwich all of which were delicious. We will definitely be back often. read more

Always A Great slice. Located in Beautiful North Jersey, Mandera is a staple for everyone who knows it. Along with the great ambiance of Flowers, plants, and paintings, the service and food is out of this world. Servers that help you with your every need, along with quick fresh delicious food makes this my favorite pizza place by far! read more

Pizzeria Mandara - Always Delicious at Pizzeria Mandera! I love the Sicilian Style Deep Dish - Italian Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

See all

I heard about this place from my sister-in-law and brother. They said the food was good and last night I was in the mood for pizza. Well, the menu looked so good we had to try a couple of things. We shared the Fig and Gorgonzola salad which was over arugula and endive with red onion, crumbled gorgonzola, olive oil, aged balsamic, and walnuts. The figs were delicious and so fresh. We also had the fried calamari, one of the best we've ever had. They were so tender and melted in your mouth. We ordered the Nona pizza forgetting that it was a square pizza and not thin slices. It didn't matter because the dough was airy and the crust around the edges was perfect and easy to bite into. And the flavor was the best that I've had. They don't have a large drink selection, primarily wine, which must be bought by the bottle. They have half bottle sizes for a few of their wines. Their menu states that according to NJ law wine must be sold by the bottle. I've never heard this before I'm restaurants as we've always ordered by the glass everywhere else we've been, so not sure what that was all about. We had the house Chardonnay, which was okay. We decided to have the dessert special, Lemon Almond Cake. Oh my goodness. First of all, anything citrus gets my attention, especially lemon anything. But this dessert is a classic Italian cake. It was amazing! Delicious! I wish I could buy the entire cake. I'll have to inquire about that. We also had cappuccino along with the dessert, which was also very good. Our server was very pleasant and the staff was attentive. This restaurant gets busy quickly. We came at 5pm on a Friday evening and we're seated immediately, but it fills up quickly. Make a reservation if you can or come early. It's located in a shopping plaza across from the Stop N Shop so there is plenty of parking available. Highly recommend this place. Forgot to take pictures of some of the items we ordered before devouring it but sharing it anyway. Also, forgot to take pictures of the Nona pizza, which I reheated in my air fryer this evening and it was just as good as it was yesterday. Enjoy! read more

See all

Pizzeria Mandara never disappoints. Anything you order from here is always cooked to perfection. Highly recommend the pollo caldo salad, the campano sandwich and the ravioli pertuso. Slowly going through the menu but these are my top faves. And of course all the pizza is to die for. read more

Pizzeria Mandara - Perfect Salad Pollo Caldo - Italian Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

Since I'm now diabetic have to avoid a lot of carbs - did enjoy this POLLO CALDO (WARM CHICKEN) Grilled chicken breast, shiitake mushrooms and sun dried tomatoes, with balsamic on a Bed of baby arugula and mixed greens Friendly service. And lovely to have leftovers for another meal. read more

Pizzeria Mandara - a plate of chicken and vegetables - Italian Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

Great place! Their portions are large and you'll likely have leftovers which is great! They have a good menu too! I'd go back!

First of all woman who answered the phone said I could order for a specific time of pickup so I asked for 1 hour, 4:45 and my husband got there 20 minutes early and it was already waiting for him... It has absolutely no flavor whatsoever, potatoes were never seasoned and neither were the onions the bottom of the crust is soggy. So disappointed! read more

Pizzeria Mandara - Pizza Roma - Italian Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

See all

The tuscano is the best steak sandwich on the east coast. Change my mind Never a bad meal read more

Great pizza; friendly owner. Great food in restaurant and yummy desserts I recommend the grandpa pizza and delicious white pizza as well read more

Incredible food served nice and hot. Attentive, proactive service (ready with Parmesan before you ask, etc). Fried zucchini appetizer is nice and crispy without being greasy, served with their delicious marinara. House salad is only $7 and is huge with a nice dressing. All four entrees were delicious- two pasta dishes and two veal dishes. Reservations recommended. It does get very loud just from guests talking and the acoustics of the restaurant. Otherwise a fantastic experience! read more

See all

Upbeat and fun place to take the family. The pizzas are fresh and flavorful. I enjoy the offering of local NJ wines as an option, but without any pressure and freedom to BYO. PLUS + More than just a pizza place + Delicious comfort food + Nice decor and ambiance + BYO with some local wine selections FAVORITES * Amatriciana pasta * Arancini stuffed rice balls * Calamari appetizer read more

Really excellent pizza and pasta! Great local spot. Support local! Always feels of comfort food!

Been coming here for years, never had a bad meal. Tonight was especially excellent. Phenomenal Scampi, excellent service, just an outstanding spot. read more

Very good neighborhood-feel pizzeria. We had a small party here a few years ago and they hosted a really nice party for us. I do recommend this restaurant regularly to friends. read more

We were a party of 6 and everyone really enjoyed their meals. We had 3 appetizers and a pizza to start that were all really good. Our entrees were all very tasty. The desserts as well were really good. This was our second time here and will definitely be back. read more

This is a very nice, very busy Italian place that I went to with my wife and in-laws on a Friday night. Reservations are a must and one taste of the food will tell you why. As a starter, they give complementary bread and the garlic knots that came with it was scrumptious. I ordered the Michelangelo without tomatoes and it was outstanding. The bowtie pasta was perfect and the sauce that accompanies it was very tasty. The menu has a lot of options and service was good. I wouldn't say the place blew me away but it was definitely very good. I would definitely try this place again. read more

See all

Just checked out this restaurant with friends of ours. The ambiance is modern and clean and it was just right for dining with family. (Aka kid friendly) We were seated by a friendly staff member and soon thereafter were welcomed by a knowledgeable waiter. He helped us navigate the menu and we selected the calamari and antipasto to begin. We asked for the kids dinners to come out with the appetizers and they worked the timing out perfectly. The calamari was in the sweet spot of crispy and tender and the antipasto was a creative medley of Italian delicacies. It had the traditional meats and cheeses but also featured olives, mushrooms, roasted peppers, and some excellent beans. (Maybe Gigante) For an entree, I went with the chicken scarpariello. The menu indicated it would take longer to cook but it was definitely worth the wait. Juicy chicken and sausage with a bit of a kick in a flavorful sauce including peppers and onions. What solidified my opinion regarding this restaurant was the attention they paid to the sides. Often an Italian restaurant can prepare a tasty entree and then dumps some steamed vegetables on the plate, Pizzeria Mandara served al dente green beans that had flavor and also included decadent mashed potatoes. I was stuffed but I still took a piece of their excellent bread and sopped up the sauce. All of the other entrees at the table looked delicious and each diner had positive things to say The fact that it's BYOB, saved us a ton on the bill and allowed us to bring in some excellent wine to pair with the food. Definitely looking forward to returning. read more

Menu is solid with a wide array of options. Pizzas are very good and the portions for the entrees are generous. BYOB to go with your dinner. Service is spotty as it gets crowded & you may have to flag down your waiter/waitress for more water or a question. read more

Been there many times & never been disappointed. I love their varied menu, they definitely have something for everyone, even 2 fussy kids. Came for my daughter's birthday, enjoyed all our food but have to compliment our server Hasman (hope i got that right!) especially - Ive noticed for years that this is one of those rare restaurants that have workers who stick around - we have seen the same people there for years. While Hasman was new to us, he did an amazing job: courteous, the perfect amount of attention & even tried to get a little who was shy, to talk to him. Good food, great service! read more