Best Italian restaurant in New Jersey! always consistent! Been going here for over 30 years. Not only is food great, but they make you feel like family. Love the arranchini! read more

After reading so many glowing reviews, I am absolutely stunned by how awful our experience was on Friday, May 8th. Between an absentee, scatterbrained server and poorly prepared food, this was one of the worst dining experiences we've had in years. We had been looking forward to this dinner all week, especially since we were celebrating two special occasions, but from the moment we were seated, it felt like we had been placed at the "afterthought table." For the first 30 minutes, no one acknowledged us. We weren't given menus, water, or any interaction whatsoever. When our server finally appeared to take a drink order, we asked for a wine list. She disappeared for another 15 minutes, and I eventually had to get up and ask another employee for menus myself. When the server finally returned, she apologized by saying she was "busy with Phil Simms" at another table. That is not something you say to paying customers. My time and money are just as valuable as anyone else's. The rest of the evening followed the same pattern: long stretches without service, forgotten requests, and excuse after excuse. When our wine finally arrived, the server spilled it across the table and onto my wife's glass, then joked that she had "forgotten how to do her job" after being on vacation and earlier she even forgot to put someone's dinner order in! At that point, I politely explained that service had been extremely slow and asked if things could improve. Her response was to laugh in my face. After taking our entrée order, she then informed us she had forgotten to tell us the specials. More than an hour after being seated, our appetizers finally arrived. They were bland and disappointing, and once we finished, the empty plates sat untouched on our table for quite some time while our server once again disappeared. Nearly two and a half hours into the evening, our entrées finally arrived. Unfortunately, the food was just as bad as the service. The chicken dish was room temperature on the outside and refrigerator-cold in the middle, with unmelted cheese still visible -- clearly something that had been prepared earlier, refrigerated, and poorly reheated. The gnocchi was overcooked to the point of being mushy and gelatinous. The braised short ribs were dry and overcooked, and the risotto was watery and flavorless instead of creamy and rich. After one or two bites, we asked to speak with a manager. The manager appeared somewhat indifferent, though he did offer to comp a portion of the meal. He also said someone would come wrap the food, but of course, no one ever did. We then sat for another 20 minutes with no interaction until our server returned and cheerfully asked, "I hope everything was great tonight!" We explained all of the issues, and her response was simply, "Oh, sorry." We asked for the bill and waited another 15 minutes. When she finally returned, she offered more excuses and told us we should give the restaurant another chance because "the kitchen is preparing for Mother's Day." At that point, it was hard to believe how tone-deaf the entire experience had been. Needless to say, we will never return and would not recommend this restaurant to anyone. read more

We absolutely love Arturo's! This gem is a three-generation family owned authentic Italian spot, that has been around for over 40 years. I was astonished by how massive their menu is. But even more so, how incredible every single dish we tried was! Rated #1 on door dash for pasta in Bergen County, there's simply no surprise! The portion sizes, flavors, and home made pasta is simply incredible. The arancini's and chicken parm vodka were highlights for me. But the game changer is the extensive home made desserts and gelatos made in house. The cheesecake was hands down the best I've ever had. The service was excellent and we loved the live music (Monday and Thursdays) to add to a lovely date night or celebration type of ambiance. Overall, would absolutely recommend this spot! read more

See all

Food is excellent. Bartender is obnoxious he ignores customers unless you flag him down. He has his regulars and you can wait while her talks to them. He refills their glasses when they do t even ask read more

My family and I JUST discovered Arturo's and I feel so grateful we did! The atmosphere is excellent, the wait staff are so kind and friendly, and, most importantly, the food is always a hit. My favorite part of their menu is the fish section, where they provide almost a build-your-own dish where you choose your desired fish AND style. I usually go for the salmon oregenata which is always delish. I do wish they'd put more veggies on the plate though (because they're so tasty!) read more

Arturo's Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Midland Park, New Jersey

See all

First time dining here. Appetizers and meals were sloppy and chintzy. Will not be returning.

It was my first time here with a small group and I was pleasantly surprised by the quality of the food, the generosity of the portions, and the ambiance of the restaurant. There was a pianist/singer in the bar area but it was a nice addition to the dining experience. I loved the murals on the wall. The server was nice. It did get busy so the waitress staff was busy also. It was very nice to have been given pick food of soppressata, provolone, rice balls, and bread before ordering. Everyone enjoyed their dishes. The stuffed artichoke and sautéed cherry peppers were on point. I have been craving a pasta carbonara and have been left underwhelmed the last several places that I ordered it from, but tonight my craving was taken care of. It was very good. The rustic cannoli pie is a must, so leave room. I would definitely give this place a try if you are thinking about it. read more

See all

We come here frequently. The food is always excellent and the service is superb. Wonderful atmosphere. read more

Arturo's Restaurant - Chianti Classico Bacci - Italian Near Me - Midland Park, New Jersey

See all

My husband and I went to Arturo's tonight, sat at the bar and had a great meal! To start they brought us hot bread and butter, a small cheese plate and rice balls. We ordered the buffalo mutz app with figs which was very good (see picture). We also had chicken parm and chicken scarpariello which were both delicious. The bartender is amazing! Busy bar scene and the service was still top notch! Definitely recommend! read more

Arturo's Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Midland Park, New Jersey

See all

Food was fair. The appetizers were very good. The main course, stuffed shrimp was average at best. Service was terrible. The waiter never came back to our table to see if everything was OK. I left a 24% tip and never said thank you as if he felt it wasn't enough. Ambiance was very good. read more

This is a very well seasoned restaurant with old school charm, and old school service, especially with complementary appetizers. The dinner was very well displayed and tasted as good as it look including the dessert recommend going and will visit again read more

Came here for my bday with my hubby, parents and step sister. As we arrived they had a platter of meat & cheese and arancini balls and bread on the house. We had calamari which was excellent, I had the escargot which had no flavor and was too buttery And a Stuffed artichoke ~ excellent. For dinner I had the special rack of veal chops oreganata on a bed a sautéed spinach and potatoes. Mine was so good I'd go back just to get this again. Husband had the braised short ribs with risotto, very good again. Parents split Cavatelli and broccoli al dente and it was fresh home made pasta, they loved it. We then had dessert which I posted a picture of we all had different flavors of gelato that just melted in your mouth it was so good. Our waiter was very attentive and came over multiple times to see how we were doing and if we liked everything. We went at 6pm and there weren't many people in the establishment but I can see on the weekends it must be packed. They also offer a full bar with special drinks. Overall I would definitely go back again. And recommend this restaurant to anyone who likes Italian. read more

See all

Food good mozzarella en carazzo Shrimp oregagato and Beef carpaccio Excellent!! Pounded out veal chop parmigiana good very Heavy. Service Gina is our regular waitress very efficient Francesca bus lady shows she is proud of her job and Appreciates Customers. Our waiter this time just got the job done not a Professional but nice. Atmosphere here dated but very clean and I do like that look!! Prices not bad just one bad cranberry and soda $4 nice $6 for Iced Tea pricey when asked if he wanted more was charged again $12 for 2 teas would probably make me not go back!! Last dessert all average except there homemade cannoli pie u can tell it's made with Love but never have it anymore. Sad to post this but was always one of our Favorites. read more

as one who considers herself a good cook, Arturo's slays each dish dont bother asking for additional cheese on the pork bracciole- there is plenty the duck however can use a few more currants and the friday noght bartender could use another hand!! the pianist is magical !! read more

Last Saturday my family went to Arturo's for dinner. I was upset because all the bar seats were reserved but it was empty. My brother said to the hostess, "Can we sit at the bar?" But the hostess said to him, "You can't sit at the bar, you have to go to the table." So my brother said to the bartender, "Can we sit at the bar and wait for our family?" He said yes. So for about 20 minutes, we waited at the bar before our family arrived. Outside the parking lot was crowded, but there was no valet. The food was excellent, very expensive, but my family loved it. My overall experience was 3 stars. read more

Great meal, great service. Will definitely be back for another delicious meal. Drinks and desserts were great too

Delicious. Food is always fresh and good. The linguine & clams is so good & garlicky and the crabmeat cocktail was delicious.

My wife and I invited another couple to join us at Arturo's on Friday night. We have not been there since the passing of the chef/ owner. We have been going to Arturo's for 20 years, and always had a great meal there. Well what a disappointment! Not sure what was worse, the food or the service. They were bringing food to our table that was not ours. Our server Lily was just awful. She could not have been 22 years old and very clueless. My wife and I were quite embarrassed for bringing them to a restaurant that we said was great and turned out to be a disaster. This is all I am gonna say. I believe one of the son's is now the chef, not good. He did not inherit any culinary talent from his dad. We will not be returning to this restaurant any time soon. We wasted 345.00 hard earned dollars. read more

My absolute favorite and go to Italian spot in Bergen county! I highly recommend if you are in the area, you will never be disappointed. Dinner is great with fresh bread and butter, and rice balls for the table. Service is outstanding here and if there is any question it will be answered above and beyond. The inside of the restaurant is cozy and very well decorated. Should you choose to sit at the bar you will also be very pleased. The cannoli pie is a MUST HAVE for dessert. It is homemade by the owner and the most delicious dessert I have had at an Italian restaurant. The stuffed shrimp was amazing and a perfect portion, extremely well flavored and cooked to perfection. The lamb special was phenomenal. Desserts are always a must here. Our server, Michael went above and beyond with his service and recommendations. I will definitely be back and cannot wait for the next time I can dine here! read more

Arturo's Restaurant - Bourbon - Italian Near Me - Midland Park, New Jersey

See all

We went out with friends and really enjoyed the restaurant. The food was amazing, especially the stuffed pumpkin. Our waiter was excellent too!! Definitely going back. read more

Excellent service food was excellent with the exception of The rack of lamb. Needed to be sent back to cut the rack. Lamb chops were tough and not up to the standards of Arturo's. read more

A new favorite!! We live minutes away and drive past this spot all the time. We love it! The hospitality is so wonderful and everything on the menu is delicious!! Such a nice traditional ambiance that's perfect tor lunch or dinner. Just an overall lovely experience and a new favorite place for us! read more

Classic old world Italian fare. Good value for the money. Lovely staff and bartenders. Not a "scene" -- more of a family, Sunday party place. read more

Always the best authentic Italian food around! Also the best cheesecake in the world!! Seriously.

The food, service, and ambiance are the best! Portions are large, and there are lots of gluten-free and vegetarian options. It's our favorite family restaurant. read more

Another stellar visit to Arturo's. Had the eggplant pie and knocked back a few peronis. I love this spot, the live music , and the friendly owners. Ava, our server, was stellar and always knew when to check up on us . See you soon! read more

Went there last night for the first time , food was great , service not so much Took forever to get water for the table and our waiter who was a real big guy had absolutely no personality, never smiled and wasn't as attentive as he should've been . Not a cheap place so overall loved the food but was very disappointed in the service . May give them another try as experience with another waiter may be better next time . read more

We went there for a Celebration and ordered fish, by the time I got home I was as sick as a dog! Will not go back!

I asked our waiter about the salmon. he recommended the special. it came out in a pool of water very soggy with a few uncooked small potatoes. it had no flavor or taste. I should have sent it back. it will be a long time before I return. read more

Our favorite restaurant! Wonderful classic Italian dishes! One of my favorites is Nonas Chicken! Every meal we've had over the years has always been fantastic. The service is great too! Thank you! read more

43 Years of Extraordinary Food, Service and Atmosphere. My wife took me to Arturo's on Friday night June 27, 2025, for my 75th birthday, which is actually Monday, June 30th. We were greeted by a smiling and energetic young lady who showed us to our table. Next we were served potato croquettes, cheese and the most phenomenal Sopressata I've ever eaten with great basket of bread. YUM and YUMMER!!! Our server Isabella greeted us and took our drink orders. My wife had a Negroni (her favorite cocktail) and I had a Markers Mark on the rocks. When she returned with our drink she told us about their specials for the night asked if we had any questions about the menu then gave us some time before returning to take our order. I ordered 2 appetizers, stuffed zucchini flowers, stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella and prosciutto and escargot. Both apps were incredible. My wife ordered Capellini with Crab Meat, made in a light tomato sauce with garlic, arugula and sun dried tomatoes. There was an amazing amount of jumbo lump crabmeat, so sweet and delicious. I totally enjoyed Braised Short Rib with Risotto. Its braised for 48 hours and served over Arborio Risotto with tomato and toasted pine nuts. The short rib was sooooo tender if I did not have any teeth I could have eaten it. Just marvelous and astonishing. I enjoyed a glass of Chianti with my meal. Molto bene!!! We ended of our dinner with two regular coffees and shared a slice of house made cheesecake with caramel sauce. A Phenomenal Ending to a Great Dinner with Extraordinary Food and Service. Thanks to ownership for creating notable memories with great people, great service, great food resulting in great experiences. I want to recognize our server Isabella. She is a benchmark in my opinion for servers to strive to be. Truly an asset to Arturo's. If you've never been to Arturo's give it a try. I know you agree with me it is a fantastic restaurant. read more

Celebrated one of our good friend's birthday at Arturo's Saturday night. He the oldest of our bunch and leads us off to another year older! Our waiter was friendly, knowledgeable and knew the menu and specials quite well. We all started with good cocktails - Moscow Mules, Godfathers and other concoctions - all very good. Even their Cabernet by-the-glass was very good! For appetizers we ordered the calamari (very tender), mussels in white wine sauce (very good), and the burrata mozzarella with figs and balsamic glaze (excellent!). For entrees, we enjoyed Chicken Scarapiello (good), special homemade pasta with lump crab (not great - sauce needed more flavor)and their special double cut Veal rib chop simply grilled with shitake mushrooms and cherry peppers (outstanding!). For dessert we had our own birthday cake from nearby Market Basket (wow!) but also ordered a round or two of gelato with some Espresso, Sambuca and Marie Brizzard cordials to finish off a great meal. Highly recommend Arturo's for a great night out with family and friends! read more

See all

Great service and the best food - easy parking and perfect location. Good family vibe.

What a wonderful experience The FOOD the Service the Atmosphere! I can't believe I didn't know about this places , I guess I will have to go often for my missed years. Everything was quality ingredients and prepared perfectly. I review lots of places and Arturo's is going to my 10 ten in the world. read more

It is the best Italian restaurant in northern NJ bar none. The food is consistently exquisite, the bar area is happening and the piano player plays his heart out every time. I have been going there for 20 years + and love it more and more. I have yet to have a bad day there. Mario the chef and owner goes out of his way to accommodate any food request you may have. I recommend it 100%. read more

The food was excellent as always but the service was a little disappointing for the price. Had to ask for ice a few times, water glasses were not filled regularly. They didn't ask if you wanted any cheese on the pasta and didn't ask how everything came out after we took a few bites of our food. read more

LOVE THIS PLACE! My hubby and I discovered this place a few months ago, and we go back weekly. The service, the staff and food are excellent. It's a pizza place/restaurant and very homey. My kinda place. Good food at a reasonable price. Very clean. read more

It has been several years since I have been to Arturo's, My last visit was not pleasant. Tonight we decided to take a chance again, and I am glad I did. The food did not disappoint The complimentary arancini and fresh bread was a delicious way to start I had the lemon sole florentine and my other half had the rigatoni bolognese. Presentation and taste were excellent. Desserts made on premises were exquisite. However, the best part of the dining experience was our server Gina. She was an absolute joy, attentive, gave great suggestions, and made us feel at home. People make the experience and i look forward to the next time we get to dine in her section! read more

Just had early dinner at this place for the first time. Very impressed by the great menu. They ran out of the dish I wanted but the other option was delicious !! Emily our waitress was super nice !! . My friend and I will definitely come back !! read more

Arturo's Restaurant - a platter of oysters - Italian Near Me - Midland Park, New Jersey

See all

Words cannot describe how incredible this place is. The food, the atmosphere, Nonna greeting you at the door. It is everything you need in an authentic family owned Italian restaurant. First I'll start with the atmosphere. Like I said you have Nonna greeting you at the door making everyone laugh really giving you that small town family vibe that you want in an Italian restaurant. The murals on the wall are incredible and the U shaped bar is so nice and cozy. Now, the food. Just wow. If you don't get the Shrimp Gratin appetizer you are making the biggest mistake of your life. Just so flavorful and delicate I could have ordered five more. Second you neeeeed to try the rice balls. Best I've ever had hands down. Please do not get intimidated by the menu. The chicken scarpariello, shrimp arrabiatta, shrimp fra diavolo, and the list goes on! Everything is made to perfection. I was with a big group so we all got to try each other's dishes and I can safely say that each one was made with the love, care, and authentic Italian recipes you would hope for. If you are looking for authentic Italian in the heart of New Jersey this is the place to go. Hands down. I cannot wait to go back and explore more of the menu. read more

Arturo's Restaurant - Shrimp Arabiata with Linguine - Italian Near Me - Midland Park, New Jersey