Tonight I felt like treating myself, so I figured I would try Pizza Love for a change. I ordered a chicken Parmesan 7 inch sub with vodka sauce and it was the most delicious meal I've had in months. The bread was soft yet crispy. The cheese was generous. The vodka sauce was tasty and the chicken was tender. What else could you ask for?? I think I might have to get this meal at least once a week! Try it and you'll agree with me! read more

Pizza Love - Pizza Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

I decided to try the chicken Caesar salad from here, since I saw a review saying that they make it fantastic! Sad to say but I was totally disappointed.. the dressing tasted like it was a generic dressing from restaurant depot and the lettuce was extremely soggy and almost inedible.. I hadn't eaten all day so I was forced to eat this salad. I definitely recommend going to uncle Louie's or even franks pizza in Oakland, if you're looking for a good Caesar salad. read more

Literally the best margarita pizza I ever had!!! I love Margerita pizza in general but depending on the place usually it always feels that it misses spots for fresh mozzarella. Well this one is perfect!!! The best quality cheese, delicious sauce and crunchy crust. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The ambience is cozy and perfect for a weeknight casual dinner with the family.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I will be returning. read more

Pizza Love - Pizza Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

I keep coming back to this place because the food is consistently good. I always get the chicken and broccoli Rob sandwich as a standard. I keep coming back here because I feel like compared to other places that sell this sandwich Pizza love fills it with the most ingredients. It's also tasty and fresh. I've also gotten several pizzas from here and they're always pretty good. read more

Super delicious with a lot of excellent options. The drunk grandma slice (with vodka sauce) is my absolute favorite, but one cannot go wrong with any of their pizza. I also highly recommend their vodka chicken parm sandwich. read more

No. Just no. I cannot remember the last time I felt like I got rolled price wise on a meal, until pizza love. [[HIGHLIGHT]]There is no love. Just profit or rent that's too high, maybe too much staff when the place is empty...but disappointed is an understatement.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] 2 slices, mid at best. Square veggie, mostly onions and mostly bland. Crust was crunchy but not crispy. Roasted pepper, chicken finger, balsamic slice. Again. Bland. Really no flavor profile beyond "food". 2 bottles. 20.00 The economy might not be good but that's a wild mark up across the board. You can get a whole pie for 23 bucks. Skip it or let them back on bravo so they can lower the prices read more

Pizza Love - Bland. Bland. Bland. - Pizza Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

Second time in and a great pizza spot. Huge slices, friendly staff. Will stop by whenever in this area.

The pizza was inedible. I threw out the calamari entire order. The rock shrimp was ok

Place is crazy underrated. Don't sleep on the garlic knots chicken parm. Staff could be a little friendlier. I had a large order and had to take multiple trips to my car. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The place was empty with nobody inside.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Kid at the counter didn't even offer to help carry anything. However, pizza and food is legit here. Don't sleep on the vodka sauce. It's addictive. read more

Nope. Got two plain slices to go. Should be easy right? Nope, I didnt see any plain slices while looking in the glass display. The girl says yes they have and proceeds to pull from a rack behind the counter. I said no need to heat them up as i will do later when i get home. Should be a no brainer right? The slices were cold as in the refrigerator cold from last night. And $4 per slice? For plain? Cmon guys, do better. read more

the best food around eggplant Parm is the best Pizza Love Salad the biggest and best around Peggy and Jim read more

See all

they offer table service, pick up, or you can head to the counter and order. theyre byob. they take cards. ample parking in the front. prices are reasonable. the food is great. good service. clean atmosphere. do yourself a favor and get the huge ass knots. stacked with 5 HUGE fluffy garlic knots, you will be impressed like i was. abundance of garlic, these hit the spot. my only complaint is the marinara was cold. drunken grand ma slice came to the table and my friend and i were both slapped in the face with the vodka sauce. this was impressive. i liked the slice, but felt it was cooked a min or 2 too much. however, this is a must try. fresh basil, good cheese, and tasty vodka sauce go a long way. Kathy Wakile keep up the good work! read more

See all

I love pizza not just for their pizza but for their wings, pasta, and more. Whenever I go I always get buffalo wings and I always get them as flats only not the drums and they do that for me which is amazing because I am more of a flats person than drums. Service was good. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Ambiance was good I love the blue and that you can see them making the pizzas in front of you and the pictures on the wall.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Overall pizza love is a good spot for catering a quick lunch place or a nice place to just sit down and eat. read more

My sister and I stopped in here for dinner after shopping and were super happy that we did. Service was so friendly and helpful, whatever you need -- to go boxes, bread with your salad, they were above accommodating and made us feel really welcomed as patrons. Salad was one of the freshest salads I've ever had which says a lot coming from a place that specializes in pizza. Generous portions and not a wilted leaf in sight. Pizza was pretty good -- we just grabbed a couple of slices. Would be interested in just trying out their cheese last next time but they had a bunch of options with options for all. Thick crust, veggie pizza, buff chicken! The seating area is also really clean which makes you stop and think before taking your slices to go. We'll definitely stop by here again to grab a quick bite. This place is a prime example of a small business that appreciates your business! read more

See all

The workers there were very nice. We got our food extremely fast. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The mood there was very relaxing and had very good soccer game on the TV.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]The workers were nice and it was a nice building.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I WOULD HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!! read more

Pizza Love - Delicious piece of pizza with pasta on it - Pizza Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

Food has always been solid...pasta dishes (which tend to be HUGE portions), sandwiches and pizza. My only complaint is I ordered a sandwich off of their "Cold Sandwiches" menu and it was served hot. They threw it on the panini grill and it was heat hot to the middle. It tasted great. But I went to the cold menu because I wanted a you know...cold sandwich. Please Pizza Love just clean that up. read more

Randomly stopped by for an early dinner. Such a great spot! Tried the bbq pizza slice and the penne vodka with a side of fries. Highly recommend it! Super casual place, great service! read more

I ordered from Pizza Love because they deliver. That was about the only thing I liked about it! The ordering and delivery were excellent. However, the quality and portion of the dishes ordered and their prices were a complete disappointment! The soup was greasy, and the eggplant parmesan was droopy and tasteless! I expected more! If it would be possible, I would give this restaurant 3 1/2. read more

I really wanted to like this place because I'm a HUGE Real Housewives fan. [[HIGHLIGHT]]I went here with my 2 young children and they ran out of highchairs so I had to hold my baby while eating which was a bit frustrating[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] and the employees were not friendly at all. They did not seem to be all there when ordering. I'm glad I tried it but definitely won't be back. read more

I was looking for a spot for lunch and stumbled across this location. I called in my order of the southwest wrap. When I arrived I parked in the plaza parking lot. I walked in and told the man my name and he grabbed my food. I paid and left. When I dug in the wrap and fries were good. I had a good experience. read more

See all

Got takeout from here the other day and when I came to pick up I had my baby with me. One of the employees carried my food to my car for me so I didn't have to carry the car seat and food at the same time. Very thankful for that! Food was also great, would recommend their La Rosa Salad- it has perfect portions and was delicious! read more

I ordered two pies, chicken fingers and a salad for an office party. It was absolutely perfect. Don't forget to try the Grandma Love pizza. So great. read more

The food was amazing and the people who work there are so nice and polite!!! I had the pizza and hero and it was great!

Ordered a large pie with breaded chicken. Was cold when i got it. Nothing tasted fresh. The, cheese and the chicken were pretty gross. Wont be coming back here again theres better pizza in nj. read more

I've driven past this place and wanted to try if for a while. I stopped by for lunch. It didn't look like they were open for eat in at all, but I was happy they had slice pies and they all looked awesome. I tried a grandmas slice and a margarita slice. They were both amazing and I don't know which I liked better! I didn't know each slice was going to be like 5$ each but it was worth it! The margarita slice had sweet sauce with mozz and basil. The grandmas slice is more of a deep dish with traditional sauce and cheese mix. I am getting hungry writing this review and thinking about it. Everything they had looked so delicious! Next time I'm gonna plan ahead and order a pie for a pickup but I have no idea which one! read more

See all

I called for my food just after 7pm I was told it was gonna be a 45 minute wait my food did not arrive until 8:15 PM. Not only that part of my order was 6 20 ounce bottles of Dr Pepper upon delivery I only received one bottle. Thankfully they only charge me for one but if you go back and listen to the recording of my call clearly hear me say six bottles. The driver called and spoke to someone at the restaurant told him what happened and I got nothing but attitude. It was a waste of time and money to wait over an hour for food only to get it wrong after working a 15 hour day not happy read more

I ordered pizza & wings .. actually not edible!!! I can't believe that people eat this pizza !!!! How does this place stay in business! 86.00 for 2 pies & wings that is all going in the garbage !!! read more

I was becoming anxious after moving here that I could not find a pizza place that held up to my faves from former hometowns I lived in to the south in North Jersey. Then I found it! This place makes some of the best pizza and hot sandwiches in the Franklin Lakes, Oakland, Wyckoff area. Whew. Good find! read more

i have finally found the best pizza. [[HIGHLIGHT]]comfortable surroundings.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] crust is great. on the thin side. with old world slightly yeast smell. toppings. chicken parm pieces were huge and vegetable square was fantastic. i'll be coming back for sure read more

Great selection of pies for slices on the go. It was my first time here so I dipped my feet in the water with a slice of margherita and a plain slice. The slices were huge (about 1.5x the size of a "regular" slice) and both were right-out-of-the-oven fresh! Great crisp, the cheese was incredible, it wasn't too oily, and all the proportions were just on point! Ordering was super easy and they had pepper & garlic packets to go, though they did offer limited capacity indoor seating (now that it's allowed). I didn't get to try them yet but the penne a la vodka pizza and buffalo chicken pizza both looked really good too. Those will be for my next visit! read more

Pizza Love - Pizza Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

Love the food everything have Oder from there was great I would give more then 5 stars it worth Odering or go there

Staff was very nice & friendly, but pizza was not good. The crust had the taste & texture of bread (vs real hand rolled pizza dough) & the margherita pizza which says on the menu is supposed to be just fresh mozzarella (that's why I order it) was loaded with regular mozzarella with a touch of fresh on top. It didn't taste good so I threw the pizza in the garbage. This is NJ, pizza should be on point! read more

Stopped in for the first time today. Had a slice of bruschetta pie. It was delicious, hot and crisp Ordered the mussels appetizer and it came to me looking a bit watery, tasting a bit off and not very hot however when I brought it to their attention they immediately insisted on making me another mussels appetizer to take home Upon getting it home it was perfectly prepared That is the way you take care of your customers and you'll be sure I'll return. The pizza was amazing. Thank you read more

Pizza Love - Bruschetta pie - Pizza Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

The one thing I really appreciated was how easy the pick up order was. I called them to let them know I had arrived and they walked my order to my car window. I got the arugula salad pizza and spaghetti and meatballs. The pizza was a bit dry and needed more balsamic glaze but the spaghetti and meatballs made up for it. Although a bit pricy it lasted me for 3 meals. I would order again and try something new! read more

Pizza Love - Pizza Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

Always delicious doesn't disappoint the Chicago style Buffalo pizza is out of this world and great boneless wings and penne vodka, get some!

Ordered a chicken parm sandwich and the cheese is stuck to the foil SMH genius wanted a coke regular got a diet instead. OVER PRICED read more

Pizza Love - Pizza Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

See all

Ordered this place from UberEats when everyone was quarantined from the coronavirus. I must say I was pleasantly surprised. Only complaint is that they forgot to give my driver the pizza and he clearly didn't check the order and showed up at my house without the pizza lol. (He went back and they even made me a fresh pizza while he was driving back!) Pizza is loaded with cheese, true New York style. Crust is crispy and made in a brick oven. 5 star. Loaded fries were fantastic but my hubs said "just ok" (he's crazy though, I devoured them before they made their way to his hands so he barely got to get a fair impression)! Onion rings were good, but the ranch was just meh. Good big onion rings though and worth the 7 bucks they cost for sure. Overall- highly recommend the cheese pizza. Lots of flavor. Solid texture. Loads of cheese. Definitely filling but not overly greasy and gross like papa johns lol. Also. I ran into Kathy in Walgreens a year ago and she had a bike helmet on and was super nice to me at the checkout line. So the owners are also friendly. Famous last words.......the verdict is in.... I'll be back!!!!! read more

Pizza Love - Cheese pizza 16" - Pizza Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

See all

Honestly the most amazing salads and food! So much more than your local pizza place. From the garlic knots and salads to the pizzas and pasta.... **chef's kiss** The Love Salad with the citrus sesame dressing is my favorite! read more

I'm not even gonna lie to you as soon as I found out that a NJ housewife had opened up a pizzeria I was all over that ish and let me tell you Pizza Love did not disappoint one bit. I ordered over the phone and went in for pick up. The location is in a strip mall with ample parking and easy access. The store itself is very clean and has an upbeat family feel to it which I really liked. I ordered a rice ball and 2 slices of pizza along with a sandwich for my friend. Everything was fresh and delicious and very flavorful. The rice ball was crisp on the outside and soft and creamy on the inside. The pizza was to die for! I highly recommend the drunken grandma pie! I can't wait to come back and try out some other menu items. read more

Pizza Love - Rice ball - Pizza Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

See all

Every time we have a large gathering, we order catering from pizza love and it is delicious every time. The order is always right, the delivery is right on time, and they are always accommodating of any requests we have. Highly recommend. read more

Pizza Love - Pizza, garlic bread, calamari, boneless wings, eggplant parm, chicken parm, penne vodka and sautéed mixed vegetables! - Pizza Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey