My first time and my mom third or fourth time here busy cone on Easter Food: great love it so great Service: was wonderful cone on Easter Sunday Ambience: love old school itlain restaurant very well done Must go to if can give you ten stars that what would be read more

See all

Super friendly environment and courtesy from the house they make us feel welcome and appreciated with a limoncello and sambuca shots. Food was outstanding and very flavorful I had duck in a coconut style sauce with vegetables and mashed potatoes delish!!! We also had cheese ravioli, calamari with ginger sauce, muscle in red sauce and a combination of seafood. Great night! Happy Easter 226 read more

See all

Came here for Christmas dinner , and it was packed. For the amount of people there , they served food very fast , there was little to no waiting from apps to main course. The food was average, most of it being super salty , chicken Milanese was overcooked. I liked my lobster ravioli, it def has a good amount of lobster in it, but the pasta was too thick and chewy. I think the crowd was too much for their kitchen to handle so I will be back to try it again (Reviews have been good for the restaurant) The one thing I could t get over was one of the waiters had horrible BO to a point I was tasting it in the food every time they passed by. read more

Limoncello Ristorante - Lobster ravioli - Italian Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

Two Marsala, a Shrimp dish and Pasta. Really good. The chicken cut like butter. Salad / bread included. We all enjoyed. Service was outstanding. We used a gift certificate, which is what brought us here . Be back soon. Byo. Don't forget the dessert. read more

Limoncello Ristorante - Italian Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

See all

The food, service and prices are beyond compare!The menu offers a wide variety of choices, and the early bird menu is excellent. The family is friendly and courteous and I truly recommend it for a great meal! ANTHONY S. read more

food was amazing and the service was great especially from the 2 younger gentlemen. Definitely going to return

The staff was exceptionally attentive. The food was depressing. The rack of lamb was cooked to the perfect medium-rare temperature. The portion was about 8 ribs as expected. However, the sauce was sweeter than expected. The spinach tasted almost Vietnamese, as it had the taste of fish sauce. The veal with mushrooms reminded me of hospital food. But the veal here was tougher and the texture was difficult to chew. The sauce tasted like a British brown sauce. The food was 1 star for my wife and I. We will not eat here again. read more

Great service friendly staff excellent food. It's always a place that never disappoints love the specials

I had really hoped to like this restaurant but the truth is that it was VERY disappointing for many reasons. The first sign of trouble was when I poured myself some of the olive oil in the bottle on the table on my plate to dip the bread. To be fair the fresh Italian bread on the table was delicious - very fresh, round authentic loaf. So I was so excited to dip it in the flavored olive oil. I did only the realize the oil was TERRIBLY rancid!!! Once I discovered that it was not surprising. The bottles are clear, not dark. They are sitting out in the tables and I am sure they don't take them in and put them away at night or during the day when they are closed and it must get very warm in there. It you have ever tasted old, rancid oil you will know EXACTLY what I mean. And I am not saying it was "off" or not fresh. It was BAD. I would bet all they do is top it off. After that I gave the complimentary garlic bread a try - that was a mistake too. Some very oily garlic in oil and spread on bread - not toasted though. Just sliced bread. No seasoning. But it was free so I guess that's appealing to some and I can't complain that it was not very good. We had the steamed clams in the white sauce and fried calamari as an appetizer. Calamari was fine. Crispy. Tasty. The clams - bland. Very bland. The sauce was oddly gummy and thickened like they used cornstarch - it was most definitely not due to butter. It was strange. The lobster ravioli were terribly overcooked and mushy although they tasted fine. The pink sauce was okay - needed salt but then was edible. The mushroom ravioli dish however was terrible. It had the same insipid white sauce as those steamed clams. The ravioli were terribly overcooked too and they were lacking flavor. The shiitake mushrooms in the sauce are canned. They were slimy, limp, and tasteless. The tomatoes were overcooked so mushy and tasteless too. The fresh spinach leaves on the top and the crumbles sausage were the only redeeming parts that had any flavor - which might have been fine had I ordered sausage and spinach. I hate to say this but I have to be honest. The restaurant was full. We are in our 50s and other than one other young person we were the youngest people in the house. I guess this restaurant is frequented by a loyal older crowd. And perhaps that is why it can survive with this quality of output. Particularly because it isn't low end price wise. On that note, I will add that after dinner you got a complimentary shot of limoncello or sambuca. This is smart marketing because they were tiny shots and they were certainly watered down. I'd be angry if I paid for them, but they too were free. This however is the sort of marketing ploy that makes people say wow that's great. But again I come for the meal. Not the watered down half shot at the end. Bottom line: If you are looking for decent Italian this is NOT the place to choose. There are many other better options - especially for the price. I'm sorry to say this but I would never recommend this to anyone who expects even decent tasting Italian food. Don't be fooled by the good reviews. If you notice the five star reviews are almost all coming from people who have only that review on Yelp and those pictures. They are not true reviews by real Yelp users. Note how many if any are from Yelp elite or Yelpers with a number of reviews. That's important to reading the ratings for what they are. If you go like we did only to find out they are so off, do others a favor like we did and review it honestly. read more

See all

I had vodka in pink sauce for my entree and my father had the rigatoni with sausage and peas. Both of us were surprised how bland both meals were. We never add salt to food, but we had to because they both tasted like nothing. With salt added my penne was edible though not enjoyable. I have had better from my local pizzeria I am sorry to say. My father's rigatoni was similarly disappointing. The sausage was so overcooked it had very little flavor left. The peas were too were overcooked to the point they were mushy and didn't taste like anything either. The best part of the meal was the fresh bread with butter. I can't recommend this restaurant. read more

Limoncello Ristorante - Rigatoni with sausage and peas in pink sauce - Italian Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

See all

We were a party of 7 last night. The service was great and the food was fantastic. The place is on the smaller size but they don't rush you and we all really appreciated that. It was the first time there for all of us. We will definitely be coming back. I cant wait!!!! read more

I have a "no return" policy for Any restaurant experience that leaves me with diarrhea. Please check the freshness on what you serve. You cannot hold onto food past its prime. Best of luck read more

one of the best restaurants that we go to good is excellent especially the fish dishes service is wonderful read more

Servers don't answer you and not welcoming at all. Food was good but bad service won't have me go back.

Came here for date night, food was delicious. Easy parking out front. Very nice environment with the service on point. The manager or possibly the owners were very friendly and helpful. They have a set dinner menu option if you're interested. Dessert menu was the highlight. Limoncello and coconut cake topped off the dinner night! Will definitely be back again. read more

Just came back from a lovely meal at Limoncello with 4 others. Some of us were having difficulty understanding the menu choices (Price fix, specials, regular menu). The food was abundant and mine was delicious! The staff was attentive and VERY patient throughout! We definitely will be returning! read more

The limoncello drink! They were awesome. Good cigar selection too When it was legal... read more

Great dinner before 6pm $25 for app, dinner, and dessert with coffee/tea. Great service and BYOB. You cannot go wrong here ! read more

Limoncello Ristorante - Polo Pollo Parmigiana - Italian Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

See all

So happy to have found amazing food within a 4 minute drive from me! We met a friend for dinner here on a Saturday night. We found that there were quite a few employees - either slow night or well staffed for great customer experience. My partner ordered the chicken Marsala that was very good and I ordered the bolognese that was amazing! I'm confident that the sauce and noodles are freshly made. Rather passing a dessert menu, they present you with a tray of options to choose from (I think that's pretty cool for visual decision makers). We decided to pass on desert but everything looked great! We'll be back soon! read more

Limoncello Ristorante - Parpadelle Bolognese - Italian Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

See all

We heard great things but we're so disappointed! Went for a birthday lunch on a Wednesday. Soggy and flimsy trout, dry calamari, questionable oysters and everything drenched in sauce left little to celebrate. No one asked how the food was even though my husband took only one bite. Decor needs updating but this is the least of the issues. Will not be returning. read more

Delicious food with authentic Italian vibe! Their goat cheese stuffed dates and short ribs with creamy risotto are ON POINT

Very kind staff. We got the rollatini, which tasted a little bland. My wife got the artichoke hearts (but was disappointed as it was breaded). While I got a veal specialty that was just too heavy for me to finish. I think the manager saw we didn't finish our food, so gave us an amazing desert on the house (a banana pudding). Given the staff we will try again and try different selection. read more

Awesome food and great service. They even serve a complimentary after dinner cordial. Nice touch. Definitely reccomend for a special evening out. read more

Good food, nice people they have been around for a good for a long time. Portions are big!

Value priced BYOB NJ Italian menu. Service is fast and straightforward. Placed was packed the night we were there.

What couldn't improve? Take your pick. Unlike most people, I don't like making my negative views public. Everyone has the right to make a living and I'm not saying don't go there. But if you do, beware that the prices are more than reasonable. The service is average (which is good). But the food and preparation of that food is below par. That's all I have to say about Limoncello. read more

I haven't been here in a long time, but it was just as great, if not better than I remember. When you are seated, they serve you some delicious slices of garlic toast, as well as a basket of bread with herbed olive oil. After you order, they bring you complimentary salads. I feel this is becoming rare in restaurants, but I absolutely LOVE when a little salad is included! The menu has some traditional Italian dishes that you'd expect to see in any Italian BYOB, but it also has some more unique dishes as well. Mine was a chicken dish with an orange ginger glaze sauce, toasted almonds and dried cranberries. It was served with plenty of veggies and some mashed potatoes. Our table also shared a side of penne vodka. It was only $5 so why not, right? The pasta was perfectly Al Dante and the sauce was flavorful. When we first arrived, it seemed like there was a little confusion as far as Open Table reservations, but they handled it gracefully and got everyone who was waiting seated quickly. The place was packed but the service was still welcoming and very attentive. Dessert and cappuccinos were delicious, followed by complimentary Limoncello or Sambuca. We will be back! read more

Limoncello Ristorante - Pollo Ginger- very good! - Italian Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

See all

Ate there last night for New Year's Eve. The reservation was for 7:30. The venue was packed; but we were seated on time. I was impressed. My bf ordered the chicken parm, I ordered the eggplant parm. The chicken parm was 10/10! So soft and delicious. The eggplant parm was 25/10!; the best eggplant parm anywhere hands down. We've been coming to limoncello for over 10 years; as a couple; several times as a party of 15 with family, and with friends. Jimmy & Remy never disappoint. The service and food is flawless - never have had anything but excellent service and food - Madelyn Steinberg read more

For many years lemon cello has been our go to restaurant never a bad meal tonight. We celebrated Father's Day. What an amazing meal food was amazing service top notch. This is why this restaurant a true gem fills most often read more

Pretty damned good lunch special! I used to work in Waldwick but I don't know if this place was even here back then. At any rate, came out to Jersey to visit a friend and this is where she wanted to go, she was the driver, so off we went! The menu offers tons of good choices. The lunch special comes with a salad and coffee or tea, so I had a good time! I chose the salad with sliced almonds and feta cheese. They give you a plate of manzanilla olives and cubes of feta cheese, and slices of garlic bread, for the table, too! After my salad, I had the snapper livornese - ample sliced olives with capers, in a decent tomato sauce. It's a good filet of fish served over slivered carrots and fresh, crisp green beans! All that for about $16., more than reasonable for the quality and quantity of the food. My friend had a salad with Caesar dressing, I think, and a filet of snapper also - hers had a half peach on top and I forget what else, came with a scoop of rice. We "had to" share a decadent dessert! The waiter brought out the tray of possibilities. We ultimately had the chocolate chip molten chocolate lava cake, the size of a large muffin with the melted chocolate inside, served with a small scoop of vanilla ice cream. We had a large, tasty, satisfying meal for about $55, tax & tip included. These days, that's a good deal! To top it off, my friend had a 15% off coupon, so we spent even less! Definitely a great place for lunch; there were several large groups of what looked to me like retired colleagues. Pleasant ambiance, pleasant service. Go! read more

My first time was awesome. Staff was great. Food was so delicious. Will be back. Ambiance was cozy. The line out the door says everything you need to know. Don't miss out. read more

I was was not expecting much but I must say the food. The prices in the service was great. I would definitely go back another time. It certainly a great bang for the buck and worth the calories.! read more

Limoncello is a very charming restaurant that makes you feel like you're in Italy. The building and decorations are splendid, and the art displayed is actually from Italy. The servers are super friendly and hospitable. We ordered one dish to share simply because the portion was too big, but the server gave us two full dishes instead. Consequently, we had no room for dessert and had leftovers to take home. The dish was so delicious that I couldn't stop eating, which left no room for dessert. read more

Food is AMAZING! Service is impeccable!!! Wonderful place!! I was celebrating my birthday, and had 11people, including two little ones, for dinner. They set us up in a quiet area, a wonderful place where everyone enjoyed very minute, including parents of young ones. The calamari is incredible, the fish dishes, EXCELLENT, pasta is perfect, desserts to die for! This is truly a wonderful place to enjoy either friends and family, or just a quiet dinner for two! read more

Decent strip mall type of Joint, which is fine for an nice Italian meal. Prices were appropriate Nd the service was very good read more

As always, great service good food. I recommend the crispy duck, if you like dark meat, it's my favorite. What makes the restaurant better is BYOB, so don't forget your bottle of wine. Plenty of parking read more

Limoncello Ristorante - Duck - Italian Near Me - Waldwick, New Jersey

Great meal. Pasta fragioly delicious, Chicken Parmesan is best i ever ate. It just melts in your mouth. Top notch service. The best.

From the little corner of a strip mall in Waldwick, Limoncello was an incredible find on Open Table. Named after the classic Italian liqueur with a unique unmistakable lemon flavor and opened for 10 years, this establishment is a small casual BYOB restaurant. From the beginning, my partner, our friends and I were impressed by the hospitality of this family owned restaurant of two brothers (Remy and Jimmy) functioning as both host and server and decided to have dinner tonight. Reservation is highly suggested as the place was packed upon arrival. The menu has many traditional Italian dishes. Complimentary garlic bread, warm loaf and salad started our meal. As appetizers, we got Brie Cheese in a phyllo dough fresh fruit honey cranberry glaze and Calamari with sesame ginger sauce. For entrees, Pollo Calabrese (breast topped gorgonzola, wild mushrooms and red wine), Rigatoni Vodka in pink sauce, Rigatoni Angello with sweet sausage peas mushrooms pink sauce, Stuffed Rigatoni consisting four cheese vodka pink sauce and Homemade Cheese Manicotti with Bolognese meat sauce and spinach. The food was fresh, well seasoned, delicious and the portions generous. Some of us had room for dessert and got the limoncello cake and lime mousse pie. The staff including one of the owner's son Danny was very friendly and provided great service. They were attentive but certainly not intrusive. The restaurant appears to be very clean with comfortable table seating and tablecloths. Our first visit to Limoncello will not be our last as we can recommend this place. read more

See all

I ordered the crab cakes. The menu states that they are Pan Fried. They were deep fried, a very big difference . They also were full of fillers vs actual crab meat . Please do not advertise the way something is prepared and then totally prepare it another way . read more

My wife and I have been to this gem of a restaurant several times in the past few years. They deserve a 5 star review. The hospitality with excellent service along with great appetizers and entrees for a byob restaurant make this special place in Waldwick a must for dinner when u have a chance. I highly recommend this friendly fair priced establishment. read more