One Twenty Three Burger House was exactly the kind of lunch spot we were hoping for. Everything…read morejust hit right. I ordered the fish burger and it honestly surprised me in the best way it was way better than I expected. My partner went with the regular burger and loved it too. I also have to mention the banana pudding because it was AMAZING. Easily the best I've had so far, and I'm not even exaggerating. The service really stood out as well. Our waitress went above and beyond to help me figure out what the veggie burger was made of and even looked into the company that makes it since I'm picky about veggie burgers. That level of care doesn't go unnoticed. We dined outside and although noisy from the traffic, it was nice. Overall, such a great experience. They really have something for everyone. Definitely recommend checking it out and don't skip the banana pudding.

First: I paid extra to upgrade to a 1/2lbs from a 1/3lbs. When the burgers arrived, my patty was…read morenoticeably smaller than both my wife and daughter's burger. I asked the server about it and she just told me that it was a 1/2. In an effort to not make a big deal about it, my daughter jumped right in and offered to switch patties with me since she wasn't that hungry. It was immediately obvious that I had a smaller patty since the new one filled the croissant. Second: I asked to substitute the burger buns for the croissant buns they have on a different burger. I was surprised to see the bill showing a $2.50 up charge despite the burgers costing around the same amount and buns being needed anyway + no mention of any up-charge! Third: Our party included two adults + three children + a toddler + an infant. Somehow that warranted an automatic gratuity. We're normally generous tippers but it didn't feel right to have an amount pushed on us without disclosure. We would have tipped anyway despite the servers obvious fake smile and negative demeanor but this just added to the overall poor experience. Our family has no issue paying 25%, or more if service is exceptional, on $600 bills (often at steak houses more-so than regular restaurants) but I walked away feeling cheated here.

Cool spot. Great food…read more Our server got seated the entire upper floor for herself at same time which took away from service a bit. The musician was awesome Bartender was one of best I've had anywhere. Would definitely go here, worth the wait

The atmosphere is perfection. We expected the food to be better, but unfortunately it was just ok…read more My fried chicken sandwich was the star of our lunch, but it was only a B. My husband's burger, ordered a medium rare, was well done. We didn't see a server for a while after we received our food, so he just ate it. The $4 up charge for sweet potato tots is so not worth a dime. They were inedible, but our server didn't ask how ANYTHING was so there wasn't any opportunity to change, send back etc. My fries were piping hot and tasted good for about five minutes until they cooled. After that, they were very mealy...you know how those taste. So very disappointed after hearing good things about this place. We won't be back here. Plenty of other places to eat in SA. Restaurants are crying the blues about costs, but don't seem to care much about quality any longer. I don't know about you, but until these establishments can show me they care about customers and quality, I'm going to be cautious about spending my money on a lunch costing $70. You?

If you're in St. Augustine, do yourself a favor and check out Treylor Park!…read more We grabbed seats at the bar and immediately loved the vibe--super friendly atmosphere, really clean, and a menu that's anything but boring. One of the coolest touches? A TV disguised as a piece of art that's actually a live stream of downtown St. Augustine. Such a fun, unique detail! Now let's talk food I ordered the shrimp and grits tacos, and WOW--they were packed with flavor. The grits added this unexpected crunch that worked so well with the shrimp. The textures blended perfectly and made every bite interesting. My husband went for the Miyagi beef tacos... and let's just say there were zero leftovers. He cleaned his plate, which says everything. Great vibes, creative food, and a memorable experience all around. Definitely a spot we'll be coming back to!

Treylor Park was such a fun find in St. Augustine! The vibe alone makes it worth the visit--think…read morequirky, creative décor with an RV-inspired interior that gives it a laid-back, offbeat charm. It got pretty busy while we were there, but impressively, they were running with just one server--and he absolutely held it down. Despite the crowd, he stayed attentive, friendly, and kept everything moving smoothly, which really stood out. The menu is where things get especially interesting--unique, playful, and definitely not your standard fare. I tried the chicken apple pie sandwich, which was as unexpected as it sounds. It was fun, different, and surprisingly good! It is one of those dishes you won't find just anywhere. Husband loved his upscale bologna sandwich and the waffle fries were yummy! Overall, Treylor Park delivers on atmosphere and creativity. It's a great spot if you're looking for something a little outside the box with a fun, energetic vibe and memorable food.

I wanted to try BR and sample the lamb burger. I heard it was good. It was GREAT! Service,…read moreportions, prices, and the fresh quality along with thoughtful components on each plate made it a wonderful experience. Thank you!

Great place for lunch or dinner. Kitchen open until 12:30 and closes at 2am. No bad or ugly here…read more Been here twice and happy to go back. Food is very good and healthy sized portions. Had the lamb burger the first time, which was great. This time I had the yummy shaved beef toastie, with sauteed onions and mushrooms, came with good fries and coleslaw I enjoyed. Son had the shaved beef mac and cheese both times with sangria. Since we happened to be there during happy hour we had the $5 sangria and the $4 Tullamore DEW whiskey sour. Everything was very good and our waiter waa great, especially for being short staffed that particular day. Waiter was super helpful as hubby ordered the double smash burger and the waiter poibted out the HH special would net him 2 regular burgers for less. Place is a block parallel to St George and cozy comfortable. Looking forward to going back already.

While walking the downtown area- we saw this place with outside seating which we expected for the…read morepooch in our party. But it was drizzly and the gal at the door assured us they were "very pet friendly" so we were able to sit inside with the husky girl. The menu had a vegan burger right up my alley- no beyond beef here- there were peas coming out of the patty. He got wings which are his soul food. The beer was good, the food perfect ... I will be back, saving this to my St Augustine, pup friendly, favorites.

Came here for lunch on a Saturday. There was no wait. We got to sit down and you order your food at…read morethe counter and it is brought to your table. The service was fine, there wasn't much interaction with staff. They did keep the place clean though. We did feel like the prices were very high for burgers. While the cowboy burger was VERY good, the surf and turf burger was plain and basic.

Food and service was excellent! I had the fried green tomato sandwich and it was all I could have…read morehoped for. Bloody Mary was delicious!! (I got the spicy) And the house dressing for the salad is excellent.

This place was nice. I heard a lot of good things. I was excited for the 'N GRITS with shrimp, but…read morethe temperature was off. The shrimp was overcooked and rubbery. The grits were room temperature, when I expected them to be hot. The pork tenderloin was our other dish. The mashed potatoes were amazing! I have never had crispy spinach, quite reminiscent of seaweed. I could eat a bowl of them. The AUTUMN PORK TENDERLOIN was cooked well and very tasty. The Coquito Daydreamin' cocktail was yummy. Our server was very nice and attentive.

This by far was the best meal I had this trip! Everything…read moreabout this restaurant is 1st class. The staff is amazing and the craft drinks are great Even the homemade soda my daughter got was incredible. The salad was a work of art! And was amazing. The burger was cooked perfectly. Very cool restaurant and I will definitely be going back.

The ice plant was so good that we ate there two days in a row…read more We had the blue crab beignets BOTH days, they were heavenly pillows of goodness, and they were not skimpy with the blue crab. Also loved the fried chicken and hoecakes. Amazing. The drinks had a bit of variation between bartenders. They were all good though, so no complaints. It's a little bit outside of the "party" area of town but still walkable and completely worth it!! We ate at quite a few places and this was the stand out.

The Philly cheese steak sandwich is AWESOME!!!! There are lots of arcade games and tables for large…read moreparties - we were a family of 8. The service was quick and friendly. Most of us had the cheese steak but the others who had the hamburger and ham sub equally enjoyed them. The best part - we took home cheese steaks to enjoy the next day and they were delicious.

Not gonna lie.... for the amount of times it have been in St Augustine it took me way too long to…read morefinally make it to South-A-Philly. First off love the spot it's simple and for a good Cheesesteak that's all you need. Of course they had Herr's so we got 2 bags. Went with 3 Cheesesteaks, 2 Wiz Wit (Cheese Wiz & Onion) and 1 White America with Onions. If you're asking well what Herr's did you get it was 2 bags of the Jalapeno Poppers Cheese Curls. They are the best Cheese Puff on the market. So the Cheesesteak, for sure in the top of the 904 area. My go to was the Wiz Wit and this was fulling packed. Tons of steak and plenty of wiz. Everyone knows there is nothing worse then a dry cheesesteak. Bread was soft, onions caramelized and on the bigger side for sure. It's for sure a very finely chopped steak. I can see us coming back and enjoying again.

Place was packed we had 5 people saw a table open and grabbed it - had a snide remark by…read morebartender/waitress because table wasn't cleaned yet, we told her we had 3 more people and 3 times she insisted we give her a drink order - then the rest of the party shows up and she never comes back to the table we took the 2 beers that she made us order left them on the bar untouched and walked out! Don't get nasty with your customers bad business

When we arrived at St. George Tavern it was packed. We got lucky as when we got there one of the…read moretables opened up so we ran to grab it. The server kindly requested we wait while she buses/cleans the table. It seemed like that server (Heather, I think?) was the busser, server, and bartender for the whole restaurant. I saw only one other person working there, which I believe was the cook. With a packed restaurant, Heather was still able to provide us good service. Unfortunately, the place needs a deep cleaning as exhibited by the insanely dusty chandelier pictured. My burger was pretty good, but the queso con carne was essentially super-greasy chili with cheese on top. There are plenty of other bars/restaurants to choose from, this one wasn't it for me.

Visiting from Charleston and this restaurant was absolutely fantastic. We sat at the bar and the…read moretwo lovely bartenders were amazing and so friendly. Ordered a n/a little prayer and the Piña Colada and they were so yummy. Not pictured are the eggs rolls that we absolutely devoured. Would absolutely recommend to anyone visiting and it is off king street so not very touristy!

We went to Forgotten Tonic for din and has the best time. It's edgy and great for a girls…read morenight/casual date night. The food was SO GOOD and filling that wasn't too pricey. The arancini, meatballs, and pasta alla vodka hit the spot. We will definitely be back when visiting St Aug again.