Solid 4 with Buckeye Barn. Don't come for me Popeyes lovers, I love it too; that being said, Buckeye Barn has fantastic fried chicken. Best in town, so far. And the hot pepper cheese bites hold their own. Decent, nothing remarkable, Cole slaw. One problem, they put the cold with hot. And warm Cole slaw doesn't do it for me. Maybe you love it, what do I care? Baked beans came cold, maybe that's a fluke or maybe they always come cold. Either way, I won't be ordering them again. And they ALWAYS forget the rolls, which is fine taste-wise, but the miser in me gets pissy about paying for something and it doesn't come. The chicken makes up for it. And I'm telling you now, skip the slice of Buckeye Pie at, like $4, I took a pic of the slice I bought to try and used a Hersheys size as a size guide. You get my drift? This is not a negative review, friends! I think it's a great restaurant! Seriously, we order from it all the time. Try the dang chicken! read more

Buckeye Barn - Hot pepper cheese bites. And burnt fries thrown in for FREE! Don't be jealous! - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Ohio

See all

Maybe not a topping famine on my pizza. This was not our first pizza from here either; just the first bad experience. read more

Buckeye Barn - This is the box with Deluxe lg pizza -mushrooms. - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Ohio

See all

I drove by this place dozens of times before deciding to try it. It's much nicer that expected of a "barn" restaurant. The dining room and bathrooms are clean and well kept. The service wasn't terribly quick, but I did come in right after a large group of senior hotties. Service was polite, smart and friendly. I had the 4pc wings with coleslaw and potatoe salad. The chicken was cooked perfectly and the wings were good sized (not like the BW3 disappointment wings). The breading was light and golden as advertised. The sides were excellent too. Pleasantly surprised by everything, and the pricing was very reasonable, too. read more

I have been going here through 5 different owners and each one changed things a little bit each time. The newest owner has proven to me many times that he doesn't care about the customers (unless you are a family friend). They can't make a well done pizza and definitely can't cut it either. If you go in the evening after work service is worse. I will not be going back any more and CAN NOT recommend. read more

it's supposed to be a pizza not soup. WAY too much sauce. pizza is chewed not drank. had to enjoy something that is spilling all over the place and is a soggy mess. figure out a method of measuring the proper amount of sauce and stop guessing. it makes for a bad experience and people won't come back. read more

Haven't eaten here more than a couple of times but we've never had bad service or bad food! People working are friendly and accommodating. The atmosphere is ok, it's definitely intended to be casual, bring kids/grandkids without a problem. Definitely need to return and try some different food on their menu! read more

Great fried chicken, fresh and very tasty. Good burgers food was good. Friendly staff. Pizza was good too! read more

I trusted Yelp once again for food recommendations in the Springfield area. It didn't disappoint! This place has the best taco pizza! You order at the counter, not a big deal though. We'll go back. read more

Buckeye Barn - a wooden planked wall decorated with beads and bows - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Ohio

See all

They bake a great pizza. Haven't done much besides carry out but the quality has always been good

Chicken is AMAZING! Pizza and onion rings were a huge hit as well. Staff was very friendly and welcoming.

This place used to make excellent pizza, but it doesn't any longer. The pizza I got the crust was overcooked and it was pretty much in edible. I won't be back. read more

Great pizza! Service is OK - if they are not too busy!! Nice little seating area - in a way, kind of intimate. NICE !!!

The food is amazing, no matter what you order, service is awesome and I love the atmosphere! I recommend everyone to enjoy this place

Terrible food. We ordered a large pizza and it was awful. Bland, cheese slipped off was very hard to eat. Raw in middle. Wait staff were young kids who didn't care. No refills on drinks. Just bad all around . We wont go back or refer anyone read more

Very cool place. In a world full of cut and paste chains that are identical from one place to another, this is a unique local flair place. The people were very friendly, the pizza was quite good and had a unique personality. Appetizers were pretty good too. nice atmosphere was real authenticity. read more

We tried the Buckeye Barn out originally for pizza. When we got there, we separated into ordering different entrees. A) we didnt know, and it wasnt well signed, to order at the counter. So we sat and waited and eventually the manager came over and took our order. He then explained that people ordered at the counter. B)getting refills was slow. C) the kids ordered fried chicken, I ordered the Italian Sub, and my wife ordered the Loaded Potato Pizza app. D) the food was okay. The chicken was thoroughly cooked and hot. The Loaded Potato pizza had a lot of onion on it, and it overpowered the rest of the flavors. My "Italian" sub was sliced processed ham and another meat, marinara and cheese, heated. No lettuce or condiments. A large let down to be honest. The staff is nice, I just wife the food was a bit better quality. read more

The buckeye barn is excellent good food nice people I have pizza chicken and sub sandwiches all was good will definitely go again when I'm back in town read more

Love this place food is great. Staff is always friendly. The 6 year old in my life loves it and requests it. Pizza is very good top 5 in springfield. Very kid friendly. read more

Great pizza, crispy wings, solid prices. With some original styles and a monster of a meat lovers pizza it's a great bargain and plenty of bang for your buck. Eat in or pick up it's the same every time. If you give it a try in the summer time, make sure to get the strawberry pie! read more

Why would you cut a pizza into 30 tiny squares? If you have any sauce or toppings, you are going to need to wash your hands after eating. Huge fail. It also prevents you from getting the nice balance of crust and toppings. Pizza should be sliced into triangles, unless it's a party pizza. I would rate the crust quality as slightly above frozen pizza. Would not order again from here. Also dining room was closed an hour before advertised hours. read more

Best pie ever!!!! We go every year for the fresh strawberry pie (it's amazing) and ran out right before Thanksgiving and came home with two "Buckeye" pies. Mmmmmm! Oh, and there is a drive up window. Drive thru pie - don't even need to get out of the car! read more

I would like to give a special Thanks to Phil and his team for putting together meals for our staff during COVID 19 . The food was amazing we will defiantly being using the Buckeye Barn for more staff events. Thank You From The Fox Run Senior Living Team read more

Great people, great pizza, great atmosphere. My family and I got the loaded potato pizza. One word: Amazing! I would definitely suggest green onions in place of the white onion, either way, we were impressed. The staff was welcoming and personable. I come here at least once during my trips and won't be stopping anytime soon. read more

Have been there several times. Sometimes the service is good. Sometimes the service is lacking. I can say although descent flavors and tastes, but it is very obvious to the customer that you will receive the very bare minimum of what's required for any thing that's made there. I order a large sausage pizza, I get 9 tiny pieces of sausage. 9. It's like that with all their made products. I may have to stay away from there for a while. Update. They zinged me again. I will not return without compensation read more

So glad to see this place back in business, albeit under new ownership. This is some of the best pizza in the area. I was visiting for Thanksgiving and we got a pepperoni pizza and a sausage, green pepper, mushroom pizza. I wish there was more sausage since I am a meat guy. The squares are great, the little pepperonis are perfectly crisped. Nom, nom, nom. read more

Great pizza! Great service, good booze selection. If I could give it more than 5 stars I would. Would highly recommend this place to any and everyone! read more

My husband and I went to Buckeye Barn a couple years ago but stopped at the door because there was a rude sign in the window announcing the owner's politics. We don't like to ruin our meals with political angst, so we turned around and ate elsewhere. This past week we went again and the sign was gone, so we went in. We ordered a pizza, a sub and chicken. The chicken was good, crispy, the way we like it. The sub was way too salty and the bread was very soggy. The pizza was ok, but bland sauce, very skimpy toppings, little cheese and the crust was almost raw. I like a little garlic and oregano in the sauce. The prices were about average for the area. It's like other family restaurants in the area, midwestern food that's meant to fill you up without being nutritious or delicious. We won't be in a hurry to go back, but if it's the only place available, we'd eat there. The good thing about it is that the dining room was nearly empty when we were there, so it wasn't noisy. read more

Great food! Good service....the best pizza on North side. Better than Donatos hands down.

Pizza was solid. Don't expect anything fancy but definitely good. The dining room closed earlier than we thought.

Ok, I have not been here in years even though I live close by. I had heard it recently had changed owners and had received some coupons in the mail for their chicken. I love good chicken so decided to try it. First of all, they had pretty much gutted and redid the whole interior and it looked MUCH better!! I peeked into the restaurant side and loved the Ohio State decor. It wasn't in your face OSU but tastfully done. I ordered chicken, potato wedges, and coleslaw from a very friendly lady. I then proceeded to look around while the hot stuff was made fresh on the spot (nice!!). They have a wide selection of wines, beer, alcohol, snacks and even have a deli! In the deli case and saw a to die for rich looking Buckeye pie...had to get that of course! Ok...in short, the chicken was tasty and juicy, coleslaw sweet like I like, yummy potato wedges ( came with sour cream too), and the Buckeye pie??? OMG!!! So good! I will be back. Period. read more

Italian subs are fantastic. Great pizza, service and prices. Highly recommend.