I believe that this is the best pizza in town. I've had Mikey's 5 times now since moving here and the crust is thin, crispy, and you can tell it's top notch all the way. They use "old world" pepperoni, which is smaller, but curls up and is so much more flavorful and crunchy than normal pepperoni used by the bigger chains. Also, their bacon bits are thick cut, and pack so much flavor. Wish they had chopped garlic, but they constantly say they don't have it....despite that it's on their menu. It's a small gripe, but I like garlic on my pizza. I have not tried any other main menu items so cannot comment on them. Will say I did have a bit of their cheesy bread and it was not good at all. I'm still giving this place 5 stars because the pizza is the STAR of this restaurant and it delivers strongly. If you haven't had this place, you are missing out!!!!! read more

We were working and then driving all day so picking up pizza was dinner move. I checked some of the pictures and the pizza looked good so I ordered two pizzas and cheesy bread. The guy who answered said to give them 20-25 minutes and when I got there it was ready. The pizza was even better than it looked and we were all in agreement on that. The cheesy bread didn't look like what I had in mind but it was delicious too. I had to make myself stop eating and save some for breakfast in the morning. This spot is kinda out of the way, a hidden gem if you will, and is a hole in the wall but I would definitely order from Mikey's again. read more

See all

Most amazing crust! Somehow it crispy and chewy at the same time. Very friendly staff! Lots of locals and regulars. Highly recommend! Mostly for pick-up but there are 2 tables for dine in. read more

Some of the best pizza I've ever had...the food is top tier. The service is so sweet, we dined in and they checked in with us twice. read more

Mikey's Pizza - Chicken bacon ranch - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Ohio

See all

Fast, friendly and delicious is a great combination! Eight of us stopped in on a whim and took over their two tables. We devoured one pepperoni and one veggie pizza. Nobody had ever been there before, and everybody was very satisfied. High marks for crunchy crust, tangy sauce and quality ingredients. read more

My go to spot for pizza even though it's a drive for me. Reminds me of the pizza we'd get when we were kids. The interior space could benefit from an hour's wort of organizing and light cleaning. I love the thin crust and the way they bake it just to the point before it burns. Delicious! read more

Excellent pizza, we ordered for takeout and thoroughly enjoyed it at home. Definitely step above regular delivery pizzas.

Doesn't look like much if you drive by, BUT IT IS AWESOME. Take out order and the pizza was still hot, crust still crispy and perfect ratio of sauce and cheese. The toppings we get on half the pizza were awesome and didn't skimp on anything. Don't listen to the low star reviews...they're picky and silly. OH and the service? 7 stars if that's even possible. Such nice people with an awesome product. YUM. Oh and we're from NYC...so I promise our opinion isn't skewed. And the slices are small which makes it perfect for adults AND kids (if you're looking for family friendly meals!). THANKS MIKEY YOU ROCK! read more

Mikey's Pizza - Half cheese half bacon, pepperoni, ham, and pizza peppers! - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Ohio

We love Mikey's pizza and they are always the friendliest! Will probably ask for extra cheese next time though! read more

We got Mikey's tonight. Tried to call but the line was busy, so I drove over. Mikey, the owner was working, he apologized and said they were very busy. I made my order and told him I would wait, he offered me a free drink, but I said, it's ok I was thinking about getting a pop and could pay. We got the BRC, pep/mushroom/extra cheese, garlic wings, and cheesy bread. The pizza and wings are great, love the crust, see my previous review. read more

Best ZA in Springfield!! We have tried all the "good pizza" places in town. Our son asked to try out Mikey's after returning from a late trip. We for the EZBreazy, a cheese pie and a pepperoni pie. Damn. What great pizza. Excellent crust, great amounts of toppings, and cooked to perfection. Skip the chains. Skip the inn's, barns and whoever else claims to be the best. Go to Mikey's and get the best!! read more

This is my 2nd visit. The first time my daughter and I ate in, this time I took food home. Ordered subs, all Italian but two had variations of holding onions, ham, etc. They were all good and I had no complaints. Pizza was good, a little on the greasy side but comparable to Cassanos thin crust, yet not as salty( which is a good thing in my opinion). Overall, good food, reasonably priced, unfortunately for them, not crowded, but it was a Monday evening so that maybe why. read more

This is the best pizza in Springfield and I've tried them all. The pizza crust and sauce are excellent along with the toppings.

The owner coordinated a large pizza order with me when my school's team was visiting a nearby school. This is an awesome pizza place with great service. You can't go wrong getting pizza here! read more

Mikey's Pizza is our favorite pizza place outside of St Louis. We are truck drivers and we have the best pizza in St Louis, Mikey's is a close second for us. Read the reviews and looked at the pictures and decided this was a place we wanted to check out. Bobtailed down and found a parking lot big enough for our truck (no trailer). Called first to make sure. Place was quiet on a Tuesday evening and we were waited on shortly after we sat down to look at the menus. We were pretty sure already what we wanted to try so ordered our food and drinks at the same time. Service was great, prompt and efficient. My husband ordered a salad and when it came we were surprised at the size of it. Dinner plate size. We each ordered a 12 inch pizza since we like different toppings and also ordered the cheesy bread with the meal not as appetizer. We also wanted leftovers to take back to the terminal for later and/or breakfast. Pizza and cheesy bread arrived all at the same time as requested and all of it was HOT and FRESH. Cheesy bread with garlic parmesan dipping sauce was great. Pizzas were loaded with toppings as close to the edge as possible. Both were delicious. Mikey was there and we told him about our place in St Louis and told him his place was a very close second for us for pizza across the country so far. We will definitely come back the next time we get to Springfield! Thank you guys for a great meal and great leftovers! Loved it! read more

Mikey's Pizza - Ham and pineapple with extra cheese on top. - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Ohio

Well I do have to say this was a very good pizza, being from Chicago I'm always on the lookout for good thin crust pizza. There were only two things that would make this pizza a number one, first they need to not use such a tomato flavored sauce is a little too acidic it needs to be a little more robust, the other thing is they need to have larger chunks of sausage, sausage is meant to be in chunks not ground up in small pieces. Other than that it was very good the pepperoni was god the onion and green pepper were done just right love the way they cut it in squares, my family and I loved it cut that way. So I say keep up the good job. Thanks for a good pizza. read more

Ok, this pizza joint is AMAZING! Indoor dining area isn't huge, but it is nicely done and well kept. Tables were large, which is great when you're loading it up with delicious pizzas. Pepsi on tap... Yay! We ordered a Cheesy Twist appetizer: 4 large breadsticks with mozzarella cheese inside. They were fabulous. You get to pick a dipping sauce. Unfortunately, they were out of cheese sauce. Their pizza sauce was unique and delicious. Our pizzas came out quickly, and still quite hot. We over-ordered so that we would be able to take home extra. Not a single regret. My kiddo ordered a regular pepperoni and cheese with bacon. It was perfect. read more

Great pizza & great customer service! I strongly recommend especially if you want something different than the regular pizza places Springfield has. read more

Mikey's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Ohio

What are you doing for dinner tonight? You're going to order Mikey's pizza. Go ahead. Call them now. I'll wait. Ok, first of all, who would have guessed that this is a good location for a pizza place? Happy neighbors in the neighborhood are happy once again. Enough of that. Mikey's is awesome! Crackery, thin crust pizza, cut into squares, cornmeal on the bottom. The crust is unique. It has a great texture and the inner squares support the toppings no problem. The cheese is also really good. My pie came out GBD, Golden, Brown, Delicious, just like the pizza I would make at home if I lived in a pizza restaurant. Mikey's is on point. The interior looks great. The renovations were done by the owner. This is not a franchise, it came from the brains and effort of one of your neighbors. Local pizza shop now open on Harding Rd. What else do I need to say? Go get it. Five stars. read more

See all

You can make good pizza but people still like friendly service, limited hours and limited staff.

Awesome pizza and cheesy bread! This pizza was perfect in every way. Cooked perfectly, topping crust to crust, perfect amount of salt and plenty of cheese. Crust crisp and golden brown and soft and fluffy inside. A perfect compromise between thin and deep dish crust. We absolutely enjoyed this place. Customer service was incredible and friendly. Thank you for the great lunch experience! read more

We travel from Bellefontaine , home of the Fahrenheit 600 pizza to get a Mikey's pizza. I have type 2 sugar and their sauce in not hard on me, best pizza around. read more

The service is terrible. Very rude when we called and when we went to pick up our order. The inside looked almost run down. They also put the wrong name on our order (sammie instead of Samantha) They also got our order very wrong and told us it'd be an hour and a half wait plus to get the correct one because they had other customers waiting. read more

Worst service in town. Every other time I try to order a pizza, it's either an unacceptable wait time or they won't answer the phone or they just say they can't take my order. When I expressed my disappointment, he started yelling at me! They are rude, and if you go in, you will find it not to be the cleanest. Don't know how they stay in business. Don't take your bad day out on the customers! Sad thing is, I do like their pizza. Not at that price though. read more

Tonight was our first time having Mike's Pizza! We ate in, but noticed we were the only ones that did that. Most were pick up. The dining room was chilly, the outside temp was warmer, 64. It was very clean though! Our pizza was very good. Crispy crust and lots of delicious toppings, edge to edge! Staff was professional and friendly! Will get again! read more

Mikey's Pizza - We got cheese, pepperoni, half mushrooms, half green olives. - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Ohio

Just tried this place for the first time since it changed hands and became Mikey's. Got pizza only and got it to go. The pizza was very good, it's a thin crispy crust and was browned cheese with old world pepperoni (which is spicy but greasy). I did notice that if you dine in their fountain drinks were out of order and they had a coke machine so that you could buy cans. read more

Not very good pizza. They did not put an ingredient I ordered on the pizza and I didn't realize this until I got home. The people who work there also look very confused and aren't very friendly when you're there. The pizza had so much cornstarch falling off the bottom of the crust, which I did not care for. I won't return. I tried it and didn't care for it. read more

Nice thin crust pizza. The crust was crispy and it's cut into squares but I don't mind that. Nice and heavy on the toppings. The staff was friendly and if I were in the area and looking for pizza I wouldn't hesitate to hit them up again. read more

We saw the write up in the Springfield News Sun, followed the Yelp brick road and landed at a GREAT local pizza place! For me, the review that claimed the center crust remained crispy, no matter the toppings, was all the bait i needed. And it is SO TRUE! The meat explosion was incredible and that crust was perfect. Whatever magical sorcery they have going on in that kitchen has won two customers who appreciate local food and business. The restaurant is true Buckeye and the staff friendly and knowledgeable. Good luck on many years of growth and success! read more

Mikey's Pizza - Yum. Unbelievable yum. And more yum! - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Ohio

One of my favorite pizza places in Springfield!! Crust is crispy and baked to perfection! Has a Authentic Italian taste and the ingredients are huge ! tray it yourself read more

I am on the road for work and this was great pizza a short drive past all the run of the mill fast food chain restaurants. The price is excellent and Mikey himself is making the pizza!! read more

Mikey's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Ohio

See all

Called in order for pick up...first time ever trying mikeys...was ready when i got there ...smelled great...place looks nice Smelled great but was in a hurry...didnt check it...we always get pep mushroom and cheese with a side of wings....got home to find a pep pizza...no mushrooms and hardly any cheese...also was very salty...other than that it was ok...the wing order was right but slimey...not our favorite....called to let them know and they took care of it to my satisfaction....thanks for that read more

We we're from out of town and visited for dinner. The restaurant was empty as we chose to dine in which made us nervous but it ended up great. The service was attentive (I mean we were the only ones). The pizza came out hot with a crisp crust. A little on the greasy side but ya know, it's pizza. If we're over back we'll definitely visit again. read more

Mikey's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Ohio

See all

The Fat Jackie and Cheeseburger pizza were awesome! The decor is Scarlett and Grey, just like any respectable Ohio restaurant. Our server, Hunter, was friendly and dreamy. I imagine he probably saved a litter of kittens before his shift at work.:-) read more

Mikey's Pizza - The Fat Jackie and The Cheeseburger pizza were awesome!! They came out piping hot by our hunky server, Hunter! - Pizza Near Me - Springfield, Ohio

It's Christmas Eve and you're in from out of town and you realize you made no plans for dinner! Options were slim until we decided to take a chance and call Mikey's. It was 7:45 pm and someone answers the phone at Mikey's and kindly let us know that he was planning on closing at 8pm. Sensing the "bummer" in my tone, he quickly said, "but I can stay open a little longer if you need me to!" YES, we definitely needed him to. We placed our order and went to pick it up in 15 minutes. Thanks to Mikey's for saving the day on Christmas Eve. The Nana's Garden and Fat Jackie were killer! And special thanks for the Sausage and Pepperoni extra cherry on top :) MERRY CHRISTMAS MIKEY'S! read more

Low-key spot with awesome pizza! Owner/chef checks on everyone to make sure they had an awesome experience. Great tasting toppings, REAL cheese and crispy crust! Perfect combination!!! read more

Stopped here based on a Yelp recommendation. Was not disappointed. Pizza was delicious with crispy crust and ample toppings. Price for salad, pizza, iced tea very reasonable. Would definitely return! read more

I like your pizza but I'm tired of calling and get no answer when you are open. This has happen a number of time. So I give you pizza a 4 but a 1 for service by phone. read more

Nice pizza. This crispy crust was just right. Cheese to the edge. Pepperoni were little cups of love holding just a little grease. Across town but I can see myself eating here weekly. No fountain drinks but cans are a buck, and they are generous with a big glass of ice. read more

Mikey's pizza has great flavor. Love the thin crust. The hamburger specialty pizza is unique and flavorful. Try it if you're looking for something different. read more