I believe that this is the best pizza in town. I've had Mikey's 5 times now since moving here and…read morethe crust is thin, crispy, and you can tell it's top notch all the way. They use "old world" pepperoni, which is smaller, but curls up and is so much more flavorful and crunchy than normal pepperoni used by the bigger chains. Also, their bacon bits are thick cut, and pack so much flavor. Wish they had chopped garlic, but they constantly say they don't have it....despite that it's on their menu. It's a small gripe, but I like garlic on my pizza. I have not tried any other main menu items so cannot comment on them. Will say I did have a bit of their cheesy bread and it was not good at all. I'm still giving this place 5 stars because the pizza is the STAR of this restaurant and it delivers strongly. If you haven't had this place, you are missing out!!!!!

We were working and then driving all day so picking up pizza was dinner move. I checked some of…read morethe pictures and the pizza looked good so I ordered two pizzas and cheesy bread. The guy who answered said to give them 20-25 minutes and when I got there it was ready. The pizza was even better than it looked and we were all in agreement on that. The cheesy bread didn't look like what I had in mind but it was delicious too. I had to make myself stop eating and save some for breakfast in the morning. This spot is kinda out of the way, a hidden gem if you will, and is a hole in the wall but I would definitely order from Mikey's again.

I drove by this place dozens of times before deciding to try it. It's much nicer that expected of…read morea "barn" restaurant. The dining room and bathrooms are clean and well kept. The service wasn't terribly quick, but I did come in right after a large group of senior hotties. Service was polite, smart and friendly. I had the 4pc wings with coleslaw and potatoe salad. The chicken was cooked perfectly and the wings were good sized (not like the BW3 disappointment wings). The breading was light and golden as advertised. The sides were excellent too. Pleasantly surprised by everything, and the pricing was very reasonable, too.

it's supposed to be a pizza not soup. WAY too much sauce. pizza is chewed not drank. had to enjoy…read moresomething that is spilling all over the place and is a soggy mess. figure out a method of measuring the proper amount of sauce and stop guessing. it makes for a bad experience and people won't come back.

Ordered a small pepperoni pizza, a meatball sub, a grinder and a slice of lemon blueberry cake…read morewith mascarpone! Every single thing was delicious!! We went at opening and it got busy fast!!! We are 45 minutes away and will be back!!!

Ohio Judo & Jujitsu Academy this is our number one pizza & sub shop for all our special events…read moreWe call ahead for our order and everything is ready right on time when we get their to pickup our order. Bill

This is a liquor store that also has a pizza oven. The pizza is a 6.5 bar style pizza. Better than…read moreyour usual carryout chain pizza. They use lots of sauce and cheese on their pizzas. No need to ask for extra. Pick up only no seating.

Pizza is one of the best in town. Highly recommend. Consistently excellent. Never had a bad…read moremeal here.

The pizza was great. I haven't tasted pizza like it since I left NYC. the owner was very…read morepersonable.

Hands down, the best pizza around! Consistently outstanding quality and superb taste.read more

Went to Ohio for the first time and got cassanos twice in 4 days so if that doesn't say how delish…read moreit is idk what does. The crispy crust with the sauce makes the perfect pair. The cute little shapes they cut the pizza into makes it fun. I'm just mad I waited so long to go to Ohio now!!!!

Don't get to get this that often being from out of town but it was yummy. My only negative was that…read moretheir coupons are misleading. Went to use it and then told it was only good during lunch. Bummer.

Great pizza, will be back for more visits! Service was great, quick turnaround from order to ready.read more

There are a lot of great pizza places in Springfield, but we decided to try Crust & Co during our…read moremost recent visit to The Market. The large pizza was at least an inch bigger than most places, and we enjoyed the sauce, which was more herbal than sweet. We were staying at the Courtyard Marriott across the street and our to-go order was ready in a quick 15 minutes, and they were happy to provide paper plates. Great pizza and great service, we'll be back!

O my gosh the best pizza ever .. So perfect . Wish they had…read morebetter deals so ppl on fixed income could order more But if you want pizza go here So if i could id give 100 stars

This was delivery so no ambiance…read more Cassanos, what the hell are you doing? Ordered a large deluxe pizza from Store #23 (this is store that serves my area). Again, your store fails miserably! As you can see I ordered the pizza WELL DONE! The center of the pizza was so doughy that I couldn't even pick it up, and toppings were falling through the fork I tried to use to pick up the pizza! It's not the fact that it is not thoroughly cooked, but it is almost raw in center ($30 for an uncooked pizza) I didn't know you had started the cook your own pizza at home! You can't get an address right (been customer for many years at same address) and now can't even thoroughly cook a pizza! Update: some manager called, left a message about calling back to get a credit for the above problem. Phone number left was for retrieving messages, not leaving! I sent a voice message to this manager (Adriana I believe was the name) but have not heard anything back, not that I really expected to, their customer service is a lot to be desired (hardly any at all)! People don't waste your money or time! It is a real disappointment with them for about 4 years now!

From Columbus Ohio was in Springfield doing hvacr work. This is my go to food spot moving forward…read morecustomer service excellent and food even better. Fair priced. Good culture vibe no weird vibes good people go to good places! Thank you currently at bar typing

ordered a meat lovers pizza pepperoni and cheese was all over pizza everthing else was in the middleread more

Natalie at Bentino's was so kind and welcoming. We were in YS for a show at the Firehouse and ate…read morehere first. Salad, pizza and wings. Would for sure visit again! Thanks Natalie

We were running later than usual for a show and had just argued about whether to call ahead and…read moreorder a pizza or not. We sat down w/out phones and enjoyed the pizza parlor vibe while we looked over the menu and enjoyed our cokes. We settled on a pepperoni and mushroom thin crust. The toppings were generous and covered the crust just right. The flavor of the sauce was exactly what I wanted it to be-a little spicy sweet. Glad we got a large for leftovers later. Can't wait to try a different combination of toppings and crust next time. Our server was friendly and attentive. Our argument was for nothing because the timing was perfect. After an unhurried meal, we were able to take our leftovers back to the car and still arrive before the first comedian hit the stage @The Firehouse.