Crust & Company

I believe that this is the best pizza in town. I've had Mikey's 5 times now since moving here and…read morethe crust is thin, crispy, and you can tell it's top notch all the way. They use "old world" pepperoni, which is smaller, but curls up and is so much more flavorful and crunchy than normal pepperoni used by the bigger chains. Also, their bacon bits are thick cut, and pack so much flavor. Wish they had chopped garlic, but they constantly say they don't have it....despite that it's on their menu. It's a small gripe, but I like garlic on my pizza. I have not tried any other main menu items so cannot comment on them. Will say I did have a bit of their cheesy bread and it was not good at all. I'm still giving this place 5 stars because the pizza is the STAR of this restaurant and it delivers strongly. If you haven't had this place, you are missing out!!!!!

We were working and then driving all day so picking up pizza was dinner move. I checked some of…read morethe pictures and the pizza looked good so I ordered two pizzas and cheesy bread. The guy who answered said to give them 20-25 minutes and when I got there it was ready. The pizza was even better than it looked and we were all in agreement on that. The cheesy bread didn't look like what I had in mind but it was delicious too. I had to make myself stop eating and save some for breakfast in the morning. This spot is kinda out of the way, a hidden gem if you will, and is a hole in the wall but I would definitely order from Mikey's again.

Menu detail

Menu pt. 2

See all

Menu pt. 3

Buckeye Barn

3.8(31 reviews)

2.6 mi

Solid 4 with Buckeye Barn. Don't come for me Popeyes lovers, I love it too; that being said,…read moreBuckeye Barn has fantastic fried chicken. Best in town, so far. And the hot pepper cheese bites hold their own. Decent, nothing remarkable, Cole slaw. One problem, they put the cold with hot. And warm Cole slaw doesn't do it for me. Maybe you love it, what do I care? Baked beans came cold, maybe that's a fluke or maybe they always come cold. Either way, I won't be ordering them again. And they ALWAYS forget the rolls, which is fine taste-wise, but the miser in me gets pissy about paying for something and it doesn't come. The chicken makes up for it. And I'm telling you now, skip the slice of Buckeye Pie at, like $4, I took a pic of the slice I bought to try and used a Hersheys size as a size guide. You get my drift? This is not a negative review, friends! I think it's a great restaurant! Seriously, we order from it all the time. Try the dang chicken!

Maybe not a topping famine on my pizza. This was not our first pizza from here either; just the…read morefirst bad experience.

This is the box with Deluxe lg pizza -mushrooms.

See all

Hot pepper cheese bites. And burnt fries thrown in for FREE! Don't be jealous!

Catanzaro's Pizza & Subs

4.3(71 reviews)

1.5 mi

Pizza & subs are the best in this city . They get a lot of traffic so ordering online and give them…read more20-30 min and it's usually ready. Not a fancy place, food is all take out but browse around and you'll find lots of snacks, drinks and desserts to try. Items you probably won't find anywhere else in the area. Great place!

This was a pizza that I will return for if in the area. Nice building, clean in and out. Great…read moreprivate lot. Salad was excellent. The sauce on the pizza was amazing. This is very good pizza. Friendly service. It's worth a stop.

Pizza Subs and merch. Create Your Own Pizza / Sub

A close up. This is the thin crust.

See all

One meatball with sauce & cheese deliciousness! So good!

Keg 'n' Cork

4.1(23 reviews)

1.6 mi

I live down the road from this establishment. It is a busy placeand beside selling beer,…read more wine,and liquor thay also serve a delicious pizza. The pineapple pizza was the first time trying and I was sold forever...absolutely delicious. This place rocks,it has a long history of customers and customer satisfaction.

This is a liquor store that also has a pizza oven. The pizza is a 6.5 bar style pizza. Better than…read moreyour usual carryout chain pizza. They use lots of sauce and cheese on their pizzas. No need to ask for extra. Pick up only no seating.

The Villa Pizzeria

3.4(7 reviews)

3.3 mi

We tried this place for the first time and had high hopes. Unfortunately we will NOT be back. The…read moreservice was so slow and young children ran around the small dining area screaming with NO adult supervision. I watched a table get seated and wait over 20 minutes to get their order taken.

The pizza was great. I haven't tasted pizza like it since I left NYC. the owner was very…read morepersonable.

Mader's Market

5.0(1 review)

3.5 mi

Absolutely awesome food, and coldest beer around!! I've had pizzas, subs, well, just about…read moreeverything on the menu. I have NEVER been disappointed!!

Cassano's Pizza & Subs

3.2(17 reviews)

1.8 mi

Went to Ohio for the first time and got cassanos twice in 4 days so if that doesn't say how delish…read moreit is idk what does. The crispy crust with the sauce makes the perfect pair. The cute little shapes they cut the pizza into makes it fun. I'm just mad I waited so long to go to Ohio now!!!!

Don't get to get this that often being from out of town but it was yummy. My only negative was that…read moretheir coupons are misleading. Went to use it and then told it was only good during lunch. Bummer.

See all

Cassano's Pizza & Subs

2.9(34 reviews)

1.6 mi

Cassano's pizza has been my go to pizzeria since I was in high school. In my opinion its heads…read moreabove the rest in town. I recently tried their deluxe with pineapple. I was hesitant for awhile until I finally satisfied my curiosity. Bam! That was it,I'm locked in forever. The steak Hoagie is another mouth watering favorite of mine. The menu is loaded with great selections. Give Vic Cassano and Mom Denisi a try. It has survived many years for a reason. I'm ahomer so an easy 5 stars is appropriate.

This was delivery so no ambiance…read more Cassanos, what the hell are you doing? Ordered a large deluxe pizza from Store #23 (this is store that serves my area). Again, your store fails miserably! As you can see I ordered the pizza WELL DONE! The center of the pizza was so doughy that I couldn't even pick it up, and toppings were falling through the fork I tried to use to pick up the pizza! It's not the fact that it is not thoroughly cooked, but it is almost raw in center ($30 for an uncooked pizza) I didn't know you had started the cook your own pizza at home! You can't get an address right (been customer for many years at same address) and now can't even thoroughly cook a pizza! Update: some manager called, left a message about calling back to get a credit for the above problem. Phone number left was for retrieving messages, not leaving! I sent a voice message to this manager (Adriana I believe was the name) but have not heard anything back, not that I really expected to, their customer service is a lot to be desired (hardly any at all)! People don't waste your money or time! It is a real disappointment with them for about 4 years now!

Black on all sides

Cold and smashed from Cassano's and took an hour and half. Never again.

See all

Pizza

Station1

3.2(38 reviews)

0.4 mi

Station 1 is an unpretentious dope spot for wangs, pizza, and some brews. Found this place while…read moreout in the area for work. The mango habanero and parmesan garlic honey wings were effin delicious! Their pizza was super good. The prices... so damn cheap for the quality of food. A cool place to hang out and chill and have some drinks. It happened to be trivia and wing night. So much fun! We really enjoyed ourselves. Great service and everyone was wearing a mask.

From Columbus Ohio was in Springfield doing hvacr work. This is my go to food spot moving forward…read morecustomer service excellent and food even better. Fair priced. Good culture vibe no weird vibes good people go to good places! Thank you currently at bar typing

Skyline Chili Pizza

Chef salad and chicken finger sandwich and a pitcher of beer

See all

37 drafts. New draft choices added every week!

YS Pizza

4.2(111 reviews)

9.0 mi

Food was amazing and the place was super cute. Cute nice area to walk around at as wellread more

Natalie at Bentino's was so kind and welcoming. We were in YS for a show at the Firehouse and ate…read morehere first. Salad, pizza and wings. Would for sure visit again! Thanks Natalie

Thin crust

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Emily D.

4 years ago

We were in town and looking for something new. What are great find. We will definitely be coming back.

Crust & Company - pizza - Updated November 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Springfield, Ohio Restaurants near Crust & Company

BEST of Springfield, Ohio Coffee near Crust & Company

BEST of Springfield, Ohio Desserts near Crust & Company

BEST of Springfield, Ohio Things to Do near Crust & Company

BEST of Springfield, Ohio Breakfast near Crust & Company

BEST of Springfield, Ohio Parking near Crust & Company

BEST of Springfield, Ohio Cocktail Bars near Crust & Company

BEST of Springfield, Ohio Dinner near Crust & Company

BEST of Springfield, Ohio Shopping near Crust & Company

BEST of Springfield, Ohio Movie Theatre near Crust & Company

Best of Springfield

Things to do in Springfield

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Crust & Company also viewed

Staunton Country Store

4.6

(13 reviews)

This small drive thru serves some of the best pizza and subs around. I've had most of the items on…read morethe menu, but my favorites are the Italian sub and the 12" pizzas. I don't know how they fit that much yummy food into such a tiny store, but I commend them for it. There's usually tables outside if you are looking to stop for a bite, or take it to go. Oh! Don't forget about the footlong hotdogs! The Kraut dog is my favorite.

We wanted a really good pizza during our trip as where we live it's hard to find a really good one…read more So we hopped on Yelp to see what we could see. This one had a great rating and we can see how it got one. It's a little bit out of the way but it's in a beautiful setting along the Miami River corridor. And the pizza is great. It takes 3 things to make a good pizza. The balance of the crust, the dough, the sauce, and the cheese. Everything else just adds to these 3 elements. This place does this well. They were fast, clean, and friendly. The right amount of toppings so you could taste each item without drowning out the other flavors of the pie. Just fabulous! You can eat outside if you choose or take out. As good as it gets. Highly recommended!

Phat Daddy's Pizza

3.2

(31 reviews)

The pizza was Good but would not make my top five. It was nice to take the back roads from Columbus…read moreand sit down in an established pizza joint. The sitting area was full of history and pictures of the growth of Phat Daddy's. Caricatures of past and present employees give it that small town feel. The staff were very polite and attentive to our drink needs. You get the menu but go to the register to order. The menu had many options to choose from. Over all it was a pleasant night out for dinner

Bedt place for the bank and very reliable service and the respect of the the workers outstanding…read moreand always right made to order

Cassano's Pizza & Subs

4.5

(4 reviews)

I love cassano's pizza and have for many years. They have…read morealways went out of there way to treat me with their best service. For the past 30 years I have been very satisfied with there level of service I love there attention to detail They are always dressed very nice very professional people and business

Ya'll in the Miami Valley are spoiled because there are Cassano's pizza EVERYWHERE. It isn't until…read moreyou move out of the area that you realize how delicious it is. My high school memories include many post-game, post-meet memories of stopping by Cassano's for some sustenance. Cassano's with it's salty, thin crust, fresh out of the oven. It makes my mouth water just thinking about it. I like the combo pizza, although I like it sans pepperoni, otherwise it's too salty. The breadsticks are also delicious. Cassano's, I miss you, and between you and Marion's, I get my pizza fill anytime I'm in the area.

Home Town Pizza

5.0

(1 review)

Ordered a pepperoni and mushroom pizza. Cooked to perfection. Soft chewy crust with slightly crisp…read moreedges. I'm not a huge fan of Italian subs, but I was quite pleased with this as well. Will definitely be a long time customer here.

Main Street Pizza

4.8

(15 reviews)

We love the pizza every time. The onion rings are good too. Staff is always friendly. I can't ever…read morefind an up to date menu online, added a picture.

We absolutely LOVE Main Street Pizza! Customer service is #1. It has a hometown atmosphere, like…read moreyou are right at home there. Friendly staff with smiles as soon as you walk in the door. The best food too. I especially love their homemade ranch dressing. It goes with everything we order. I look forward to our dinners from there. I highly recommend this restaurant.

B, Pizza

5.0

(2 reviews)

This pizza place is totally awesome. This place is not like your typical franchise pizza spot, but…read morethe taste of their delicious pizza is worth the wait. It was hard to get through on the telephone to order, so I went in. For a Friday night, I expected a wait. The owner said she selected the sauce, and that counts on a pizza. This place did a fabulous job and you will be completely satisfied.

B Pizza Artist!! I tried it couple weeks ago then came back for more within weeks!! DELICIOUS!!read more

Sparky's Pizzeria

3.5

(24 reviews)

Decent pizza spot in Urbana. A little too much cheese for my liking but the service was great…read more(although the building looks a lil rundown). Would recommend trying if in the area, but I don't think I'd personally visit again.

I've tasted their great tasting fresh food pizza is good staffs friendly helpful their values good…read moreatmosphere is good ambiance is casual services are great I couldn't wait review them a time ago got some pizza never reviewed then their great for community

ILLYS Fire Pizza

4.5

(10 reviews)

We are from the Fairfield, OH area (north of Cincinnati). Stumbled across West Social Tap & Table…read morewhen we visited the Aviation Trail museum. Illy's pizza is excellent. We enjoyed a cheese pizza for my son and the toasted ravioli. What really struck us was the owners positive energy and vibe. He just has an energy and passion that you can see in how he interacted with us and others. You can truly tell he loves what he has built here with Illy's. And lastly as a child of the late 70's, growing up on Slick Rick, Run DMC. LL Cool J, The Roots, etc - the 80's/90's Hip Hop theme is just a great bonus! :)

Robert and his family make an incredible fire-roasted pizza. Ours was loaded with cheese and…read morevegetables! Located in the West Social Tap and Table food hall, across from the Dayton Heritage National Historic Park. Visit when in the area, you won't be disappointed!

Enon Pizza & Company

4.4

(8 reviews)

Wow! What a gem, it's tiny hole in the wall with amazing pizza. Perfectly crispy edges, seasoning…read morewas on point (I think it's garlic salt on the crust). Funnel fries delicious. Don't let the modest building fool you. Will go again!

Great food and service. Friendly staff. Always a great tasting pizza. I usually go here once a…read moreweek. Their side items have been really good also. Would recommend this carry out . M.G.

Crown Market

4.3

(21 reviews)