Old Scratch Pizza was the perfect stop off lunch in Troy, OH while traveling on I75…read more The white pizza was AHHHmazing! Large enough for us to share, we left pleasantly content. We ordered at the pick up counter, and the pizza ready in 15 minutes. The inside was large enough for parties, or cozy enough for family night or a date! Outside sitting area also. Give Old Scratch Pizza a try! You will love it!

Ordered for the first time today, a carryout Mr. Scratch 12" pie. Parked right in front in one of…read morethe designated pickup spots, very convenient. Nice looking place, clean and with a great looking menu board. I logged in and my order came out in just a couple of minutes. I would have preferred that the guy who brought it out wouldn't have been carrying it in one hand at a forty five degree angle like he was getting ready to pitch a horseshoe though. The box was a lot lighter than I expected, and it wasn't as hot as I anticipated. The pie was good looking though, cut in six wedge shaped pieces. As light as what it was the crust had some browning in spots, but it was kind of doughy. The ingredients look a little sparse other than the basil, which had several large pieces. Sausage, caramelized onions, basil and Calabrian peppers with cheese. Those little peppers really bring the heat! Can't taste the sausage much as the pieces are kind of small, same with the onions, which I honestly couldn't tell were there. One thing I wanted to try were the meatballs as a side or a shareable, but they were listed as online as being out of stock. Next time I will dine in and ask for a crispier bake and spring for double portions on the ingredients. And I might skip the Calabrian peppers.

The pizza was excellent! Even better than Marion's pizza…read more The people were nice. There were like 9 TVs lol. Banners for 2 Troy sports teams :) Root beer.

First off I like to support local businesses, instead of the everyday chain restaurants. Ordered at…read more4:53pm arrived at 5:10pm to pay and pick up, as it was to be ready at 5:13. Was told "we are a little behind" and should be another 10 min. We got our over sauced, burnt pizza at 5:22. When question the person who checked me out , he say that's the way they always look. If this is the quality of the product they are going to put out, then this building will be for lease again real soon. As far as the ambiance, just a bunch of loud kids that were working there is all you can hear. As I think back I don't believe I saw an adult supervisor around. Anyway don't waste your money , you'll be sorry and just have to write another bad review.

Pizza was loaded with toppings and edges were crispy! The service was great and staff were kind…read more When walking into this place, you'll feel like you stepped back in time to a mixture of an old Wendy's sunroom and a mall cafeteria area! Very family friendly and they available rooms to reserve for parties as well.

I always like to stop at a Marion's location when I am working in the area…read more Marion's pizza is unique. It hasn't changed for decades. It will always be the hometown pizza. Today I ordered a 9 inch pizza with mushrooms, extra cheese, and extra sauce. Also a side of ranch. The dining room here is very large and uniquely decorated.

Ordered a pizza through door dash yesterday and it arrived fully sealed but missing a piece. This…read moregrossed me out cause it could potentially mean someone was messing with the food. I know mistakes happen etc but we couldn't bring ourselves to eat it. DoorDash fully refunded and I let the store know but I'd be reluctant to order from there again.

I had guests over and we decided to order pizza. Someone mentioned Cassano's Pizza, and since some…read moreof us had never tried it before, I decided to give them a shot. I went online to place an order for 3 large pizzas and couldn't believe my eyes when the total was over $80. Thinking maybe I was missing some specials, I called the store to ask. The only "special" I was offered was free cheesebread with the purchase of a large cheesesteak pizza. Since nobody wanted that, it didn't really help. I was curious why the pizza was 2 to 3 times more expensive than our usual pizza spot, so I Googled it. The explanation was "premium crust" and "premium toppings." Fine. I figured I'd splurge for my guests and we'd enjoy some premium pizza. Boy, were we disappointed. Because of the prices, I changed the order from large pizzas to mediums, and even then the total was close to $60. The pizzas were barely okay. They seemed overdone, the toppings were skimpy, and the taste was below average. I understand thin crust pizza, but for those prices I expected something impressive. What really shocked me was that after 3 medium pizzas for a group, people were still hungry. I actually had to make microwave chicken nuggets and mac and cheese afterward because the pizzas were so skimpy and unfilling. We were hoping to have leftovers... lol. Very disappointed overall, especially for the outrageous price. I would never recommend this place for pizza. Literally every other pizza spot is better pizza, and better value.

Should employess be handling raw dough and toppings with bare hands? I watched this today...he…read morerolled dough, put a pizza together, answered the phone, used the computer & went back to handling dough with no gloves on. Never again for me

Pizza is good, but the guy on the phone taking orders is a asshole.I would give 0 stars if i could.read more

Before the fire Donatos was about the only place in Troy that I would go for pizza. The locals like…read moreothers but all I can figure for them is that they like the cheap beer more than the pizza. At donatos the actual pizza taste good. They've rebuilt after the fire. They are back in business and have settled down for a little while. I need to revisit them.

All tables dirty manager throwing things around not friendly over all bad experience i just can't…read morebelieve you can't go out and get a good experience

Local, yummy, decent priced. I'm not sure what else you could ask for…read more I'm a big fan of supporting local businesses in these guys fit. They make decent food in their local store. The big guys are trying to push out, check out the new tree gas station across the street. I like their people. They have great people working for them. And they also make really good food. Some of the food isn't my sort and some and I like it. I also like that it's integrated with a corner store, it has a great mom and pop vibe, and I can pick up things besides the food if I need them.

Great food. Friendly staff. Best Pimento Cheese spread and pasta salad. Great pies. Especially Mud…read morePie. Never disappointed.

I almost always order from this location using their app and my food is always ready on time…read more Interactions with the staff are minimal due to the way the place is set up, but they always seem friendly and professional.

Update on my review from Saturday. Papa John's corporate sent me a link to provide a review on…read moretheir pizza. I basically told them what I posted below on Saturday. The next day I received an email from a Papa John's regional manager who was very apologetic and offered a free replacement pie. I picked that replacement pie up this evening and it was excellent! In the rush of doing business sometimes Quality gets dropped, but it's nice to see a company that steps up and makes things right! Well done Papa John's!

Good service right away. Seated quickly. Brought coloring books and crayons for my kiddos. Drinks…read morewere quick to the table. We put an order for pizza and she asked if the spicy stuff should be on the side, again being considerate of my Littles. My Littles aren't fans of spicy. My prankster second daughter put Rick Astley on the jukebox, and a half dozen patrons down the restaurant started singing out as it went. This is a hometown place with a decent sense of humor and community. Also kid friendly.

The pizza we got was great. We ordered an appetizer and it was forgotten about. It came out after…read morewe brought it to the waitresses attention. It came out fairly quickly after that and was good also. The service was very slow. My nephew needed a drink refill and it never came. We ended up having to go to the bar and ask for one. I doubt we will be back as there are other places in the area we'd try.