Pizza Alley was surprisingly good. We ended up here because there was a Choral Concert we…read moreattended in Mechanicsburg and we were looking for a place to grab a bite to eat close because we had several family members coming in from various places. So I found this place via a search and it worked out. It didn't hit me that it was a bowling alley with food associated with it until I did some more digging into where exactly we were going. There ended up being about 20 of us who wandered in (we didn't really know how many of our family members were going to join us) and we were a bit put off because it is a bowling alley that has food (like most do) and we have never been to a bowling alley just to get food. But it is your typical bowling alley. We couldn't bowl because they had a party going on and then they needed to treat the lanes so we literally decided we may as well try it and see. They had an arcarde room and your typical bowling fare for what you see in most bowling alleys. Bathrooms were relatively clean as well. The pizza was surprisingly good. We got their peperoni sub as well and it was actually pretty good. We went here because they offered a GF pizza crust that wasn't cauliflower based (Yes, my GF daughter can't do a lot of the alternative options for GF) and she said it was pretty good. (Side note...she had some gastro issues on Monday so isn't sure if that was connected to the pizza or not) All in all, the food was good, the service was great and for being an old bowling alley, the place was decent. I will say we ordered 2 sausage pizzas and one was clearly more cheesy than the other. One was the jumbo and the other was just the large, IDK how that would have anything to do with it but there was a clear taste and look difference. Not sure I would suggest bringing a date here for the first time unless you really like to bowl and can bowl...but just know if you bowl and order food, the food won't be a disappointment.

Great pizza or so so pizza, depends on the night. Can be the best in town! They have a wide range…read moreof menu items. Subs, pizza, hamburger, hotdogs and other sandwiches, along with ice cream and treats

I believe that this is the best pizza in town. I've had Mikey's 5 times now since moving here and…read morethe crust is thin, crispy, and you can tell it's top notch all the way. They use "old world" pepperoni, which is smaller, but curls up and is so much more flavorful and crunchy than normal pepperoni used by the bigger chains. Also, their bacon bits are thick cut, and pack so much flavor. Wish they had chopped garlic, but they constantly say they don't have it....despite that it's on their menu. It's a small gripe, but I like garlic on my pizza. I have not tried any other main menu items so cannot comment on them. Will say I did have a bit of their cheesy bread and it was not good at all. I'm still giving this place 5 stars because the pizza is the STAR of this restaurant and it delivers strongly. If you haven't had this place, you are missing out!!!!!

We were working and then driving all day so picking up pizza was dinner move. I checked some of…read morethe pictures and the pizza looked good so I ordered two pizzas and cheesy bread. The guy who answered said to give them 20-25 minutes and when I got there it was ready. The pizza was even better than it looked and we were all in agreement on that. The cheesy bread didn't look like what I had in mind but it was delicious too. I had to make myself stop eating and save some for breakfast in the morning. This spot is kinda out of the way, a hidden gem if you will, and is a hole in the wall but I would definitely order from Mikey's again.

Food was done when we were told it would be done. Deluxe pizza and cheesy garlic bread were good…read more They have a couple tables inside along with a picnic table outside. Interior of the restaurant is small.

Best pizza in town! The best & only restaurant in town too! LOL! Very friendly staff in a really…read moresmall town.

Hand crafted with fresh ingredients! Excellent pizza! A good lunch option to feed a hungry crew!read more

Hand crafted with fresh ingredients! Excellent pizza! A good lunch option to feed a hungry crew!…read moreTried the cauliflower crust with pepperoni, sausage and banana peppers. It was really good! Had wings with garlic dipping sauce. Wings were crispy and sauce was really good. Will go back for this! I enjoy the items on their menu. I'd ask PLEASE get the beef crispitos back. The whole fam loved them! Months ago I was told the wrong order was put in and all they had was cheese so I gave it a shot - not the same! I've tried ordering other times hoping they'd get the beef back. Recently called and asked and was told 'yes, have the beef', got it home and nope, all cheese. So two requests: 1) If possible order the beef again and 2) train your associates on what's available so customers Don't waste their money on what they don't want. The cook Justus demateo is a great cook. I have never been in to eat. This review is based on pick up and carryout only. Overall impressed with the speed and accuracy of this Hut. They have never gotten one of my orders wrong. I have never had to wait on an order either no matter how busy they were. The app makes pick up and carryout a breeze as well. Good staff who clearly know how it all works as well. Good service and every there was good and my pizza and wings where good overall good experiencer

Amazing!! Seriously some of the best pizza I have had! We were driving through and had to order…read moresome to go! Ate right in the front seat of my Tucson!! We couldn't wait to dig in!

Stopped in for dinner and it did not disappoint! Started with the garlic knots and the dip sampler…read more All of the dips paired well with the knots. However, I was not a fan of the cheese dip. We ordered the Detroit style Americana pizza. The crust was crispy and the toppings were plentiful. It was topped with some extra sauce on top. Will definitely be back

Ambiance is minimal. A fair amount of table groupings. A TV playing the food network and nothing to…read moreblow you away with related to decor. Local OSU stuff on the walls. The kid at the counter was helpful. We wanted some onion rings but their fryer was down so we pivoted to order wings. I don't remember what sauce we had but we ordered 8 and it looked like the most pathetic basket of wings ever seen. Super small wings. They tasted good but it could be just because they were drenched in the sauce. Waited a while for the wings and even longer for the pizza. The pizza was good. Good amount of toppings. It wasn't bad pizza but it wasn't great. We couldn't tell why we weren't overly impressed with the pizza but it was just pizza. Pizza came out screaming hot, which was nice because the restaurant was chilly because it was below zero outside. So one upside is the pizza was hot and stayed hot for a while as we ate it. Hard to see as it sat at the end of a strip of other businesses as the end of the building away from the road. All in all, it wasn't bad pizza but we probably won't drive to Bellfontaine for Fat Boys. Gave it a 3 out of 5 because of what was mentioned plus the one menu on the Yelp site was old and the pizza we thought was going to be $19.99 ended up being almost $10 more than the new menu listing. Didn't think a medium pizza was worth $28 bucks...especially when two shared it and we only took a couple of pieces home.

We love Fat Boys pizza. We quit ordering for awhile because toppings were no where near the edge…read more And the price was one of the highest around. Which we don't mind paying for quality but can't justify it when you are not getting a complete product. After a couple of years we decided to give them another shot. Still great pizza and it seemed like they were finally getting the toppings to the edge until last night. And I understand prices are crazy on everything now but $49 for this pizza and 14 wings when the pizza was missing toppings.

Their wood-fired pizzas are samples of culinary artistry - but don't miss the other gems on and off…read moretheir menu. The Caesar salad is the best I've had, Mom's meatballs, cheesy bread, etc.; all are a delight. If you're looking for excellent Italian cuisine in an atmosphere where you feel like family and just want to stay a while (even the ovens are named after mom and dad), the quality and creativity at Bella Sorella is a great foodie find!

Had a party of 8 girls lunch at Bella Sorella Pizza today! Bella Sorella is a cute, cozy,…read morecomfortable restaurant. Open atmosphere, plenty of seating, with large glass garage doors that open when the weather allows. Some of our party arrived late, but a pleasant hostess sat us at one of two large tables. Our waitress was busy, a bit distracted, (it was busy and she was the only one), but she was organized and did a great job getting our drinks, food, and checks out in a timely manner! I ordered the Italiano Lunch only sandwich and a bowl of minestrone soup. My sandwich was absolutely delish...I mean one of my all time favorites - so, so good!! Not a lot of description on the menu, but the flavors were well put together - you gotta try... but according to the menu - lunch only. The soup was good as well, but too spicy for me. Others in the party enjoyed their pizzas, meatballs, and calamari. We'll be back!

I didn't get any pictures because we demolished our food before the thought ever crossed my mind…read more The best BLT pizza I've ever had! The crust is airy and focaccia-like, with the perfect balance of crisp and soft. They don't skimp on the bacon either! It's loaded and absolutely delicious. Rissa (the owner) graciously took the time to tell us about the process of hand making their dough, shredded the cheese, and fresh cutting all their vegetables. You can truly taste that each pizza is made with love and attention to detail. The owner is so passionate about her business, and it clearly shows in the care and quality she puts into every pie. Highly recommend!

prices are not what the show on the menu. I was told that…read morethere was an increase so these price vary, which is fine but I'd never thought I'd be paying 26 dolls for a 13inch pizza..... first and last time coming. Pizza was ok,but definitely not worth almost $30 for what is consider a medium.

We were driving by and hear it was a good place so we had to check it out. We only hit up the store…read moreand didn't do the restaurant and this review is based on that. We bought a Groot garden statue, coffee, caramels and a scented candle. I popped a caramel in my mouth and was it ever good! I'd stop here just for these caramels! Next time I'm here I'll try the food side! As Arnold said, 'I'll be back!'

Looks like this place is the go to after visiting the Ohio Caverns. The exterior of the building…read morelooks like a barn house and is a very nice vibe in this small town. It's spacious inside and is adjacent to a market place selling local goods - wines, candles, jams, soap, jewelry etc. Burger is what they're famous for - beef are local. We ordered 3 different burgers and they're all good. Fort Worth Cowboys Up Garlic We were so full from it. This place gives me a small town vibe.