We were driving by and hear it was a good place so we had to check it out. We only hit up the store…read moreand didn't do the restaurant and this review is based on that. We bought a Groot garden statue, coffee, caramels and a scented candle. I popped a caramel in my mouth and was it ever good! I'd stop here just for these caramels! Next time I'm here I'll try the food side! As Arnold said, 'I'll be back!'

Looks like this place is the go to after visiting the Ohio Caverns. The exterior of the building…read morelooks like a barn house and is a very nice vibe in this small town. It's spacious inside and is adjacent to a market place selling local goods - wines, candles, jams, soap, jewelry etc. Burger is what they're famous for - beef are local. We ordered 3 different burgers and they're all good. Fort Worth Cowboys Up Garlic We were so full from it. This place gives me a small town vibe.

Food is average. Customer service was extremely rude,…read morehanging up on me after I had to cancel my order after being told it was a 40 minute wait. (I could not wait due to needing to pick up a prescription before pharmacy closes). Called back because I thought it was disconnected, just to be lectured how a 40 minute wait isn't long. Just lost my future business Hope it was worth it!

they copied off of Pop's pizza in East Liberty , Her son worked at Pop's pizza, can't out do Pop's…read morepizza ! The sub I got was not good it Dry had all meat on it 1 thin slice of ham couldn't taste sausage had more crumbled hamburger on it no onion or peppers no sauce no flavor at all! So much hamburger on it that's all you could taste!

Pizza shop with a variety of pies. Great service and great food! Something to be found for every…read moretaste. It was pretty busy, so it may be a good idea to get reservations. They have a patio and plenty of tables. Luckily we were able to get a table easily.

Stopped in for dinner and it did not disappoint! Started with the garlic knots and the dip sampler…read more All of the dips paired well with the knots. However, I was not a fan of the cheese dip. We ordered the Detroit style Americana pizza. The crust was crispy and the toppings were plentiful. It was topped with some extra sauce on top. Will definitely be back

Ambiance is minimal. A fair amount of table groupings. A TV playing the food network and nothing to…read moreblow you away with related to decor. Local OSU stuff on the walls. The kid at the counter was helpful. We wanted some onion rings but their fryer was down so we pivoted to order wings. I don't remember what sauce we had but we ordered 8 and it looked like the most pathetic basket of wings ever seen. Super small wings. They tasted good but it could be just because they were drenched in the sauce. Waited a while for the wings and even longer for the pizza. The pizza was good. Good amount of toppings. It wasn't bad pizza but it wasn't great. We couldn't tell why we weren't overly impressed with the pizza but it was just pizza. Pizza came out screaming hot, which was nice because the restaurant was chilly because it was below zero outside. So one upside is the pizza was hot and stayed hot for a while as we ate it. Hard to see as it sat at the end of a strip of other businesses as the end of the building away from the road. All in all, it wasn't bad pizza but we probably won't drive to Bellfontaine for Fat Boys. Gave it a 3 out of 5 because of what was mentioned plus the one menu on the Yelp site was old and the pizza we thought was going to be $19.99 ended up being almost $10 more than the new menu listing. Didn't think a medium pizza was worth $28 bucks...especially when two shared it and we only took a couple of pieces home.

We love Fat Boys pizza. We quit ordering for awhile because toppings were no where near the edge…read more And the price was one of the highest around. Which we don't mind paying for quality but can't justify it when you are not getting a complete product. After a couple of years we decided to give them another shot. Still great pizza and it seemed like they were finally getting the toppings to the edge until last night. And I understand prices are crazy on everything now but $49 for this pizza and 14 wings when the pizza was missing toppings.

Awesome pizza and cold beer.Their special recipe sausage, crispy crust makes the best pizza ever.read more

It's a great place to get pizza if you like dive bars. The sausage is homemade and the beers are…read morecold!

Never had a bad pie from Cardinals. Always reliable and better than Benny's all around.read more

Very easy to order, a decent place to go, you won't have any TVs or music or any frou frou kind of…read morestuff if you're looking for a place to tell you how amazing you are this is not that kind of place, but they are friendly., but a nice dining area. You go and take your order and sit down and eat or get it to go. From my understanding they don't have doordash or anything like that. The have a variety of food other than pizza, spaghetti , sandwiches, the locals tell me the taco pizza is a fan favorite. I had a basic pepperoni and sausage and it was great.

Ordered a pepperoni and mushroom pizza. Cooked to perfection. Soft chewy crust with slightly crisp…read moreedges. I'm not a huge fan of Italian subs, but I was quite pleased with this as well. Will definitely be a long time customer here.

From the owner: Pizza, Subs, Salads, Beer, Groceriesread more

It's not a big resteraunt but there's just 2 of us we love to sit and eat at the bar. I really…read morelike The Florentine pasta, I add mushrooms. My hubby likes the lasagna and the meatball sub. You get the basket of garlic bread w dinner. Yum.

Food is wonderful always!! They have never gotten any orders wrong and their service is great. We…read moretry to get food from there once a week if possible.

Great spot, interesting located with an excellent decor. Just stopped for a beer and did get a tag…read morea brew also! Weird parking out front. Good service and great ambience. Would go again.

First time in Urbana and what a treat! We swung by Urbana Brewing, the town's only brewery, and it…read morewas a fantastic stop. The town center itself has a charming layout, with a circle reminiscent of Troy, lined with shops and activity. The brewery is new, welcoming, and already turning out some excellent beers. We appreciated being able to sample before choosing -- I went with the Blood Orange IPA, which was bright and refreshing, while Nicole enjoyed a smooth white milk stout that was absolutely delicious. The atmosphere is modern yet cozy, with oak tables paired with iron chairs, and a rooftop patio that overlooks the heart of town. They also had some really nice merch available, though we didn't pick any up this time. A fun, inviting place that blends small‑town charm with quality craft beer. Highly recommend stopping in if you're anywhere near Urbana!

Food was done when we were told it would be done. Deluxe pizza and cheesy garlic bread were good…read more They have a couple tables inside along with a picnic table outside. Interior of the restaurant is small.

Best pizza in town! The best & only restaurant in town too! LOL! Very friendly staff in a really…read moresmall town.