The brick oven pizzas makes the place what it is! Not a fan of stacked oven pizza ovens so walking…read morein this and seeing a brick oven pizzas oven already has my mouth watering the smell is like no other! If you have followed Mr T well this is me! T was for tinny a child hood name! So far so good Rick our server has to be the nicest person I've met who actually seems like he enjoys his job! Which is extremely rare to say! Helpful with his suggestions not over barring and actually listens to your likes and dislikes! Whoever hired him good job! Now let's talk about the ambiance of this place! Great if you like being in high school or any other pizza place! Other than that great vibe, love the menu that shows what the pizza looks like and should look like when delivered to your table! Now to the food! Order three small classic pizzas The Montana Tasteful but not a fan of white sauces on my pizzas not saying negatively just saying my preference is traditional red sauces Montana had me wanting more The Tonto Great pizza however I'm not a fan of canned mushrooms and why even have it as a topping, Asked Rick to change that to all fresh ingredients and he delivered! And their newest one on the menu The Cantina This has to be my personal top three best pizzas ever! No kidding Make sure you order this if you like spicy like do my wife is a bit spicy so that says everything! lol Now order this with extra meat and jalapeños I mean the flavor the taste is to die for! I asked for honey on the side and tasted with or without honey on all three and either way you like it it doesn't change how good these pizzas where made not the taste of the ingredients and sauce! Perfectly cheesed and delicious cheeses pulls away as it should and doesn't over do it! Absolutely a perfect ending to a great weekend trying to find new places and meet new faces Bellefontaine OH has some hidden gems and honestly I will come all the way from California just to 600 Downtowns newest pizza no joke that's how delicious this place is!

Best pizza around here for sure! We appreciated the website working smoothly and being able to pick…read moreup and eat our food when it was hot still! Thank yall so much!

Hand crafted with fresh ingredients! Excellent pizza! A good lunch option to feed a hungry crew!…read moreTried the cauliflower crust with pepperoni, sausage and banana peppers. It was really good! Had wings with garlic dipping sauce. Wings were crispy and sauce was really good. Will go back for this! I enjoy the items on their menu. I'd ask PLEASE get the beef crispitos back. The whole fam loved them! Months ago I was told the wrong order was put in and all they had was cheese so I gave it a shot - not the same! I've tried ordering other times hoping they'd get the beef back. Recently called and asked and was told 'yes, have the beef', got it home and nope, all cheese. So two requests: 1) If possible order the beef again and 2) train your associates on what's available so customers Don't waste their money on what they don't want. The cook Justus demateo is a great cook. I have never been in to eat. This review is based on pick up and carryout only. Overall impressed with the speed and accuracy of this Hut. They have never gotten one of my orders wrong. I have never had to wait on an order either no matter how busy they were. The app makes pick up and carryout a breeze as well. Good staff who clearly know how it all works as well. Good service and every there was good and my pizza and wings where good overall good experiencer

Hand crafted with fresh ingredients! Excellent pizza! A good lunch option to feed a hungry crew!read more

Vicario's pizza is the best in Logan County,Ohio They put tremendous amount of toppings on and the…read moresauce is amazing. They also deliver in most places in Logan County too.

The only issues I have is this Food was rushed and sloppy,…read moreI guess if it's 2am and looking for food to eat after a night at the bar! I guess but I wouldn't give the food more than two stars the bright spot for three stars is the server Daniel she's the reason for the three stars! Friendly and above an beyond expectation! Ambience felt like a high school hang out spot trying to be a bar and sports hangout! All mixed and trying to find its identity as to what exactly is this pizza spot trying to be! Reminds me of my ex wife! I'll stop there! But when your place is bi polar what do you expect sorry pizza crust was burnt spaghetti was over cooked had no taste However those wings that should be your focal point and stay at that level everything else your doing gets lost in translation

It's not a big resteraunt but there's just 2 of us we love to sit and eat at the bar. I really…read morelike The Florentine pasta, I add mushrooms. My hubby likes the lasagna and the meatball sub. You get the basket of garlic bread w dinner. Yum.

Food is wonderful always!! They have never gotten any orders wrong and their service is great. We…read moretry to get food from there once a week if possible.

Admittedly, I'm a bit of a food snob. I know what I like and know what I want. This is some great…read morepizza!!! With dining closed due to COVID we had take out. Friendly staff, appears to be clean from a drive through look. Prices reasonable and the taste was great. I always tip for good friendly service and especially now dining is closed, and gave a little extra. Try it.

Ambiance is minimal. A fair amount of table groupings. A TV playing the food network and nothing to…read moreblow you away with related to decor. Local OSU stuff on the walls. The kid at the counter was helpful. We wanted some onion rings but their fryer was down so we pivoted to order wings. I don't remember what sauce we had but we ordered 8 and it looked like the most pathetic basket of wings ever seen. Super small wings. They tasted good but it could be just because they were drenched in the sauce. Waited a while for the wings and even longer for the pizza. The pizza was good. Good amount of toppings. It wasn't bad pizza but it wasn't great. We couldn't tell why we weren't overly impressed with the pizza but it was just pizza. Pizza came out screaming hot, which was nice because the restaurant was chilly because it was below zero outside. So one upside is the pizza was hot and stayed hot for a while as we ate it. Hard to see as it sat at the end of a strip of other businesses as the end of the building away from the road. All in all, it wasn't bad pizza but we probably won't drive to Bellfontaine for Fat Boys. Gave it a 3 out of 5 because of what was mentioned plus the one menu on the Yelp site was old and the pizza we thought was going to be $19.99 ended up being almost $10 more than the new menu listing. Didn't think a medium pizza was worth $28 bucks...especially when two shared it and we only took a couple of pieces home.

Cassano's at the lake…read more It had been a minute since Iast had Cassano's, and it was pizza Friday in the house, so we placed the order. The pizza was delicious, as usual. Extra sauce all the way, and the family loved it. If you're looking for good local pizza, you won't go wrong with Cassano's.

Let me start with it has been years since I've been back, but when I got the fish and chips, I…read moreexpected something like I remember instead it was fish nuggets, battered, in pancake mix. Restaurant was clean. Staff was courteous. All I have to say is do better.

Well, I just ordered a pizza from the location in Russells Point, Ohio. They were very helpful with…read moremy order. The young lady I talked to Kamai Was very helpful with my order. It's so nice to see someone. That loves their job. And treat customer with Personal experience. She should get a raise. Ha ha. Thank you very much, Matthew Reif

Excellent spot for pizza and subs. I'm glad I didn't base a yelp score on dining here. Everything…read morewas fresh and delicious. The pizza was a perfect cracker style crust. Loved it! We would definitely return when in the area again.

Are you still reading yelp reviews to decide what is good to eat?..pathetic…read more It good. Me like. F the internet.

I got the large beer battered fish and it was only 4 small pieces and the fish I got wasn't cooked…read moreall the way and it was made up of either the fins or the spine of the fish and not the fillets.

We order from Donatos all the time. The food is always on point! They are always so kind. Not only…read moreis it one of my fav pizzas, salads are also amazing. I would highly recommend Donatos in Bellefontaine ,to anyone who asked. Great job! Keep up the great work and service.

Great pizza and a wonderful staff! Our pizza was exactly what we expected and everything we wanted!read more

Always enjoy a meal from Brew! Great food, a welcoming atmosphere, and consistently a wonderful…read moreexperience. Brewfontaine is definitely a favorite and always worth a visit. Highly recommend!

Stopped in after a museum tour. Sat at the bar. Very good service, fantastic bartender! Spinach…read moreartichoke dip was amazing! Smaller on the inside, but there are more rooms and a nice patio!