Have not ordered here for 3 years because the pizza quality had went down and price went up. Heard it was better. Ordered a Lotsa meat pizza and bread sticks. $43 fine but pizza had very little toppings. I mean there were pieces around the edge that were just cheese. Honestly one of the worst pizzas I have ever ate. Back in the day this pizza was so good, so many toppings. The people that bought Als should bot even be allowed to keep the name. It is more like Little Caesars pizza now. Do not recommend. read more

Delicious! The Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza was great!! We ordered a medium and we have enough for another meal! Thanks. Our new favorite

I was disappointed that the menu selection is limited. If you enjoy thick - doughy pizza, you will enjoy their's. A good "chewy" slice of pizza. God Bless! read more

The buffet is great. I love the bacon cheeseburger pizza, deluxe pizza, bacon chicken ranch. I love the Italian Big Sinker submarine sandwich. The service was good. Plenty of parking. For pizza made with a conveyor belt, Al's is my favorite. read more

I have never heard of an italian stromboli with lettuce and tomato. Or a mushroom stromboli with provolone and pizza sauce. Let alone a cheese steak sub with no cheese. Most definitely will not be ordering from them again. Shameful. read more

Great pizza really tasty breadsticks and wonderful cheese top 5 pizza I have ever had

The subs and pizzas here are perfect. So good, and the square pizza cuts are always best!

Wifi is crappy. Nice waitress and decent food. The tunes were great! Soooo much food! read more

Al's Pizza - Family outing! - Pizza Near Me - Sidney, Ohio

Al's sold business. New owner changed the pizza sauce. Not nearly as good as the original Al's pizza. What an idiot! Save money, get a frozen pizza read more

I used to love their pizza but last time I got one it was all provolone cheese. Hard to chew and not great flavor. I might try them again in the future. read more

Absolutely love this place!! Food is delicious and reasonably priced. I've never had an issue with my order being incorrect.

I Made a Togo order and I had to ask the lady to repeat everything because I had no clue what she was saying because she was talking so fast. read more

Address needs updated. Perfect place to eat. Best food in the area. Great servers, awesome owners. You must get the half pound cheeseburger.

When I ordered double pepperoni ...I expect to get a pepperoni in every slice...didn't happen...look like the usual amount...disappointed

Great pizza! Been a fan since they opened! Good local restraunt

Al's Pizza is another old time Sidney favorite place to get a good pizza. I would probably rate Al's Pizza as the best in Sidney if you like the old fashioned thick crust piled high with toppings (Cassanoes Pizza a close second). Their salads are pretty good sized and the subs are also good. If you like the "old fashion" thick crusted pizza, this is the place to go. You can eat in or carry out. The usual time to wait on carry out is 15-20 minutes. read more

I ordered a Al's pizza for delivery. It just wasn't that good. I hated how they put the cheese on top of the toppings rather than toppings on top of cheese. The pepperoni - salami and sausage had no chance to be crisp buried under the cheese. read more

Overall, I love this place for pizza. The chicken bacon ranch is my personal favorite. Our family likes to go to the buffet, but it is sometimes hit or miss for selection and freshness - especially if you don't go during the prime lunch hour. The pizza served on the buffet is actually different (lower quality) than the pizza you order. I'd definitely recommend ordering a pizza - and be sure to get the cinnamon sticks, so good! read more

Holy crap. You can go all around the world; the best 2 pizza places are in Sidney. Al's, and if you live in Sidney, you know the other. The buffet is great. The subs are great. The pizzas are by far the best you will have that come from a conveyor belt oven. They deliver out in the country too. Taco Pizza is an awesome speciality of theirs too. Would recommend to all. read more

The service was horrible. I was overcharged for my pizza. I caught the mistake before I left the parking lot. When I went back to tell them, the lady blamed ME for not having caught it before paying. She refused to reimburse me because I had used a card to pay, and apparently that made it impossible to correct. She recharged me and supposedly voided the incorrect charge. I was actually charged TWICE for the one pizza. Als refuses to correct this. I have filed a fraud claim with my bank. I will never spend money at Al's again. read more

still one of the best in sidney for pizza after the re-modle dinein is nice but prices have soared to new hight if u like pizza its good stuff but your gonna pay for it a little high for pizza and subs read more

Was trying to get pizza as a surprise for the kids at home, worked with me and pizza was hot fresh and devoured when i got home lol, thanks Al's!!! read more

The pizza is ok but beware of fraudulent charges on your credit card. I had to fight them through my bank to get my money back after being charged DOUBLE. The manager took zero responsibility for this and refused to help in any way. read more