This is my ABSOLUTE FAVORITE pizza place of all time!! It's just a shame that I have to drive so far to experience it (I live in IN). I always order pizza, but I've been known to order Cassano Skins and chicken tenders. ALL of which are outstanding! (I hear that the subs are terrific as well). Back to the pizza. It is faultless. The crust, the sauce, the toppings. And ALWAYS baked to perfection, with just the right browning of their provolone cheese (I believe they shred it right there in their kitchen). We almost always do carry out, and it never fails to be a grand experience too. They're always on time, and the people never fail to be friendly and courteous; both on the phone when ordering and when pick up is made. There are several other pizza establishments in Sidney, but I have never tried them. I've found the very best, so why would I bother? (NO offense intended ) read more

A Sunday night favorite at our house. Good pizza, prompt service. Best pizza in this area.

First off I tried to order a meatball sub. NO meatballs. So I order a ham and cheese instead. I get my order and open my ham and cheese. Bun woth ham,no more. I call them to get a replacement with everything I'm supposed to get on it. It arrives in about 15mins. A bun, ham and cheese. No onions,peppers, tomato,lettuce,dressing or amything else that's supposed to come on it. WOW. Don't thinl I'll order from there again. Just as bad as Al's.1 read more

I love this pizza and I am a pizza hound. My order was prompt and perfect. Family friendly environment with clean ambiance

Always delish! Great team of workers. Always busy. Never had a bad pizza. Love this place.

We like getting pizza from here. My husband and I like the deluxe. Not all Cassano's around here are the same but they have never changed and we love that. read more

I'm going to be very upfront about this review. I am partial to Cassano's and may not be completely unbiased. That said. I love this place! The server was super nice and took great care of us during our lunch meeting. The food was of course awesome. Who doesn't love a great sausage and pepperoni pizza on a wonderful thin crust. The salad was actually a surprise, but it shouldn't have been because everything here is great. Now, I'm not from Sidney so this is the part that I really love about this location. All the hometown pictures on the wall and cozy feel just make you feel good. Stop by here if you are in the area. It's a wonderful little pizza place. Why we don't have them in Cincinnati is a complete mystery to me. Next time I talk to the owners I will ask them. read more

Cassano's Pizza & Subs - Personal size pepperoni and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Sidney, Ohio

See all

Pizza was excellent and service for pickup was fast and friendly. We also had the breadsticks which were excellent.

Great food, good service at a great value! Hope the menu pics help some folks realize this is a great spot for a few beers and a pizza! read more

See all

Everything is awesome there. I don't get pizza like this in TX. Service was outstanding!

best pizza I have ever had good breadsticks good cheese and pizza sauce good potato skins all around great. Great service

Best pizza ever!!! I use to live in Sidney Ohio but moved to Georgia when I was young and every time we come to visit we have to have Cassanos. I wish they would open one in Georgia read more

The people are great and the pizza is yummy! It's really nice inside. We had the deluxe pizza I recommend it.

If you are familiar with Cassano's Pizza King, this is not one. That's really odd since it has the same logo. But, their staff will tell you, they are independently owned. And apparently not like a franchise. Cassano's Pizza King does not list this location. Sure, they make pizza, but it became apparent as we tried to order from the www.cassanos.com website, they don't have the same menu. You cannot order online. Call the restaurant and they will tell you, they don't have a website or internet menu. "Come in and we'll give you a to go menu." So no specials that the other restaurants have, no toasted raviolis, no Big 60. Oddly no breadsticks, at least not resembling breadsticks... more like Pillsbury crescent rolls that weren't allowed to rise. So no Pepperoni Stuffed Sticks, no Jalapeño Stuffed Sticks. No tater babies. The pizza we ordered was okay. A decent Ohio pepperoni pizza, square cut, thin crust. But not the Cassano's we know from the Dayton-Springfield area. This is more like a "Coming to America'" McDowell's when you were expecting McDonald's! If you are from Sidney, you might know this and it's okay. But if you go there expecting Vic Cassano's, be prepared. read more

Always delicious food and the prices are reasonable for a high quality pizza. We order for pickup since they don't deliver to our area. Our order is always ready on time and is hot and fresh read more

This is my favorite pizza in Sidney. We typically get carry out as the seating is a bit small.

Great locally owned business. Reasonably priced. Well staffed. Good food. I would recommend to anyone.

What's going on with this place? I use to really like this place, but now the quality of the food has decreased and it takes forever to get the food. Customer service is ok, but I have had better customer service at Chick-fil-A in Troy (of course, they have the best service around). Still, the pizza has too much cheese and not enough tomato sauce. Overall this is a 2 star restaurant that people think is SO good. I know, it's Sidney, which doesn't have a single thing to do, but there's better pizza in Sidney then Cassano's today. read more

Driving up from Cinci to Michigan, we stopped into this Pizza joint for lunch. We asked the server how the wings were, and she told us they were quite popular, so me and my buddy ended up ordering that with some breadsticks. The breadsticks came out first steaming, but they ended up being doughy in the middle... then the wings came out... they are the worst wings I've ever had, completely flavorless and disgusting. We asked for hot sauce and all they had was mild verde cholula. The sauce made the wings worse. My buddy and I could stomach only 3.5 wings each out of the two dozen we got (we can put down wings btw). Then we got our bill and the wings were not priced as advertised on the menu. The pizza here might be good, but the wings are not, and good pizza joints should make good wings. At least the dogs will be happy when we bring back the hefty amount of leftovers. The server was nice though, and could see our disappointment. read more

Cassano's Pizza & Subs - The wings... - Pizza Near Me - Sidney, Ohio

have been coming here for years. GOOOD Fooood!!! good value too! lots of sports teams come in after games, it is always busy! Love the vibrant atmosphere! read more

Service and food at Sidney location are always great. They do their best. Can't go wrong with the deluxe pizza, any of the subs or pastas.

A favorite Pizza place. Love the pizza and the servers are all friendly. Community owned and operated. Took my kids there when young and now we get our Pizza from Cassano's when we have pizza night. read more

Was craving see pizza while in Sidney and based in reviews this was the place. First impression was the box was all the weight and after opening the box it was confirmed. After trying the pizza it was a good thing crust small pepperoni pizza that is way over priced. I don't eat big meals and wanted a small pizza and this left me hungry. read more

Cassano's Pizza & Subs - Good but over priced. - Pizza Near Me - Sidney, Ohio

Wow! Very pleasantly surprised tonight with my carryout order. Cassano's has always been "ok", I personally have never felt it was as "Great" as others in Sidney express it is, but tonight it was EXCEPTIONAL! It was like eating a perfect pizza. It even LOOKED delicious and tasted even better. Got a couple of sides as well, all equally good. I hope this is the new normal for them. Whomever prepared my order was on point today....thank you! It's hard to find good food anymore, this really made my day. I'm looking forward to devouring my leftovers tomorrow! read more

This is one of the reasons I always look forward to visiting Sidney, OH. The extra large thin crust pizza with whatever toppings your heart desires then cooked well done is the absolute best in the entire world!! read more

Cassano's Pizza & Subs - a person taking a slice - Pizza Near Me - Sidney, Ohio

Best Cassano's pizza around. And also our favorite pizza joint in Sidney. The crust is good and just the right amount of toppings.

Subs are great !!! With less onion it would be a lot better !! The big cheese pizza is awesome !!!

Cassano's Pizza are the absolute best however..............as a senior on a fixed income a little pricey. If I may make a polite suggestion, could you consider one day a week having a senior discount on pizzas? Thanks for your consideration! read more

Favorite pizza if you enjoy a light, thin crust! Food is always fresh. Staff is not super friendly. Last carry out order the person taking our order was extremely rude. We were confused because the menu on http://places.singleplatform.com/cassanos-pizza-and-subs-11/menu?ref=google that is linked to this location is incorrect and we did not know that. The man would cut me off as I was ordering to tell me they don't have a deep fryer. When I tried to apologize and question the menu that was online he got very short with me. Despite being rude, food was good and what we (were able) to order. read more

This place is so consistently frustrating! WHY, every time we come here do we stand at the designated "stand here to be seated" oh, and also "RIGHT here to pay" location - up to a couple minutes - and can make eye contact with as many as 6 different employees who make no acknowledgment of our presence?! I swear I'm not wearing an invisible suit, don't look like the elephant person, am typically showered, arms aren't crossed and am even likely wearing a smile (granted, I'm sure the degree of smile has diminished over the course of these s*ck visits). The friendliness of the person telling us to "seat ourselves" was, I suppose, "friendly" if one considers the command didn't include projectile spittle accompanying the attitude of frustration and impatience in our having chosen to dine in their establishment. Although not necessary, as we knew what we wanted, the slow-to-arrive menus were in practice still probably a good idea. Should fear and intimidation accompany ones placement of an order with their server? Well anyway. The drinks arrived before the pizza, so I guess that was good. The salad ("appetizer") also arrived before the pizza so I guess having been able to track down another server (as ours seemed to be donning the invisible suit) to request said salad was also good. *Why am I SO demanding?! Who the h*ll else wants condiments such as salt and pepper and why does it irritate me to have to ask EVERY time?! I'm such a jerk! Pizza finally came out. It was hot and tasted good. It was nice sitting on the patio. Almost equally nice was seeing the server show back up to check on our meal more than halfway through. Guess one never knows, maybe during the latter part of the meal we may have needed something, you know, say the first and only soda refill for a nearly empty cup? In the end, our dripping-with-appreciation-for-our-patronage server nearly simultaneously dropped the check (careful not to make any eye contact when thanking us for coming in) while practically making a 180 dash from the table. Maybe she was in a hurry to *greet* the next invisible guests. Bottom line: In spite of the food nearly consistently tasting good, the service is nearly always as consistently very slow and very poor. What continues to bring us back is that it's only one of two places to sit outdoors without hovering clouds of cigarette smoke. It's also close. And I'm also always hopeful (or a glutton for punishment)... read more

Best pizza around. If the wait is long don't let it bother you because the pizza is delicious and worth the wait.

Waited over an hour for delivery they said 20 mins called told it would be another 30 mins went and picked up pizza .It was burnt and very cold read more

My all time favorite pizza! We get Cassano's every time we go home! Love their pizza, breadsticks and subs. I also worked here for over 5 years and both owners care a lot about their business, employees, and customers. They put a lot of focus on cleanliness and service! read more

Love Cassano's pizza ... it's my go to pizza restaurant when I'm in New Bremen visiting my boyfriend ... the sauce on their pizza is sooo good, such a great flavor their pizza, garlic bread with cheese, and salad is overall great quality, and the price is sooo, worth the drive ... my boyfriend eats a whole medium pizza by himself ... I was also impressed with how well this establishment is managed which is always a plus, since I prefer to dine in ... definitely going back read more

On Tuesday 8-10-2020 we stopped by our favorite Cassano's Pizza place in Sidney. Found this to be one of our worst times there. Wife ordered a salad and when it came it was all the heels of the head of lettuce. When pointed out to our server she said it must be a bad batch that came in. No sorry or let me get you another. Then when the pizza came the crust was so tough they hadn't even cut all the away through it. When we asked the server about that she just shrugged it off. Sorry to say it will be awhile before we try them again. Server never even came back to check on how things were or refill our drinks. read more

I've been getting Cassano's pizza for years but we nearly always get it to go because the place is so small. Their pizza and bread sticks are good but they ALWAYS forget to put in the extra sauces for our bread sticks. Today was no different. When I told the girl there was only 1 of each she said they were double the size. I didn't ask for double sauce. I asked for 2 of each. She said it would be extra. Whatever you have to do. I just need 2 of each because we don't double dip. I was reaching for my wallet to get out the $2.00 when some guy (I want to say he was a manager/owner) very rudely said he'd put them in single containers. Then he said I should have told them that when I placed the order. Guess what genius I did exactly that when I called. I can handle a lot of screw ups with my order but don't treat me like I'm an idiot or an inconvenience simply because you didn't do your job correctly. I said some things and used language of which I'm not proud but that's not the reason I will ever go back in to this place. Neither will I ever recommend it to anyone. read more

Cassano's has been a place to go for years and years if you want a good pizza. The building is on the small side and a line of people waiting on a table is usual on most weekend nights. The sub sandwiches are also good and there is outside seeting available on the warm months. read more

Best pizza in Shelby Co. Don't forget to order the cornmeal and salt under the crust. Perfection

Phenomenal pizza. Just plain phenomenal. This is one of the only Cassano's this still use the old way of preparing the pizza with the old concrete ovens. The taste is obviously better. The decor of this restaurant is great too, vintage sports oriented. Has a patio, beer, great service. Cassano's is the best pizza on earth, and this restaurant is the best Cassano's for sure. Its a franchise, but believe it or not, the franchises are the only ones who make the pizzas the old delicious way. read more

This is my favorite pizza on the planet. Perhaps I love it so much because I grew up eating it, however, even my wife fell in love with Cassano's pizza when she first had it. I try and order a pizza at least once every time I visit home. I have also tried the Troy branch and it was just not as good. It would be 5 stars but I do admit when I dine in often times the service is questionable. But when I am there with a beer and having my favorite pizza it doesnt really bother me. . . read more