We go here all the time. It's a great casual restaurant. Their pizza is the best anywhere. They…read morehave a good beer/drink selection. They have these won ton nachos that are amazing! I'd definitely recommend!

Waited almost 15 minutes to get drinks. Had to go to bar to order drinks and was told will bring…read moreout drinks. When waitress came to table with drinks she asked if we had ordered food. I told her no we haven't had a waitress till she came and she started getting sassy about how the were open past there normal operating times for a party. No sorry you had to wait nothing . Everyone else that came in after us was getting served before we did.! Will not go back!!!

This pizza place is totally awesome. This place is not like your typical franchise pizza spot, but…read morethe taste of their delicious pizza is worth the wait. It was hard to get through on the telephone to order, so I went in. For a Friday night, I expected a wait. The owner said she selected the sauce, and that counts on a pizza. This place did a fabulous job and you will be completely satisfied.

B Pizza Artist!! I tried it couple weeks ago then came back for more within weeks!! DELICIOUS!!read more

Awesome pizza and cold beer.Their special recipe sausage, crispy crust makes the best pizza ever.read more

It's a great place to get pizza if you like dive bars. The sausage is homemade and the beers are…read morecold!

I LOVE Karen's. It is a family favorite and a pizza go to especially when we are unable to decide…read morewhere we would like to eat or order from. Delivery time can get lengthy during busy hours but that is going to be anywhere you go. LOVE. LOVE. LOVE.

Delicious pizza!!! Wonderful employees and management!!! We order every week!!! Love the Meat…read moreLovers pizza and the wings are crispy and yummy.

I drove by this place dozens of times before deciding to try it. It's much nicer that expected of…read morea "barn" restaurant. The dining room and bathrooms are clean and well kept. The service wasn't terribly quick, but I did come in right after a large group of senior hotties. Service was polite, smart and friendly. I had the 4pc wings with coleslaw and potatoe salad. The chicken was cooked perfectly and the wings were good sized (not like the BW3 disappointment wings). The breading was light and golden as advertised. The sides were excellent too. Pleasantly surprised by everything, and the pricing was very reasonable, too.

it's supposed to be a pizza not soup. WAY too much sauce. pizza is chewed not drank. had to enjoy…read moresomething that is spilling all over the place and is a soggy mess. figure out a method of measuring the proper amount of sauce and stop guessing. it makes for a bad experience and people won't come back.

We wanted a really good pizza during our trip as where we live it's hard to find a really good one…read more So we hopped on Yelp to see what we could see. This one had a great rating and we can see how it got one. It's a little bit out of the way but it's in a beautiful setting along the Miami River corridor. And the pizza is great. It takes 3 things to make a good pizza. The balance of the crust, the dough, the sauce, and the cheese. Everything else just adds to these 3 elements. This place does this well. They were fast, clean, and friendly. The right amount of toppings so you could taste each item without drowning out the other flavors of the pie. Just fabulous! You can eat outside if you choose or take out. As good as it gets. Highly recommended!

Tried Staunton County Store for a pizza and a pizza sub...both were phenomenally good!!! The new…read moreowners and the service was incredible and NO WAIT!! Will be ordering again soon!!!

I've tasted their great tasting fresh food pizza is good staffs friendly helpful their values good…read moreatmosphere is good ambiance is casual services are great I couldn't wait review them a time ago got some pizza never reviewed then their great for community

Sparky's pizza is an Urbana original! The dough for the crust is homemade in house and is truly…read moredelicious! My only dislike is that the onions are not cut fresh for either the pizza or the sub sandwiches.

Ambiance is minimal. A fair amount of table groupings. A TV playing the food network and nothing to…read moreblow you away with related to decor. Local OSU stuff on the walls. The kid at the counter was helpful. We wanted some onion rings but their fryer was down so we pivoted to order wings. I don't remember what sauce we had but we ordered 8 and it looked like the most pathetic basket of wings ever seen. Super small wings. They tasted good but it could be just because they were drenched in the sauce. Waited a while for the wings and even longer for the pizza. The pizza was good. Good amount of toppings. It wasn't bad pizza but it wasn't great. We couldn't tell why we weren't overly impressed with the pizza but it was just pizza. Pizza came out screaming hot, which was nice because the restaurant was chilly because it was below zero outside. So one upside is the pizza was hot and stayed hot for a while as we ate it. Hard to see as it sat at the end of a strip of other businesses as the end of the building away from the road. All in all, it wasn't bad pizza but we probably won't drive to Bellfontaine for Fat Boys. Gave it a 3 out of 5 because of what was mentioned plus the one menu on the Yelp site was old and the pizza we thought was going to be $19.99 ended up being almost $10 more than the new menu listing. Didn't think a medium pizza was worth $28 bucks...especially when two shared it and we only took a couple of pieces home.

We love Fat Boys pizza. We quit ordering for awhile because toppings were no where near the edge…read more And the price was one of the highest around. Which we don't mind paying for quality but can't justify it when you are not getting a complete product. After a couple of years we decided to give them another shot. Still great pizza and it seemed like they were finally getting the toppings to the edge until last night. And I understand prices are crazy on everything now but $49 for this pizza and 14 wings when the pizza was missing toppings.

The food was delicious we waited a little longer than usual for this place, but the pizza was worth…read morethe wait. The restaurant was clean and the outside dining area was also well kept. I heartily recommend Old Scratch Pizza in Troy, Ohio.

Old brick oven pizza with fresh, good quality ingredients. Love the hummus and veggies! Great place…read moreto relax and catch up with friends, especially on the patio. ​

You will not find a place that trys harder than this place. Food is delicious and quality…read moreingredients. Presented well in a wonderful atmosphere. Place was clean, well light and beautiful inside. The staff was knowledgeable, friendly and attentive. They hustle and work..The outside of the building was attentive, good signage and nice parking lot. Highly recommend you visit. We had the Chicago style deep dish pizza.

Went for my 55th bday tonight. So disappointed. Ordered Vodka pasta for my meal. After 30 min the…read morewaitress tells me they ran out. Fine so I got spaghetti which I was kinda bummed. But then I ask for the white chocolate cheesecake for dessert and she comes back to tell me sorry again but it's frozen. Doesn't offer a free dessert or even sing. Just all around not a good birthday experience at all. Being a server my whole life I know I would have made up for all these mishaps and made it extra special for my guest. Very bummed because this was my favorite restaurant as we are new to Ohio. Probably wont ever go back. Service is everything and this was a big fail.