Referred to this local famous pizza joint. Fast & casual: Order at counter & sit down & foods brought out to you. Guy at counter was gruff at 1st but had quirky sense of humor as he comes around frequently checking on you & cracking jokes. Rustic feel w/ old antique decor & lotsa wood. Good classic music too. Hot food came out fast - just as salads were done. Mac & cheese pizza - daughter loved. My BBQ chicken pizza was pretty good. Lotsa toppings. Spaghetti & meatballs were also enjoyed w/ the best breadsticks (long twisty ones). Side salads were huge - we coulda shared one. Drink station in middle affords free refills. Good value too for portions. read more

See all

Great pizza, small space to eat with a large party, but they are always willing to accommodate. Meat lovers and BLT are some of my family's favorites, to name a few. read more

Listen we're from Jersey, so the standard for pizza is pretty high. However, it got the job done. Flavor was good, crust was nice. But... it was the bbq chicken pizza that stole my heart. Mmmmmm! Delicious even leftover. Town is quaint and service was nice and this is a nice sentimental stop for our family. Our Jersey kids thought the pizza being cut into squares was quite funny. read more

Colonial Pizza - BBQ chicken pizzaa - Pizza Near Me - Cedarville, Ohio

See all

Classic small town pizza place. The staff are friendly and helpful. Pizza is always delicious!

Finally got a chance to stop in and get pizza a few weeks ago. The other two time we stopped, the place was packed, and so busy we were too busy to wait. Pizza is worth the drive to Cedarville, dough is chewy and had a good bit. I was disappointed with the antipasta salad, I would like a little more meat, cheese on it, and a nicer visual presentation (check out my review of Venecia Italian restaurant) We will defiantly come back, and we have learned to order ahead, and they will likely be packed or busy most of the time. read more

See all

Alright the food was amazing! Perfect crust! I mean you wanted to eat it all, the sauce so much flavor. Everything you would want when it a local small town pizza place. Atmosphere was great. The servers were nice and quick! Highly recommend! read more

Person taking order didn't know how to use the register. Waited 40 minutes, still no pizza. Several people had the same issue and went to the register wanting to know why the wait. They weren't that busy either. No apologies. read more

Very good pizza I recommend . The place is very nice , well maintained, decoration is country still, handicap accesible and pet friendly. read more

See all

First time here and found almost everything we tried was good. We arrived before it got crazy with dine in and carry out. We tried the pizza, two different subs, potato skins and mozzarella sticks. The pizza is a hand tossed crust with great flavor, the sauce is a sweet sauce. The only thing we tried that we didn't like was the mozzarella sticks they were baked and not long enough for the cheese to get hot and melted. read more

See all

Coming from someone that works at a pizza place I was reluctant to try this place, but my buddy wanted me to go. I'm glad I did... one of the best places I could have stopped at. The pizza had the freshest toppings in the area, and there was a generous amount of sauce. The wings were as large as my hand and cooked to perfection. Any time I'm in the area I will be returning here.... It's my new favorite read more

We have been long time customers. Colonial is expensive so we do not order often. We just ordered this evening to support a fundraising event. We got an 18" BLT pizza. It was inedible. It tasted like bacon bits piled on crust. The bacon bits were held together with cheese and kept falling off of the crust. There was way too much "bacon" on it and it was teeny tiny crumbles. I'm positive it was bacon bits or bacon cooked in bulk one day a week, chopped up and refrigerated. $30 bucks down the drain because we couldn't even chew it! Colonial used to have nice large chunks of bacon on the pizza- not teeny crumbles of dry unchewable bits. I left my review at 4 stars because one bad experience doesn't mean I'll knock off more than one star. We will not be ordering any time in the near future, though read more

Colonial Pizza - Uneaten pizza with tiny bacon crumbles. - Pizza Near Me - Cedarville, Ohio

See all

Good pizza. I could have ordered better, perhaps. We ordered 2 large pizzas, One more traditional and one without meat and low dairy. The regular pizza was as expected. Eaten quickly by teens. The veggie pizza was unremarkable... now... maybe I should have tried harder to find out if there were other veggies I could have added... like banana peppers or jalapeño peppers, more bell peppers or whatever, but as is, it was a bit boring. But- that may have been my fault! My recommendation- give it a try! But if you want a veggie pizza- try to see what additional veggies you can add to flavor it up. As for advice to the business, I would suggest to try hard to feed your plant based customers well- lots of veggies on veggie pizza- because those plant based eaters might be the mom who pays the bill. I'll try this again in the near future- and advocate for more veggies when I place my order. Thank you to colonial for making our dinner on a busy day! read more

Good pizza. The service is good as well. They do offer a rewards program to Cedarville University students. The decor is pretty and comfortable feel. read more

Best pizza ever!! I love the crust, chewy but a little crispy. Love the dining room, very eclectic feel. Great baked goods, and breadsticks. Used to come here all the time in college and I go back every time I'm in town. I miss it on Friday nights when I'm too far to order! Buffalo chicken is my fav read more

Colonial Pizza - What's left of our 18" buffalo chicken pizza. We buy and add ranch! Yum! - Pizza Near Me - Cedarville, Ohio

I've had their pizza, wings and subs everything was great. Clean and very friendly. I would highly recommend this establishment. read more

Sooo gooood!! First trip and we got a veggie pizza and a deep dish pepperoni. Very good! Really enjoyed the toppings and the sauce was not sickly sweet like Little Caesars or Pizza Hut. A little pricey but delicious! read more

Colonial Pizza - Veggie Pizza and deep dish Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Cedarville, Ohio

Colonial Pizza has friendly staff and great pizza! Their dough is make in-house freshly every morning, which makes for some amazing pizza, breadsticks, and more! read more

This place is a hidden gem. The food is great! The wings are one of the best around. The pizza is amazing. My only complaint is that they have done away with their online ordering. They updated their menu with new pricing and the online ordering went away. Online ordering capabilities are essential and critical in todays market. They could be making so much more money. The ambiance is quite unique. I believe this was an old train station so it's very nostalgic. I highly recommend at least trying this place. read more

We stopped by on a trip through town. The restaurant was very cozy inside. It was Friday night and the phone was ringing off the hook for carry out orders. The daily special was a one topping 18 inch pizza and a basket of cheese covered breadsticks. The breadsticks came out really fast and they were delicious. The pizza came out just as we finished the breadsticks, so perfect timing. The pizza was huge and our family of four could only eat half of it! This restaurant was keeping up all of the COVID restrictions- seating spaced apart, wiping everything down and mask wearing. I highly recommend this place! read more

Nice decorated walls with laminated newspapers from decades ago, tv show posters, arts, etc. even the restroom was pretty cozy and decorated with art. But despite all that i didn't quite enjoyed their margarita and olive pizza. It was quite bland and generic. Or may be the ones I ordered were like that. I don't know. Otherwise it's well decorated place, interiorly. read more

See all

Went for a hike at the local Green county park and found this wonderful delicious pizza place. Awesome home made dough and it shows. Delicious! read more

Not much to choose from when visiting this part of Ohio but Colonial Pizza was a "college campus" suggestion. The place was a bit divey which lead me to believe that this pizza just my have a shot with me. Nothing really special about the Franks Red Hot chicken wings but those garlic Parmesan wings was on point the thin crust sausage and pep had just the right amount of sauce and the garlic butter that I slathered on the pizza crust and cheese bread was delicious. The steak sandwich was decent but that chicken bacon tach sandwich was slamming. AND NO I DIDNT EAT ALONE! anytime I'm back this way it's a pretty chill place to grab a pizza only thing I hated was walking out without grabbing a slice of that Oreo pie and a couple slices of that Turtle pie DAMN DAMN DAMN !!!! read more

Colonial Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cedarville, Ohio

Pizza was very good; I like the square cut. Staff was very friendly. Atmosphere makes you feel cozy.

We placed an online order for pickup, two pizza's, one pepperoni and one chicken alfredo pizza, and an Asian salad. When we came in to pick it up, we were accused by the manager of having beer in our coffee cups and questioned several times about it while we waited to pick up our order. Then we received food that was not made as expected. The website states that the chicken alfredo pizza comes with chicken, Alfredo sauce, bacon, onions, and cheese, but our pizza only had chicken, cheese, and sauce. The website also states that the Asian salad comes with spring mix, red cabbage, craisins, almonds, rice noodles, chicken and Asian dressing. Our salad was made with iceberg lettuce instead of spring mix and came with raspberry dressing instead of Asian dressing. Since we were visiting from out of town, there was no way to have our order corrected. But when we called in to let them know our order was wrong, we were met with a rude response from the owners son that our order wasn't made incorrectly, but that the website was incorrect and they apparently are not responsible for what their website says. We will not be eating at this restaurant again. read more

See all

Have ordered from here over a dozen times in the last year and the food has always been awesome. They have a wide selection of pizza, sandwiches and pasta and they are are really good. The best review I can give it that we will continue to order from them. read more

Stopped here on a ride, it's just a couple blocks off the bike trail. Nice place with all the sports pics and other memorabilia on walls, clean, and the staff were pleasant. Had the Saturday Special which was a salad, garlic bread and a drink which all hit the spot and came to less than $5. read more

We went here today to see the Grinch. Not expecting to find my new favorite pizza place. The service was great. The food was piping hot. My new favorite pizza. That cheese. Mmmhmmm. My son had the best breadsticks of his whole little life. And it definitely didn't break my bank. We'll be back!! read more

I ordered the Margherita pizza. Barely any cheese and way to much tomato. The bottom crust was still raw. With the COVID rules, they lock you out the back patio so you can't go back in the back door. Instead, you have to go all the way around. If I go back,I think I'll just stick with a plain cheese pizza. read more

Carry out only -no dine in due to COVID. Pizza was excellent - very fresh and hot. Would definitely eat here again.

If we're talking best pizza in town, Colonial's the place. It's also the only place. They have solid pizza and sub's. The menu has a lot of good choices and they have good hours. If you're looking for a good place to eat for dinner, colonial is a solid choice. It's not the delicous thin crust east coast pizza I've become accustomed to, but for an Ohio pizza joint it's not bad. They also have Pepsi, which we all know is the inferior cola. Overall a solid choice for food in the 'ville! read more

Good pizza. Great option in town when you get tired of cafeteria pizza. They close early and I am pretty certain that they do not deliver. Fun for groups and parties and pick-a-dates. read more

Nice atmosphere. Pizza was delicious. Good crust. Nice place to grab a quick meal. Breadsticks were great. Ordered a large pizza and had plenty to take home. Staff was friendly. read more

Pizza is fine, can be a bit on the greasy side...Breadsticks and cheesesticks are a hit. Salads are also very good. Service can be a bit on the slow side, but it's understandable because there are usually only two or three people running the whole show. read more

Considering it's in the middle of the corn fields it's a good pizza joint, although it's priced a little higher as there is no competition.

Not a bad pizza shop, but there aren't too many food options in this college town. Their wings are good & so is their spicy hot sauce pizza.

Visiting in town. Realize businesses may have altered hours for Labor Day so called ahead. Message said were open till 11. At 930 we're closed. Bush league. And very disappointing. We actually stayed in Cedarville b/c we had been very happy with the pizza on a previous visit. Maybe our first and last. Will look for a different town and a different pizza next time. read more

Service was terrible and We had to wait a long time even when we called in 15 minutes before. Wouldn't eat there again

Three words: Todd's big meat. That's the order of any self-respecting customer with half a brain and an empty stomach. Although more expensive than your typical cheese pizza, TBM will always leave you satisfied and counting down the seconds until your next meal read more

By far the best pizza around! period!!!! Always polite. Order does not take long even when walking in for a take out. Large pizza with everything on it is our favorite! My daughter and Grandkids will be here soon and they'll get to enjoy it. read more

Colonial Pizza - Wil.i.am and myself in Columbus Ohio. - Pizza Near Me - Cedarville, Ohio

We ordered a pizza and they charged our card aNd told us it would be ready at 6:45. We called them at 7:00 and told them our pizza was no where to be found. They said it would be 10 mins bc the delivery guy just left and our pizza was supposed to be delivered first. They called us back at 7:25 and told us that they couldn't find our order, even though our card had been charged and they put us on hold to talk to the manager. After several minutes of waiting, they transferred me to the wrong person and we had to wait some more. They then said that we could reorder and repay for our order. The manager was very inconsiderate and did not help the situation. I was very unimpressed by this experience read more