This is the go to pizza if you live close by or happen to be in the area. I like the grandma pie which is jam packed with flavors. Try the other pizza options but you will be back for Brooklyn Pizza Crew. They had chocolate chip cookies, I don't know if they still have them, but if they do, skip them. read more

Food: 3.5/5 With a pizzaria or two on many blocks, Brooklyn Pizza Crew is better than most. The pizza is solid. Thin, crisp crust, slightly chewy dough. Definitely try the garlic knots. Service: 5/5 Good quality service that's effective and cordial. Ambiance: 3.5/5 Low-key, chill vibes. Two long picnic tables that allow for communal dining. Not a spot for date night but does the trick for a quick bite of quality New York City Pizza. read more

Was looking for classic New York style pizza and this really hit the spot! The Brooklyn pizza had a classic feel, with tomato sauce and cheese on top. The crust was on the thicker side but the dough was chewy and delicious. If you like more toppings on your pizza, the Sophia Loren was a great option, with slices of juicy tomato, cheese, garlic, and basil. This one was a little more heavy than the Brooklyn, but still very good. Delivery was quick and easy! read more

See all

Great pizza, it was reheated to perfection and so delicious. I ordered the mushroom and it had the perfect amount of truffle oil and so many mushrooms (in the best way). I also ordered the garlic knot bc it looked so yummy and i highly recommend. Service was quick and there's a few picnic style tables to sit at if you're staying! read more

Garlic knots taste so good here! They look so authentic and baked from scratch! Doesn't look like it's frozen and very freshly made! Margherita pizza is on par and fresh too. Not overly saucy or over seasoned. All the condiments and ingredients on the pizza make the taste exact to the touch! I will come by again! read more

See all

Bro ! shit is super dirt , realistically what's the plan here?? never nothing hot and ready ? Even at 11:30 when you supposed to start you're day you're pizza looking sad! I just got my pizza on a Friday night and it's DEAD FCKN COLD ?? it's 8:30 pm and all trays are empty, a quarter of some old pepperoni and they brought out some cold regular cheese. EVERY OTHER TRAY IS EMPTY ! EITHER SELL OR DO BETTER! read more

I ordered the large paesano pizza for takeout. It's a pretty good neighborhood spot for pizza. There was a generous amount of toppings and a good proportion of cheese and sauce. The sausage was perfectly tender and seasoned My main gripe is that the bottom crust wasn't crispy at all (borderline soggy). read more

Brooklyn Pizza Crew - Paisano, large - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

delicious vegan options & high quality ingredients yet somehow still affordable prices

I order pizza from this place for a pizza party I was throwing at my job. I ordered the margarita pizza pie, the gluten free pizza pie and a salad. Everything was delicious! I highly recommend the pizza here. read more

See all

Tried Brooklyn Pizza Crew for delivery and was very pleased. It's always risky trying a new pizza spot and Brooklyn Pizza Crew did not dissapoint :/ The highlights were the garlic knots---absolutely outstanding! They're larger than most and come in four per order. If you don't like sharing, get your own lol! The Margherita pizza is decent, not my favorite overall but I'm eager to try their grandma pizza next time and individual slices since those seem to be consistently good. read more

I love love love Williamsburg Pizza / the brooklyn pizza crew! from not only throwing amazing live events and having sick merch and now a cool new rewards app WBP makes a really solid slice! my favorite is thejr grandma slice, the crust is soft and buttery , the sauce is light and zesty and the cheese super fresh!!! I always go here when I can! they also make a killer heart shaped pizza that is customizable which is great for parties and special events read more

The Cup and Char Grandma is shrinking in Size! Shrinkflation has hit the Pizza Making Market... This was a great Pizza. THE PIZZA FIT THE BOX , 2 MONTHS AGO...NO MORE.... read more

Sophia Loren was tasty. No complaints. So good I ate the leftovers an entire week. Kind of pricey for the area but I'd go back, not a lot of other good pizza spots in the area. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Crew - Sophia Loren LG - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Not sure how I'm suddenly outside of all of their Brooklyn delivery ranges despite ordering delivery from them once a week for months and genuinely living in the middle of the triangle among three locations, so I really can't be bothered to rate them well anymore! They were good but are you fucking kidding me? It's ten minutes by car. read more

An easy-to-miss slice joint from the same people as Williamsburg Pizza. Got the Cup and Char (pepperoni Grandma slice), and it was damn good. Did I also spend $1 on a single garlic knot? Guilty. But it was a dollar well spent. Super nice folks, good amount of seating inside. read more

See all

This is my first time trying this place. But I will say I'm glad I did. I was pleasantly surprised of the different types of pizza they had. The person at the register was really sweet and patient. And inside was really quaint and fun. I love the Brooklyn airbrush on the wall. The pizzas I did order was really good and tasty. When I got home I put hot honey on the Brooklyn pizza, which took it to another level. I will definitely be back. read more

Great brick oven pizza around the corner from me. I love there pies and so does my family. Great all the time

We ordered a grandma pizza with mushrooms and a salad for delivery. When the food showed up there was pepperoni on the pizza (we are vegetarians) plus the pizza was ice cold and the salad soggy. Called Brooklyn Pizza Crew to let them know this and the response was "interesting." Then was told they would not only not deliver the correct pizza but they even fought me on getting a refund since I already had "the food in hand." When I explained for the 10th time that the order was incorrect I got a spiel about "that's not even my driver." I had no clue what he was talking about. "Look," I said. "My order was wrong. The food is ice cold. And since you won't re-deliver what we ordered, then I deserve a full refund." To which he grudgingly accepted. Of course he never called in the refund to GrubHub so I had to call back, several times, over the coming days to get him to do it and every time got the same attitude. Finally, I had to snitch to GrubHub (which I never do) and they refunded the full amount. This place does not respect customers and doesn't care that your 50 dollar order is incorrect and cold and will not lift a finger to make it right. read more

Great spot! I highly recommend it! They have a lot of variety of not just Pizza but also so many Toppings ( White Truffle Sauce, What?) As a teen who needs a quick snack after school Brooklyn Pizza Crew does not disappoint! read more

Great slice on the block. They stay open pretty late which is convenient for walking back from a happy hour or for a late bite to eat. I recommend the pepperoni and the Sophia Loren. I've never sat inside to eat, but they have limited tables to enjoy your meal. They also sell dough if you're looking for a place to buy some to make pizza at home! read more

The Calabrese is the meat-covered grandma pie of your pizza dreams.* Order it into a nearby bar, and you will be an absolute hero to all your drunken clown friends. Go ahead. Be a hero. ____________ *Red Onions, Sopressata, Cured Black Olives, Fresh Basil, Parmigiano-Reggiano, Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato Sauce. read more

See all

The best cheese slice in the neighborhood and maybe the best white slice in the city. The cheese slice has a crispy thin crust that easily holds up. Perfectly balanced amounts of cheese and sauce. Tasty crust. The white slice shares the same crust as the cheese slice. With dollops of ricotta plopped throughout the slice for small explosions of cheese. Well-seasoned so it's not a boring slice. read more

By far my favorite pizza in Brooklyn, the Cup and Char Grandma is incredible, as is the Paesano. Highly recommend!

The best example of New York pizzas out there. Most places serve greasy, doughy, floppy slices. Here they have quality ingredients and the cool their pizza until the crust is crispy. read more

My favorite place for pizza takeout/delivery. Caeser salad is nothing special but gets the job done. I love the margherita and the grandma is sooooooooo good. I always get the grandma when I'm ordering for multiple people. Orders are almost always delivered more quickly than anticipated. Recently I accidentally received the wrong order number, called, and the correct order was here in no time. read more

I grew up in Italy ... so somewhat qualified to talk pizza. This place gets a 5 star but I must say, that Cup And Char was REALLY CHARED and burned as you can see but didn't bother to call it in. . Quality ingredients are noticeable... if it's not quality, then they definitely know how to hide that fact. It's incredibly fresh and the crust is superb. Doughy, chewy and crispy all at the same time and toppings are not scarse. Everything is distributed evenly and with care. You can tell. I have had pizza that looks like an old man's head with a combover. Blah The only problem I have is they don't deliver to my address, it's a short 5 min. Drive distance on the same same street and I have To use Uber eats. And Uber eats is a STUPID expensive service with fees and delivery charges they can't explain. It's just fees.. A $27.50 will cost you $42 or so....I am not cheap... just don't like to be taken for a ride. I had a special discount with them so I ordered these, it was a lot since I live alone (hey, I did have a friend over...don't judge me)....I put the rest in the freezer for a rainy day pizza cravings. ...like tomorrow can be one.. or tonight. SORRY... Neither one of the pies made it whole to their photo shoot... oops ... so so good read more

Brooklyn Pizza Crew - Cup and char grandma - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The newest location from the guys behind Williamsburg Pizza is now open in Crown Heights. Aside from the rebranding and some exciting new off-menu pies, it's the same great pizza we know and love from the growing mini-chain. I got the classic Brooklyn Slice with Pepperoni and a Grandma, as well as a newer creation, an Apple Bacon square slice, which is also topped with walnuts and Gorgonzola and all works surprisingly well together. I am definitely coming back for more of the excellent secret menu stuff, like their take on the L&B Spumoni square style. read more

See all

We often order a regular pie or add the homemade sausage. Very good, fast pies. Nice sauce, nice crust. Definitely a cut above your average NY slice. read more

I order from this place all the time because often the pizza is great but I'm giving it a three because the quality is really inconsistent. I've had pizzas arrive that are cold or haven't been cut or the majority of the cheese is stuck to the top of the box. read more

First time grabbing a classic pepperoni pie and did not disappoint. Huge slices, sturdy crispy crust and plenty of flavor. Excited to try their cup & char Grandma style next. Would rec as a go-to spot if you're in the western Crown Heights area! read more

Classic NY slices at a great price, what more can you ask for, I love the friendly staff and overall vibes here, a good selection of drinks and the cookies are fresh baked too. A go-to spot in my book, I always leave feeling satisfied! read more

Love the pepperoni pizza with onions here. It's addictive. I order this monthly for sure probably more often. They make the pizza super quickly. If you are in the neighborhood I'd pickup. You'll be eating at least 20 minutes earlier read more

This place is amazing! I ordered a pizza from here and it was delicious. I ended up getting a vegan pizza because I can't have cheese, but put pepperoni on it because I do love meat. Everything was so fresh. The sauce was amazing, and wow, that crust. It was soft and not too crispy like at some places. They didn't cheap out on the toppings, and the pizza came pretty quickly. I ordered garlic knots too which were pretty solid. I'm not in this area too often, but next time I am, I'll make a point to stop over at this pizza shop. read more

One of the best Brooklyn pizza spots, which says a lot. A little fancier than your dollar slice joint but not ridiculous or pretentious. Love the square pies and even the white pie, which I find bland elsewhere, Is spot on and delicious. read more

Probably the worst margarita pie I've ever purchased. Barely any sauce on the pie. More crust than pizza.. Not enjoyable at all .. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Crew - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

We order pizza here at least once a week- the last three weeks have pretty bad- a burnt pie, an over sauced pie with virtually no cheese and now a pie that isn't fresh. The first two occasions we informed the staff of the issues and all we got was- Sorry. We will no longer be ordering from Brooklyn pizza crew. They have definitely changed ownership, as this location used to have great customer service. But now we can no longer rely on food quality or customer service. Also-Please check your order before you leave the store. read more

Our family orders a large pie every week; unfortunately, it has been burnt several times in the past months. Service has also dropped dramitically; it's time for a new spot... read more

After a long day of sightseeing in the city we were looking for a good pizza place for dinner. We started searching Yelp for a place nearby where we are staying. This place popped up and had mostly good reviews so we decided to give it a go! We ordered a large pizza...extra cheese and easy on the sauce. My husband walked to pick it up and it was ready in about 15 min. It was still hot by the time he got back. The pizza was great! It has a great taste and the crust was good too. The slices were HUGE! I forgot how big a large can be from these local pizza places! We each only ate one slice and were full. We are looking forward to cold pizza for breakfast with our leftovers. They were extremely polite on the phone. We have food allergies and always have to inquire about that before we eat anywhere. They put the manager on the phone and he was very knowledgeable about handling ingredients to prevent cross contamination. He helped me feel confident that this would be a safe choice for us. read more

Brooklyn Pizza Crew - Large = HUGE! Our 3 pieces were already devoured. Very good! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Good flavor, but the "Paisano" was super soggy toward the center - nothing like pizza crust. The crust on the round, medium pizza we ordered was much better. read more

This is my go-to. Margherita for my daughter, 1/2 with smoked chicken and mushrooms for Papa. Neapolitan for my son. Always solid. Ingredients super fresh. Literally About to put in an order now. read more