We love coming here. The pizza is awesome and so is the service. Welcoming staff always making sure that we are fully served. I hope you will open a location in Green Cove Springs too read more

The good was absolutely amazing! The service was a bit slow but they were extremely busy! I do wish the pizza was hot when we got it but I know the server was going table to table and was over busy. For how busy it was it wasn't too loud! We will be back again read more

Bronx House Pizza - Meatball,pepperoni, ricotta cheese pizza and half cheese - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

It's like a 2.5 . I want to start by saying that nothing was horrible. But nothing was really good or even great. First of all- do NOT choose to sit at the booth. The seat backs of the booths rock with every movement of the person being you. Choose the table option. For the food, we got the Nonna's Meatballs & Garlic Knots to start. The meatballs were good, nothing special, but good. Good size, sweet & acidic tomato sauce, topped with ricotta. The garlic knots came out and....they were room temperature at best, the bread was basically stale and the bread dough wasn't very good. Top anything in enough oil and garlic and it's edible though lol. We ordered a small Beast of Burden pizza- it was ok? It has the stretching of melting over processed pre-shredded cheese. The best way to describe it is like gourmet Chucky Cheese pizza. It's edible, has a nice crust at the bottom of the pizza and all, but maybe don't waste your time if you're looking for a really good or great pizza. Staff seemed a little busy/overwhelmed but were very nice, was tempted to give 3 stars just for that. If you're in a pinch, or just need to feed the family, do stop in. But if you're looking for a delicious warm meal & great pizza, look elsewhere. read more

Hungry for a good pizza , and seeing the sign saying " Voted best pizza" ... we stopped in. The restaurant looked clean and inviting. We were sat quickly, and the waiter took our order. The booth we sat in had a loose back on the seat, and every time the lady and kid in back of me moved, I moved too... uncomfortable to sit and be moved by someone jarring you. Would have liked to move, but no real option. The wait for the pizzas we ordered wasn't too long, and they were getting busy too. I got a spinach pizza, called the popeye, and my husband got the butcher shop. There were two pieces of spinach on each slice.. skimpy . I was hoping for more. The butcher shop pizza was topped with different meats, but not loaded. Both pizzas were not very hot, just warm. They were both mediocre. Nothing really special. Then there was a confusion with our bill getting mixed up with someone else's bill.. it got straightened out, but didn't add anything good to the dining experience. This was a one and done for us. Maybe it was an " off" night, but with the price of eating out higher lately we won't take a chance. read more

The Dept. of Sanitation pizza, yes this was the name of the pizza, was so yummy. Thin crust, heavy toppings, tasty marinara. The atmosphere was Italian themed. The restaurant was clean with soft music playing. The bathroom was easy to find and clean. The ladies were quite attentive to what I needed. My glass was always full. read more

See all

Great pizza place in St. Augustine. They have different menu options than most pizza places. They do have a full bar too. If you love pizza and want to avoid parking issues. This is a great spot to stop at. read more

Bronx House Pizza - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Tried new pizza location. Service was very good! Don't like they only have 2 coed bathrooms. I can tell you the pizza is delicious! If you have not have the Hot97 it's soo good! We ordered the pepperoni and garlic knots. Fantastic! Place is brand new very clean read more

Bronx House Pizza - Hot 97 - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

OMG, I think I died and went to haven. Best pizza I ever had. The crust was amazing, the sauce was doke. The cheese was like they had a cow out back. They import the toms, the cheese is from Michigan, the crust is simple but delish. The server was well trained, the atmosphere was like an NY off Broadway joint. Hugh pasta dishes this place is new and I can'twaitto go back. read more

Bronx House Pizza - Atmosphere - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Bronx House Pizza is definitely a very good and popular pizza spot, the service and food is very good read more

See all

Parking was impossible! Their parking lot is pretty small and fills up really quickly, so we ended up parking on the street which is a little risky. The service is very friendly and we ordered a new york style pizza. It was delicious and cooked well. If we are ever back in St. Augustine, we will come back for more pizza. read more

Bronx House Pizza - New york style large pizza with olives - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

I loved the vibe when we walked in, definitely a feel of a good pizza joint. We got a Greek salad that was huge, three of us split it. We also got a deep dish pizza and it was amazing. The bacon jam was a great balance with the acidity of the tomato sauce and the pepperoni. The server was nice but started off kind of slow due to the number of tables she had. read more

Bronx House Pizza - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Pretty red brick exterior fixed up an old eyesore building. And brick interior old Bronx style. Nostalgic pizzeria style. Pizza is good. Pasta Bolognese- I, the Italian girl, couldn't put my finger on it, good not great. comfort food for sure. Great drinks.Friendly wait staff. read more

See all

Had a calzone. Was fantastic. Enough said, go here you won't be disappointed! ................ read more

The food was solid, Detroit Pizza was very good as well was the spicy penne a la vodka. Being from NY, I'm a tough critic of Pizza and this was very good. read more

See all

A fairly new Pizzeria on Route 1 in St Augustine, FL. At 6:00PM on a Sunday evening the place was hopping, but we were able to be seated in a booth in no time. Our waiter, Wyatt was super. He took our drink orders, and a plus was that they had Heineken. non alcoholic beer. The Greek Salad and the 2 pies were delicious. One was the 12" Butcher Pie and a 12" Popeye Spinach Pie. We took enough home for lunch tomorrow. Unfortunately they were not able to make a cauliflower crust. It was on the menu. It was a tad disappointing. Will definitely return. read more

Bronx House Pizza - NYC PIZZERIA VIBE - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

BRONX HOUSE! I was a bit annoyed when my husband went ahead and ordered the meatball appetizer without asking what I wanted ... well, well, well, they were AMAZINGLY Tasty! Good job hunny! Bruschetta was a WIN! We had the Chicken Parmigiana with Fra Diavolo sauce OMG OMG OMG!!! YES! You can taste the Fresh Ingredients!! Yeah worth every calorie! Dustin was a great Server... Best place in St. Augustine thus far! Will be back! BUONO! ESOOOO... Felt like I was home great ambiance! read more

Bronx House Pizza - Bruschetta - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Ordered in for delivery tonight. One small pie, one calzone. Both were fresh and good. Reminded me to f the pizza shops I. My old neighborhood in Washington Heights. Delivery was quick. read more

No pictures today because we were hungry. First time at this location as we usually go on the island. They have a really nice bar area and good seating. They do not serve slices here. We ordered a small pizza and a chicken caesar salad. That salad is one of my favorites. They cut the chicken into very small pieces and it is seasoned perfectly. Pizza was delicious. Georgia was our server. She did a great job. We really enjoyed our lunch. read more

We decided to order to-go from Bronx House because my sister and I were hungry, but opted to split a meal. We ordered a chicken Milanese and an order of garlic knots. Everything we ordered was done by the time we arrived to get it to go. When we got home, we saw our order was correct. I like that they put the chicken and salad in one, and then didn't add the dressing or balsamic glaze, so it wouldn't get soggy. We've ordered the chicken MIlanese a bunch of times, and normally we'd say the portion is super healthy (normally we've gotten three breasts in one order) This time around, there was maybe one and a half, which is disappointing. The food was prepared deliciously. I love the salad and salad dressing they use and the chicken was breaded nicely. The garlic knots were good, too. read more

Cons: parking is horrible. This place gets super crowded. The wait staff is nice, but rude at the same time. It's a very small restaurant. Pros: the food is good. Some of the staff is nice. Wait time is quick and food comes out fast. We spent a good 10-15 minutes looking for parking. Finally when we were able to find parking we walked in, they let us know it would be about a 25 minute wait. It was more like 10 minutes which was great. They pointed out where we would sit and told us to go right ahead and sit down. Gave me the kids menus and we walked ourselves to our table. The waitress had a bit of an attitude, I would assume it's because the place was slammed. She was attentive, but not really. It was odd. She would walk by quick ask if it was good and before we could answer she would walk away. The food came out pretty fast and it was good. Nothing out of this world. We tried the lasagna balls which were good. My kids tried the cheese pizza and it was good. My husband had the beast of burden pizza and he liked it. Over all the food was good. It wasn't out of this world. The service could use some training and it was just mediocre. read more

First time trying it, and I must say it is yummy! I ordered it to-go. If you plan on staying t there is parking, but the later it gets the parking lot fills up. I ordered the PopEye well done, next time I will order it differently well done was a little too crispy for me. read more

Bronx House Pizza - Popeye - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Had a great dinner at this place! Abby was our waitress and she was welcoming, attentive, and so funny! Definitely recommend the whipped ricotta appetizer and the haymaker pizza. One of the best pizzas I've ever had. Only "complaints" would be that the pizza was a little cold and I wish there was more pepperoni on the pizza. Definitely coming back whenever I'm in the area!! read more

Bronx House Pizza - Whipped Ricotta - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

We visited here after a convention. Their parking lot is easy to get in, great location for visitors to the city like us and a fantastic menu. Their dough was crispy and delicious. read more

Great pizza! Cool vibes and espresso martini is where it's at Aubrey was a great server. Worth a visit!

Our first visit to this establishment was in Palm Coast....we were hooked. 2 visits in one week. When we were in St Augustine this past weekend I found out that there was one close to downtown! YAY off we went. We shared the Detroit style Nuts & Bolts pizza and two glasses of wine. It was just as good (if not better) than we remembered. They have a full menu of amazing dishes....a word of advice COME HUNGRY! Portions are generous. Service was also very welcoming. There is also a bar if you like bar seating - which we do - but there were no seats this visit. Either way you will not be disappointed with a stop here. One note of caution:: during the holiday lights, parking is quite limited...so go early or do take out! read more

When the first one opened up in the Anastasia Plaza in St. Augustine, the pies were GREAT, in fact, I was one of their biggest supporters, posting how GREAT their pies were, and they were the real deal! A few months back, we ordered a large DEPARTMENT OF SANITATION, which is what I call an everything pie! What a disappointment, we actually had to look and see what exactly they put on the pie..... it looked terrible, the pepperoni were as small as a dime, you could hardly see any green peppers, and the rest of their toppings were skimpy as well! It appeared they were trying to cut expenses, and if that's their intention, they'll cut their business, too! read more

Went for lunch had the chicken cutlet sub with mozzarella tomatoes bacon and balsamic dressing it was very good and had a huge portion size. Unfortunately they did not have any individual slices for sale. The dining area is big and they had a nice size bar. The service was quick and friendly. read more

Bronx House Pizza - Chicken cutlet sub - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

The second location in St. Augustine, this restaurant has elevated the pizza dining experience. It offers a full bar and a relaxing atmosphere. I recently visited this place with my three littles (all under the age of 5 yo) and my daughter. We arrived for lunch and were greeted by a friendly young lady. We ordered a cheese pizza for littles and the Haymaker for us. It was delicious. The littles ate their pizza and wanted more. The pizzas were made fresh and served hot. They offered kid menus and crayons. (Parents: Please be aware that no outside food or beverages are allowed. The kids snacks and beverages will need to stay home). If you're looking for a sit down relaxing pizza place, this is it. read more

See all

First of all - make sure Abbie is your server. She is the best. The food was delicious too! Really a must visit if your are anywhere near it. Love the Bronx House. read more

Bronx House Pizza - Penne Vodka - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Food- it's just not ny style pizza. It's isn't horrible just not NY. Service was great newly opened but waitress was friendly and on top of things. Ambience- ummm nouveau Italian pizzeria. Not upscale definitely casual. They have gluten free and cauliflower crusts. Next time I'll get it more well done. Little pricey $20 for a 10" pizza? read more

Bronx House Pizza - Dining full bar and kitchen - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Great service. Better food. We shared antipasto meatball sliders(beyond yummy) pizza and lasagna bowl. Fun family outing

I think we got a pizza that was ordered by someone else and they resold it because it was cold and the crust was soggy. I ordered this at 6:12 and the order was ready to pick up at 6:18. Don't tell that this was made fresh. read more

Bronx House Pizza - This is the text message I received from the restaurant. - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Bronx Pizza - St. Augustine, FL Bronx Pizza serves what I would confidently call the best pizza in Florida. Having tried authentic New York City pizza, I can say this place is absolutely comparable in both flavor and quality--truly impressive. The indoor seating area is comfortable, and while the parking lot is small, it's manageable. The staff is friendly and efficient, making the experience even more enjoyable. Their mixed drinks and beer selection are also worth noting--well-crafted and satisfying. Whether you're dining with family or out on a date night, Bronx Pizza is a great choice. That said, the pricing for dine-in is quite high, especially for pizza. It's delicious, but definitely on the expensive side. If you're looking to enjoy the same great food at a more reasonable cost, I recommend opting for takeout, which is noticeably more affordable. Address: 1050 N Ponce De Leon Blvd, St. Augustine, FL 32084 read more

See all

DELICIOUS !!!!!! My family ordered the butchers pizza which was loaded with lots of meat and was delicious. My grandchildren went with a half pepperoni, half cheese pizza with french fries and medium buffalo wings and they were both really really really good. The fries were so crunchy like really crunchy and really good. Our server came and took our order very quickly after we were seated and we did try the fountain drinks and sometimes fountain drinks to be hit or miss so they do need to do some adjusting, but we switched over to bottle root beer, which was the perfect drink with our pizza and wings. After a long day at the beach, this was the perfect place to stop for dinner. Unfortunately after we finished our pizza and wings there was no room left for dessert so next time we will try the cheesecake. We highly highly recommend definitely a five out of five. The location/shopping center is currently under renovation so you do have to really look for the sign on top of the building, but please do not pass on this amazing pizza joint. read more

Bronx House Pizza - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Terrible parking lot. It's awkward and someone is going to hit their car in the back lot that must only be backed out of to get out. But food is greatttttt. yummy wine and pizza! read more

Good ambiance and good food. Parking is available which is essential when looking for a place to eat close to downtown St Augustine. Service was nice and very friendly. read more

Bronx House Pizza - Beast of Burden pizza - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Large Butcher shop pizza on top and small chicken Parmesan pizza on the bottom. Also split the garden salad and buffalo wings. Very yummy and cheesy!! Staff were super polite and fast. We'll definitely be back to try more!! read more

Bronx House Pizza - Large Butcher shop pizza on top and small chicken Parmesan pizza on the bottom. - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Detroit pizza at its BEST! 5 slices UP! Abundant toppings and well made. Also the side salad was delicious too read more

Bronx House Pizza - Pepperoni & basil- fantastic taste and cooked right - no soggy crust or burned crust. Just right! - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

I've been here twice, both times the pizza is fresh and very tasty. This time we got the "tuxedo explosion" as a dessert, and it was delicious. Our waitress was very friendly and excellent. I will keep this on my list of regular places to eat! read more

Bronx House Pizza - "Tuxedo explosion" - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Excellent pizza. Good portion. Ate at bar. Server was attentive. Drinks were great. Prices were reasonable. Good seating and nice atmosphere. Parking is a bit tough at times. read more