Boat House

Be sure to have Victoria make you an Espresso Martini! Great location with ambience. Bright, airy,…read morehomey. We loved it!

Well, at some point I was going to have to post a negative review, right? This was a sad stop. A…read morevery rainy morning, I'll guess other staff had trouble getting in. Still, in a mostly empty restaurant, it took way too long to just get a seat (and i couldn't get a table away from the door, even though I asked), and that was followed by a long wait to even get water, let alone coffee or my order taken. I asked for the Eggs Benedict, but was told they were out. Ok, just the simple bacon and eggs will be fine. Anyway, yes, it was awhile before the food came out. I requested eggs over medium that were beyond overcooked. The muffin? Served without butter or anything to put on it (I guess that's on me for not checking it when brought out). The bacon? The one good thing that morning. It took forever to get someone's attention for more coffee. I was really patient with the young waitress who was there seemingly by herself for the first 15-20 minutes I was there, but attentiveness didn't pick up even when three other staff joined. Then there was a long wait for the check. Finally, when I went to pay, they left with my card and came back to the table without it...a simple error that could happen any time, but just another reason to have had a negative impression of this place.

Interior

Breakfast

See all

Victoria's espresso martini

The Nautilus

4.3(200 reviews)

I've been twice now, haven't been able to get a reservation but had luck walking in both times…read more The duck is worth the wait, cocktails are great, everyone is nice. Highly recommend!

I wanted to like this place more!! It was difficult to get a reservation so I expects a lot. The…read moreseating is limited. They serve very quickly. Tapas are the call! The options seemed to fuse too many different things together, for meI liked the blue crab fried rice best! The ribs were a pass. Scallion pancakes were fine. Miso cod skewer was reminiscent of Nobu. I felt rushed. It's good, just not necessarily, for me.

Calamari

See all

Mushrooms

The Club Car Restaurant

3.8(164 reviews)

Fun happening bar. Great atmosphere. Delicious summer vegetable salad. I would come again.read more

Mikey was awesome! We sat at the bar to eat and drink prior to wandering over to the piano room. We…read morehad a great time talking to Mikey and he did a wonderful job serving us. We had many meals during our extended stay in Nantucket and this was one of the best. Tye scallops over fresh pasta were to die for! I lived the espresso martinis as well.

Bouillabaisse

See all

Calamari

Oran Mor

4.4(254 reviews)

Excellent all around -- creative menu, great service and extensive, reasonably priced wine list.read more

If you are looking for a nice dinner with vegetarian and vegan options this is your go to. The…read morehouse made pasta dishes are also creative and delicious. I had the black truffle bucatini, my husband had the fennel orecchiette, and my son had pasta with cheese and everything was top notch. My son's pasta might have been one of the most delicious things I have ever tasted. Service was fantastic and the restaurant itself is full of Nantucket's classic charm and laid back vibes. We had a couple mocktails and those were great too. Highly recommend!

Sign

Halibut

See all

Complimentary focaccia and bread with butter

Straight Wharf Restaurant

3.9(227 reviews)

ANOTHER FANTASTIC VISIT TO STRAIGHT WHARF RESTAURANT (bar grill side of course). We had the…read morecrostini for an appetizer and it was one of the most delicious things I have ever tasted. On the flip side, we did not enjoy the SWR popcorn. It was rather wet and made for a weird gastronomic experience. But the crostini was just so so good that I am overlooking the popcorn. For my main, I had the salmon which was very delicious. Whatever magical sauces they serve it on were so good, and the salmon so tender, and the cranberries a great addition to the flavor profile- I was wowed! My boyfriend had the eggplant pasta and he really loved that. My visit this time was definitely a lot more quiet than when I went in the summer. Less people, music not as loud but audible. Overall, quite nice for a date night! I can't wait to come back... hopefully before the season ends!

Straight Wharf is staying its course. My most recent visit was solid, but I don't necessarily…read morethinks warrants 5 stars. The $90 prix fixe includes an app and an entree - pricey. The Buffalo fried fish app the waitress recommended wasn't my favorite and doesn't seem to be a dish that should be on the menu. It def felt like TGIFridays met Nantucket but not in a good way. Literally a deep fried block of fish smothered in buffalo sauce served on like a whipped blue cheese spread. Honestly, I think it was trying to elevate Buffalo when Buffalo can't be elevated. The fish entree I had was fine. Nothing out of this world. Actually quite unmemorable. Overall, $90 for 2 dishes that were fine, the app being even on a don't order suggestion, is a little jarring. Service and ambiance was great. I love the comp bread and little dip amuse bouche. Overall, fine. I think I ordered wrong, but I do think there are some better value and more exciting food happening at other places.

Pasta à la Norma, steak, swordfish

See all

Stubbys

4.1(106 reviews)

•$

I can only speak to the clam chowder, but it was amazing! It was perfectly thick, creamy, and…read moresalty. A perfect cup to warm you up on a fall Nantucket day. Pro tip, take it by the sound for a lunch with a view! There was some seating in the restaurant, but it is definitely a grab-and-go place. The service was friendly and attentive.

So far every spot we have hit on the strip has been excellent and Stubbys is no exception. We…read moreordered a cheeseburger, waffle fries, and a grilled cheese. Everything was on point, came out hot and quickly. Staff were friendly as well. Location is perfect for taking your dinner over to the benches to eat near the water. Looking forward to coming back to trying more menu items!

Menu 6/26

Mozzarella Sticks

See all

Beef Chili

Slip 14

3.6(146 reviews)

Fun spot for a quick bite or watch a game. Great service, lobster roll was delicious and fun vibe…read more A bit loud FYI.

Great place for a quick drink before hopping on the ferry. Off the main drag so less busy and less…read morenoisy. Ample bar seating available and drinks were strong. Staff was limited but still well attended while we were there and they were friendly.

Mussles

See all

Tavern & Gazebo

3.2(169 reviews)

Busy waterfront food and bar. The Gazebo was packed at 4:30. Had a clam casino appetizer, while…read morewaiting for the ferry. Great place to kick the can. Wasn't wowed but good enough! Casual casual. And casual.

I don't get why the rating is so low, great for your typical seafood resto if you're not trying to…read morebreak the bank in Nantucket. Ordered an app and 4 entrees for about $160. Everything was delicious and service was good.

See all

Island Kitchen

4.3(271 reviews)

0.2 mi

I come in almost every morning after my walk and get the steak and eggs or the animal. The food is…read morealways consistent and so good! I also always sit in Kristin's section and she is a joy and gives the best service. I look forward coming in for my breakfast.

Decent meat lovers omelette. Decent Bloody Mary. Excellent service. Nice ambiance. Biscuit was very…read moregood. Potato pancake was ok. None of us really liked it but it tasted fine. Was just mushy like hash browns. Everyone enjoyed their breakfast. I would absolutely return.

Terrace / porch area

Rolls w butter

See all

Outside patio

Queequeg's

3.6(129 reviews)

Every summer when our daughter visits she says this is her favorite; cozy intimate, sans fast food…read moreemporium. Last night was spectacular . We sat at Q1 the bartenders table. This man could probably show them how to handle guests at the Waldorf . Shrimp scampi ,short ribs and mussels top shelf ; all topped off by extraordinary service. Thank you Sir!

We walked in and was able to grab a table when they opened at 5:30. This wasn't really a sit and…read morerelax experience. Our server checked on us a lot until we ordered. It was hard because we really wanted the braised short rib but it would not be ready until 7. Not having all your food ready until 1 and a half hours into service seems like an issue. So we needed extra time. We ended up with just a clam chowder and a seafood stew. Both were full of flavor and nicely seasoned. We walked out a little after 6:30. The server could have offered another glass of wine while we waited for a short rib. However we got the odd feeling we weren't wanted. They wanted to turn the table for a 7pm crowd. We didn't get a recommendation or encouragement to order anything else. We left hungry. Walked down the street and ate some BBQ.

Entrance to Queequegs

Swordfish Sandwich over salad, Clam Chowder

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Hera M.

11 years ago

Fresh fast and delicious, great food if u get to it. It's always fresh and always fast. Plenty of parking spot, located on 2 Sanford rd

Felix A.

3 years ago

I like the food here are the better food like tacos , nachos , burritos , I love it. These foods

Michelle M.

9 years ago

Great food good price nice staff

Boat House - newamerican - Updated November 2026

People who viewed Boat House also viewed

Surfside Taco Stand

3.9

(15 reviews)

This is my go to spot when the line for the juice bar is too long or they're closed!…read more The ice cream is reasonably priced and you can get soft serve ice cream with a topping mixed in for under $10 which by island standards is basically free!! Speaking of free, kids eat free on mondays! They do only have soft serve but I don't mind. The cyclone is so fun! I liked mine with the Oreos more than the Reese's, it was a texture thing. But there are some other great mix ins! Their food is good too, I've had some quesadillas and salads from there, and they've been a convenient and tasty option. It's open late and there can be a young crowd on summer evenings. Fine for most, awkward for some who perhaps work in the school system.

This fun little taco stand was a great stop during our day on the island. We were walking around…read moreand wanted a bite to eat. This place was just the thing! They have a unique menu of tacos, quesadillas, burritos, fajitas, etc. It's quick service style so you just order and pick up at the counter! No reservations of anything needed, which is a nice change from everything else on the island. They have a big patio for outside seating as well. The food was all very good. Tacos tasted fresh as did the quesadilla! Food came out quick as well!

Millie's

4.2

(265 reviews)

Millie's is a solid 4-star restaurant that gets a bump to 5 because of the location and the paucity…read moreof quality affordable dining on the island. Everything's fresh. Seafood is cooked properly. Portions are generally pretty generous. However some of the combinations could be better thought through. Some of the items are pretty messy (perhaps it's intentional). If you get the lobster salad, demand that the lettuce be substituted for something simpler like romaine.

Arrived and were greeted by the hostess team. They were friendly and accommodating. Maddie was our…read moreserver which she was friendly as well and efficient! I had the New England clam chowder and the lobster roll Connecticut style. Both were flavorful and hardy. I was full after and relaxed. The view is homes and the ocean while sitting and listening to great tunes. I do have to share for the owners sake on training that one star missing is due to the restrooms being unkept with urine splattered on the floor, urine in the toilet and a dirty toilet. Had I gone in there first, I may have not stayed for a bite to eat. Perhaps assign on team member as a floater with the assignment of keeping the restroom spotless. Hope this helps.

Millie’s Mid-Island at the Rotary

4.3

(7 reviews)

Millie's mid-island location is a savior. We rode our bikes out to Sconset during the Daffodil…read moreFestival and there was no food anywhere on the trip, until we found Millie's at the rotary. I will admit that we would have enjoyed any food, but instead we found that Millie's food was excellent. We had the shrimp burrito and the shrimp was big and perfectly cooked. The spices added to the flavor without overpowering the mild shrimp taste. Everything tasted very fresh. Thank you, Millies, you made our day!

Millie's has nailed it again! They are now offering a complete lobster dinner to go. It came in a…read morelovely warming bag and in each portion was the most delicious chowder, perfectly cooked corn and potatoes and a warm prepared and cut generous size lobster. The butter was drawn. It even came with all the tools to crack the lobster. Every element of this meal was done to perfection. This is an awesome solution for a family dinner when you don't wanna cook or a beach dinner or a treat of a meal when you can't get a reservation in town. I really can't recommend this enough!

Back Yard Bbq

4.2

(316 reviews)

Back Yard BBQ was one of our favorite meals on Nantucket! The lobster roll was absolutely…read moredelicious--fresh, flavorful, and generously filled. What really stood out was the value; while many lobster rolls on the island can cost $60 or more, theirs was in the $30 range and well worth it. The burger was equally impressive--juicy, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. Service was quick and efficient, making it a great spot for a casual meal without a long wait. Great food, reasonable prices, and friendly service. We'll definitely be stopping by again on our next trip to Nantucket!

Great BBQ place located on the island. Seats located outside bc today was a beautiful sunny day…read more Sunny service from the bartender was great. Plenty of booths and counter top seats for the bar. They have Pacifico beer which has been hard to locate. Bbq flavors were smoky with a sweet honey taste on our chicken.

Stubbys

4.1

(106 reviews)

•$

Yummy

4.2

(37 reviews)

Delicious breakfast sandwich! The coffee was also good. Great place to stop for quick bite in the…read moremorning .

Are these the best sandwiches on Nantucket? Might be…read more Conveniently located on the bike path. Yummy was the perfect place to stop for a sandwich after the beach. They have a big menu of burgers and sandwiches. They also serve ice cream, which appeared to be very popular. We got the wipeout turkey sandwich and added fries. The sandwich was great, exactly what we're looking for, and came with a mountain of fries. They were crispy, salty, and delicious. It was enough to split. You order inside, and then they bring the food out to your table. They have picnic benches and umbrellas for you to enjoy them outside. Will definitely be back to try other sandwiches or maybe ice cream.

The Nautilus

4.3

(200 reviews)