Remodeled in 2019. I literally drag my butt out of bed at 6 on holidays in order to be one of the first people here, and I'm always shocked by how many people are here. And yet not shocked. This is the only place in this area that I'd get my holiday's baked goods. Now I'm standing on line, Thanksgiving 2019, I'm writing this as quickly as possible because the line is moving FAST. Everything I've ever gotten here in my 45 years has been fresh and delicious. Fantastic place! read more

See all

Wanted a heart shaped engagement cake. The baker and staff all were so accommodating. Cake was just what we ordered and delicious too. Everyone was raving over it. Will definitely we going back. read more

My twins birthday cake came out amazing! It tasted so good and looked great! Will definitely be going here again! read more

Benkert's Bakery - Birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Centereach, New York

Update time! Benkert's Bakery is GREAT for CAKES! I was invited to a dinner party and I'm definitely NOT the type to cook or help cook, so I did what I do best-- bring dessert. Benkert's cakes are DELICIOUS and beautiful, not to mention they have an amazing selection-- cheesecakes, pies, chocolate cakes, yellow cakes, red velvet cakes, you get the idea. The 7-Layer Cake I picked up was a real crowd pleaser and was only $13.95. For the next dinner party, I already know where I'm going and what I'm bringing! read more

They made a delicious cake for my daughter's bridal shower. A young lady named Maria was very nice and helpful.

I'm extremely unhappy with this bakery. I had a wedding and the cake was included in the package. I went to the store for their "tasting" and spoke with someone on the phone regarding the new design idea for my cake. My original design had changed drastically in between the visit and the phone call. I had emailed my new design twice. She had confirmed the design on the phone. I was charged extra for the flowers. My cake turned out NOTHING like I had wanted. It was like someone read the notes from the two designs and put them together in this horrifically ugly cake. The coloring was off. The flowers were way too big and clumsy and were not the right colors for the piping done on the cake. I very specifically mentioned that I only wanted 2 colors on the cake in the piping. But I got multi-colored miscellaneous flowers that didn't match the shades of color that were on the cake. The picture I sent had ALL WHITE FLOWERS and they were all the same type of flower!! I count a hundred ways they could have designed a better cake. The only saving grace was that the cake actually tasted more delicious than the tasting I had in the store. The tasting in the store had a loose, crumbly cake with processed sloppily put together fillings. The cake we received was firm & moist and had a much better tasting filling. If this cake wasn't included in the package, I would never have used this bakery. And I will never ever ever go back to this place. I have to live with the ugliest wedding cake I have seen in a looooong time in my wedding photos. I don't even like to look at the pictures of us cutting the cake because all I can see is this hideous hideous cake. read more

Benkert's Bakery - The left was what I emailed. The right was what I received. - Bakeries Near Me - Centereach, New York

Owner gave us two pie 7" pie kits at NO CHARGE because he forgot to put the order together His Staff was so respectful and sweet to I have been going to Benkerts since 1980 The place is clean The cakes cookies donuts etc are plentiful colorful and well stocked Thank You again read more

Benkert's is right on Middle Country Rd. Seemed somewhat active during the week. Some items looked more colorful and commercial than high end. Tried a B & W cookie and a super looking chocolate coated crunchy pretzel shaped pastry. When back couldn't put out that it was clearly very dried/ stale. Cookie was fine just no real flavor. read more

I have been to Benkerts many times over the past 20+years. picked up a lemon cake. The cake was dry and stale, the frosting was okay but the lemon curd (not sure what it was) was absolutely disgusting. Threw it all out. Definitely not a Benkerts cake. It's a trek for us to get there may not be patronizing Benkerts anymore. read more

We ordered my sons 2nd birthday Cake from here.We ordered 7"cake with chocolate cake with cherry filling.They told it will be $55 for Cake.We then decided to changed color of cake to yellow from blue so they added extra $10 for it.After coming home in 20minutes ,we decided to go for original color -blue but for my surprise they increase again to $75 which they originally quoted for $55. Also cake was worst cake and dry. Never ever go to that place!! read more

30+ years ago, I would come to Benkert's with my grandparents & they would get my sister and I each a Cookie Monster or Big Bird cupcake. Delicious. 10 years ago my kid's birthday cakes all came from here. Beautiful, fresh cakes! Today I went in with one of my kids to get a cake for my husband's birthday. Of course we each got a cupcake for a treat. I am so incredibly disappointed the cupcakes were stale, the frosting ... grainy almost. The girl that waited on us couldn't be bothered. She wanted to just get back to whatever it was she was doing (which I understand you have a list of things you have to get done throughout the day but she is still in a service oriented occupation) I think will be sticking to Audrey's in Sayville from now on. So sad to give up on Benkert's but really not happy. Edited to add- I bought a black & white cake- cutting it in a bit, will see how that goes. read more

Benkert's Bakery - Excuse the silly candles. Benkert's black & White cake, icing just like the classic cookies. - Bakeries Near Me - Centereach, New York

I was pleasantly surprised by their cake! The cake was moist and just the right amount of frosting. I've NEVEE had frosting that was as light, airy, with just the right amount of sweetness from any bakery INCLUDING ALPINE in Smithtown. I have found my new bakery for birthdays and other special occasions. It was so good I HAD to call the bakery back to speak with the baker to give him his just praise! I mean my entire office raved and commented positively on this cake, I can't say it enough. Great maple cake! read more

I don't like to leave negative reviews at all! I'm not the type cause i support a lot of local buisnesses i went in spoke to a very nice young lady she took my cake order correct . Everything was right ! The decorating was awesome !! However the cake tasted disgusting . My kids even said it was gross . My daughters 3rd birthday was ruined :( the icing was as hard as a rock and did not taste like funfetti at all ! 42$ down the drain giving them another shot isn't an option i do not reccomend read more

Benkert's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Centereach, New York

I've always used this place to buy my cheesecakes and regular cakes and have never been disappointed. Until now. I bought a cookie and creme cheesecake, a few rainbow cookies, a few macarons, and a cupcake. The rainbow cookies and macarons were on point. The cupcake was so dry I didn't even finish it. The cheesecake which was for my sons birthday was dry and tasted old. I was so disappointed that I will never go back here again. read more

We have been using Benkert's as our go to bakery for holiday cakes and pastries for over 8 years. For the most part their items were pretty good. Our last two purchases however were so bad I don't think I will be back: We recently purchased a crumb cake that we brought to a party. This crumb cake was horrible! It tasted more like bread than cake...it might have been the worst crumb cake I have ever tasted. Entenmann's would have been a better option. Just this weekend we ordered 10" round cake for my sons birthday party ($55). Inside was vanilla cake with chocolate pudding and outside was buttercream. The cake itself was "OK" nothing great but not bad. The buttercream however was not edible. It had an awkward, almost sandy texture and didn't taste like any buttercream I have ever had before.....super super sugary and just gross. Looks like we will be finding a new local bakery... read more

I don't understand why this bakery has such low reviews. I found their items decently priced and their cheesecakes to be very good. I'm not a big baked goods person but when they had their Brooklyn cheesecake out for sampling I took a taste and fell in love. I bought a cake for thanksgiving and people loved it! I also ordered a truffle and a brownie. I found those to be decent but American baked goods is just not my thing. Unless it's lava cake....customer service was not the fastest but at most average. It seemed like students were working the store and they were pleasant to talk to. It's always nice to see a business hiring students. In conclusion, I really liked their cheesecakes and their baked goods were pretty good. I'd recommend this place to a friend and my fellow yelpers! Definitely try the Brooklyn style cheesecake read more

If I could give 2 1/2 stars I would. I've dropped in on this place a few times last month. I've been pretty disappointed with the items I got. It's not that they were bad, it's that it wasn't anything special. Their prices are pretty fair. Some of their items are cheaper than 7-11's bakery items. 7-11's stuff might actually be better than Benkert's. I've had great service experience, which is what made me give it a 3 instead of a 2. read more

My family has been coming to Benkert's Bakery for years. Their cakes are outstanding. Try the chocolate fudge - you WON'T regret it! :)

I have used Benkerts for every cake for my daughters birthdays for the past 6 and 1 year(s). They're great. The cake that was made last year was amazing!! All of my daughters friends and parents were talking about how good it looked and tasted for weeks!! I chose the spongebob cake they had in their cake album, and I modified it to my desire. ((note: I used spongebob figures we already owned for the characters on the cake)). This cake really was incredibly delicious and very cool looking. I can't say enough good things about Benkerts. read more

See all

Talented artistry. The cake looked beautiful and tasted great. Most staff is friendly. read more

Benkert's Bakery - Benkert Bakery has talented decorators. Tastes good, looks good. - Bakeries Near Me - Centereach, New York

Very happy with our experience here. I went in for a cake the day before the event and I wasn't quite sure what I wanted, even after looking at the selection, and the girl who helped me talked me through my options and put together a custom order even though it was such short notice. The cake was beautiful, fresh and delicious. I'm a little surprised reading some of the other negative reviews here but even still, we will definitely be back. read more

The cannoli here is reason enough to come. It is pretty perfect. If I lived closer, I would be in real trouble. read more

Benkert's Bakery - Lobster tail and cannoli - Bakeries Near Me - Centereach, New York

Very sad because the last 3 things I've bought from here have been stale. I've been a regular customer for years and I love the convenience, the staff, and the prices; but unfortunately the quality just isn't there anymore and I will have to find another bakery read more

I love this bakery and visit I every time I visit NY. Huge selection. My sister uses this bakery for every major event. Her wedding cake, first communion cakes etc etc. delicious huge M and M cookies, crumb cake is yummy too. Drove here right before we flew back to AZ so we could bring some goodies back with us! Yummy! read more

See all

Everyone in the Coram - Centereach - Selden - LakeGrove area must know Benkert's Bakery right? It's been the go- to-bakery for all specialty cake needs for years, for our entire area. And the cakes have always been delicious. So after all these years, what prompted me to write a review for this local institution? Well, I bought a cupcake from there today.... It was delicious. It was Red Velvet. And it was only $1.99. After going to deluxe cupcake places in Boston, NYC, Hoboken, DC and doling out about 4 dollars a cupcake... it was mind blowing to walk into a bakery and eat a delicious Red Velvet cupcake for half the price. I can't ever looks at NYC Crumbs the same way again. Benkert's, you just won yourself a regular cupcake customer. And she couldn't be happier about this. Now if only you would stay open past 5. read more

Nice pastries, but the staff here is quite lacking in the customer service dept. when we came, there were a bunch of young girls (probably high school age) working. They continued to chit chat and gab in corner while a small line was forming. Not very professional. Normally that type of stuff doesn't annoy me, but when it is obvious that there are people needing help, you should probably help! Especially at a place where people want to get in and out. This is a recurrent theme at this place.... read more

In business for a zillion years and only 4 reviews on yelp? I just have to comment. I haven't been here in a long time but used to live in the area. It was a favorite for the neighborhood and surrounding communities. They make cakes to special order and will add just about any decoration or photo to the top. The cakes are absolutely delicious and special. Prices are competitive with other bakeries. My sons are now in their 30s and I bought all their special occasion cakes there, since birth. I currently know of people in my area who travel the 1/2 hour to get one of Benkert's cakes. It still gets rave reviews from friends. I highly recommend this bakery! read more

Just went with my dad to get an oreo cheesecake for my brother's birthday. Was very unhappy with the result. It was probably the worst cheesecake I've ever tasted! My 11 year old sister can make a better cheesecake... it tasted like they just made it from a mix. I'm really disappointed. I rarely give bad reviews on yelp. But this cheesecake was pretty bad. They're cakes and cookies are really good though! Just don't get the cheesecake... not worth your $14.95. :( read more

Local bakery with a huge selection of beautifully decorated cakes, cookies, pastries, and breads. I want to like this place, I really do. I bought cookies from here in the past and they were pretty standard buttery, chocolate dipped Italian cookies. I stopped by a couple days ago and bought a cannoli cake and a premade cookie tray. The cookie tray was standard. I was a little disappointed that there weren't any rainbow cookies in the tray. The cannoli cake was okay. I wish I had better words to describe it. It looked pretty but the taste just fell a bit short. I liked the fact that it wasn't overwhelmingly sweet but there wasn't much flavor in the cream filling or cake itself. The buttercream frosting was a good consistency, not too rich or sweet, but nothing tasted like a cannoli. I couldn't actually tell what the filling was supposed to be except there was vanilla in it....maybe. I REALLY want to like this place but I can't help wondering if I should have just saved some money and gotten a supermarket cake instead. The service is not as friendly as I would imagine a bakery would be. I wasn't greeted when I walked in. In fact, there was no one behind the counter when I walked in this time. I can't even say if I remember a smile being exchanged after I completed my purchase but maybe I'm just expecting too much? I'm not yet ready to write this place off. We need bakeries like this to stay in business. I just hope my next experience is better. read more

This bakery has outstanding cakes and pastries. In addition to their great quality, their prices are slightly lower than many of the other well known bakeries on Long Island. Their apple strudel (when available) and their coffee rings are excellent. Their crumb buns have just the right proportion of cake and crumbs. Also try their napoleons. Their bread and rolls are good, but the selection is somewhat limited (e.g., no sourdough bread). You can't go wrong with any cake, including their chocolate or strawberry cream cake. read more

This bakery was once pretty good, but its fallen drastically from its once much better ratings. I heard it changed hands and is no longer owned by the Lorch family, but that's unconfirmed. What IS confirmed is that the last two cakes I ordered were pretty bad. Look at my photo here of the 12" round cake I ordered. The chocolate filling did not even come out to the end of the cake, and the yellow cake itself was DRY. The chocolate pudding filling had a bad metallic taste. The left over cake has been sitting in my fridge untouched, which is pretty unusual. My family devours cake, but nobody wanted seconds on this one! For FIFTY dollars, it should be at least edible. read more

Benkert's Bakery - A horrible $50.00 cake from Benkerts! - Bakeries Near Me - Centereach, New York

Seriously....This place blew my mind. Suprisingly have never been here before. I was having a dinner party for my birthday & decided to get a last minute cake here. Well....this was a hard decision! I went with the cannoli cake because it was the last one so it had to be good. I was right!!! Super moist, fresh & not too sweet! Great for $18.99! I cannot wait for another event to visit again! YAY BENKERT'S!!!!! read more

Benkert's Bakery - Cannoli Cake! - Bakeries Near Me - Centereach, New York

The owners are actually my family There macaroons are amazing!! ( my favorite is vanilla) they always have so many to choose from. There cakes are also great ( my recommendation is the " seven layer cake " As you can tell I'm very basic when it comes to dessert ) They usually have 6-7 workers in the front helping costumers !!!!! There bread , cupcakes, etc. are also amazing too!! I definitely recommend it read more

We love this bakery. When you walk in the door you are greeting by the wonderful aroma of a real bakery smell. I've never ordered a bad dessert at Benkert's. Our favorite is the 7 layer cake. Really all the cakes we have tried were amazing. The cookie platters are slightly high in price. But you do get a nice assortment of cookies to sample. read more

yuck found a big black dead bug at the bottom of the bread bag! What happened?- they used to be good! ?? And the pre wrapped cookies were all stale!! If you must buy cookies there only get the ones in the case!-- Wow I gave them another chance they must need to clean up thats twice it happened to me - thats it I'm done.(I had forgotten I had reviewed them before and forgot that I had found bugs before wow) read more

This is one bakery I miss, having moved from the area. They cleverly decorate cakes for the season, which are unique, irresistible and tasty. I had them custom make a Kahlua cake for my daughter (out of season), and a custom Godzilla cake for my son. During the holiday season, especially Easter and Christmas, the line goes outside the building and you can barely get parking. The prices are appropriate for what you purchase. If it is slow, the staff can be friendly and helpful most of the time. read more

I really want to say how impressed I am with this bakery. I planned to get a cake last minute for my engagement party, and I decided I would go here because it was close to my house and because of a friend's recommendation. At first I was nervous because i didn't know how their cakes were and how they were as a bakery. I showed them a picture of how I wanted the cake and they said they might not be able to do one or two parts of the cake which i was okay with since I knew they werent a wedding bakery or specialized in that stuff. But wow, they ended up doing everything I asked for and really worked with my budget. The cake tasted amazing and everyone loved it. I definitely recommend it to everyone. I got a 2 tier chocolate cake with strawberry filling and butter cream on the outside. read more

Benkert's Bakery - The cake that benkert's bakery made for my engagement party. It looked and tasted awesome! Chocolate cake w/ strawberry frosting - Bakeries Near Me - Centereach, New York

Wow! So I came here about a month ago and just got around to writing a review. I was about 6 pm and I was in dire need of a birthday cake for a surprise birthday party. I found this place and drove with a friend there. I wasn't expecting much since it was already night time and I assumed many of the great selections were gone. When I got there, I was informed that they have just baked red velvet cakes. There was a huge selection of other cakes and cookies and it smells so good in there. I ended up purchasing the strawberry shortcake which turns out to be AMAZING! Loved the cake. It wasn't dry and not too sweet. Can't wait to be back again. read more

Boyfriend and I picked up four treats from this place this morning. We got a chocolate iced doughnut, a small Apple turnover, a cheese Danish and a chocolate crumb square. All four cost us just under six bucks and all were delicious. read more

I stopped at the bakery to pick up a couple of cupcakes for dessert being on a diet when you decide to have a little cheat you're looking forward to it sadly the chocolate cupcakes were stale I am very disappointed I stopped at the bakery because I wanted something fresh and delicious how can you have stale cupcakes at a bakery read more