Who knew?! As an avid follower of their Instagram account @thecookieshopli, I stumbled upon the fact that they actually have a storefront tucked away in a strip mall not too far from me. It was their IG post inviting followers to come down and grab a free slice of their vintage meringue cake that made me come to their storefront realization. That aside, this cute little cookie shop specializing in macarons, cookies, tarts and cakes. Upon entering, it's got a very warm, welcoming vibe. The friendly owner was there creating a beautiful masterpiece and happy to chat answering my questions about their menu. Everything looked so beautiful. I was given my free slice of vintage meringue cake and I purchased two macarons. I got creme brûlée and white chocolate raspberry. They were both yummy. I'll be honest in that little treats are a bit pricey for my everyday budget, but I can see splurging for special occasions. I would also consider ordering a cake for a special occasion. Their presentation is on point. read more

See all

Came here to grab some cookies for the family. I got 3 large stuff cookies for $11. All of them tasted good but our favorite was the lemon with berry jam. None of the cookies were overly sweet and i liked the fillings in the middle. Will definitely be coming back to get more. read more

See all

I wanted to say a big, 'Thank you' as the cake was amazing! Enjoyed by everybody. Absolutely fabulous - we can't thank you enough - the everything was amazing and tasted absolutely delicious! Everyone was so impressed by your work. Fresh ingredients! The cream was so delicious!! read more

The Cookie Shop - Bakeries Near Me - Brookhaven, New York

As soon as you walk in the aroma of baked goods hits. The young lady at the counter was very friendly & pleasant. The place is very pretty, upscale high end bakery. I tried some macarons & they are honestly the best I've had on LI. Bursting with flavor! The shell was perfectly chewy! I tried peach Bellini, the peach flavor was great. I also tried honey lavender & you could taste both flavors, which I was blown away by. The chocolate strawberry was also full of fresh strawberry flavor. All the flavors were very natural nothing tasted artificial. I am very very impressed. Their other baked goods look really good, so I will be back read more

The Cookie Shop - Honey lavender, peach Bellini,chocolate strawberry - Bakeries Near Me - Brookhaven, New York

This place is not only adorable to look at, but it smells so damn good when you walk in! The girl behind the counter was super friendly and answered all my questions about the different items. As expected, I left with more than I came for. Not only do all the items look pretty but they taste delicious and fresh. And on top of that, the prices are extremely reasonable. Definitely a must try if you're in the neighborhood! read more

See all

I wish I took a picture to share. Everything was so fresh and delicious. The raspberry tea cookies were incredible.

I ordered my daughter's "18" on their website which makes the process so much easier than calling or stopping by. The even better part was that the cake was to die for!!! 10/10 on appearance AND taste. We will definitely be ordering more cakes in the future! Thank you! read more

The Cookie Shop - Bakeries Near Me - Brookhaven, New York

How this place isn't more popular, I don't know. But its an instagrammer's dream! You walk in and its all pastel pink with flowers and accents. Directly in front of you is a glass case filled with macarons, tart cakes, and cookie sandwiches. If you have any questions, the owners are kind enough to answer. Over the last couple of weeks, I've had a few macarons and a tart cake. I'll admit, the chamomile apricot was a bit of a letdown. A good, standard macaron but no discernable apricot or chamomile taste to it. The creme brulee on the other hand was the better offering of the two. A lightly burnt sugar crust on top led to an almost tart filling which was nice! On the other hand, the tart cake was wonderful. Aesthetically pleasing and not too sweet. But rich at the same time. The added fruit in between layers was a nice touch. Even the merengue on top had a nice caramel flavor to it! For the price point, it's a wonderful dessert for the summer or even a little sweet treat for someone you care about. Overall, would 1000% recommend this place to anyone. I sincerely hope they stick around! read more

The Cookie Shop - Bakeries Near Me - Brookhaven, New York

See all

10/10 experience! I ordered a cake for my baby shower from the cookie shop and I can't rave enough about it First of all, everything she makes is absolutely stunning - its a work of art! I've had her macaroons and they are delicious but I never tried the cake before ordering so it was definitely risky! But it was DELICIOUS. I probably had 10 people come up to me and ask me where the cake was from. Light, fruity, not too sweet, it was just incredible. The owner is also such a warm human and so accommodating - it just made the experience that much better. Don't hesitate to get any event cake done from here!! Only order early because I think she books up quickly - I now know why! read more

I wish there were more bakeries like this one on Long Island. The staff is super nice and the decor of the place is upbeat and cute. I love their macaroons and their smores brownie. The only request I would have is a super chocolatie cookie, but other than that I would highly recommend visiting if you want a sweet treat. read more

Apparently, no one is flocking to The Cookie Shop...well, no avid Yelper anyway. I say this because my trip to this brand new-ish storefront was a couple weeks back now and their review total still clocks in at a goose egg. Well shame on anyone who stepped foot in TCS and didn't write up their experience because this place is the real deal! Let's back track for a moment as it's totally possible you've never heard of The Cookie Shop...or, perhaps, you've heard of them via social media. My girlfriend was the one to turn me onto TCS through her searching around for local sweets and so it became an interest to check them out, especially when their Centereach location opened its doors. Walking through said doors showed off a contemporary tea house type feel that almost seemed a little coffee shop-esque as well (only brighter). It's a pretty welcoming vibe from wall to wall. Several displays helped to show what's available, which looked like a lot of satisfyingly sweet selections. A few varieties of cookie sandwiches, tea cookies with raspberry jam, and several types of macaroons were the choices at the time. The female and I decided to try out a chocolate chip cookie sandwich and a handful of macaroons, including their Cadbury cream option (which tasted like...well, you can guess). Each macaroon was fresh and flavorful while that cookie sandwich was soft, creamy, and delicious. Now this review wouldn't have even happened had it not been for a big portion of what The Cookie Shop does which, surprisingly, has nothing to do with cookies. TCS makes tart cakes and these glorious creations are often showcased for the letters and shapes created for sale. Our main reason for swinging by that day was to pick up our preordered bunny-shaped tart cake (for Easter). This thing was beautifully concocted and even tastier when eaten. It was filled with berries and cream that were sandwiched between two pieces of a soft, cookie-like (oh, now I get the cookie connection) pastry dough. Not the cheapest endeavor, but one that was wonderfully light and refreshing, hitting the dessert spot without overdoing it. Just one more quick mentioning of the staff member there (which will help with the five stars I'm throwing out) as she was friendly without being over the top and nice enough to let us know that if we bought a few more macaroons that it was 10% off. Also, that tart cake pre-order was easy to do and pick up which is worth nothing for anyone interested in getting a personalized letter or shape for an event. Hmm, perhaps that'll come in handy some time in the future... Overall, The Cookie Shop is a pleasantly near-perfect place that holds just the right amount of sweets and honestly ones that are not necessarily amongst your average selection. Don't expect chocolate covered peanut butter puffs here (though I just saw they are offering edible cookie dough). Instead, look for some fresh sweets made with plenty of quality and time. And hopefully, with this review plug, we'll see some other reviews popping up on here real soon. read more

See all

The cookies were delicious!! The staff is knowledge and super helpful. Ordering a special birthday cake for this weekend.

Such an amazing dessert spot! I first found out about this gem on Instagram and decided to take a little ride to try some goodies. I am so glad I did (and my daughter was too)! Our first impression was that the store itself is decorated beautifully. The pastel interior with faux flowers cascading down a dessert cart next to a gorgeous pink chair make for perfect instagrammable photos. The sweets display is easy to navigate and the gentleman working behind the counter answered all the questions we had. We wound up trying 6 macarons and two cookie sandwiches. They were all absolutely delicious. My daughter couldn't eat the birthday cake macaron fast enough. The triple chocolate cookie sandwich with cherry hazelnut filling is now in my top three desserts of all time. The cookies are top notch. I can't wait to go back and try some more. read more

We stopped here on a whim after driving by and in search of a dessert treat; I am so glad we did! The owner was very friendly and explained all of the cookie creations and we also chatted for a bit. The inside decor is beautiful! I love that there are other local vendor items for sale inside (flower arrangements and jewelry). He was very passionate about his work and it showed. We ordered a couple of different cookies to sample, my favorite one was the apple pie! I forget which other two but they were chocolate and did not disappoint. Highly recommend and will be back when we are visiting the island again! read more

Cute tasty treats. I love how small some of the deserts are. Will definitely go again

Delish macarons!! We had one of each flavor so you really can't go wrong. The snickerdoodle cookie was also a big highlight. Definitely worth a return trip. The ladies who work here are lovely and helpful. It's small owned business so let's keep them open!! read more

The sandwich cookies were delicious but the tarte was perfection! We came from out of town and needed to bring dessert to a catered family party. The caterer's were so impressed with the Tarte and sandwich cookies and asked for details. read more

This place exceeded my expectations! My wonderful friend bought me a cookie cake from here for my birthday and it was so delicious! I wish it was acceptable to eat a whole cake by yourself lol. Highly recommend! read more

Came here today to grab a few treats to bring to my mom for Mother's Day and ended up buying a ton of deserts. The apple tart was my favorite, while my boyfriend liked the cookie butter cookie sandwich. Can't wait to try to macaroons and tuxedo cake we bought. Check this place out! read more

Everything she makes is so beautiful and delicious Yum!! Worth the visit, will return when in town

I don't normally leave reviews but i just had to! These are the best cookies i have ever had ! The macrons are absolutely delicious the best i have had to date and i have tried many. The peanut butter cookie as welll i mean come on! I didn't know cookie could be that good. The service was great as well the woman that helped me was so kind. Will be returning. read more

I absolutely adore this shop. Stephanie is amazing and she puts so much love and care into her shop and bakes, it really shows! The seasonal selections are always fun and tasty. I have never eaten something from there I didn't like. Plus the aesthetic inside is A+, so adorable, clean, cozy and photo worthy. I drop by the shop whenever I have a special event or occasion where I need something not only beautiful, but delicious. And I love being able to support this shop and it's owner. Highly highly highly recommend. read more

The Cookie Shop - Harry Potter themed treats! - Bakeries Near Me - Brookhaven, New York

I was looking for favors for my daughter's baby shower and decided on macaroons. I'd never been here, but it was the closest specialty shop, so I thought I'd give it a try. This place is adorable! It's decorated with a feminine touch in pale pinks. There's even seating. The displays are pretty with a rainbow of macaroons and stuffed over sized cookies. Ordering is more an online thing, so don't expect to walk in and place an order. I got 80 boxed baby blue macaroons with vanilla filling, but not before bringing home a variety to taste. They were all delicious! These are a great hostess gift, wedding or shower favor, or just a colorful addition to your dessert table. I'll definitely be back. BTW, the tart cakes are beautiful! read more

The Cookie Shop - Bakeries Near Me - Brookhaven, New York

A one of a kind dessert shop! Like no other on Long Island. When I first tried their macarons, I knew I'd have to go to their beautiful shop location. The atmosphere is so dreamy and delightful with desserts to die for! Will absolutely be going back!!! read more

The Cookie Shop - Delicious treats like no other on Long Island! - Bakeries Near Me - Brookhaven, New York

Very cute little shop with amazingness in their baked goods my favorite so far are the shortbread sandwiches with raspberry filling very addictive just saying they are moist flavorful just yummy all around. My daughter loves the assortment of macaroons that they have quiet a few flavors along with these huge cookies that my hubby and youngest devoured all in all I enjoyed my visit and the nice and friendly staff they also deliver which is very convenient, will definitely return need my shortbread cookie fix. Need good deserts come and get them here. read more

When it was time to celebrate my husbands 25th anniversary at his workplace, I knew where to go. My daughters showed me pictures of beautiful tart cakes from Instagram. The Cookie Shop was the answer. I messaged them with an idea and they made an amazing "25" tart cake in the color theme needed. The cake was not only beautiful but delicious as well. If you are looking for something different, creative and delicious head on over to The Cookie Shop.. everything was easy from ordering to pickup . Communication was constant and I'm so happy my daughters found this new place! read more

The Cookie Shop - Bakeries Near Me - Brookhaven, New York