Still over 10 years later I can't look at my wedding photos or hear a wedding story and not immediately think how awful the Rolling Pin Bakery. The owner was rude and dismissive when I asked for refund of the profit she made. I really really suggest you go somewhere else. The fact they treat your wedding day like just another day, no care, no love, nothing but disappointment, disrespect, and distain if they screw up and you'd like it to be corrected. Rolling Pin is awful in all aspects. DO NOT ORDER ANY CAKE FROM THEM!!!!! read more

I had my wedding last Sunday 4/6 and had our cake made by Rolling Pin. They sent us a tasting a few months before and we picked vanilla sponge cake with strawberry jam. Absolutely delicious and was even better in the actual wedding cake. The one blemish on a perfect cake was that we ordered lilac or light purple icing for flowers on the cake, they turned out to be a dark blue. But great tasting cake nonetheless. read more

The Rolling Pin - Bakeries Near Me - East Setauket, New York

Ordered a fudge cake. Got home and cut it open and it was vanilla with vanilla icing. Not only was it stale and dry but they refused to swap it out for the one I actually ordered. read more

The rolling pin made my daughter's 15th and 16th birthday cakes, they were beautiful and delicious. Great customer service, The Price is good for the great quality of the cakes. read more

I have found this bakery to be very reliable. Plenty of well made pastries and tarts. We are fans of their many fruit tarts, cheese danish , macaroons and biscotti. My daughters love the lemon , raspberry and caramel nut squares . read more

The rolling pin made our wedding cake and man was it delicious I totally recommend this bakery as they were so easy to work with and even did special filling for us! We came back today to pick up our free 1st anniversary cake! So sweet for a bakery to do this. Thank you Rolling Pin! read more

See all

The current head baker is great and the quality of the cakes, fruit tarts and pastries is back to how it used to be! All the staff are sweet and helpful read more

I recently reached out to Rolling Pin to make cookie party favors for my parents surprise 30th anniversary party. I spoke to them through email and it was very organized and clear. I provided then with a photo as a sample and the color of the writing I wanted and they said they were able to get it done. The cookies came out absolutely gorgeous. They were one of the highlights of the party and my Mom was so excited about how well they came out. Additionally, every year for the past 20 years for Mother's day and Father's day I come to this bakery very early in the morning to pick our my parents respective favorite pastries. Me and my siblings serve the pastries to them for breakfast in bed and it makes their day every year. We normally get raspberry squares, black and white cookie, apple turnovers, cinnamon raisin bread (sliced) and lemon meringue pie. All of those pastries are consistently delicious every time we get them which is why we come back. I also recently discovered that they make different types of scones, besides their classic raisin scones. I had the lemon poppy scone for the first time 2 weeks ago and now I find myself constantly trying to find them in the bakery if I have some spare time to stop by and check! The blueberry scone is also quite delicious and only $2.95! Overall, this has been and still is my favorite bakery growing up and I will continue to be a frequent customer at this establishment. read more

See all

I live in Florida and took a chance ordering a special occasion cake for my daughter's bridal shower from The Rolling Pin. Communication via email was excellent and the final product was the best cake I've had in ages. It was a vanilla cake, chocolate chip cannoli filling with butter cream and it was so fresh, flavorful and so pretty too! Everyone loved it and I highly recommend The Rolling Pin to anyone needing a cake!!! read more

This ain't it. The Linzer Tart was gingerbread? Not good. The regular sandwich cookies had little taste. When you walk in, it doesn't even smell like baked goods. The cherry turnover was decent and they had dog, cookies, so they get 2 stars for that. This is a skip. read more

I placed a phone order for my son's birthday cake at the Rolling Pin in Setauket, or so. I thought. I went to pick it up a few days later and they were looking all over for my cake. They asked me about when I placed the order? What time I called approximately? when I looked to see when I called I saw that I had instead ordered it from the Rolling Pin in Madison, Wisconsin. . The manager asked me if I had a half an hour and she put together exactly the cake that I ordered. I can't tell you how appreciative, thrilled and happy I was to not be disappointing my sons on their birthday. Everybody in the shop was helpful and kind for my error. And of course the reason why I was ordering from there is their cakes are delicious. Everything from the rolling pin is wonderful. Thank you, thank you, thank you. What a professional shop. read more

If I could give less I would. This bakery was included with my venue and it is ridiculous. Just bc u r "included" doesn't mean u can steal... David's prices r ridiculous for upgrades. If u want flowers u must supply them, ribbons... supply them... Basically any decorations r extra... he quoted me 545.00 for basic sugar flowers which I made in my kitchen... (I make custom cakes) he said they take 10 days and r tons of work and I could buy them if I wanted to and bring them to him... they took me 2 hours.... just sayin... also when I called about a tasting they said come anytime no appointment... this sounded strange... i called 3 times and got the aame answer. after my 45min drive I was told oh... just go online, pick a cake and email the owner... hmmmmm Basically he wants to ice the cake and drop it off. I'm pretty sure he outsources his decorating and that's why he charges so much... if someone wants a ribbon, a flower etc u SHOULD BE DOING IT... silk ribbons, fake flowers... clients should not supply it. I asked for a plain white cake in the end and said I would decorate it myself b4 my wedding... it was becoming too stressful honestly.... He said no problem.... it came all nicked up and with blue buttercream dots... NOT WHAT I ASKED FOR... not the final decision... my Florist ended up decorating my cake... no extra charge bc she felt bad and it turned out beautifully... Now b4 I get a response from rolling pin... just know I have ALLLLLL my emails including what we decided on and your price gouging... and the buttercream was nicked up BEFORE my Florist touched the cake... ALL BRIDES SHOULD CHOOSE ANOTHER BAKERY IF ITS AN OPTION. read more

The Rolling Pin - My beautiful cake AFTER my Florist decorated it. See the light blue border, which was not what I asked for. - Bakeries Near Me - East Setauket, New York

Tried their vanilla cupcakes. The cake part was a bit drier than I like but had a mild amount of sweetness which I like. The butter cream felt light and not overly sweet. Well balanced and simple, but well decorated. read more

Went to rolling pin Lady behind the counter was super nice and helpful They didnt have a big selection maybe they were restocking I grabbed a chocolate mini cake with rainbow cake inside which was really good She mentioned some other cakes that looked good as well Their tarts looked very good I would have like to see more cookies maybe rainbow pignolis some linzar tarts read more

See all

Always fresh! Always excellent. The pastries are the best around! Stop here and get something and you'll see. Try the raspberry torte- OMG! Amazing! read more

The cake was gone so quickly I forgot to get a pic of it. The cake was nice and moist. Everyone loved it. read more

The Rolling Pin - Bakeries Near Me - East Setauket, New York

See all

Wonderful bakery with delicious items and a very pleasant staff. I have known this Baker and his father for 40 or 50 years. Originally that a wonderful bagel shop and then David went to culinary school and opened the Rolling Pin. read more

Wonderful working with this bakery for our wedding cake. Prompt email repliers and made it easy for the selection-choices outlined clearly with possible add ons and what is/isn't supplied. We went with the banana custard with vanilla sponge cake to have something different- it was an absolute hit. People are still complimenting it a few days later as a highlight of the event. Not only that but the cake was beautiful, very classy and simple design just as we hoped. Thanks so much!! read more

Passed by here after eating a few doors down. It's a small place...but pretty. Has all their cakes displayed nicely. I ordered: - gluten-free chocolate cake - bailey's irish cream cake - oatmeal cookie - blueberry scone Nothing much to say here other than it all looks delicious. Just my 2¢ though, they should have/get transparent plastic covers to cover the stuff on top of the counters. So the pastries can be displayed without flies getting to it, or it won't get stale as fast... Other than that, this place is great! read more

See all

Fantastic bakery. They made our wedding cake (filled with cannoli cream) and it was outstanding. We just ordered a smaller version for our Anniversary and they knocked it out of the park again! read more

We ask Rene at the Rolling Pin to make a small version of our wedding cake to celebrate our 24th anniversary. Chocolate with chocolate frosting and raspberry filling. It was out of this world! Both in the presentation and taste! There were beautiful flowers on the top and she added an extra touch of a bow around the cake. All of it delicious. We highly recommend the Rolling Pin!! Dan & Patty Callahan read more

The Rolling Pin - Wedding Anniversary cake - Bakeries Near Me - East Setauket, New York

Wow What an Amazing cake this Chef Made for my Sister for her Birthday Perfectly decorated Gorgeous flavor Moist cake Delicious trio of frostings And All Vegan Superb !!! Thank you Chef David read more

The Rolling Pin - Bakeries Near Me - East Setauket, New York

Amazing!!! We exclusive go to rolling pin and we are never disappointed! They make beautiful cakes at great prices!! read more

The Rolling Pin - Bakeries Near Me - East Setauket, New York

Won a gift card here, used to buy little treats for the family. Everyone enjoyed their dessert and felt everything was reasonable priced.

Best black and white cookie! Super moist, melt in your mouth, excellent icing. I don't normally go for this type of cookie but it was so good from here. We also got marble cookies, those were not as fresh and on the harder side. Had an amazing glazed chocolate donut, also one of the best I've had. Overall about 70% satisfied with what we got. If it's fresh, it will be super delicious. read more

This bakerys wedding cake came with our wedding package at the stonebridge. We got a few options to chose from and ended up going with a traditional chocolate and vanilla based cake with a vanilla buttercream icing. Cake was nice and fresh and looked exactly how we ordered it. To order the cake we had to do everything online which was a little annoying to be honest but all worked out. I also had to drive about 45 min each way to get out samples. The girls behind the counter were not that friendly but maybe they were just having a bad day. Over all a pretty solid cake for a wedding. read more

Nice solid bakery. Blueberry tart had nice cookie like crust. Will definitely try again

Posting on behalf of Susan; Many thanks to Rolling Pin Bakery in Setauket, NY for the most fantastic Baby Shower cake for my daughter. David and his staff created the exact vision we were hoping for. -Susan K. read more

The Rolling Pin - Bakeries Near Me - East Setauket, New York

This is a small, neighborhood bakery with great cakes and cookies. It didn't have a huge variety but everything you get is good. The strawberry shortcake is particularly delicious. read more

The Rolling Pin used to be our favorite bakery, but after our recent visit, we'll stick with supermarkets for our baked goods. We were there on an early Sunday afternoon, when it was moderately busy. We ordered a seedless rye bread and a cherry tart. One of the several young women behind the counter was reading a lengthy message on her phone to all her fellow employees, bringing all business to a halt. I felt like apologizing for interrupting their fun by trying to buy something from them. Eventually, we got our order and left. The poor service was Strike 1. At home, we tried the cherry tart, which was very good (although a bit pricey, like all of their baked goods). However, when we tried the rye bread, IT WAS NOT RYE! Strike 2. A day later we went to make sandwiches with the not-rye bread, which was already getting quite stale. My wife discovered a blue patch on the bottom of some of the bread slices, which looked like MOLD! Strike 3. They're out! We will not waste any more time or money at the Rolling Pin. read more

The Rolling Pin - Moldy Not-Rye Bread - Bakeries Near Me - East Setauket, New York

I am giving my review 3 stars because of the generous free samples they offered for my wedding. They have 3 free cake samples which were cupcakes one for each bride and groom. You can get up to 5 so I selected 2 extra and paid for those. However the samples were dry and the frosting was very sugary. My fiancé and I personally were not a fan of any of the selections. We tried vanilla, chocolate, marble and red velvet with different frosting combos. Our search continues for our perfect wedding cake. read more

My favorite bakery. They made my wedding cake and husbands custom tres leches cake for his birthday. Will use them for every occasion!

I have been going here for years and will keep going because their cakes are usually amazing and so beautifully designed. But, I recently ordered a custom cake for a birthday. Way too much filling! Everything was tasty but there wasn't much cake and there was an enormous amount of icing and filling, and it was just odd. I don't know what happened but we didn't feel we were eating a cake, but rather just a lot of filling. Might need to be more specific about just how much filling we want in the future? read more

The Rolling Pin - Cake, or mostly filling - Bakeries Near Me - East Setauket, New York

So it's my turn to buy the cake for a birthday celebration at the office, and I had a Groupon for The Rolling Pin ($10 for $20 worth of baked goods). What better way to put it to use? I go there before going to work and it's PACKED at 8am on a Thursday morning! That was totally unexpected, but a good sign. I picked up: 1) 8" Cannoli Cake - $14.95 2) 8" Chocolate Mousse Cake - $14.95 They had no problems accepting the Groupon, and my total came out to $9.90 (so basically $19.90 including the price of the Groupon). This was an excellent deal as both cakes were beautiful. I didn't try the Cannoli Cake (I don't like Cannoli- is that weird?) but the Chocolate Mousse Cake was fresh, fluffy, and not overly sweet-- although I wish it had less frosting/cream and more cake. Both cakes were big hits with my coworkers! ----------------------- HOWEVER, this bakery still only stands at A-OK because: 1) They didn't have anything original. I could have gotten similar cakes with similar prices at similar bakeries elsewhere. 2) It seemed like a CHORE for the woman behind the counter to be helping me. You work in an atmosphere where you're surrounded by cake-- be happy damnit! OVERALL: Good cakes and a good deal after the Groupon, but since I don't live in the area, and can find the same products closer to my house... I don't know if I'll be back. read more

See all

went the other day and the stock was down for sure then had some apple pie and it went

Went last night to pick up a dessert to bring to a friend's house. Was pleasantly surprised they were open late. We bought chocolate cigars and everyone was raving about how good they were. read more

The Rolling Pin - Chocolate cigars - Bakeries Near Me - East Setauket, New York

This bakery was my included vendor in the wedding package I did at the View in oakdale. I spoke with David for about 3 months about my cake, did my tasting and all that. Throughout this time he kept telling me "any of the standard 30 cakes on their website were totally included in my package deal. However any cakes with sea shells, flowers, or ribbons - those are extra." So I picked a very simple tiered cake, no extras. Then a month b4 my wedding, when I gave them all my final choices and actually ordered the cake, i suddenly find out fondant icing is $285 extra. Uhhh what?? Lol The upcharge itself wasn't the issue, the problem I had was that after 3 months of conversing, they decided to tell me this at the very end of the ordering. Coincidence? No. As I vented on fb (lol) another bride who used them commented and let me kno the same thing happened to her. It's clear they do this on purpose to be sneaky and get the extra charge in at the last min. There are disclaimers on their website for the flowers, ribbons, etc. but nothing about fondant. They prob figure by that time most brides will feel its very late to start all over and they'll just pay the upcharge. But not this bride! We called David and he wouldn't budge. He was a bit rude and said "well u can always go to another bakery." And that was it! Psht. What a waste of my time and almost my money! Looks like since my complaint they added a fondant disclaimer on their website, but they cud have at least lowered or waived the charge for me for the confusion. read more

Best in town!! That doesn't mean it is the best. As for bakeries in the Stony Brook area, can't beat it yet. cons: Too much grainy sugar in the creme bruele. read more

The Rolling Pin - Bakeries Near Me - East Setauket, New York

I purchased a cake for my friends bridal shower. It was very easy to order exactly what I wanted, the price was fantastic, and the cake came out beautiful and was so delicious. We did vanilla cake with buttercream frosting, and custard with banana inside. It got a ton of compliments. I will definitely plan to be a repeat customer! read more

The Rolling Pin - Thrilled with the bridal shower cake we got from Rolling Pin! - Bakeries Near Me - East Setauket, New York

Stopped in the Rolling Pin bakery and was greeted by the workers who were very nice and recommended some of their best cookies and they were not kidding, the chocolate chip cookie was to die for as well as the m&m one, i high recommend this bakery and I can not wait to try everything else they have. read more