It's nearly a half hour drive for me to go Tilda's Bakery in Rocky Point. I don't go to bakeries a lot so it must be good. I love their Pecan Coffee Cake. They make it in a ring or in a long, wide strip- either way it is The Best. Sometimes I buy bread or Banana Nut Loaf also , but I make the drive for the Pecan Ring. And everything else must be good too, because there's always a line, in the middle of this town that's deader than a mackerel- no offense intended. Good bakeries are hard to find. read more

The best in baked goods. The service is prompt and friendly. A scent of heaven when you walk in.

In Tilda's on April 21, 2026, about noon. Waiting in line. 3 people in front of were waited on by people behind the counter. Came to my "turn" the lady, tall dark hair, talks to a lady behind me, like they are friends. She then looks at the lady behind me " what can I get you"? I spoke up, "wait, am I invisible"? The lady behind the counter, instead of waiting on me says" I have to go in the back, be right back"! I spoke kind of loudly, I am out of here, and will not tolerate that kind of service. Will never go back to Tilda's again, and mention that to all my friends etc... read more

My family gets all of our custom cakes from here because they never disappoint! Recently we had my sisters baby shower and of course came to Tildas for the cake, when it came down to design I asked if they could do Winnie the Pooh I emailed a couple Inspo pics and said I trusted their design choices. When we picked the cake up we were all so excited to take the top off and look and of course the cake was BEAUTIFUL! My sister was in love with it and of course everyone raved about how amazing the cake tasted. Thank you Tildas for always making such beautiful and yummy cakes! read more

Tilda's Bake Shop - Winnie the Pooh cake - Bakeries Near Me - Rocky Point, New York

See all

It was my sister's birthday and we ate at Sea Basin right next door. I've been meaning to come to Tilda's for a while now but just never had the right occasion to get something. My job was going on about one of their pastries so I'm glad I got to check it out. The line moved quickly and we were helped right away. My sister didn't know what she wanted but knew she wanted chocolate. So I asked the person, "what is your best selling chocolate cake?" He said, "chocolate cake layered with chocolate mousse, covered in chocolate ganache". I said, "that's the one, thank you!" It was the last one, too! I've been controlling my sugar intake but this day, I was going to make it a cheat day to have that. It was soooooo good! Definitely coming back! read more

See all

The the customer service was amazing treats desserts was delicious!!! I found this place on yelp stopped by and they were friendly and helped me I was able to get my cake ordered for tomorrow read more

This review is just for the jelly donuts. I purchased 4. The donuts themselves are delicious and may be the best on long island. But 3 of 4 had maybe a small spoonful of jelly in them. The last one I gave up and combined it with a jar of smuckers raspberry because the jelly content was so low. I do not understand why so many bakeries do this. Do not cheap out on the jelly. Charge more if you have to. But when a donut has 8 bites and only 2 have jelly in them, that's not good. read more

So good! Everything we got was amazing! Big crowd pleasers! Will absolutely be back.

Placed an order for Father's Day. Got 3 almond danishes, one apple danish, 12 rainbow cookies, a rainbow cupcake and 3 mini pecan pies. Only picture I could get before everyone started demolishing them. Incredible service (as usual) and super super yummy. read more

Tilda's Bake Shop - In caption - Bakeries Near Me - Rocky Point, New York

So disappointed. Have been a customer for nearly 20 years and decided to have them create a cake for our engagement photos, unfortunately the simplest ask of "all white cake with white roses" wasn't met. Upon ordering 4 days before and making a visit to double confirm everything 2 days before, I came to pick up the cake with green stems, when I explicitly asked for all white everything. Upon voicing my disappointment and stressing the importance of the cake, i was told "nothing we can do the decorator isn't here today." Basically was turned away and charged full price for the cake with no offer of any kind of support for the mistake. Really disappointed and such a bad taste in my mouth with them after this experience. read more

I ordered a custom cake for my daughter's birthday. Amanda was a big help assisting me in ordering the perfect cake. The cake was decorated beautifully and was delicious! read more

Tilda's Bake Shop - Custom Birthday Cake! - Bakeries Near Me - Rocky Point, New York

This bakery has really gone downhill. Baked goods are stale & tasteless. They taste like perfume or some kind of sanitizer is on them. And when you walk in there is absolutely no smell of baking...??? What a shame, used to be really good before they sold it to this new owner And all the sweet, kind employees are gone read more

I've been going to Tildas bakery for years. I was always very pleased, but I do have to say that as of late, the last two cakes that I purchased have been dry, and they have not tasted fresh. Everyone that ate a piece of them said the same thing. So right now, I'm going out to get a cake for dessert as we're going to my son's house for dinner. I'll be going to King Kullen for that cake. Sorry Tildas, I hope you get back on track. The service is always good and the establishment is always clean. read more

When I heard Tildas was bought by a Reinwald then I knew it would be the best bakery in Suffolk co. Their doughnuts are the best as are their danishes! I've loved them since Bellerose and New Hyde Park!! read more

Hmm. Turn the car around to check out this small town friendly looking neighborhood bakery with at least three other customers coming in though mid day /mid week. Tilda's since 1955 has its regulars. Saw some gently baked pale looking butter cookies. Tried a few and flavor of the almond butter cookies was fresh and good. Tried the ordinary looking Cannoli . I specifically asked if made with Ricotta or the other way milk/flour. On one bite I could see they were as said made the right way and had exceptional crunch to the shells and flavor. For flavor I rank them right up there with the better known places. Other items similar to most bakeries. Danishes, donuts, cheesecakes, bread etc . All looked fresh. That's a good thing Nearby a Prestano's closed. But still the main one is up in Selden So bakeries are often hard to last with more than one in a town now. But this one looks like it's part of the town. Cheers to small towns that stay that way. read more

Tilda's Bake Shop - Bakeries Near Me - Rocky Point, New York

Upon finding out that Tilda's was under new ownership and the owner was a Reinwald, I made the trip to try out some of their baked goods. Rye bread was as good as Reinwald's (Huntington, RIP) was. Jelly donuts were fantastic. Upon being previously disappointed in Buttercooky's (bought Reinwald's in Huntington) bastardized take on a Black Forest Cake - newsflash, there is NO vanilla cake in a Black Forest Cake! - my wife got a Black Forest Cake for my birthday last weekend from Tilda's and it looked and tasted the same as I remembered from Reinwald's. Tilda's will be our new go to bakery, even if it means making the longer drive. So worth it! Great job Dan & crew! read more

This place needs some competition. Lack of options is what makes Tilda's so popular. There are no other bakeries around neighboring towns. I've never had anything bad there. I used to work for a bakery, so I know what really good baked goods should be like, and this isn't it. Everything is ok. Donuts are great. Pizza dough used to be fresh & delicious. now it's frozen and significantly smaller. The stuff baked fresh daily is good. Cakes and cookies that are there for a while before you buy them are decent. But very expensive! My in-laws always bring dessert from Tildas to my home. It's good. When I need a cake or a pie, I go to Sam's club or Bakewicz farms for a fresh made pie read more

Great Place to go for doughnuts, danishes and pastries... I always stop by when I'm in the area. read more

Tilda's Bake Shop - Napoleon's and Cannoli's - Bakeries Near Me - Rocky Point, New York

Tilda's used to be the best but I just had a chocolate eclair that was absolutely awful. It tasted stale, the custard in the middle was frozen and tasted horrible, and they added the custard by slicing the eclair in half - it wasn't piped in like it usually is. My husband had a Boston cream donut that was soaked in grease. read more

Ohhh the Kaiser rolls! Seriously, donuts cakes, etc is delicious. But the rolls? With the 20 minute ride to get there. Trust me. I'm and expert on carbs! read more

I have been coming here to Tilda's for years. This is the best bakery I have been to in Suffolk County. They have a large selection and everything is delicious. I highly recommend this bakery for all occasions. YUMMMM read more

If you get used to buying you bread where you buy your groceries, there's something that your missing out on. Sure Stopping and Shopping for everything all at once has some convenience and the King is so close that it seems wasteful to make a trip all the way to a Stand-alone bakery JUST to get bread. But if your thinking this, you've clearly forgotten what f real fresh baked bread smells like. Let that aroma fill you car for the ride home and and you;ll know that this is the only way to go. We haven't even eaten it yet but the smell is intoxicating. I know many times we are too rushed and that extra 30 minute to make a separate trip seems so unmanageable, but once that aroma fills your car, you'll realize you need to re-prioritize to experience more often. read more

Asked if they had lemon meringue and was told special order. Cool! I have zero problem with special ordering. The ordering process was simple. I wish that I knew special order meant that they never make this. Lemon filling was good - tart and smooth - just wonderful, but there was a layer of breadcrumb between the meringue and the filling, which, I've never seen before. Creating this awful, off putting texture. The meringue itself didn't appear whipped all the way. Instead of being smooth and glossy it looks like sea-foam and has the same texture. Customer service was great. Review is specifically on this one pie type. read more

Tilda's Bake Shop - Sample pie spoonful. - Bakeries Near Me - Rocky Point, New York

I went to get a Father's day cake, I told the young girl the one I wanted and can she write HAPPY FATHERS DAY, she goes the guy will write it soon anything else, we started asking about pastries she said she didn't know about some but the don't sell so guess they arent good. WOW after waiting for this guy on his phone call, us being the only 2 people in the bakery she said to him can you write on the cake ,he said I'm to busy! WHAT you made me stand there for what. So the young girl wrote on the cake as you can see it came out horrible. They treat you like you are bothering them its very sad! They need new help A.S A.P who are these owners? You can't leave kids there, well The guy wasn't a kid but he did not want to be bothered! Need a new bakery can't deal with tildas anymore. read more

Tilda's Bake Shop - A HORRIBLE WRITING FOR HAPPY FATHERS DAY!! VERY BAD SERVICE, RUDE EMPLOYWEES! I DO NOT RECOMMEND THIS PLACE.THERE IS ALWAYS A PROBLEM. - Bakeries Near Me - Rocky Point, New York

See all

One of the best bakery in the area. Cakes, cookies brownies all amazing and delicious. Let's support local businesses.

We were bringing dessert to a dinner invite at friends in E Hampton. We pre-ordered a strawberry short cake. This is not our first rodeo with Tilda's Bake Shop and up until that day, were very satisfied with their products so the trip there was always worth it. The cake was quite stale, and we were not only shocked, but embarrassed as well for we had bragged about the quality of products from this bakery. So very disappointed. read more

If you are looking to assemble yourself the ultimate "big sandwich" look no further than Tildas for your source of carbohydrates. The Italian bread has the perfect balance of crisp outter shell and soft dense center. The sandwich will 100% need a canoe job (some inner bread removal). Crumb warning. A dust buster may be needed as this monster isn't going down without a fight! Tip: you can head to the source OR have your local deli or bodega start to carry this bread in store! read more

Tilda's Bake Shop - Seedless Italian bread - Bakeries Near Me - Rocky Point, New York

See all

My daughter's boyfriend lives nearby and she had purchased goods a few times.... Im vegan so a bakery??? Lol but they had vegan cookies so I got some... uh not that good . But I can say a huge assortment and friendly service...expensive too.... It's no secret that the vegan population IS GROWING so the world needs to be open and serve !!!!! read more

Cute little bakery in Rocky Point. Bread and pastries are usually fresh and delicious. A couple of times they were out of the bread I wanted but I think everyone in the area loves them and they sell out sometimes! My favorite in the area. read more

It is one of the few bakeries in the area and probably one of the better ones. Better tasting bakeries are a distance away. Bakery is clean and well stocked. It read more

Peanut butter Carmel cake discontinued and you can no longer order it even in advance. They said it didn't sell well. What a joke. What do you mean you can't order it? What do you not have eggs and chocolate cake mix now? I was told it's the only cake with Carmel. Please give me a break. I'll take my business elsewhere. It was good while it lasted. The replacement cake for what it is worth sucked.!!! read more

Tilda's is terrific local neighborhood bakeshop with a huge range of cakes, cookies, breads, and pastries. It's been around for many years and is a classic because they're always consistent. They have online shopping and great seasonal offerings too, especially for St. Patrick's Day and Christmas. I love the mini offerings of treats like cannolis, napoleons, and cream puffs because they allow you to try a range of desserts without getting stuffed. read more

See all

Smelled like grandmas kitchen when you walked in. Very homey, friendly staff, great price and most importantly delicious pastry

Stopped in today. Everything looked amazing! I couldn't resist this eclair. I'll be back for a cupcake for sure! read more

Tilda's Bake Shop - Bakeries Near Me - Rocky Point, New York

Take out Date: January 31, 2015 When I got together with my husband and some of his friends to geek out with a star wars pen & paper role playing game we decided to have a pot luck dinner. The game manager got two pies from here for dessert. The pies were okay. The apples in the apple pie had a cinnamon flavor to them, the crust reminded me of an apple pie from the grocery store though. The chocolate creme pie was okay too. I liked the pudding but the whipped cream was just okay and I felt like there wasn't a great balance between the ratio of whipped cream and chocolate pudding. Not a bad bakery but I wouldn't say it was extraordinary or spectacularly yummy. read more

Tilda's Bake Shop - chocolate cream pie - Bakeries Near Me - Rocky Point, New York

See all

Banana creme pie was great. Key lime pie was horrible. There was NO key lime filling, just whipped cream and crust. Might want to pay attention to this instead of all the rainbow mafia nonsense. read more

They're always closed. Love their baked goods but I will walk from my moms in the rain expecting them to be open because it says they're open. These people do not like business. They are business snobs. Got sick of it so they lost my business forever. read more

Extremely disappointed. Placed an order over a week ago for specialty cupcakes. I was very specifoc that i moreso wanted carrot cake muffins and wanted absolutely no frosting in or on them. Was told no problem. Went to pick up and they were not correct. Unfortunately they said there was nothing that they could do...they cook in bulk and that the person who took the order should have known they couldn't make carrot cake cupcakes without any frosting. Unfortunately this is not the first time they have messed up an order read more

I feel so sad even writing this not only did they ruin my sons birthday cake but they were beyond rude about it... Iam not one to complain or give people a hard time but this cake was just unacceptable. I was hung up on and spoken to very rudely. I felt extremely disrespected I reached out to the bakery by e-mail a month prior to the event for a birthday cake after not hearing back i called and was told the e-mail was not correct on their website.... After i got intouch with them I gave them 2 cakes to pick from to see if they could make it because i did need it to be vegan.. They picked out of the two and promised that they could do it . The cake looks nothing like what we asked for and we paid 120.00 for it , i would have went with another cake or a different bakery but they were dishonest about it. When i had called and told them about the cake the guy was so rude to me and kept hanging up on me... My husband was able to get 50.00 back because we do understand the cake costs money to make we weren't at all trying to pull a fast one and get a free cake out if this it was just so bad and so disappointing. The weren't even sympathetic , or apologetic... they were so rude and that's what made this even more upsetting ... there was no compassion . Again i am not one to make trouble and give people a hard time but this was just so unfortunate and disappointing . This cake was an absolute joke and we will not ever be returning to this bakery and advise others to do the same.. It is sad people run their business like this . This cake will forever be in every picture of my sons big day and a horrible memory to say the very least . I posted the pictures of the cake we got and what it should have been on the google reviews and facebook as well. read more

Tilda's Bake Shop - This is the cake we got... never again - Bakeries Near Me - Rocky Point, New York

See all

Uggh. Horrible, overpriced overrated. Don't waste your money here. Unfriendly staff, long lines for some unknown reason because nothing good here. read more