Saturday November 8th, 2025. Bought a tres leches cake for my mothers Birthday. Has fruit filling and topped with fruit. The cake was moist and delicious! read more

See all

Not a place to go if you don't appreciate being insulted by the trash working at the counter. I'm a Latina and I went to try this bakery for the first and last time with my Caucasian husband. I guess the ignorant bastard was unable to deal with our age gap because he's obviously the relationship therapist. He had to interrupt the nice young man that was helping us to share his views. The owner should be aware of the poor behavior of his employees. As a Latina I expect to walk into a white owned business and be treated with respect. My husband should be able to go into a Spanish owned business and get respect too. This is a huge failure. read more

Order a chocolate and more chocolate birthday cake. It was absolutely delicious. I would highly recommend Celeste Bakery!

I celebrated my daughter's fifth birthday at the Long Island Aquarium and I was looking for a Little Mermaid themed cake to have at our lunch after. I contacted Celeste Bakery since they were close to the aquarium and I am so happy I did! They prepared a spectacular themed cake that was exceptionally delicious. I've ordered special birthday cakes from a number of renowned Long Island bakeries and this was by the far the best. My daughter loves strawberries and they made a strawberry flavored cake with whipped cream and fresh strawberry filling. My family is still talking about it! I reached out to them again when I was planning a Summer Olympics event and they again went above and beyond by preparing an amazing themed cake and themed individually wrapped cookie favors. They were able to do Red, White, & Blue layers inside the cake again with fresh strawberries. I look forward to our next family event so I can order from them again! read more

See all

I was so pleased with my cake. Not only was it moist But it was soooo delicious.. the service was great staff helped me load my cake and made sure it was secure. THANK YOU Celeste Bakery for an awesome experience read more

Celeste Bakery - My Daughters Graduation Cake And it was sooooo delicious - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

My wife went in there for the first time, today. Was very disappointed. One the workers did not understand English. Two they were rude she (wife) understood some of language and they were talking about her(wife) in their language! So wife asks for semolina bread they had no idea what it was! That was the first time going there and will definitely be the last! No stars for this place! read more

Fantastic whole wheat/grain croissants at a reasonable price! Friendly staff! I LOVE croissants, especially whole grain ones, so will definitely be back for more! :) read more

I googled bakeries closest to me after shopping at Tánger right before Christmas. They thankfully had Christmas cookie platters and I was delighted to see an absolutely gorgeous selection of cookies, cakes and breads, and much more. So so SO glad I stumbled across this bakery. Thank you for making such delicious treats! read more

Celeste Bakery - The most beautiful and DELICIOUS sponge cake with custard and fruit on top - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

See all

I bought a tres leches cake and the fruit was old and dry and started to mold. When I talked to the manager they told me that their is nothing that they can do for me. They can't switch out the cake give me a refund nothing. This is ridiculous and just downright shamefull. read more

See all

I noticed this bakery when we went to the UPS store next door, tummies rumbling because we'd rushed out to run errands without eating breakfast yet again. Wasn't sure if it would be any good since we were in a Riverhead strip mall, but plenty of Latinos were going in, so I figured it must be legit. Sent hubby in to pick up breakfast while baby and I stayed behind in the car, and he came back with tres leche cake, sweet bread, a cream-filled donut, and an orange crumbly pastry which looked like an empanada, but was actually filled with a vanilla cream and had the texture of a cookie. They satisfied our hunger pangs without being saccharine sweet. read more

See all

Great little spot! A huge array of Hispanic and non-Hispanic baked goods, plus paches (Guatemalan potato tamales) and tamales on Fridays and Saturdays. Friendly, bright and cheery. I had two spicy chicken paches and a guava turnover. Everything was delicious! read more

Absolutely wonderful chocolate croissants! A real surprise. Also, a fun little treat for dunking, called a cat's tongue, read more

Tres leche cake with fruit filling (for 20 people) was an amazing cake ! So happy I ordered it from here. Cake was moist and not super sweet like any other tres leche cake (especially the icing). The cake decoration was nice. I highly recommend this cake from Celeste bakery. read more

Celeste Bakery - Tres leche cake with fruit filling - Bakeries Near Me - Riverhead, New York

I've had a home on the North Fork for 20 years and only recently discovered Celeste Bakery. The pastries are excellent, and authentic variety. Also custom photo cakes to order in advance. Celeste Bakery has extended hours, perfect for people coming out from the city through Riverhead on a Friday evening. I recently left an expensive item accidentally on the counter with my phone number on it, and I had no idea where I left it. The staff called me twice to pick it up, so thoughtful! Make the stop! Right near the circle in Riverhead. read more