We had the opportunity to stop in and enjoy this special spot in St. Augustine. We are visiting from out of town and my child's classmate recommended this place. It was perfect for a teenager. It would be a good idea to make a reservation but our wait was only 10 minutes while the table was prepared. We each chose to do the sample plate and our $9 per person for the reservation was applied toward the order. The pricing was more than reasonable for what we received. Our 13 year old enjoyed choosing the cakes he wanted to try and I could see how this would be fun for the teen age group as well. They have a wide variety of flavors to try out. Also, we were offered complimentary tea as part of the experience. There are seasonal and regular choices and the savory options were different and delicious. We sat and talked and shared in a great experience as a family. It is a good option to stop in after walking around Flagler and some shops to just sit in a peaceful setting with a unique experience. We were so glad we took time to step in and try Bar Harbor out. The cakes, service and setting were delightful! read more

Wonderful!! Chocolate, cheesecake and port!!! Great spot for dessert! Really enjoyed. Ladies who work there, or own, make the whole experience very special!! read more

Super cute and intimate little dessert place tucked away in downtown st Augustine. We always get 2 of the cheesecake flights and share them to mix and match the flavors, can't beat the price. A flight of 3 flavors for $7, we usually do 6 flavors for $14 each and spend about $28-30 but it's so worth it as a sweet ending to date night. They have SOO many flavors to choose from, my personal favorite is the dark chocolate orange truffle and my husband loves the cannoli and red velvet! Check them out, you won't be disappointed. read more

Delicious cheesecakes samplers, teas, and fun atmosphere in a 100+ year old building! They even offer a lobstah cheesecake! read more

Bar Harbor Cheesecake - Amazing cheesecakes, teas, and atmosphere!! - Desserts Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

This is such a hidden gem and new business to St Augustine! The cheesecake flight was such a great ending to our day. They have over 70 flavors to choose from and are all made on site. They also offer wine tasting and small plates. We chatted with one of the owners and their story is so Interesting. Everyone currently working there is a partner and that includes their first location in Bar Harbor Maine ( which is open seasonally) they quit their jobs and moved to Maine from Indiana and then to Fl in Dec 2020! They are always adding more flavors. We liked GA peach, white chocolate macadamia and Irish cream although all were light creamy and delicious! Do yourself a favor and stop by for a bite of cheesecake and a great experience! read more

Bar Harbor Cheesecake - Two cheesecake flights, - Desserts Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

Sweet little spot with great service and a wonderful cheesecake. Perfect for couples, girls weekend and family. You feel extra special here and our family loved the experience read more

Bar Harbor Cheesecake - Cheesecake - Desserts Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

See all

Five stars for super friendly service alone! We passed this place during a ghost tour (it's right next to a cemetery and also the famous love tree!) and were intrigued. They have $5 flights to try 3 pieces of their many cheesecake flavors. Super good! Felt like finding a hidden gem. read more

Bar Harbor Cheesecake - Desserts Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

Love that we found this place everything was great and will be back, highly recommend the wines with the cheese cake read more

Bar Harbor Cheesecake - Everything was great - Desserts Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

Another fantastic spot in Saint Augustine! Cute little house set up perfectly with tables for1 to 5 people. Huge menu of delicious cheesecakes. I wish I could have tried them all but my friend and I each bought a sampler platter with three good size portions of cheesecake. I had the blueberry lemon which was my favorite, I also had the chunky monkey, and I can't remember the last one but it was delish! This sampler is only $5 and SO worth it! Lisa was so nice and knowledgeable of the flavors. This is a must stop when in St. Augustine. read more

They have 100+ flavors for cheesecake. Don't knock it until you try it. Flavors are well balanced and the consistency is smooth. The cheesecakes are not overly sweet which I enjoyed. The service was quick and the ambience was friendly and relaxing. read more

We stopped here to get a couple cheesecakes to go. We got the triple chocolate and lemon chiffon. Both were 10/10 - excellent. We didn't see inside but the place was charming from what we did see. read more

Such an awesome hidden gem in St Augustine! We did the cheesecake and wine tastings for $9 and for the quality of the cheesecake and wine it was SO worth it! Definitely recommend for an intimate date night or if you're just looking for some top notch dessert in the area! read more

Bar Harbor Cheesecake - Cheesecake tasting - Desserts Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

See all

My husband and I went here for dessert on our last night in St Augustine. I saw this cute little place across from the BBQ place where we were having dinner and knew I had to try it. The atmosphere truly draws you in. It is such a quaint, cozy place and I can only imagine what this place looks like around Christmas time. We did the wine and cheesecake tasting and it was incredible, it was hard to choose a favorite. Our server was very friendly and knowledgeable on the menu items. The service was quick although it's the kind of place you want to stay for hours. Definitely try this place out! read more

Had a really disappointing experience here today. After visiting this restaurant in the fall and loving it, we were very excited to go back for my mom's birthday. We arrived at 11:15am (they are supposed to open at 11:11am) - the gate was closed and the restaurant was dark. We called to see if they were open and there was no answer, so we left to shop for a bit. We thought they might have gotten a late start, so we called around 11:40am and they let us know that they were open. My mom and aunt were finishing shopping, so I went over to the restaurant to have a drink and snack before they arrived. When I got there I explained that it would be a party of 3, but that it would just be me for a bit. The host let me know that they only serve full parties. I asked if I could have a table for 1 until they arrived and then I could close my tab and move to the table of 3 then. He called to the back and they said they would only seat the full party. I 100% understand waiting for the entire party, but the restaurant was completely empty and I was going to be purchasing items and then joining my mom and aunt once they arrived. At that point, I left and we found another place to go to. We had been planning on spending a good chunk of the afternoon there drinking wine, having lunch, getting cheesecake, and purchasing bottles of wine to go, so it was super disappointing that after walking there twice today, I wasn't able to do any of that either time. read more

We had an amazing time at Bar Harbor Cheesecake. From the moment we arrived we were treated like family. We tried both the savory and sweet cheesecakes. We love how it feels like home. read more

I'm obsessed. I think about their food more often than I'd like to admit. You can't go wrong here! And after speaking with employees, they are among the happiest bunch I have ever come across. their satisfaction with the working environment shows in their food. 5 stars all day. I can't wait to visit St Augustine again so I can come here everyday read more

Delectable! Amazing experience, they offer both sweet and savory (yes, savory cheesecakes) wine and charcuterie boards, complementary tea and more is an adventure of flavors, a place full of character with great service. Try the Triple Chocolate Chunk Cheesecake! Yummy read more

After much consideration due to the high price tag ($14 and $16) for a very small pie, we decided to buy two cheesecakes to take home, we settled for pistachio and banana cream pie.Well, when we opened the banana cheesecake was a coconut cream pie, which not only we did not ordered but we didn't like. The coconut taste is very strong and fake, they added way too much extract and overpowered the delicate texture of the cheesecake, the pistachio taste nothing like pistachio, I am not saying that it was bad, but if I am buying a pistachio cheesecake I don't want a green cheesecake with a few crushed pistachios that taste just like any other regular soft cheesecake. I will never go back. read more

The atmosphere is very inviting. The Bar Harbor Cheesecake Company is located at 6 Cordova Street in downtown St Augustine. Nestled in a turn of the century building we were greeted by smiling faces and sat indoors. The menu has a variety of food, meat and cheese boards, smoked salmon boards, salads, hummus, and much more! They specialize in wine flights paired with cheesecakes over 40 varieties homemade.. Give yourself and your tastebuds a real treat! read more

See all

It was great experience, recommend ordering the simple basic cheesecakes. We had 2x cheesecake flights! Definitely the spot to go for a date night experience in St. Augustine. read more

Bar Harbor Cheesecake - Cheesecake flight - Desserts Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

We will come here every time we visit St. Augustine. They offer flights of wine and flights of cheese cake. We get two wine flights, a cheese cake flight, and a hummus platter. It was less than $40. It was quiet (even though we had a baby with us), and everyone was friendly. They have chocolate and charcuterie boards as well. I would recommend this place to our friends. read more

We got cheesecake to go... it was the best cheesecake I have ever had! They were so kind and gave great recommendations! We left with a butter pecan and a lemon cinnamon cheesecake :) read more

I will start by saying that if I could give more than 5/5 stars, I would! This place is amazing! First, the servers are so kind and helpful. Second, the wine is delightful. Third, the cheesecake is the BEST I've ever had. They had over 20 flavors of the sweet cheesecake to choose from so we ordered 4 flights to share and they had at least 6 different savory flavors so we ordered 2 of those as well. It was so good and if we lived here in St. Augustine, we'd gain 10 pounds because we'd be there all the time. You are seriously missing out if you don't give this place a chance!! read more

See all

The service was great, it's a very intimate experience even with people dining at near by tables. The staff was very kind and attentive. Enjoyed the variety of cheesecakes offered and the ambiance of the restaurant being converted from older home. Will definitely be going back to try some more items! Ordered a flight and all the cheesecakes were a moose like consistency and not overly sweet! read more

Fantastic experience! What a cool little gem of a place tucked away in historic downtown St. Augustine! Best charcuterie board I've had in Florida and the wine was yummy too! read more

Bar Harbor Cheesecake - Desserts Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

A romantic place to celebrate your birthday. There was a very sweet woman who was so helpful and nice who also gave us a cake as a gift for my birthday. We eat outside at one of the small tables on the outdoor patio. We ate the hazelnut cheesecake and the key lime pie cheesecake, both were very delicious. It felt very romantic and a special experience to celebrate your birthday with your spouse. read more

This was such a beautiful place with wonderful staff and delicious food. We had the salmon board and a sampler of cheesecake, and we loved every minute there. This will be a "must go" place for us whenever we visit St Augustine (or Bar Harbor) read more

Bar Harbor Cheesecake - Salmon Board - Desserts Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

This place is fabulous! What a lovely find!! The cheesecake is delectable!! Looking forward to bringing family here and maybe doing a wine tasting too!! read more

WOW isn't enough!!!! We went here after a terrible ghost tour and as a treat because we were leaving the next day. What a treat it turned out to be! Very friendly!! We showed up at 10:45 (closes at 11) but we were not rushed or made to feel rushed in any way. The cheesecake is INCREDIBLE!! I recommend the flight so you can try multiple flavors. It was the perfect amount, especially for a late night "snack". We are not wine drinkers but others were raving about the wine as well. Would visit this business again and not sure I will ever have a Cheesecake Factory piece of cheesecake again!! Our server also gave us a recommendation for a brunch spot the next day which also turned out to be great!! read more

This place is fantastic! I got a cheesecake flight and a wine flight with my boyfriend and everything was delicious. The prices are SUPER reasonable and the staff was beyond friendly and helpful. A must stop if you are visiting! read more

Stopped in here on a Friday evening for cheesecake, were weren't able to get a table together for our group of 5 but the host suggested we get a carryout, that was a great suggestion brought it right back to the rental. Family really enjoys their cheesecake. read more

Some of the nicest staff we had the pleasure of meeting at Bar Harbor. The woman working the to-go counter was super helpful and offered suggestions. We had 3 small cheesecakes as a take-away order, turtle royale, snickerdoodle and key lime. They were all good but the turtle was overwhelmingly the favorite of our bunch. read more

Took a group of friends to St. Augustine for a week, and Bar Harbor Cheesecake Company was our favorite stop by far! We called in advance since we had a group of 16, and they were more than accommodating and got everything ready for us! The cheesecake and wine was phenomenal! Most of us got the flights, which contained three flavors of cheesecake and three wines. There was a wide selection of cheesecake, so the flights were perfect to get to try a little bit of everything. The staff was especially what made this place unforgettable. Each of them were so kind and were excited to be there! Our server, Christopher, was extraordinary. This place is a MUST while visiting the area. Such a fantastic and unique experience! read more

Had a great cheesecake experience here today during a foodie tour. Lovely hostess did a marvelous job of treating us to 3 exquisite cheesecakes and a glass of wine. Bought one whole cheesecake to take home. read more

We had the best experience! Impressed by the cheesecake flights (choice of 3 sample sized pieces) and wine flights to pair. I recommended trying a few of each. Such reasonable prices with great quality. They also had tea, charcuterie and cracker platters. Such a cute place with the nicest staff and EVERYTHING WAS DELICIOUS! Tip: Go there hungry because there are so many to choose from you will want to try them all. Great location behind Potter's Wax museum so easy on and off from the Trolley Tour (stop 3) and walking distance to so many other great things too. Only recommendation is that they should add coffee as a menu option - it would pair well with some of the flavors too :) read more

Lovely! We were very surprised at how reasonable this place was. $5 cheesecake flights (delicious and lots of choices). $5 wine flights. Usually I'm not a big fan of sweet wines, but these wine was great! Great staff as well. Highly recommend for great dessert experience. read more

Interesting concept for sure mostly because of the savory cheesecake. My husband tried the sweet and savory; I had only the former. The flavor choices were amazing and those I selected were good but unfortunately also all slightly frozen in the middle so I don't think my taste buds got the full experience. The staff was fabulous and the ambiance lovely. read more

New England establishment with sweet Southern Hospitality! The cheesecake is so yummy and not that dense heavy NY texture. I thought I would like the blueberry lemon the most, but simple strawberry on its own was simply delicious! They have more than 100 recipes in total, and you can taste a flight of 3 for $5! They also have a drive up window and offer frozen cakes for travel. Local wine parings offered as well! Also, savory cheesecakes are an option for entertaining which can be served warm. Going back tomorrow to pick up the King Crab. read more

Service was amazing. Cheesecake out of this world and hummus to die for. This is a must go to!!!!!

We were looking for somewhere to get a dessert (to put a candle in for my boyfriend's birthday) and were coming up empty handed as it was a Wednesday evening at 8pm in St Augustine. I found Bar Harbor Cheesecake on a Yelp search and we headed over. It was magical!!! From the initial greeting at the front porch and cozy decor to the phenomenal cheesecake sample plates and amazing service (They provided a sampler piece of Birthday Cake cheesecake with a candle in it!) It was a 5 star experience no matter what way you slice it!!! Absolutely perfect in every way... read more