What a cool comic store right here in Indy. This was our first visit to this location. The…read moreselection was outstanding and the staff were incredibly knowledgeable and friendly.

This is a nice little shop with extremely friendly staff and a great selection. I also was very…read moreimpressed with the organization of the back issues. Everything was in complete order and well organized. I do think some of the pricing is quite a bit higher than other shops, but there's something to be said for nice Staff and not having to search too hard for what you're looking for.

Best comic shop in Indy. After 50 years they must be doing something right. Used to play Heroclix…read morethere. Sad to see no more gaming after Covid....oh well

I used to think that Downtown Comics Castleton and Circle City Comics (formerly) used to be my…read morefavorite comic shops, but now Comic Carnival is my favorite comic shop to visit! It also a perfect shop for pop culture fans. I love the selection of new and old comic books that I can find (such as Marvel, DC, Image, IDW, etc.), the good customer service I can provide, how much any of the comics cost, and everything else that makes it fun to visit! I sure hope a next comic shop will be my second favorite like Comic Carnival!

I've been a loyal customer for about 3 1/2 years. Simply the best option for your comic needs, the…read morestaff cares and will always try to help you in any regard. Not only in purchasing a vast array of books but also the community they've built. Book clubs every month, hosting watch parties, collecting vintage media. A giant backlog of single issue comics at a great price. Truly the best option for the nerds of Indy.

This store is phenomenal. It had a great selection of comics, aswell as volumes and compendiums on…read morethe shelves. The prices were good too, with comics being pretty cheap, especially compared to prices in other stores. The man running the store was very nice and talkative aswell, helping you if necessary. Amazing store, deserves way more attention

Lots of good funky pops and staff is friendly they have good comic books and some fun mystery packs…read moretoo

A hidden gem in the White River Plaza in Muncie, IN. Owner is an expert in new trends in graphics,…read moreformat and story and has a collection of current Eisner winners along with deep collections of classic Marvel titles. Local artists, graphic novels and RPGS all in a large retail location with plenty of parking. I'm there every month!

An absolutely wonderful hobby shop, and with an incredible and diverse selection! I've been coming…read morehere for years, and it really is one of the best FLGS I've been to. For the staff, it's a family-run business and they're all incredibly nice and personable. It's easy to talk to all of them and they're more than willing to help with special requests and orders. They also offer a 10% in-store credit reward system which is simple and quite generous too! In terms of location, while it's a bit off the beaten path, it's close enough to one of the main streets in tow (and another hobby shop) to not be an issue. Parking can be cramped on busy days, but that's to be expected. As far as product goes, there's a lot! Miniatures in particular are well-represented. All Games Workshop IPs are here (some more than others, but also including some boxsets that aren't available anymore) and they're always getting new product in for pre-orders. While they do sell them at GW retail price, their rewards program has let me get away (more than a few times) with getting a few boxes for free or for more than 50% discount. Dungeons and Dragons + Pathfinder minis are also available, as are Star Wars: Legion, BattleTech, and HeroClix, as well as more niche stuff, like Blood and Plunder. A fair selection for various card games, but also a generous and wide selection of board games as well! Lastly, there is also a selection of paints, primers, brushes, magnets, basing material, and other hobby tools that are readily available. As far as gaming space, the backroom has space to accommodate plenty of people and for different games. Plenty of tables to set up at, and a wide selection of terrain to make use of for wargaming. While I unfortunately cannot comment on the music section of the store, as I have not made use of its services, I can say that the gentleman who runs it is very respectful and helpful. Overall, a very worthwhile visit for hobbyists who want a wide selection of goods to peruse at an honest price from honest staff. This place means a lot to me, if you couldn't tell from the review lol

The second downtown comic shop... You could walk from one to the other... this is also a pretty…read moregood shop. It has more of a hipster vibe than the other two, but they are very friendly here, as well. They should do with a bit more inventory. I wish all the shops in Muncie much success.

What a friendly, fun and well stocked store. Eric, Brian and the rest of the staff my husband and I…read morehave been fortunate to have met are very knowledgeable and eager to help you find the perfect graphic novel or game pieces (along with gaming supplies) you may desire. Eric and his staff take an active support in local events.

This shop is split between Krypton Comics and Singer Hobbies, two businesses owned by brothers that…read moreshare the space. The front of the store has a lot of paintball equipment and some gaming card packs. The rear left is set up for gaming tables. The rear right is set up for comics, a few comic related toys, and graphic novels. There are some boxes of old comics as well, but the collection is rather small. (I've seen larger collections at conventions.) The guy behind the counter was friendly and made sure to let me know to ask if I had any questions or needed assistance. The problem is that the inventory is on the small side compared to most comic shops I've been to and it could do with more wall displays promoting the new story lines that get collectors excited. Review #2121

Nice lil shop some good buys I'm not a big gamer but had a nice assortment of comics c collectibles…read morean gaming interest, definitely one of those spots your sure to find a little something of desire, I went in an walked out after spending 300....lol the woman who helped was easy going an answered my questions an made me feel comfortable instead of weird for asked few questions

This place is awesome! We stopped by before heading to dinner with family, not knowing what to…read moreexpect. There is such a large selection of comics, games, and other really cool items. I ended up buying a new comic compilation to read for the plane ride back to California. I am sad this store isn't in Cali, because I would be there every week. The staff was really nice, as the guy at the front counter showed my boyfriend how one of the display games worked. They had a practice match and he took the time to explain the rules and give a couple of tips on strategy. It's great to see someone who really enjoys their job. I didn't have enough time (or money) to grab all the things I wanted, but this store definitely was a high point for my visit back to Indiana. It's going to be somewhere I visit each time I return.

I've been buying comic books from Shawn for nearly 35yrs! All the way back to Barb and Dave's…read morestore on 17th Street (and the original store on the Square!)! He's knowledgeable, friendly, and knows his business. I'm proud of him and what he's built there on 'Geek Street'! Keep up the great work, Mr. Hilton!

This is a small shop that is long and narrow with graphic novels down one row and comics (old and…read morenew) down the other. The space is a little cramped if multiple customers are shopping in the same area. The novels are displayed in easy to find order. The older comics are filed in boxes alphabetically and have some vintage items, but definitely are weighted towards more newer material. So, finding some specific older issue is hit or miss. But at least it's worth stopping in to check. The man working the front counter was friendly to customers as they entered or were leaving. He seemed willing to carry on conversations with customers that were interested in between sales as well. Note that this location doesn't sell much merchandise since there is a specialty store for toys/collectibles just a couple doors down. This is a place for reading material. Nice selection and there's a good chance to find what you are looking for. Review #3732

This is one of the best live auctions going on Facebook- Ernie, Brooks and the Team are TOP NOTCH…read more Its really a great experience and a fun time with the live show- paypal is smooth and shipping is fast and professional. I have also physically been im the store in Indianapolis and purchased comics from them directly from Ernie- you  feel so good being in that store because your surrounded by fellow nerds and a PLETHHORA OF WELL DISPLAYED comics Really impressed with the customer service and Brook was able to turn a negative into a customer for life The original problem was that I didn't win anything on the live video but got in voice for shipping for something I never won. Called the next day and spoke with Shawn who said he would get the invoice taken off- but he didn't- so Brooks reached out to me to ask for payment. Brook really took care of the situation - I appreciate her.

Hours aren't correct. Drove an hour way for it and they put a sign saying they're closed.read more